Stand-In Soldier
John Walker x Fem!Reader
Description: You come back to the tower after another shitty date with your loser boyfriend and John is there to make things right.
CW: Mentions of sex (no smut), cursing, cheating (Let me know if I missed anything!)
Word Count: 2.4K
Your bag flew across the living room into a corner you didn’t care to look for. An inhuman grunt rang out as you threw yourself onto the large couch. You hadn’t thought your date would go exactly as planned; in fact, it was foolish to think so with your boyfriend. On top of being late and making you pay for half your meal, you left the bathroom to find him flirting with the waitress, tucking a 10 into her plunging neckline. She laughed giddily, running her manicured nails across his shoulder. You didn’t want to touch him for the rest of the night. The sex was mediocre anyway, nothing to write home about.
You reminisced plainly with your face buried in the couch cushions. No part of you bothered to sugarcoat the harsh reality that your boyfriend was a dick. You met him not long after caving and downloading the most reputable dating app you could find that would hopefully not steal your IP address. Swiping a few times rarely got you past a cheap pickup line or the rare dick pick right off the bat. It was hard not to feel unwanted in the hopelessness of modern dating, all until Frank messaged you. Yes, his name was stupid, and yes, his mustache was most definitely performative and not a true reflection of his character, but in the fog of desperation, you agreed to meet up. He had miraculously paid for the first date, placing his overdrawn credit card on the receipt tray. After that, it drawled incredibly downhill.
Most of the time, dates consisted of him playing his guitar at you, cooking a mediocre plate of dry chicken and rice (for the macros, he explained), and spending a dazzling eight minutes rubbing your pelvic bone and asking if you finished. Faking it became the go-to. You painfully feigned interest in his ‘blooming music career’, shoved down every piece of chicken with not a hint of even pepper, and of course, faked an orgasm to escape into the shower while he slept. That was where you would tap through your phone, snoop through his 3 in 1 soaps, and occasionally cry.
It was tedious. Your friends consistently inquired why you didn’t just leave the loser, but it wasn’t like you had any more suitors sending calling cards.
One night after your magical ten minutes, Frank passed out on his mattress on the floor (yes, no bed frame), and you snuck into the bathroom. It was dark, but a small mirror light illuminated just enough to see your reflection. You were still half clothed, t-shirt tugged lazily to the side, just barely covering your legs. You looked like hell. It had been ages since you had seen any sort of post-sex glow on yourself, and it seemed futile to hope for it. Your makeup was smudged and worn, and you started to feel bad for even putting any effort into it. Frank never noticed.
You weren’t sure what overcame you in that moment that was so overwhelming, but overlooking yourself, all you could do was cry. It wasn’t a deep cry. No thick gasps or sobs came out of you, but even still, warm tears fell down your cheeks on their own volition. It was quiet, so much so that you could still hear Frank snoring in the other room. Frank. You didn’t want to be around him at that moment. You wanted to leave, to pick up your clothes and go home. This crying was just PMS hormones; you would be fine in the morning, but Frank was the one who picked you up. In the foreseeable future, you were stuck there.
Leaning over the sink and clicking open your phone, your body moved by itself. Maybe you could call Yelena to pick you up, or perhaps Alexei’s father instinct would kick in and he would drive over to get you. However, even with all these ideas flying through your consciousness, your fingers still shakily crossed the screen to his name.
John.
You tapped along the screen without expecting a response; you just wanted to cast your line and see if you would miraculously get a bite.
Not an emergency, but can you come get me? At Frank’s.
Your phone shut off with your tears. Starting to feel guilty for probably waking John in the first place, you wiped off your makeup and ran a shower. You took off the rest of your clothes and crawled into the shower you should probably be wearing shoes in. There was no soap, and to be honest, you didn’t want to touch his if it was there; you just let the water run over your cold skin.
Not ten minutes later, your phone buzzed with a text.
