every day you send me a
silent message,
saying that youâre not
coming back,
and iâm happy for you,
because
i
am
not,
too.
and although itâs a
little bit sad how we
used to tell each other
not to leave and now weâre
just fine with each other
not ever coming back,
i know in my heart that
there are things that i
couldnât risk losing again,
so, this is itâ
goodbye.
I hate that you have enough power over me that my fingers have been itching to write this letter. We havenât spoken in six months, and I havenât missed you a single day, but suddenly youâre all I can think about. So here it is:Â
I have a daughter now. I wonât tell you her name because you donât deserve to know it. She is the best thing to ever happen to me, and for the first time in my life, I truly get it. All these years, Iâve been thinking there was something wrong with me - that IÂ wasnât enough. Even when I fought you, even when I pretended I didnât care, I did.Â
But now I have a daughter of my own, and I realize the problem never was with me. It was with you. A daughter is the best goddamn gift the world can give you, and if you canât realize that, then you are a sorry and miserable man who never deserved one in the first place.Â
My daughter will be different. She will know she is loved every day. I will make sure of that. Her father will make sure of that. Heâs more of a man than you will ever be.Â
I spent so long searching for the love you never gave me. And I looked in a lot of the wrong places. I think I finally found it. But the really fucked up this is: youâre still the voice in the back of my head, telling me that Iâm not worthy of it. And you donât deserve to know all the pain thatâs putting me through, but there it is. The truth. You fucked me up and I will never forgive you for it.Â
But Iâll let you in on another secret. I will survive it. I will beat it. Because I wonât allow you to have that kind of power over me anymore. You are just sad, pathetic, weak little man, and I am a giant who wonât be felled by the likes of you. If thereâs one good thing you taught me, itâs to always get back up. And I will. Â
Because I have my daughter. And the love of a good man that one day Iâll learn to accept. For now, I accept myself as the mother of a beautiful daughter. And one day, I will accept myself entirely. And on that day, I wonât think of you at all.Â
So goodbye, Father.Â
With one last, almighty Fuck You,Â
LilaÂ
(p.s. I heard mom left you. Good for her. I hope you die alone.)Â
He didnât know how to describe how she looked like. Should he begin with her physical appearance? Should he pay attention to the bags under her eyes (everyone in college has them anyway)? Should he mind that he could barely call that a smile, compared to the one she wore the first time she held Grace? School work kept Gabe from researching on whatever Lilaâs going through, so itâs safe to say that he walked into the room unprepared. He only hoped that sheâd excuse him for it, because he wasnât here to diagnose her or lecture her or tell her how to get through this shit. Heâs here because he had to see how sheâs doing, he had to make sure sheâs alright, he had to make sure sheâs still herself. He had to see her.
Gabe chuckled softly. "But have you been eating properly?â He sat down, brushed his fingers on her hand, before looking back up at her. âWho⌠who got this room for you?â As far as Gabe knew, Maia doesnât have a clue sheâs in here. âDoesnât it get lonely in here? Have they been taking good care of you? Do they serve you good food?â Questions started to flow out of his mouth, his protective feeling of her getting the better of him.
