Night Terrors [Ch. 4}
Pairing: AFAB!Reader x Yandere!Batfamily
Summary: A woman wakes in a mansion she doesnât belong to and discovers that escaping it means stepping into a city that shouldnât exist.
Words: 7k
Content Warning: Disorientation, Identity confusion, Emotional Distress, Panic, Existential Dread, and Mild language, Claustrophobia, Stalking, Paranoia, Creepy Old Men, Idk, Use of Y/N
A/N: Last update for tn :)
Prologue | Previous Chapter | Next Chapter
Y/N sat at the kitchen island, her hands trembling faintly around the mug Alfred had placed in front of her. The smell of hot chocolate, rich, warm, and comforting, didnât do much to ground her, but Alfredâs steady presence beside her helped.
Dick sat close, elbows on his knees, watching her face like he could read every flicker of emotion that passed through it. Jason lingered in the corner, arms crossed, leaning against the wall near the doorway. He looked like he wanted to be anywhere else, but the muscle in his jaw kept ticking, betraying that he was just as unsettled as the rest of them.
Alfred broke the silence first, his voice low but measured.
âMiss Y/N, perhaps you can tell us what exactly happened.â
She blinked down at her drink, the reflection of the kitchen lights shaking with each tiny tremor in her hands. âItâs⊠I donât know,â she said softly. âIt justâŠit freaked me out. The letter, the handwriting. It was addressed to someone that doesnât even exist.â
Dickâs brows knit together. âHow would he even know that name?â
That made Jason push off the wall. âBetter question: howâd he get that letter in the damn car?â
Alfredâs face tightened at that. He was trying not to show it, but she could see the worry working its way into the corners of his eyes. âI inspected the vehicle myself this morning,â he murmured. âThere was no sign of tampering.â
âSo either he got to it before she even left,â Jason muttered, pacing slowly, âor heâs good enough to do it without being seen.â
Y/N tried to follow the conversation, but it all meshed into a blur. The mug in her hands was warm, grounding, but her head felt stuffed with cotton. Every word, every sound came through the fog.
Jasonâs voice broke through, sharp but not cruel. âLook,â he said, coming to stand a few feet from her. âYou gotta be straight with us now. This isnât something you can just handle on your own anymore. Whatever this is, itâs serious.â
She looked up at him, tired eyes rimmed red. âIâm not lying.â
âI didnât say you were,â Jason replied, softer now, though his tone still carried an edge. âIâm saying you canât keep things to yourself. Not when youâve got people worried sick.â His gaze flicked toward Alfred, who was busying himself with tidying the already immaculate counter.
Y/N hesitated, chewing at the inside of her cheek. âI met him at Ink and Steam. The bookstore.â
Dick leaned forward slightly. âThe one off downtown?â
She nodded faintly. âYeah. He⊠he was weird from the start, I guess. Talked about wanting to leave an imprint on people. He said his name was Thomas. I thought it was just a strange conversation until he started showing up everywhere. Coffee shop. Grocery store. Just⊠places I went.â
Dickâs eyes hardened. Alfred looked like someone had knocked the breath out of him.
âAnd you never mentioned this to anyone?â Alfred asked quietly.
âI didnât think it was serious,â she murmured. âAnd I didnât want toâŠâ She stopped herself, glancing away. Didnât want to make you worry. But she didnât say it out loud.
Jason muttered something under his breath, running a hand through his hair. âGreat. So weâve got a stalker whoâs playing shadow games and writing creepy notes.â
Y/N tried to take another sip of her drink, but her eyelids fluttered, heavy now that the adrenaline had started to drain from her system.
Dick noticed first. âHey,â he said softly. âYouâre wiped out.â
âIâm fine,â she murmured, though her words slurred slightly.
He stood and gently took the mug from her hands before she could protest again. âCâmon.â
Jason stepped aside as Dick guided her up, one arm braced around her shoulders. She barely had the energy to argue. The hallway lights blurred into soft streaks as he led her upstairs.
