Andrew & Neil Fanfiction Recommendation
So, a little background: I first read AFTG this year in March, and these fics are just what I have read since getting into the fandom. Since I got into All for the game, I have used many fic recs, Tumblr pages, and masterlists to find more fanfiction, and since I write down my favorites in my notes app, I thought I could share with you all as well! I have read all the popular fics and wanted to share some I don't see often. Another clarification, these fanfictions are all completed works; they might belong to an incomplete series, but the ones I recommend are the ones I read. For the love of your mental health, check tags before you read. Also, if you have any underground favorite fics, share them here!
two sons (56, 926 words) by likearecord
Chapters: 18/18
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Mature
Warnings: Graphic Depictions Of Violence
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Minor or Background
Summary:
Making a documentary about the Butcher of Baltimore doesn't have to mean moving into the murder mansion with his son, but Kevin's never been one to do things halfway.
(As we go through these fic's you will notice I have an extremely soft spot for Andrew's points of view. This was one of the first fics I read when I got into the fandom, and I loved reading the parallel of Andrew's childhood and Neil's.)
Muscle Memory (20, 191 words) by elesary
Chapters: 5/5
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Explicit
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Minor or Background
Series: Part 1 of Deja Vu
Summary:
Andrew wakes in the hospital, years after the last thing he remembers, with nothing but a handful of out of date promises and a wrecked car. He is purposeless, adrift, unable to find solid ground.
Except in the blue, blue eyes of the scarred stranger at his bed side.
(My notes for this one is hurt/comfort final boss)
What Is It To Truly Lose Control? (21, 281 words) by BisexualChaosDemon
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Mature
Warnings: Graphic Depictions Of Violence, Rape/Non-Con, Underage Sex
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Aaron Minyard & Andrew Minyard, Nicky Hemmick & Andrew Minyard, Andrew Minyard & David Wymack, Betsy Dobson & Andrew Minyard, Andrew Minyard & The Upperclassmen
Summary:
Most of the Foxes still think Andrew is a monster, or a sociopath, but Neil knows better. He knows that Andrew cares deeply about a handful of people but struggles more than he will ever admit with that fact.
The thing is, despite Andrew’s commitment to apathy and to denying that he cares about anything, he is often self-sacrificing in his efforts to protect the people he cares about. As Aaron’s trial approaches, Neil gets the sick feeling that Andrew’s self-sacrificing streak is going too far.
(Trial fic of Andrew actually showing how he feels and trusting the foxes enough to tell them what he’s gone through.)
Neutral Statements (and Loving on Purpose) (22495 words) by mars_sends_their_regrets
Chapters: 6/6
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Explicit
Warnings: Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard
Summary:
Andrew tries to be more positive and decides to practice the love languages on Neil. How long will it take Neil to catch on? Can Andrew stay on track when deeper issues threaten to come to the surface?
(self-improvement romance is one of my favs.)
Push to Talk (33830 words) by alexjosten
Chapters: 10/10
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard
Summary:
Neil needs a fresh start. He has a new name and a new job in the middle of nowhere, miles away from anything to do with Exy. The only person he speaks to is Andrew, who knows nothing about him… until Neil's past catches up with him.
(Andrew knows everything about plants and literally memorizes everything. It was cute :)
A Quiet Night (Neil's Version) (26630 words) by kccastner
Chapters: 4/4
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Not Rated
Warnings: Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Kevin Day/Jeremy Knox/Jean Moreau, Katelyn/Aaron Minyard
Summary:
Neil Josten has been in Witness Protection for seven years, working as an ER nurse and avoiding getting close to anyone. When Andrew Minyard shows up in the ER with a dislocated shoulder, his world is flipped on its head.
(I have a qoute for this one as well:
“Yeah. I’m here.”
“Don’t disappear on me.”
“I won’t.”
“Promise?” It must be a really good day. Or Andrew’s still partly asleep. He'll deny this ever happened once he has coffee, but for the moment, Neil basks in the soft vulnerability in Andrew's eyes.
Neil smiles. “Promise.”)
the scientific method (9888 words) by gay_irl
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Not Rated
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Katelyn Mackenzie/Aaron Minyard
Summary:
Aaron Minyard is trying to understand his brother. So he uses his big STEM major brain and makes some observations.
