Burning Lungs and Bloodshot Eyes
Pairing: Kyle Rayner x fem!reader
Summary: Kyle and you had separated because of his inability to maintain a work-life balance. But, fate has a way of drawing him back to you, and he finds himself with you once again.
CW: mild suggestiveness, implied smut, MDNI, angst, drinking
WC: 3.16K
Leche's Note: This is the first fic from my 400 followers event!! I'm so excited to write this series omg (losing my mind actively). I hope you guys like this one, it's a bit longer than my normal fics!! also thank you @pixelbfs for reading this over and letting me yap to you about this for like a week
He’d really done a number on you, huh?
Looking around at the empty, dark space of your old shared house, he finds himself placing shards of glass in a box, hands shaking as he places them piece by piece, trying desperately to not look at the ruined photograph of the two of you once framed.
He stands, a wave of heat and nausea pressing down on his back, and steps out to the back porch, staring at the half-dying garden you’d planted. Memories flood through him against his will, and he finds himself stepping down to the patch of soft soil, standing in front of the wilting white carnations.
“Kyle, look! Aren’t they pretty? Ma says these ones are for everlasting love.” Your voice echoes, practically slamming around in his skull, like you were desperate to get away from him even then. In his mind’s eye, he can still see you kneeling there, soil dirtying that new summer yellow dress he’d insisted on buying you. Your hands were all muddy, and there was a smudge of dirt on your cheek.
His hand moves, twitching, like it’d done once when he’d wiped it off you with his thumb, earning a flush from you, watching your mouth go dry as you huffed and sputtered at him for being too charming.
Where was that charm, he wondered, when you’d packed up and left, sobbing about how he’d been working himself to the bone, how you couldn’t handle no more nights alone.
Snapping himself out of his daze when the front door’s knocked on, his legs move him back into the house, though his gaze remains transfixed on the sight of those wilting white carnations, dying like his love.
Opening the front door, he’s greeted with another unwanted sight. Hal stands in front of him, boots clicking against the wooden steps to the front of his house, a toothpick being fiddled with absentmindedly until their gazes meet. How he wished they hadn’t.
“Rayner, there you are! Y’know, you had me worried ya wouldn’t answer the door! C’mon out buddy, look, I even got you somethin’ good!” Hal says, holding up two bottles of beer, practically forcing his way into the house.
So this wasn’t even work-related, huh? Usually, Hal tended to keep his distance, separating them when it came down to the nitty gritty details. Why the sudden change of heart, Kyle wouldn’t understand.
Still, he lets him in, sighing and shutting the door behind the older man, muttering to him to take his damned boots off first. Biting his tongue, he resists the urge to say his fiance wouldn’t like it. After all, he didn’t have a fiance now, did he?
“What’re you doing here, Hal? This ain’t for a job, is it?” He asks, sitting down on his armchair, watching Hal crack open the cans against the side of the dining table, wincing when it leaves an obvious mark that Hal just brushes off.
“Nah, this is a Jordan-special, kid. You’re lucky, not many people ever get to witness this!” He laughs, making Kyle’s mood only sour further, the look on his face only wavering further between anguish and irritation.
Kyle lets out a mocking, suffering sigh, reaching out to take the cold bottle and downing a few gulps before the older man can question it. He’d need it to even hold a conversation tonight, pleasantries be damned.
“She left.” He finally admits, tears in his eyes as he meets Hal’s gaze, watching the man sit opposite to him. That was your spot, once. You’d hated it, wanting to be closer to him, but he’d resisted, claiming he wanted to be able to see your every expression, your every movement. All of you, he’d once told you, practically begging to keep you in that spot as he painted you with the cheap hardware store supplies on an old scrapped canvas.
Hal’s expression drops, and he sighs, relaxing his shoulders as he takes a swig of his own beer, looking at Kyle with an expression akin to pity. Not that Kyle was looking back at him anymore, too busy wiping his eyes against his sleeve, coughing as he drank more.