In her room, Dick helped her sit on the bed before pulling the blanket over her. She looked dazed, almost weightless, eyes unfocused as exhaustion swallowed her whole.
âHey,â he said quietly, crouching beside the bed. âYouâre safe here. You hear me?â
Y/N nodded faintly, curling under the blanket.
Dick lingered for a long moment, his expression unreadable. Then, gently, he leaned forward, pressing his forehead against hers. His voice was low, barely above a whisper.
âIâm sorry I didnât see it sooner,â he said. âIâve been too caught up in everything else. I told myself you were fine because I wanted it to be true. But I promise you this... No oneâs ever gonna hurt you again. Not while Iâm still breathing.â
His throat tightened, and for a split second, he was eight years old againâkneeling on the cold ground under the circus lights, staring at two still forms, swearing to himself heâd never let anyone else he loved get hurt.
Not again.
He stayed there until her breathing evened out, quiet and steady against his shoulder, before finally pulling back. He brushed a strand of hair from her face, then stood and left the room without a sound, his promise echoing silently in his chest.
The elevator doors hissed open, the sound of hydraulics echoing off cold concrete. Bruce strode into the Batcave, his steps heavy, his jaw tight. The tension rolled off him in wavesâthe kind that meant something had gone wrong topside.
âReport,â he said flatly, not even looking up as he stripped off his jacket and tossed it across the console chair. âAre we ready for the drop tonight?â
Tim, whoâd been hunched over the main workstation, froze. His fingers hovered uncertainly over the keyboard. âUh⊠mostly.â
Bruceâs head snapped up. âMostly?â
There was steel in the word, enough to make Timâs shoulders tense. âIâm missing a few things,â he said quickly, âbut I canââ
âWhat things?â Bruceâs tone was clipped. âYouâve had the files since last night. Weâve been planning this for a week. What could possibly be missing?â
Tim hesitated, glancing at Alfred, who was standing near the med bay with a faint frown. âI was helping Alfred with something,â he said finally.
That made Bruce turn fully. His glare was sharp enough to cut glass. âHelping Alfred?â
Alfred drew in a quiet breath, already anticipating where this was going. âIf I may, Master Bruce...â
But Bruce was already pushing forward. âTim,â he said, voice low but cold, âweâre talking about a major drug operation moving through the Narrows tonight. I need you focused. And youâre telling me youâre behind because you were⊠helping with house matters?â
Tim winced. âItâs not just house matters,â he muttered. âItâs Y/N. Sheâs got someone following her.â
Alfred wasted no time trying to cover for Tim; after all, it was he who had asked. âJust today she received a letter, it rattled her quite badly.â
That gave Bruce pause, but only for a heartbeat. His expression didnât soften. Alfred, you shouldâve brought it to me if it was that serious.â
âI tried,â Alfred said evenly, though there was the faintest edge beneath the calm. âBut you were rather preoccupied with the case.â
âI am preoccupied,â Bruce snapped. âBecause this city doesnât stop burning just because someone left an anonymous note in her car.â
That hit harder than he realized. Dick, who had been standing off to the side cleaning his gauntlets, straightened abruptly. âYou think this is about an anonymous note?â
âFrom what Iâve heard,â Bruce said without turning, âitâs vague. No name. No confirmed threat. You canât expect me to divert the team for something like that whenâŠâ
âSomething like that?â Dickâs voice rose before he could stop it. âBruce, sheâs terrified. Sheâs barely been sleeping, sheâs not eating, and some psycho got close enough to leave something in the damn car. You think thatâs nothing?â
Jason, standing near the stairs, crossed his arms but didnât interrupt. His eyes flicked between them, unreadable.
Bruceâs tone stayed even, but it grew sharper. âIâm saying we have to prioritize. The city comes first.â
Alfredâs composure finally cracked. âAnd what of your family, sir? When do they come first?â
The words hung in the air like a slap.