His concern was touching, in a way that made her heart soar and drop into the pit of her stomach at the same time. It felt nice, to have someone worry, but they were also new parents, and worrying was basically all they did nowadays. She hated that she had piled on even more. âYeah, they threatened me with the feeding tube if I didnât,â she joked sardonically, her typically quick humor having taken a dark turn along with her outlook. But Gabe deserved better than her old ways of defensive humor, so she softened instantly. âMy eatingâs been fine. Doesnât mean I feel like it, but I know Iâm here to get better. Iâm not going to let something stupid like food get in the way of that.âÂ
She listened patiently as the questions spouted out of Gabeâs mouth, a special kind of fondness for him growing in her chest at what an undeniably Gabe thing it was. âThe foodâs fine,â she shrugged, starting backwards. âThe nurses are patronizing, but the doctorâs okay. Sometimes it gets lonely, but it gives me time to think. Other times, I talk with the other patients - to varying degrees of success. And I spoke with Max - heâs in the psychology department - and he talked to a professor who gave me a recommendation. And, um, I got in contact with my mom. Sheâs left my dad and sheâs gonna foot the bill here. I told her to come visit as soon as she gets a chance....âÂ
It had been a huge step, calling her mother. Their relationship had always been distant - her fault, she knew - but in the pits of her despair, she just felt like a child herself, one who desperately needed a mommy to make it all better. And she was glad she did make that step, that she reached out across that chasm, because it turned out her mother was just waiting on the other side, looking for some way to cross, too.Â
One day youâre going to ask about the beginning of your life and I will tell you all about how you totally cockblocked your dad, and how the labor was agonizing, and how it was it all worth it when I held you in my arms for the first time. Iâll tell you all about how proud I was when I brought you home, and how for the first week I was in a delirious, but happy fog.Â
And then there will be a gap, a long pause before I pick up somewhere down the road. Maybe I wonât be able to tell you the story about the first time you smiled. Daddy will have to take over in those parts, which is fine, because heâs always been better at stories. But as you listen, conjuring those stories into images in your head so real you could swear you actually remember them, Iâll be doing the same. Because chances are, I wonât have been there.Â
Iâll have been here. Missing you every second.Â
My doctor tells me I need to start writing things down. Getting everything straight in my head, and expressing how Iâm feeling rather than bottling it up. (Itâs your grandfatherâs fault, and if I do anything right as a mother, youâll be lucky enough to never have met him.) He - my doctor - says I should start writing letters, even if I never send them. And since youâre the one whoâs always on my mind, Iâm starting with you first.Â
You, my Grace, were never what I expected out of life. I didnât know what to expect, honestly. I was just a girl, whoâd been looking for love in all the men who could never give it back to her. I was a bit of a slut, Iâm ashamed to say, but it was only because the man my heart belonged to was too big an idiot to figure it out. I threw myself around and just hoped that one of them would stick enough to parade around as love.Â
And thatâs where your father came in. He was fun, and easy, and I connected with him instantly. (Not physically... thatâs a story for another time.) We were just friends for a long time, and then something happened and suddenly, you.Â
At first I thought you were going to spoil everything. The idiot I was in love with was finally starting to notice, and âbaby with another manâ was a surefire way to kill whatever was happening before it really started.Â
So maybe you did spoil everything, and maybe I could have been happy in that life, but this one, with you, is so much better. And I know that doesnât mean much, considering Iâm currently in a hospital dealing with âpsychological issues,â but itâs true.Â
Iâm here because I have so much hope for the future. The one with you in it. The one that only you could show me. Iâm going to fix this. Iâm going to get better. And soon, Iâm going to be back with you.Â
Reagan: I'm sorry. Please take care of yourself. Of course you need time to recuperate, please don't be embarrassed Lila, you have so much on your plate.
Reagan: I'll keep it to myself though, of course i'll help Gabe and don't feel guilty, you need to take care of yourself. That's important.
Lila: Thanks Reagan. I really appreciate it. You're welcome to come visit, though it's depressing as fuck here. Very... tranquil.
Lila: And you don't need to treat it like a secret or anything. If anyone asks where I've been, you can tell them so they don't think I'm avoiding them. I think that's actually better than me explaining it myself.
Lila: and I'm trying. I'm talking everything through with the doctors, talking in group sessions. I want to get better for Grace.
Maia: What happened to Aaron is not your fault. It's not anyone's fault, it's just unfortunate events that happened. Look I'm sorry for what happened between Aaron and I. I really am and I've hurt a lot of people because of it. I can't change what happened though, I'm sorry.
Maia: People do care about me and I care about them. But I will continue to be stubborn and not take the money from you. I don't need it.
Lila: ... I do still want to see you. I'm sorry I didn't visit you.
Maia: He's vulnerable? What about me, Lila? I'm going through a heartbreak. I've been in hospital for the past week. I've even been in Chicago with Aaron. Have you ever thought about me? Have any of you?
Maia: I can do what I want and I've changed the deal. I won't accept money from you.
Lila: I didn't want to speak for you! I'm here because I let other people dictate my narrative. I'm just telling you I made Aaron vulnerable.
Lila: Don't be stubborn, Maia! It's things like that that lead to you say stupid things like 'no one cares about you'... Which I don't accept, by the way.