“I know. I know, I—” He cuts himself off momentarily, wondering if it was the right time to bring this up. Biting the inside of his cheek, he stares at Kyle one more time, giving him a once-over, his expression crumpling further at the sight of him so distraught.
He looked like he was a husk of himself, really. Of course, Hal remembered how he’d spoken of you, like you were his sun. Like he would forever be okay, revolving around you, being with you. You were his everything, his very essence. At least, that’s how he’d made it sound. At that time, he’d thought the young lad was exaggerating. Who really worships someone that much, like they’re the core of their very being?
Kyle had, apparently. He’d loved you so deeply Hal knows it must be like his heart had been ripped out and tossed aside, and he’d felt so fiercely for you Hal also knew that this wasn’t a fleeting sort of love.
No, knowing the young man, he’d probably love you forever. And that would be his very undoing, wouldn’t it?
Leaning forward onto his elbows, Hal sucks in a sharp breath, before snapping his fingers a few times to get Kyle’s attention. “Hey, look at me. Look at me, Rayner. Us? We ain’t meant for love, and you know it. Snap…snap out of this. For your sake and mine, forget about her, okay? She’s not coming back.”
Kyle chokes on a sob, looking up at Hal like he’d personally dug that dagger into his chest and twisted it aggressively. Shaking his head, he tries to deny it, but no words come to his mind. So, he instead slowly nods and slumps into his senior, gripping onto the front of his shirt and sobbing into his chest.
“I—what will I do without her?” He asks, sniffling, pulling back as Hal digs through his satchel and hands Kyle a bounty poster, a faint smile on his lips as he pats Kyle’s shoulder sympathetically.
“You’ll work yourself ta the bone—it’s what worked when Carol and I broke up.” Hal shrugs, and Kyle’s brows furrows, staring up at him like he’d grown three heads. “You’re always breakin’ up though.” He deadpans, and Hal’s grin only widens, smoothing back Kyle’s hair to make him seem more presentable.
“I know. Maybe you and yer little lady could be like that, someday. But you’ve got to snap out of this, kid. For everyone’s sake.” He huffs, and Kyle slowly nods in agreement, rubbing his face with his hand and holding the bounty in the other, gulping when he realizes it was in your hometown. He’d be in for one hell of a week if you were actually staying there, right? Not like he could tell Hal that, though.
Getting out of the house for the first time since you’d left felt…oddly pleasant, even if it only increased the stinging pain in his chest. Maneuvering his horse towards your hometown, he maps out his path, patting his steed out of thanks.
The journey takes hours, though it’s all worth it when he manages to make it before nightfall. Only, every single bed and breakfast, inn, and anything remotely resembling a motel shuts him out, claiming they’re full for the night. Confused, he mounts his horse again, clicking his tongue and slowly moving through town. Why were people turning him down? Did they know about your history or something?
Nervously, he moves down the familiar path to your old home, and stops in front of the little brick path up to your house. He pauses, unsure of what to do. One night couldn’t hurt, right? You were exes, yes, but he was sure he could probably get one night of civility from you regardless of your history.
That is, if you were even home. To his luck, who knows, you may be out on a new date with a new perfect guy who could devote all his time to you. If Kyle could’ve, he definitely would’ve. So why didn’t you know that?
Yet, now wasn’t the time to dwell on such matters. Dismounting his horse and tying the reins to a tree in front of your house, he practically sprints up the entryway with his satchel resting on his hip, climbing up the steps before he finds himself on your front porch.
Clearing his throat, he knocks a few times, before it suddenly hits him how late it was. What if he accidentally scared you? That’d only ruin your impression of him. Still, beggars can’t be choosers, and he had run out of all other options.
Still, he really hadn’t expected you to actually open the door for him. The oakwood door flings open, and you stand there, clad in a sleeveless nightgown and staring at him like you hadn’t properly rested in weeks. Worry fills his heart despite himself, even as he watches your eyes widen like you saw a ghost.