(Okay yes this fic rec is basically only andrew and Neil but I'm a Minyard lover and like seeing andreil through Aaron's point of view. Here a quote from this that make me laugh out loud
“ 9. Gay (family history: cousin*). *Is being gay genetic? Further research needed. 10. Afraid of heights.”
Like, goodness, Aaron, way to call your brother out. I also just enjoy seeing the twinyards actually have a relationship, and Aaron acknowledging Andrew actually cares for him.)
Follow You Through The Dark (22461 words) by sambutwithbooks
Chapters: 5/5
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Not Rated
Warnings: Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Katelyn/Aaron Minyard, Aaron Minyard & Andrew Minyard
Summary:
“Don’t say no-”
“No.”
“Andrew-” Aaron shakes the paper a little in frustration before composing himself. “It’s a quiz bowl. Basic trivia. It runs for five consecutive weekends and there’s a prize at the end. I need you and your sponge brain to help me win.”
His brother has asked him for many things since Bee had pulled Andrew aside to tell him he had a doppelganger wandering around San Jose, California causing trouble but this might be the dumbest thing Aaron has ever asked him to do.
----
When Andrew Minyard's twin brother signs them both up to participate in the strangest trivia competition known to man, Andrew agrees to participate under the stipulation that he is the sole recipient of this year's grand prize: three hundred and sixty-five days worth of free ice cream from Sweetie's. Instead, Andrew discovers a connection of his own with fellow loner and competition participant, Neil Josten.
(This book was so cute. Aaron convinces Andrew to play a trivia game for free sweeties ice cream and of course their opponent are Katelyn and Neil)
that's just something people say (119397 words) by nanatsuyu
Chapters: 24/24
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Minor or Background
Series: Part 1 of runaways
Summary:
Neil makes the mistake of stealing the wrong car. Andrew makes the mistake of offering a ride to a liar. They both make the mistake of turning the whole affair into a road trip ‘home.’
(This book is very much a slow burn for it to be at 119k words, but I think the timing was perfect. This fic was one of those I didn't want to finish and wish it just kept going, but I finished it, and it was amazing. Also, if I forget this book, this should help me remember. This is the book where Neil eats the chocolate that Andrew bought and gets high by accident lol. Here is a quote from this book as well:
"He's not even nice about any of it. Like pulling teeth while you're kicking and screaming."
Neil blinks at that, something else popping into his head that he'd forgotten about. "He isn't nice."
"A therapist and a parrot," Aaron remarks sarcastically.
"No, I mean-Andrew isn't nice. He's kind."
Aaron looks at him like he's grown a third head.
"Not like you expect someone to be," he rephrases. His own words hit him again, about Andrew doing things without wanting much more, out of his want for care. Neil untangles the knot tying Andrew and 'nice' together, but doesn't let go of the string just yet. "Soft and kind aren't the same thing." )
strange bouts of sentience (17530 words) by AceSirenSinger
Chapters: 6/6
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Mature
Warnings: Graphic Depictions Of Violence
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard
Summary:
Kevin finds it – a mangled string of parts that used to a murder-bot - and brings it to Andrew.
“It’s going to wake up and murder me while I try to reprogram it,” Andrew predicts.
(He’s only sort of right.)
(This fic is a apocalypse/robot au this was also unbelievable tender sweetness and in Andrew POV. Here a silly qoute from the fit.
You woke up in an unfamiliar place, with strangers, and a rogue bot tech, and you didn't run, and you didn't use your elegant kill pattern on us." Why not?
Bots were never meant to be expressive. Maybe that's why when this bot smiles, Andrew feels like the bot wound up and hit him in the teeth.
"You fixed my joints. You replaced my bad parts.
You gave me autonomy over my energy system.
Of course I didn't shoot you."
"I put a knife in your neck."
"I liked it."