John: I’m outside
You two never talked about it again. It was months ago, and, to be honest, you were slightly embarrassed. Why in the world did you panic-text your friend (tower-mate?) to pick you up from your boyfriend's house like you had a bad sleepover? It was a silent agreement between both of you that you would never talk about it again.
You rolled back onto your side on the couch, dress riding up that Frank didn’t even comment on, despite being brand new. You didn’t even bother to take off the heels that Val would inevitably be on your ass about. No “getting dirty shoes on brand new couches.” Val could suck your dick.
In your moping stupor, you didn’t even hear the commotion in the kitchen. Lifting your head like an injured horse, you peered across the room to see John in his sweats and an old Army t-shirt. Based on his instinctive response, you could have sworn he felt your eyes on him.
“Oh, hey. I didn’t see you there.” He pulled a pot from the cabinet, shooting a small smile in your direction. His eyes combed over the rest of the couch. “New outfit.”
“Well, at least someone noticed.” You smiled slightly for the first time that night.
“What, that fucker didn’t notice again?” He turned towards the sink, filling the pot with water. Without looking up, he responded with a quick, “Sorry.” You doubted he really meant that second half.
“It’s fine. I guess I kind of hoped he would notice the dress he’d hopefully be taking off.”
“I’m assuming he didn’t?”
“Well, my hair is still done, and my boob tape is in tact, so yeah.” You grinned through your jeering statement. “All I did was suck him off in the parking garage before he dropped me off.”
“What an asshole.” John’s voice grew more critical as he started up the gas stove.
“It’s whatever.”
“It’s not how you treat a woman.” He tossed back quickly.
“I mean, it’s how HE treats a woman. Besides, he’s my boyfriend, I want to.”
“Yeah but, I mean, think about it. When was the last time you came home with your hair and boob tape undone?”
You laughed at the bluntness of his analysis. His face seemed to brighten at the sound of your laugh.
“There she is.” He replied.
You sat up, suddenly revitalized and making your way to the kitchen. “Cooking dinner?”
“Yeah, just chicken alfredo, nothing crazy.” He grabbed a fistful of pasta from the box.
“That’s a lot for one.”
“I was makin’ extra. I know you like it. Besides, I’m assuming he didn’t feed you tonight?”
“Just restaurant food I had to pay for.”
“Jeez.” He tossed a little extra into the pot.
“Need any help?” You started to feel bad watching John cook the food all for you. Usually, you would step in and help Frank with most of it. He preferred to play his stupid guitar while you cooked. He single-handedly ruined ‘Slide’ for you.
“I won’t tell you no, but you don’t have to.” His bluntness didn’t feel like chiding; in fact, it felt like the chivalry you hadn’t felt in ages. It was nice. “You can grab the spices.” His eyes drifted to the cabinet to the left.
“Opening a spice cabinet feels good.” You joked, picking out the bottles of oregano and parsley. “Frank says food isn’t for enjoying.”
John didn’t say any words, but his eyes said it all: an overwhelming distaste for your boyfriend. You loved cooking with John. It was such a stark contrast to your experiences with Frank. There was no yelling or shitty guitar covers to distract you from the long-lost camaraderie you had felt devoid of. John slow-cooked the chicken in a concoction of butter, garlic, and a multitude of spices you could only chalk up to southern cooking. The aroma in and of itself was enough to make your eyes water in anticipation. He skillfully created a sauce from scratch, reminding you that you had simply forgotten sauce could come from something other than a jar. You watched in awe, wondering if he might have been a chef before being a super soldier. It was somehow just what you needed to forget your shitty date.
You were glued to his side by the time he was plating the dinner. The steam rose perfectly from the plates, twirling in a cartoonish swirl.
“It smells amazing, John.” You bet he could hear the smile on your lips.
“I know.” He grinned facetiously as he topped it off with a sprinkle of parsley and parmesan cheese. The smell alone made you want to cry with overwhelming joy, but the actual sight of a plate of food cooked with you in mind and heart sent you over the edge.
