Dean Smith and Repressed Queerness in 'It's a Wonderful Lie' (spn 4x17)
It is so fascinating how in a childhood where Dean is raised by Bobby and Ellen, Dean is not repressed in terms of expressing traits that our Dean would associate with femininity and queerness. Eating salads, watching Project Runway, dressing like Ken. He is seemingly metrosexual.
However, when he thinks that Sam is like propositioning him in the elevator or something, he gets defensive, telling him to save it for the health club, and the second time, he tells Sam that he's "not into that stuff."
He is totally unrepressed except when it comes to potentially being queer, and then he goes back to being homophobic-ish, associating queerness with health club in a clearly stereotypy way, trying to emasculate Sam.
Dean Smith is like later seasons Dean, not repressed in terms of what he allows himself to enjoy (clothes, food) except when it comes to his sexuality.
I don't know why people say that Dean Smith is like bi (and open about it) just because he's fine with like watching Project Runway. That feeds on negative stereotypes just like the pink panties thing. That is not what makes him queer y'all. He reads as bi (and closeted to me) because he was so like overly reactive to thinking Sam was hitting on him.
I know you could argue that he was into men and was saying that he wasn't into office romances or like just for story reasons not into his brother, but I don't know that his response to Sam was that of an openly queer man. Still, of course he didn't say he was straight yet again.
Though he could be for the purpose of this episode. It is an alternate universe, and he could just be a homophobic metrosexual dude. He just seems to be overcompensating in a very canon Dean way when it comes to his sexuality.
This episode also shows again how he can never really live a classic American life where he's anything but a hunter even if he wants to because deep down inside he always will want to hunt, which in itself is queercoded in a Buffy way. Yes, he does find himself unhappy in his office life, but he wanted that stability. Still, he finds himself quitting because hunting makes him happy. He wants to live a white picket fence life but knows he never will and makes peace with that. Very queercoded.
(Though I do think he's more like Faith lol. A gender swap episode with Eliza Dushku playing Dean would have been great.)