Andrew has to turn away, because his cheeks are smarting. )
Odd Eye (16394 words) by tdashshirts
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: Rape/Non-Con
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard
Characters: Neil Josten, Andrew Minyard, Nicky Hemmick, Kevin Day, Aaron Minyard, The Foxes (All For The Game), David Wymack
Summary:
Andrew spends most of his childhood thinking he is a psychopath. He is not. Andrew is, and always will be, just Andrew.
( I love Andrew introspection books!! This one is on neurodivergent Andrew and his complex post trauma stress disorder. This bad boy here is 16 k words full of Andrew growing up and finding his people and finding those to trust. I even have a little qoute I got from reading
“On it, amongst the thousands, this is the only one Andrew likes.
Andrew has been many things to many people.
He has only been Drew to Neil.” )
Sweet Impossible Blossom (16138 words) by transjorts
Chapters: 1/1
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Mature
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Kevin Day & Andrew Minyard, Kevin Day & Neil Josten
Summary:
“As much as Andrew enjoyed observing men partaking in vigorous activity with very little clothing on, he despised the comparisons he couldn’t help making to his own body. He couldn’t do half as much as Kevin since he refused to not wear his binder in public. The one time he’d tried to mimic Kevin’s usual routine with his binder on he’d nearly fainted, listing sideways until his body slammed into the wall. Kevin had cradled the back of his head as he dropped to the floor. That hadn’t been one of Andrew’s finer moments.”
TW dysphoria, transphobia—brief transphobic encounter (verbal harassment, misgendering), brief reference to a past car crash and past death
(This fic made me lmao. It was really funny and really sweet. This is a strangers-to-friends-to-lovers long one-shot about trans Andrew meeting Neil in the pad aisle.
Here is a quote as well that made me giggle.
"You should try oat milk," Neil suggested a few minutes later, as Andrew stood in front of the freezers considering adding another carton of ice cream to his pile.
Andrew tilted his head slightly in question.
Neil lifted one shoulder in a half shrug, snagging a bag of frozen blueberries. "It might help your gas."
Andrew froze, his arm arrested mid-air in its grab for a promising carton of moose tracks. He turned his gaze on Neil, who was reading the back of a box of popsicles. "What."
Neil glanced up. "Your gas?"
Andrew stared. Neil blinked.
"Kevin mentioned it," Neil said.
Of course he did. The bastard. Jesus.”
This scene made me giggle so much lmao like the Kevin and Andrew friendship is very sweet plus aroacekevin rep in this one too.)
Why do we feel alone? (39866 words) by Leocante
Chapters: 7/7
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Minor or Background Relationship(s)
Summary:
Andrew isn't a renowed author. Sure, he has his fans here and there, a few hardcore readers, but he's not famous or internationally known.
So, when he stumbles across his own book in a place where it absolutely shouldn't be and in a language it absolutely wasn't translated to, he makes it his personal mission to find the person behind it.
(Translation into Russian available here.)
(The yearning in this one was top notch. And it took me 3 days to finish and I wanted more :( But still it was super great. A little synopsis is that Andrew is an author and bought a translated book that he wrote, which he did not know existed, which was translated by Neil Josten. This cues Andrew to go down a rabbit hole of everything Neil Josten and his reviews of other books. The amount of silly bookish quotes and nerdy things made me lol a lot throughout reading. And you know I got a quote
"I could take them," Andrew shots back. "One is dead and the other an idiot, it shouldn't be that hard."
"You know me for less than two minutes and already plan to win a duel? Be still my heart," Neil says flatly, but his eyes betray him; he's grinning on the inside, bright as the sun behind the windows. He takes a sip of his drink, a black, boring coffee, and Andrew has only disgust for anyone who drinks their coffee plain.
"Keep talking and you'll be eliminated first," he says.
"I see you're as charming as through the phone," Neil doesn't waste a second. "You sure your name isn't Mr. Darcy?"
Skilled (46925 words) by wildfrancium
Chapters: 22/22
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Mature
Warnings: Creator Chose Not To Use Archive Warnings
Additional Tags: Alternate Universe, Exy, some sci fi elements, Medical stuff, slow ish burn, Oblivious Neil Josten, Past Child Abuse
Series: Part 1 of Neon Lights
Summary:
Neil has a talent for deactivating sensors that tell doctors when a patient takes their medication. Andrew, a famous Exy player, has a sensor that needs deactivating.