Even Barbara, her face lit in blue on the comm screen, frowned deeply. âBruce,â she said through the speakers, âyou might want to rethink how youâre phrasing that. Weâre talking about your daughter. Sheâs in danger, whether you think itâs minor or not.â
Bruceâs jaw tightened. He didnât respond right away. He just stared at the tactical display on the screen, watching as red lines traced the routes of the dealers they were supposed to intercept tonight.
Finally, he exhaled slowly through his nose. âWeâll discuss it later.â
âBruceâŠâ Dick started.
âLater,â Bruce repeated, voice firm enough to end the argument. âWe move on the drop at twenty-three hundred. Cassandra and Stephanie will handle ground surveillance. I want eyes on the secondary routes and all comms open.â
Barbaraâs sigh crackled through the speaker. âCopy that. Cass and Steph are already en route.â
Bruce nodded once. âGood. Tim, you and Jason stay here and monitor. Alfred, make sure the feeds stay up. I donât want interference.â
No one said anything after that.
Bruce turned, the cape on his back catching the cave lights as he walked toward the Batmobile. The sound of his boots echoed against the rock, heavy and final.
As the car roared to life and the noise filled the cavern, Dick muttered under his breath, âYeah. Weâll talk later. Sure.â
Jason shoved his hands into his pockets, scowling. âHeâs got a one-track mind. Always has.â
Alfred stood a few feet away, face drawn, the faint tremor of anger replaced by something heavier, worry and exhaustion.
Tim looked back at the screen, where Barbaraâs face lingered before she cut the feed. âIâll keep working on the footage,â he murmured. âMaybe thereâs something we missed.â
âDo that,â Alfred said quietly. âBecause I fear the situation is far from over.â
The night at the docks was cold and heavy with fog, the kind that clung to the skin and dulled the sound of footsteps. Gotham Harbor slept in patches of shadow and sodium light, cranes and shipping containers looming like skeletal giants under the low clouds. The smell of salt and oil filled the air.
Bruce crouched on the edge of a corrugated rooftop overlooking the loading yard, his eyes tracking the movement below. A dozen men in dark jackets moved crates off an unmarked truck. The sound of muffled grunts and the metallic clink of crowbars carried through the mist.
âConfirmed,â Stephanieâs voice came through the comms, steady and low. âItâs Venom. I count fourteen in the open, three near the truck cab, maybe more inside.â
âCopy,â Bruce replied. His tone was clipped, controlled. âCassandra, take the north perimeter. Steph, on my mark, move in with me. Dickâs approaching from the east.â
Cassandra didnât respond with words, just the faintest static crackle, the sound she made when she acknowledged orders. Bruce watched her form melt into the fog below, silent and swift as smoke.
From the far end of the dock, Dickâs grapnel line hissed as he swung down onto a stack of containers, landing in a crouch. âGot eyes on your left flank, B,â he said over the comm. âLooks like theyâre packing more than usual tonight.â
Bruce grunted quietly. âTheyâve been consolidating supply since the last raid. This must be the main hub.â
Stephanie perched on the railing beside him, her purple hood pulled low. The glow from a nearby floodlight caught the edge of her mask. âYou ever think maybe Gotham just likes being poisoned?â she muttered. âFeels like for every one of these rings we take down, two more pop up.â
âThen we take those down too,â Bruce said simply.
Steph rolled her eyes under the mask but tightened her gloves. âYeah, yeah. Eternal crusade, no sleep, no fun. Got it.â
âFocus,â Bruce ordered.
She grinned under her breath. âAlways.â
Down below, one of the dealers barked something at his crew. A crate lid clattered to the ground. The fog shifted just enough for Bruce to spot the glint of gunmetal. He tapped his comm twice.
âNow.â
The world exploded into motion.
Cassandra struck first; a blur of black and movement, taking down two men before anyone even registered her presence. Oneâs body hit the concrete with a dull crack. The otherâs weapon flew into the harbor with a splash.
