“Having It All” Is a Big Ugly Lie
I know, I know, I’m probably the one millionth person to make this groundbreaking statement.
Still...it’s true. It’s a lie to say that women can have it all. But it’s a lie that goes deeper than just the very obvious fact that it’s impossible.
It’s a lie that hides in plain sight. In the very language we use to describe the thing that so many working mothers have been exhausting ourselves in the never-ending pursuit to achieve.
I don’t pretend to speak for every working mother, but when I’m busy “having it all,” it doesn’t usually feel I’m “having” anything.
While I’m in the middle of answering emails, playing dress-up, making dinner, and prepping for client presentations, I feel like I’m doing and giving and being a lot, but “having”? Not so much.
Maybe that’s because, too often, I’ve defined “having it all” as “having responsibility for it all.” As “having to deal with it all.” Or, sometimes, “having to pretend that I don’t feel like saying ‘fuck it all.’”
From the conversations I’ve had over a-few-too-many glasses of wine with other working moms, in those precious moments when we try to jam in some communal “self care” after the kids are asleep, I get the feeling I’m not the only one.
We’re all so busy doing, giving, and being it all, that we don’t stop for a moment to ask ourselves what we’re getting out of the deal. But, every once in a while, in rare moments, a little voice inside us pipes up and asks, “Is this really what you wanted?”
And we laugh, commiserate with our friends, perhaps make a joking toast to “having it all!” Then we pour another glass of wine and we tell that little voice to shut the fuck up and leave us alone because we are doing the best we can.
But...I’ve started listening to that little voice. And it has some pretty damn interesting things to say.
Here’s what I’m beginning to believe (intellectually if not always instinctively): Having it all is possible. Except we’ve spent our entire lives being taught that having isn’t something we’re allowed to do. Not if we’ve got two x chromosomes and several generations of martyrdom showing us the ropes.
What we call “having,” that’s not what having means.
Having doesn’t mean doing. It doesn’t mean giving.
Having it all doesn’t mean being performing at home AND at work. It doesn’t mean being an excellent mother AND a strong, sexy wife. Having means taking. It means receiving. It means accepting. It means owning. Having isn’t about what you do for your company or your children or your spouse. It’s about determining who you are to yourself. It’s about knowing what matters to you. It’s about knowing what you want, what you need. And it’s about expecting that you will get it.
Having it all doesn’t mean going on vacation and finding yourself on a conference call while simultaneously doing dishes in the kitchen and angrily wondering why you are the only one on the planet capable of making a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. It means going on vacation and GOING ON VACATION. It means saying “I’m not available this week” and for the love of god it means doing that and NOT SAYING SORRY. Having means knowing that your time off isn’t a gift. It’s something you’ve earned. And you have a right to take that time without apologizing to anyone for doing so. Even if things are busy. Even if it feels like the company will fall apart without you. It probably won’t. But even if it does, “having it all” means knowing that IT. IS. NOT. YOUR. PROBLEM. But you know what? “Having it all” also means having the right to say, “I really want to take this conference call. It’s important to me and you all are going to have to figure out what to do with yourselves until I’m done.” And sometimes “having it all” means putting down the phone, putting down the peanut butter-covered knife, leaving everyone to their own devices and going down to the beach and reading a fucking novel without having to look up every three sentences to make sure someone isn’t drowning or to say “OHH WOW WHAT A PRETTY SEASHELL.” And “having it all” means that, NO, YOU ARE NOT SORRY.
We say we are sorry because we’ve all been taught that sorry is what we’re supposed to be all of the time, but what the fuck do we have to be sorry for?
Why do so many of us feel like we need to ask forgiveness for wanting things?
Why do so many of us we feel like we have to ask permission from our employers, from our spouses, from our freaking toddlers, to have our own needs and desires? I know this is reductive. I know our husbands do so much more than our mothers’ husbands ever did. I know that even being able to consider exercising my right to have is a reflection of privilege that too many mothers don’t have the money or support to enjoy. I know it’s a complicated issue and it’s something that affects every working parent, not just mothers. But I also know that most of the fathers I know aren’t saddled with the guilt I hear in the voices of my mother friends. I don’t hear the fathers I know worrying that no matter how much they do or give, it’s never going to be enough. And, if they do express those things, I don’t hear them turning that reality into self-hatred. I don’t see them drawing a conclusion that there’s something deeply wrong with them because they can’t do or give or be it all. And just because things are better for some of us than for others doesn’t mean that we’re not working in a bullshit, broken system. And it doesn’t mean that we can’t stand up and call it out for what it is. Bullshit. I don’t know know why or how or when we got the idea that we weren’t allowed to take as much as we give. And, frankly, I’m not super interested in digging into the whys or hows or whens. All I know is that, all this time, when we thought we were having it all, we somehow ended up, once again, giving ourselves away.
So, ladies, I’d like to propose a toast: HERE’S. TO. HAVING. IT. ALL. FOR REAL.
(Image credit: Yaskii for WorkingMother.com. Also, the lady in the illustration cracks me up. Is that zen motherhood? Or is she just a worn-out zombie, who’s like “Fuck it, kid. Have your binkie. Mama’s on the phone with a client”?)