“What are you doing here, Kyle?” You breathe, leaning heavily against the doorframe, like your legs were giving up on you from just the sight of him. He moves forward a little on instinct, but stops himself from grabbing you, nails digging into his palms hard enough to practically draw blood.
“I—I needed a place to stay. Just for tonight, and I—I’ll go badger that bed and breakfast down the street to give me a room.” He stammers, unable to look at you, but finding himself drawn to you even as he tries his damndest to avoid eye contact. His breath hitches when he sees you staring intently at him, weighing out your options before slowly nodding, pulling away from the door and letting him inside.
“Fine. Just tonight, and then you leave.” You repeat, sighing as he locks the door behind him, letting you usher him upstairs to the guest room. On the way up, he sees remnants of your shared life, from some of the decorations you’d brought, to the old photographs he’d insisted on taking. But what really takes the cake was seeing the painting he’d done of you in that old garden, still hanging up on your wall. Why was it still up? Clearly, you had to update your decor.
“This is your room. One night. You leave at first light.” You hiss, not even an ounce of warmth in your voice as you all but stomp off to your room, leaving him alone in the guest room. The guest room that…lacked much heat. But he’d have to make it do, just for tonight. Tomorrow he’d definitely find a better place.
It’s probably close to sunup, now. He hasn’t slept a wink, though. Everything in here is covered with the lingering smell of your perfume, and he’s pretty sure he saw some of your clothes in here, too. How could he possibly sleep, surrounded by everything of the only woman he’d loved.
Choking back a strangled gasp, he sits up, running his hands through his hair to try and stop the near-painful feeling of his attraction towards you. He couldn’t afford to feel like this, not anymore. It didn’t help that this room had gone from cold to downright frigid, making his already-hot body feel close to the sun’s heat itself.
Slowly, he stands, and stumbles out of the room, intent on going to the bathroom and freshening up. Instead, his body instinctually moves towards yours, and before he can stop himself, he’s opening your bedroom door. To his utter surprise, you’re sitting up as well, head in your hands as you stare down at the floor beside your bed.
Your head snaps up, cheeks flushed at the sight of him in his boxers and an undershirt, taking in a sharp breath at the reminder of what you’d left behind. God, he looked good. How could he look so good when you felt like a complete mess? It wasn’t fair.
Gasping for breath and wondering if this was another one of your dreams, you lean forwards, nightgown slipping a little as you squint to make him out in the darkness. Kyle flushes a bright pink at the sight of your cleavage, and immediately averts his gaze after remembering you weren’t his to look at. Not anymore.
“What’s wrong?” You rasp, still half-wondering if this was a dream. A dazed, disorienting dream, but it had to be a dream. There’s no way he’s actually walking into your bedroom, and sitting down right in front of you, right? Right. Then why is he so close you could practically kiss him?
“The guest room’s too cold. Can I…I’m cold.” He murmurs, tone almost whiney as he slips into bed beside you, seeming to have forgotten all about your breakup and flopping down like he still owned the place. You gape in shock at the sight of him, gagged, and gasp, shaking him awake in a panic. No, he couldn’t stay here tonight. If he stayed here, you’d never want him to leave. You couldn’t admit you still wanted him—that’s like taking the bait.
“Get out of my bed. Kyle!” You whisper, panicking already, only to pause at the sight of his wide, teary eyes. He grabs your hand sleepily, rubbing your knuckles like he used to do when you were still together, and he’d be slipping into bed after a late night chasing bounties and upholding the law.
“I missed you.” He murmurs back, sniffling as he drags you down into bed beside him, giving you enough space to pull back if you still wanted to, though secures his arm around your side. He doesn’t know where this newfound courage is coming from, but absence makes the heart fonder, so he could probably really only credit his broken, sappy heart.
“Let me stay, won’t ya? Just…tonight.” He says, nuzzling his nose into the side of your head when you move closer to his side, breathing you in and sighing in relief. This was where he needed to be, and he knew that with full certainty now.