(The whole premise of the book is Neil work in like an underground surgery guy who can deactivate sensors which are put in people to tell doctors that they took their medication. Yeah it a crazy premise but it was super interesting learning about the whole world and how things work. Plus the hurt comfort of this book was banging. Like perfect! There is a sequel to this book but I have not read it. Here's a quote:
"I'm going to touch your hand," Neil said. Andrew nodded. Neil took Andrew's other shaking hand and brought it up to his pulse. He pushed Andrew's fingers against his pulse and let go. Andrew kept his fingers on Neil. "Shut your eyes," Neil said. He wasn't sure if Andrew would comply, but after a moment Andrew let his eyes slip shut.
And Neil started quietly talking. He talked about cities and highways. Sunsets and sunrise.)
Being So Normal (18610 words) by orphan_account
Chapters: 2/2
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Jeremy Knox/Jean Moreau, Allison Reynolds/Renee Walker (All For The Game), Andrew Minyard & Renee Walker, Robin Cross & Neil Josten
Series: Part 13 of fx's writing
Summary:
Andrew has a stable life. He has a stable job, people who he doesn’t hate talking to, a cat who likes him, and a house with a door that locks. He’s fine.
But that’s the problem. He’s just fine. No more, no less. Some days, he forgets that behind the picket fences and pristine gardens are people just as messed up as him, and it feels like he’s alone in Palmetto.
Until he’s sitting at a PTA meeting, bored out of his mind, waiting to drive Renee home, when this guy steps up to the mic. And a lot changes.
(Teacher Andrew first saw Neil Josten at the PTA meeting as a dad trying to keep the arts program because of his daughter Robin. Andrew finds Robin skipping class because she gets anxious and offers to help her find a therapist. Then Andrew actually talks with Neil and exchanges numbers, and it's just really sweet and cute.)
as frightened as you of being alive (38848 words) by blueberrryink
Chapters: 3/3
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Mature
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard
Characters: Andrew Minyard, Neil Josten, The Foxes | Palmetto State Foxes Members (All For The Game)
Andrew sinks into the couch as Neil’s warmth melts through hm.
For so long, touch had been nothing but pain. A tally of someone else’s control over his body.
But here Neil is: his pink cheek resting lazily on Andrew’s knee and his trust tucked snugly into the curve of Andrew’s lap as if there is nowhere safer for it to be.
Neil touches him – and Andrew realises that not a single trace of hurt exists within it.
Early life taught Andrew that touch and care bring nothing but pain.
Neil, however, is insistent on showing him how utterly devoid of violence it can be – to want and be wanted.
Or
Andrew and Neil learn how to redefine what touch and care mean to them
(Andrew's pov of him and Neil learning how to redefine what touch and care mean to them. This was 38k words and starts with Andrew in the Foster care system, and his past families and the effect those families have on him. This fic did make me cry, too, so there's that knowledge. I love fic like this because it's the perfect length, and the fluff and angst in it are like the perfect ratio. Here a qoute:
One night, Neil bunches his fists so tightly up that the corner of his nail draws blood; just a shallow puncture on his thumb where he's scratched too hard. Andrew directs him sit him on the bed before he pulls out a single bandage from the pouch his foster sister had once left him, all those years ago. He holds out his palm expectantly and waits for Neil to offer up the hurt.
"A butterfly?" Neil asks, as Andrew presses the bandage into place, smoothing the edges down softly.
"Since when does Andrew Minyard carry pink band-aids?"
Andrew does not answer,
The gesture speaks.
Neil will hear it - if he wants.)
N for nebulous (135395 words) by minyards
Chapters: 35/35
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Mature
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard
Summary:
After his frankly terrible second year of university, Andrew wants a quiet, peaceful summer with his family. Of course, he should have thought about that before bringing a total stranger to the camp he calls home
(There a bit of everything in this book with it being in Andrew pov and some bonding between him and all the characters like Nicky, Kevin, and Aaron. I'm going to keep quiet about what it aabout and just have ya'll read it :)
If I Knew You (43145 words) by AceSirenSinger
Chapters: 18/18
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Teen And Up Audiences
Warnings: No Archive Warnings Apply
Summary:
Neil is imprisoned at sixteen years old for being the Butcher of Baltimore. Andrew obsesses, and Aaron obsesses because Andrew does, and everything goes wrong and raw and painful.