You leaned your body against him as you stood side by side, shoulders shaking with a strange mix of a laugh and a cry. You were prepared to reassure John that you were fine and just hopped up on stress and food euphoria, but that moment never came; He simply slid the plate towards you and rubbed your arm gently, releasing with a slight squeeze.
You ate in silence. The occasional thank you fell from your lips as you inhaled the food in front of you. It was weird — almost intimate the way you ravaged the food in unison, satiating your hunger. What stopped you from doing this for so long? You answered your own question: you didn’t think you deserved it. No men were lining up to court you, and even when they did, it just ended up being Frank. There had to be a reason. There had to be something ordained to keep you from ever fully experiencing this kinship.
“Want a drink?” John scooped up the now-empty dishes bringing them to the dishwasher.
“Sure.” You stood in the middle of the kitchen as he walked circles around you, going from the sink to wash the pot and the cabinet to grab glasses and some fancy bottle of whiskey. You thought for a moment that you could get used to this, but swiftly dismissed the idea.
“So,” John took a sip from his glass. “Bad date tonight, huh?”
You raised your own glass to your lips, taking a long sip of the golden liquid. “It’s whatever.”
“Stop sayin’ that.” He replied almost sternly. “It’s not whatever; half the reason you’re still in this mess is because you talk like that.”
“Like what exactly?” You looked at him incredulously, glass forgotten in your slack hand.
“Like this is the best you can get. Hate to break it to you sweetheart, but Frank isn’t the baseline, he’s just an asshole.” His face quirked into that sickening smile that usually meant there was some truth in his chiding.
“Well, sweetheart,” You began, muscles tensing under the gaze of his blue eyes. “He’s my boyfriend. The first in years, might I remind you. Maybe he’s an asshole sometimes, but everyone is.” Your tone grew stern. “At the end of the day, he chose me and invested in me.” You could feel your throat start to tighten in that familiar way that meant you were about to cry.
“I just watched you cry because I put butter in your food.” John shot back, an unfortunate amount of truth in his voice. “That’s more investment than I’ve seen him give you in months.” He took a sip from his glass. “And it cost 98 cents.”
You turned away, exasperated. Was he really doing this? Was he really going to pick apart your relationship as if he had any room to make that analysis?
“Why do you care?”
“I picked you up sobbing from his shitty apartment.” He spat out the words like he was holding them back.
“Don’t…”
“I mean,” An exasperated hand ran through his messy blonde hair. “Fuckin’ hell, I wanted to tell you to dump him right there.”
The silence fell thick over the room. You stared at him with a confusing mix of disappointment, anger, and acknowledgment; you didn’t know what shone through the most.
“You deserve good food, and to get your hair and boob taped messed up once in a while.” His voice rose in conviction. “Hell, you at least deserve sex that lasts more than 8 minutes.”
Your arms were crossed indignantly as you stared right through him. Through the misty haze of conflict, your eyes started to bead with tears.
“I just,” You began. “I don’t know what to do.” A breaking confession fell from your lips. The moment the sobbing sound fell on John’s ears, he pulled you tightly into his chest. No words were spoken, no snide remarks of criticism passed between you two, he just—with the gentleness of a lover—held you tightly against him as you cried. You didn’t know when your sobbing subsided, but at some point in the seemingly endless time you stood wrapped in his arms, you could feel the damp spots you left on his shirt cease to grow any further. A small sniffle escaped you as you lifted your head up to look at him. ‘Warm,’ you thought, peering into his furrowed brow, taking all the time in the world to drop your gaze. As your gaze settled, two firm hands ghosted over your cheek and lifted you into a kiss.
You took in a deep breath as his lips met your own, hands sliding across his body as if you were trying to memorize it. Your bodies seemingly melted into one another, curling along each bend of one another’s form. John pulled away first.
“I’m sorry, we shouldn’t-“ He swallowed hard. “You have a boyfriend.”
“John,” You looked up at him, panting. “Forget about Frank.”
His eyes glinted as if you had given him all the permission he needed.
“Gladly.”
Hope you enjoyed! Who knows, maybe I will do a part 2...