Dick dove from the container stack, his escrima sticks sparking as they met the first manâs rifle. âEvening, boys!â he called out, ducking a swing and flipping the guy onto a pallet of crates. âYou missed your shipment deadline.â
Bruce dropped from above, his cape spreading wide before he landed squarely in the center of the chaos. The impact made the ground shudder. Two men turned, raising their guns, but Bruce was already there: one arm blocking, the other driving a heavy punch that sent the first man sprawling.
Stephanie hit the dock behind him, kicking a third dealer square in the back before he could draw his pistol. âYou know,â she said between hits, âyou guys should really unionize. Might get better benefits than this.â
Gunfire cracked, sharp and wild, cutting through the fog.
âSteph! Cover!â Bruce barked, and she dove behind a forklift as bullets chewed through the air where sheâd been. He moved in, fast and brutal, disarming the shooter with a blow to the ribs and an elbow that broke his nose clean.
Cassandra emerged again from the smoke, landing a clean roundhouse that dropped another man instantly. She didnât speak, but her movements said everything; controlled, deliberate, efficient.
âSouth sideâs clear,â Dick reported, vaulting over a crate. He flipped his baton, knocking a gun out of another manâs hand. âYou good, Steph?â
âPeachy,â she said, popping up from cover and landing a solid kick to the last standing dealer. The man hit the dock hard and didnât move.
Within minutes, the sounds of the fight fadedâleaving only the crash of waves and the hiss of the wind between the containers.
Bruce stood at the center of it all, chest rising and falling beneath his armor. He looked over the scene: unconscious men, shattered crates, Venom vials spilling across the concrete.
Dick exhaled, running a hand through his hair. âThatâs the fourth one this month,â he muttered. âYou think itâs connected to Black Mask again?â
Bruce was silent, scanning the area. âNo. Something else is pushing distribution. Too organized.â
Steph nudged one of the crates with her boot. âThen who?â
Bruce didnât answer right away. His gaze lingered on the shadowy edge of the pierâdarkness pooling unnaturally deep between the lampposts. For just a second, he thought he saw movement. Something that didnât belong.
Then it was gone.
Cassandra stepped closer, her eyes narrowing. âYou see it too,â she said quietly.
Bruce didnât respond. He turned instead toward the Batmobile parked several blocks away, the faintest flicker of unease passing behind his stoic expression.
âBag and tag everything,â he said. âWeâll analyze it back at the cave.â
Dick and Stephanie exchanged a glance.
The fog thickened as they moved out, swallowing the last traces of the fight. The harbor lights flickered once, and in the dark water below, something shiftedâwatching them go.
The night at the docks was too quiet. Too clean. The air itself felt heavy with wrongness, the kind that settled in the gut before a fight.
Bruce crouched on the rusted edge of a shipping container, eyes scanning the maze of metal and shadow below. The workers moved with practiced precision, unloading crates marked with coded insignias he had seen before. Venom, again. The operation had been resurrected faster than expected.
Stephâs voice came low through the comms. âFifteen hostiles, maybe sixteen if that guy behind the truck isnât just smoking. Same product as last time.â
âCopy,â Bruce replied. âCass, north perimeter. Steph, stay close. Dick, take the east approach.â
Cassandraâs silent acknowledgment came in a short click over comms. Dickâs voice followed, steady but taut with anticipation. âOn your go, Bruce.â
Bruce waited. Watched, counted the rhythm of movement, the steady pulse of opportunity in the dark. Then he moved.
Cass struck first, a blur of motion, her fists finding pressure points before her targets even realized she was there. Bruce dropped from above, cape flaring, the crack of impact echoing like thunder. Dick was a flash of blue and black, his escrima sticks sparking as he cleared the path ahead.
Steph kept their flank covered, moving swiftly between shadows. Her punches landed clean, her kicks sharp. She smiled behind her mask, a flicker of pride breaking through the adrenaline. âAlmost too easy,â she muttered.
âDonât say that,â Dick warned.
The shot came before the words finished leaving his mouth.
