do you have anything on syntax? i'm currently in the middle of writing a story that uses old and modern magic, and i want to emphasize the differences in syntax. thanks 🫶
Syntax - the study of sentence structure.
In spoken and written language, syntax refers to the set of rules that determines the arrangement of words in a sentence.
Along with diction, it is one of the key ways writers convey meaning in a text.
Comes from the Ancient Greek for “coordination” or “ordering together.”
Syntax is the part of grammar that pertains to a speaker’s knowledge of sentences and their structures.
Any speaker of any human language can produce and understand an infinite number of possible sentences.
Thus, we can’t possibly have a mental dictionary of all the possible sentences.
Rather, we have the rules for forming sentences stored in our brains.
Essential Rules of Syntax in the English Language
The rules of syntax can be quite complex and vary greatly by language (as well as by time period and place). Depending on the language you are speaking or writing in, these rules might be very restrictive, or quite flexible.
There are 4 baseline rules when it comes to English syntax:
A complete sentence requires a subject and a verb and expresses a complete thought. This is also called an independent clause. A sentence without a subject and a verb is considered a fragment.
Separate ideas generally require separate sentences. A sentence containing multiple independent clauses that are improperly joined is considered a run-on sentence.
English word order follows the subject-verb-object sequence. (It’s usually the same in French and Spanish.)
A dependent clause contains a subject and a verb—but it doesn’t express a complete thought.
The Rules of Syntax. Combine words into phrases & phrases into sentences.
They specify the correct word order for a language. [Example: English is a Subject-Verb-Object (SVO) language. ✓ "The President nominated a new Supreme Court justice." ✗ "President the new Supreme justice Court a nominated."
They also describe the relationship between the meaning of a group of words and the arrangement of the words. [Example: "I mean what I say" vs. "I say what I mean"]
The rules of syntax also specify the grammatical relations of a sentence, such as the subject and the direct object. [Example: "Your dog chased my cat" vs. "My cat chased your dog"]
Syntax rules specify constraints on sentences based on the verb of the sentence. ["Zack tries to be a gentleman" ✗ "Zack tries Robert to be a gentleman"]
Syntax rules also tell us how words form groups and are hierarchically ordered in a sentence. [Example: “The captain ordered the old men and women of the ship”]
This sentence has 2 possible meanings:
The captain ordered the old men and the old women of the ship.
The captain ordered the old men and the women of any age of the ship.
The meanings depend on how the words in the sentence are grouped (specifically, to which words is the adjective ‘old’ applied?):
The captain ordered the [old (men and women)] of the ship
The captain ordered the [old men] and [women] of the ship
These groupings can be shown hierarchically in a tree:
These trees reveal the structural ambiguity in the phrase “old men and women”. Each structure corresponds to a different meaning.
Structurally ambiguous sentences can often be humorous:
Catcher: “Watch out for this guy, he’s a great fastball hitter.”
Pitcher: “No problem. There’s no way I’ve got a great fastball.”
UG Principles and Parameters. Universal Grammar (UG) provides the basic design for all languages, and each language has its own parameters, or variations on the basic plan.
All languages have structures that conform to X-bar schema*
All phrases consist of specifiers, heads, and complements
All sentences are headed by T**
All languages seem to have movement rules
However, languages have different word orders within phrases and sentences, so heads and complements may be present in different orders across languages
*The internal structure of phrasal categories can be captured using the x-bar schema:
**All sentences contain information about tense—when a certain event or state of affairs occurred, so we can say that Tense is the head of a sentence. So sentences are TPs, with T representing tense markers and modals:
Sign Language Syntax. The syntax of sign languages also follow the principles of UG and has:
Transformations such as topicalization, which moves the direct object to the beginning of a sentence for emphasis, and wh movement
Constraints on transformations
That UG is present in signed languages and spoken languages shows that the human brain is designed to learn language, not just speech.
Ways to Use Syntax in Literature
Besides being critical to conveying literal sense, syntax is also one of the key tools writers use to express meaning in a variety of ways. Syntax can help writers:
Produce rhetorical and aesthetic effects. By varying the syntax of their sentences, writers are able to produce different rhetorical and aesthetic effects. How a writer manipulates the syntax of their sentences is an important element of writing style.
Control pace and mood. Manipulating syntax is one of the ways writers control the pace and mood of their prose. For example, the writer Ernest Hemingway is known for his short, declarative sentences, which were well-suited to his terse, clear style of writing. These give his prose a forceful, direct quality.
Create atmosphere. By contrast, Hemingway’s fellow story writer and novelist William Faulkner is famous (or infamous) for his meandering, paragraph-long sentences, which often mimic the ruminative thinking of his characters. These sentences, which often ignore the standard rules of punctuation and grammar, help create an atmosphere as much as they convey information.
That said, all writers vary their sentence structure from time to time. Using a variety of sentences is one of the key ways writers engage and maintain their readers’ interest.
Sentence Types in the English Language
The English language is extraordinarily flexible when it comes to building sentences. At the same time, all sentences in English fall into 4 distinct types:
Simple sentences. Consist of a single, independent clause. For example: “The girl hit the ball.”
Compound sentences. Consist of two or more independent clauses joined by a coordinating conjunction. The coordinating conjunctions are “but,” “or,” and “so.” For example: “The girl hit the ball, and the ball flew out of the park.”
Complex sentences. Consist of an independent clause and one or more dependent clauses joined by a subordinating conjunction. Some subordinating conjunctions are “although,” “because,” “so,” “that,” and “until.” For example: “When the girl hit the ball, the fans cheered.”
Compound-complex sentences. Consist of multiple independent clauses as well as at least one dependent clause. For example: “When the girl hit the ball, the fans cheered, and the ball flew out of the park.”
Syntax Examples in Literature
To get a sense of some of the ways writers use syntax to express meaning, it’s worthwhile examining a few famous examples from literature.
Moby Dick, by Herman Melville (1851). Melville begins with this famous line: “Call me Ishmael.” This first line—one of the most famous in literature—is short and direct. The sentences that follow, though, are significantly more sophisticated. In the fourth sentence, Melville uses a number of dependent clauses (“Whenever I find myself growing grim about the mouth,” “Whenever it is a damp, drizzly November in my soul,” and so on) to create a sense of anticipation.
Anna Karenina, by Leo Tolstoy (1877). Tolstoy’s novel begins: “Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.” This is actually two simple sentences joined by a semi-colon. Tolstoy could easily have just written them as separate sentences, but by joining them into one sentence he shows that these two thoughts are related and balanced.
Sources: 1 2 3 ⚜ More: Notes & References ⚜ Writing Resources PDFs
You can find more details and examples in the sources. All the best with your writing <3