Feat. the twinyards breaking each other’s hearts, and a decent amount of shade on the American justice system.
( I was a bit apprehensive when I started since the whole book is in Aaron's Point of view, but if you want twinyard angst and bonding with a side a Andreil this fic is perfect! Also, another thing is that Aaron is a cop for a second, which I don’t like reading cop stories, but I understand why he did it, and this book is really for prison abolition, which I loved that it preached what the book was about. Anyway, Neil is seen as the butcher and is arrested at 16, but eventually Aaron becomes his lawyer and has Neil read Andrew's book, which is based on Neil. Here a quote:
"Andrew and I met at the People's Sexiest Man Alive event two years ago" Kevin explains later, as they take their water break. "We kept in touch."
Neil turns his laser eyes on Andrew.
"Sexiest Man Alive?"
The slight blush on Andrew's face says maybe he wouldn't have minded if Kevin didn't mention this fact. "It's a magazine thing. You missed it, being locked up.""Maybe you should show me," Neil says, and Aaron thinks oh hell no.
Andrew smirks, and Aaron wants to gouge his own eyes out.
"Break time's over," Aaron says, hoarsely. "Let's get back to the court, yeah?"
The rolling of Andrew's eyes says he knows exactly what Aaron is doing.
"I'll text you a link," Andrew promises to Neil as he gears up again.
"No, you won't." Aaron says, aghast.
"You can only text him through me, and I do NOT want to see that."
Andrew's smirk grows. "Maybe I'll just have to bring a copy in person."
Neil turns his puppy dog eyes on Aaron, "Could he? Could he come to the house?"
And Aaron thinks, fuck my life.)
turn out the lights (185357 words) by cielalune
Chapters: 29/29
Fandom: All For The Game - Nora Sakavic
Rating: Mature
Warnings: Graphic Depictions Of Violence
Relationships: Neil Josten/Andrew Minyard, Aaron Minyard & Andrew Minyard
Series: Part 1 of the dark side of the moon
Summary:
"What do you think it means to be alive, Andrew?”
“What?”
"To be alive. Is it just to eat and breathe? Just survive? Because that’s what I’ve been doing my whole life, Andrew, and it doesn’t feel like enough. But I don’t know how to do more. We’re supposed to find meaning or something, right?”
See: stupid fucking questions. Like Andrew hadn’t been wondering the same thing his whole life. “Yeah. Yeah, we are.”
Based on The Last of Us. Set five years after the breakout of Cordyceps, Andrew is tasked with bringing an enigma of a man across the country, who also may just happen to be the cure for humankind.
(This last of us au is amazing and so angsty. I loved going through this book through Andrew's point of view and having him be our so-called “Joel”. There is a sequel that is unfinished, but this book, just read as a stand-alone, is worth it in my opinion. The writing of this book is beautiful, and the banter and dialogue of this book are great as well. Here a quote:
Mimicking or mocking, Andrew doesn't know, but Neil bends Andrew's arm behind his back. He hears his own blade hit the floor before he feels the cool tip of metal against his throat, Neil's warmth crowded behind him. "Still think I'm boring?" he murmurs, breath ghosting across Andrew's nape. Andrew tilts his head a bit in response, opening his neck: a dare. The blade nicks his
Adam's apple as he moves.
Andrew matches his volume, voice hushed. "I think you're a liar.
"Why's that?"
"You said you didn't know how to use knives."
That's where you're wrong," he tells him, lightly tapping the blade against his throat. "I said I was afraid of them not that I didn't know how to use them.)
And this is where we part, lol. I hope you all have found at least one fic to read from this list, which took me a while to make. There are some fics I love but am too embarrassed to recommend lol. Let me get a little more confident on Tumblr, and then maybe I'll recommend them. As I said earlier, if you have any fic you want to recommend, you are more than welcome! I hope everyone has a good holiday and winter!!