Reagan: omg Lila, are you okay? Do you need anything? I'll help gabe out with grace no problem, I'm sorry, I had no idea! Can I do anything? Does dash know he's been busy and away. Do you need him? I'm sorry for the questions I'm just worried
Lila: Iâm okay. Or I will be. The doctors say itâs postpartum depression - the hormones plus the emotionally exhausting pregnancy took it out of me. Apparently I need time to recuperate.
Lila: I havenât really told anyone. Iâm sorta embarrassed about the whole thing. If you could just help Gabe with Grace that would be great. I feel guilty for not being there...
Text: hey! So I stopped by your place and called and I've texted gabe and I just haven't heard from you and just want to check in and make sure everything is okay.
Text: yeah⌠Iâm not there right now. Iâm at an inpatient facility⌠Turns out I can throw a bigger tantrum than a one month old⌠Gabeâs been swamped taking care of Grace by himselfâŚ.
They say itâs normal for new mommies. They told him itâs what they call the postpartum blues. Itâs the first time Gabeâs heard of it, so maybe it really was the best thing that she had to check herself into the hospital. He wouldnât know what to do, how to help her, how to be present the way heâs supposed to. Stepping into her room, he flashed her a smile. Because even though he felt helpless to see her in this state, he was happy to see her today. âHey,â he walked slowly to her and leaned to place a kiss on her forehead. âIâm sorry I didnât bring any food, any flowers, or any of those fancy stuff visitors bring in the movies.â @lila-eaton
When she wasnât meeting with doctors or having group therapy sessions, more often than not she was here, in her room, lying in bed as though if she had the patience, she could will the medications to start working and just feel her mood lift instantly. She knew that wasnât possible, but all the nurses kept shoving the idea of Art Therapy down her throat, as though she were a child, and didnât just have one. so in a fit of stubbornness, sheâd decided to just do nothing. Sometimes sheâd secretly write letters like Dr. Rivkin suggested - because that seemed more useful that pictures - but other times, sheâd just stare at the ceiling, thinking about what a complete and utter failure she was. This was one of those moments.Â
But Gabe felt like a ray of sunshine, even muted through her heavy clouds, so when he came, she managed the closest thing to a smile she had all day. âHi,â she closed her eyes against the sensation of his lips upon her forehead. âItâs fine. Iâve not really been all that hungry, and Iâd probably only cry when the flowers inevitably died...â It was her typical sardonic humor, but twisted by her current darkness. She just considered it a win that at least she was being honest. Sheâd promised that to Gabe. She intended to keep it.Â
His brow was as furrowed as it could be stepping into the facility. It had all the makings of a hospital without actually being one. Thought it was a place of healing. Halting in front of the reception, Alex harked softly before speaking. âIâm here to see Lila. Lila Eaton.â He said, his voice a little strained, The sergeant tried not to look too much around. Places like these presented him with unpleasant memories heâd rather not visit. But he was here on a visit. To see his friend. To see how she was. Alex worried a lot for her these days, he wanted to make sure she knew she could count on him. He was given directions to Lilaâs room, and thanked the lady before he left. Outside her door he paused, knocking softly before entering. âHi there.âÂ
Being in this place only intensified the feeling that all the walls were closing in on her. She hated it. She hated the nurses, with their patronizing smiles; the doctors, with all their talk about how what she was going through was âperfectly normalâ - she didnât want to be normal, she wanted to be better. For herself. For Gabe. For Grace. Her daughter was really the only reason why she even tolerated it. Because she wasnât going to get better on her own. She needed help.Â
The doctor had suggested writing letters, to just about anyone she could think of. She didnât have to send them, but the act of putting pen to paper would heal, Dr. Rivkin told her. And right now she was desperate for just about anything.Â
Today, the letter was to her father, so it was only fitting that Alex Hudson should come knocking on the door. She knew that Alex and her father had a falling out, but there was still a part of her she couldnât shake that had them inextricably linked. But she was trying.Â
âHi,â she smiled back, soft but genuine. That was the way everything seemed these days - always soft, always muted. âI, uh, what are you doing here?â Honestly, she hadnât been expecting any visitors other than Gabe in a miserable place like this.Â