You slump against him, and slowly nod, burying your face against his neck as he wraps his arms around you, pulling your body into his and refusing to let go of his iron grip on you. “Just tonight. And you’re leaving tomorrow.” You reiterate, and he nods obediently, making your throat parch.
“At first light.” He mumbles, reminding you of your own words. You freeze when you feel him sleepily kiss the side of your head, hand still holding yours like he’d completely forgotten about your breakup. It was just tonight, so maybe you could forget about it, too.
That is, until he rolls over a little, sleepily moving against you and making you pause in surprise. Hissing a little, you push him back by the shoulders, cheeks just as flushed as his. “Kyle, what the hell are ya doin’?” You ask, wondering if he’d completely lost his senses. He pauses, blinks, and looks down at the cleavage still peeking out of your nightgown, gaze transfixed on the way you’re breathing, how you’d been sweating a little from the contact, how beautiful you looked under him…goddamn it, he was getting ahead of himself, wasn’t he?
“Tell me you want me to go, and I will. I just—I can’t be without you. You’re my everything, y’know that? Fuckin’ hell, I shouldn’t have come back. I’m sorry, I—I just can’t. I can’t. I need you.” He rasps, tone damn near whiney as he looks down at you, lashes clumped together from his tears, hair ruffled from his tossing and turning, chest practically brushing against yours. How were you meant to think straight like this? You couldn’t, obviously. Your heart is beating at the speed of light, and you restrain a gasp, biting your lower lip and smacking his arm lightly, averting your gaze from his pathetic, gorgeous face.
“Kyle…one night…” You murmur, tugging his hair lightly, pushing it away from his face with a shared groan. One night couldn't hurt, right? Right. You could handle one night of passion. You deserved it, really, at this point. Three weeks without Kyle definitely did that to a woman.
So, you give in. Hands in his hair, you let go, unable to say no to him. How could you, when you wanted him just as badly? You’d be a hypocrite to refuse him now. No, you’d definitely stand strong after tonight, and you’d kick him out tomorrow morning like you’d sworn you would. It would happen, you’d make sure of it.
Waking up the next morning, you feel like you’ve been kicked down by a horse. A really attractive horse, though, seeing as you’re resting on Kyle’s bare chest, his arm wrapped around your waist and holding you impossibly close, even in sleep. With a sleepy sigh, you sit up a little, just to admire his features one last time before he’d inevitably leave.
“Mornin’, sweetheart.” He murmurs when he wakes up, feeling your gaze practically burn a hole into his forehead, lashes fluttering as he looks up at you with the most hopeful, pleased stare. Any strong will you’d had seeps out of you at once, and you groan, flopping onto the bed hopelessly beside him.
“I hate you.” You grumble, and he chuckles, the sound breathless as he pulls you even closer, burying his face into your neck, breath coming out in little puffs against your collarbone. “I can stay longer, can’t I? I’ll even move in here, if you’d like. We can replant that garden…” He rasps, making you pause in surprise. You look down at him, at his content expression, and feel yourself relaxing, before nodding slowly in agreement, a faint smile tugging at your lips.
“Can we add peonies this time too?” You murmur, and he immediately nods, humming his response and tightening his grip just a little further, as if afraid you’d leave him any minute now. “Of course. Any flowers you’d like, sugar.” He whispers, and you snuggle into him.
You were sure this would be the first of many things he’d agree with you on. Perhaps he’d even cut down his bounties, too, if you can sweeten the deal. And you definitely could, since he folds almost instantly around you.This time, it’d work out between you two if he had any say in the matter. He’d never let you go, and he’d get to rub it in Hal’s face that his relationship worked out better than his senior’s. It’s all a man could want in life, honestly.
Please do not copy, steal, or put my works into AI.
Consider supporting me through commissions!
Leche's Mailbox.
Taglist: @cinnamon-girl-writes, @that-dumb-bunny, @i-gotta-go-so-much-bigger, @sowhatifimslow, @stilestotherescue, @nightwingblvd