Itâd been creeping in the back of her mind for weeks: the idea that things were going just a bit too well. And though sheâd been trying her hardest to fight it, sheâd been distancing herself. When Gabe said he wanted to spend time together as a family, sheâd say she had a paper to write, and then hole herself up in her room and cry and stress and feel like a horrible mother. And other times, when she was alone with Grace and she was crying, Lila couldnât help but cry along with her, wondering how young a daughter had to be before she could realize her mother couldnât provide her with the stability she needed. She couldnât help it. In the back of her mind, she was just waiting for that other shoe to drop.Â
And then it did. And it started an avalanche.Â
Gabe loved her. And while she knew deep down she felt the same, she couldnât muster enough to say it back. She felt... hollow - like true, mad, deep love had been scraped out of her like a now empty carton of ice cream. And then she felt like a failure, because what kind of woman couldnât love a man like Gabe, who was funny and kind and stood by her and gave her the greatest gift ever? What kind of heartless woman couldnât say it back?Â
Aaron left her. Or she left him. It didnât matter. All she knew was that she was suddenly without the best friend she had ever had. And the worst part about it was that she really didnât feel anything. Sheâd cried. Sheâd said her peace. And then it was just that familiar hollow feeling again. She hadnât even bothered to tell anyone about it. She didnât see the point.Â
After the fight, sheâd just picked herself up, taken a fifteen minute break to collect herself, and gotten back to work. It was mechanical. And it was a feeling that hadnât left her since.Â
To everyone else, she seemed perfectly fine. Sheâd smile. Sheâd laugh. Sheâd dote on Grace. But when nobody else was around, sheâd fall apart. Sometimes sheâd cry. Sometimes sheâd scream. Other times, sheâd just stare at the wall for hours, thinking about all the ways sheâd inevitably fail Grace, and planning different ways of escaping. (She felt guilty for ever having held it against Gabe - she understood now.)Â
Grace would be better off, anyway. She smiled more when Gabe was around - she clearly preferred her father. Sheâd always just squirm in Lilaâs arms, and she was convinced that the childâs cries were just slightly more desperate when Lila was the one who tended to her. So maybe there was no such thing as too young to hate your mother...Â
But it all came to a head one Thursday night. Gabe had a night class, and Kelsey had a date with Jared, and Lila and Grace were home alone. Sheâd just put Grace down for the night, and was browsing the web to try to stave off the pounding numbness in her head. She wasnât sure why she did it, but she went to the Charlton Gossip page. And thatâs when she saw it.Â
Maia and Aaron slept together.Â
She should have been furious. She should have been hurt. She should have felt something about that news, but she didnât feel anything. The numbness had taken over everything. And in that moment she knew: she had to get away. It was for the best - for everyoneâs sake.Â
She started packing immediately. Sheâd leave before anyone had the chance to talk her out of it. They wouldnât mean it anyway - itâd just be empty words. But her movements were loud and careless, and before she could realize it Grace had woken up. And started screaming in the way she only did when she realized there was no one but her mother to help her.Â
The cry pierced her soul, made her head pound, scattered her thoughts, and made her lose direction. Packing. Grace. What do you want from me?Â
âStop crying!â she pleaded desperately, not going to her child, not going anywhere. Just standing in the middle of her room with her hands over her ears trying to block out the noise. âI canât give you what you want! What do you want from me?â Her own cries now matched Graceâs.Â
She wasnât sure how long it went on - Grace crying, her pleading - but sometime later, the agony in her head was given reprieve when Gabe entered the room. She could only imagine the way it looks: Lila, cowering in a corner crying, while Grace was left screaming in her crib and a half-packed suitcase lay open on the bed.Â
There were no words she could give. No explanation. All she knew was that there was something deeply wrong with her.Â
She didnât leave her little corner. She wouldnât let anyone get near her. All she did was cry and rock herself, repeating the same phrase over and over again. âSomethingâs wrong with me. Somethingâs wrong with me. Somethingâs wrong with me.âÂ
Her words were hitting him and he didnât know what to do. Tears wouldnât stop streaming down his face and it was the first time he had cried in ages. He hadnât even cried over his dad but thisâŚthis brought him more pain than he could have ever wanted. âN-no, Lila please, please, I canâtâŚI canât lose youâŚI canât.â His tone was desperate and he was full on crying at this point, his voice hoarse as he reached out for her. âI donât hate you, I love you, I love you so fucking much, p-please donât leave me, Lila. I need you, okay? I need you.â He was at the point where he was practically kneeling in front of her. âY-you are home for me, though. You always have been. Youâre my family, Lila. My family and IâŚI c-canâtâŚI canât lose you, please I donât know what Iâd do.â He didnât even know if his words were coming out right as some of them got caught in his throat. He took a hold of her hands and brought them to his lips. âPlease donât leave me, Lila. I canât..I canât do any of this without you. You mean the world to me. You mean everything to me. I love you so much, please.â
The sight of Aaron breaking down in front of her, crying like his whole world was falling apart, would forever be one of the worst moments of her life. The vision would haunt her for as long as she lived. She wanted to take it all back - she was so close to - but she truly believed she was doing the right thing. It hurt like hell, but this was for the best. One day Aaron would see that. âI love you too,â she pulled him up to meet her eyes, but she didnât let him go. âI love you enough to let you go. You have to let me go.âÂ
But she wasnât ready yet. She allowed herself one last indulgence. She gave herself five more seconds in his arms.Â
Five.Â
She closed her eyes, trying to just commit every part of him to memory.Â
Four.Â
The smell of him. The way it had been her easiest comfort for so long. She used to joke that he stank - she never meant it.Â
Three.Â
The sound of him. Even through his sobs, she heard the steady beat of his heart in his chest. She remembered the sound of his laughter, which had always been so sweet; his snores when he fell asleep during their movie fests; each word that fell from his lips. She was never an artist, but from those noises she could compose a symphony.Â
Two.Â
The feel of him. All the nights sheâd spent snuggled up next to him; she should have savored them more. The comfort of his presence; she would never even attempt to find another. Everything that just encapsulated him - her Aaron, her boy genius; she was grateful for every moment.Â
One.Â
And she stepped away.Â
âYou should go. You have a plane to catch...âÂ
His gut feelings were right: this was another rejection. Except this time, he expected her to not say it back. He hoped she would, but experience and their situation led him to think whatâs most likely to happen. He expected this, but that doesnât mean it didnât hurt. Heâs never felt so strongly like this to anyone, heâs never been in-love â-heâs never acknowledged the possibility of being in-love. But here he was, pouring his heart out, ready to get nothing in return. But just like the morning after their December romance, Gabe accepted it fully. Even though he doesnât really understand why she canât say it back.
Hang on, why canât she say it back? This brought curiosity to his eyes and he had subconsciously squeezed her hand affectionately tight. âWhaâwhat do you mean you canât say it back? You feel the same but youâre not sure of it? You feel the same but you promised it to someone else before me? You wanna say it back but the feeling isnât mutual? What-what is it?â He had to know. He needed to understand whatâs stopping her. If itâs because there was something wrong with him, if itâs because he lacked something, then heâd know what to improve about himself. He worked his way to earning her trust again, who says he canât do the same to improve himself?
But then again, people donât fall in-love with you because of your efforts. Thatâs not how love always works. Looking back, itâs Aaron she picked over him anyway.
She watched as his heart broke, the feeling hitting her like a thousand punches to the gut. She didnât know how Aaron had ever survived it; she didnât know if she could. She knew the risk that came from saying those words, the hurt that came from their rejection. They always were two bird of a feather, her and Gabe, reckless and fearless, always one foot over the precipice without a safety net. Her hand came up to brush away a stray lock of hair from his face. She knew it probably wasnât fair, showing him these small tokens of affection when she couldnât give him the one thing he truly wanted, but she needed him to know it wasnât his love she was rejecting; it was her own.Â
âItâs not you,â she assured him, squeezing his hand back instinctively while her other hand stroked at his cheek. âAnd I know thatâs super lame, pulling the âitâs not you, itâs meâ thing, but itâs true. There was just... a lot that happened last year. Things that had nothing to do with you.â She could sense his insecurity - it made her sick because Gabe had done more than enough to prove himself. With all the uncertainty in her life now, he was the one constant. âThings just got really out of hand. Everything with Aaron- I just, I canât let that happen with you. Bad things happen when I say love. You are the one thing I am absolutely sure of, and I canât risk that. Whatever... feelings, I have for you, no mater how strong, I canât let them jeopardize what we have. But itâs not you,â she repeated. She needed him to know that. âI wish Iâd met you first,â she admitted, echoing the words sheâd said all those many months ago. But they were different now. Aaron didnât own her heart, heâd just wrecked it. âI know you would have taken care of it better...â And I could have given it to you easily. I know that now.Â