It tore through the dark, a sharp, vicious sound that froze everything. Steph stumbled, her hand flying to her side, her body collapsing against the concrete. The bright purple of her suit grew darker, spreading red beneath her fingers.
âSteph!â Dickâs voice cracked as he sprinted toward her.
Bruce was already there, sliding beside her and pulling a patch from his gauntlet. His movements were automatic, efficient, but his chest felt tight. âStay with me,â he said, pressing the sealant into place. Stephâs breathing hitched, uneven.
Cass landed nearby, her eyes wide. âThrough,â she said softly. âBullet went through.â
âAlfred, prep the med bay,â Bruce ordered. âNow.â
They finished the fight in silence. Cass and Dick tore through the last of the men with brutal precision, no words, no mercy. By the time Bruce carried Steph to the Batmobile, the air around them was thick with gunpowder and guilt.
The Batcave was colder than usual when they arrived. The echo of Bruceâs boots on stone matched the steady rhythm of Stephâs shallow breathing. Alfred had the med bay ready, his sleeves rolled up, hands steady but pale.
âLay her here,â Alfred said, voice tight but controlled. Bruce obeyed. Alfred worked fast, cutting through fabric, cleaning blood, and sealing the wound with practiced efficiency. Dick hovered near the table, face pale and jaw set. Cass lingered in the corner, silent, her eyes dark with worry.
Tim appeared on the stairs, confusion etched across his face. âWhat happened? You said recon, not engagement.â
Bruce turned sharply. âWe didnât have full intel. You were supposed to have the shipment routes mapped.â
Tim hesitated, the realization dawning. âI was helping Alfred with Y/N. Sheâs been...â
âEnough,â Bruce interrupted, his voice low but edged. âWe canât afford distractions when peopleâs lives depend on it.â
Timâs expression fell. âI was trying to help your daughter.â
Bruceâs eyes hardened. âThatâs not your concern.â
The words cut deeper than they sounded.
Timâs pulse quickened, anger rising with every breath. He remembered empty nights in the Drake mansion, dinners for one, long stretches of silence when no one cared to ask where he was or what he felt. He had seen the same hollow ache in Y/Nâs faceâthe kind of loneliness that didnât come from being alone, but from being unseen.
And now Bruce, the man who had built a family out of broken people, was repeating the same pattern.
Timâs voice broke through the hum of machinery. âYou donât even see it, do you? Youâre mad at me for doing what you should have been doing.â
Bruceâs jaw clenched. âWatch your tone.â
âNo,â Tim said, louder now, the frustration spilling over. âI wouldnât have to focus on Y/N if you took care of your daughter like youâre supposed to.â
The silence afterward was deafening.
Bruce didnât move. His expression didnât shift, but the tension in his shoulders betrayed him. Dickâs eyes flicked between the two, ready to step in, but even he couldnât find words to break the tension.
âGet out,â Bruce said quietly.
Tim froze. For a moment, he thought about arguing, about pushing back until Bruce heard him, but the sight of Alfred bent over Stephanieâs bloodied body stopped him cold. He turned and left without another word.
The sound of his footsteps faded up the stairs until only the beeping of the monitors and Alfredâs calm, precise voice filled the space.
Bruce stood motionless. Dick rubbed his face, exhaustion pulling at the edges of his voice. âThat was harsh,â he muttered.
Cass remained silent, her gaze on Bruce. She didnât speak, but there was disappointment in the way she looked at him.
Bruce didnât respond. His mind had already started to spiral.
Timâs words repeated, clear and cutting: If you took care of your daughter like youâre supposed to.
They settled into his thoughts like a weight he couldnât shake. Why were they all so fixated on Y/N? Why was his team scattered, their focus slipping away from the mission? He had worked too hard, sacrificed too much, to have them lose sight of what mattered.
If he finished this case, if he found this stalker once and for all, maybe theyâd remember their priorities. Maybe theyâd remember why he built this team in the first place.
He turned toward the Batcomputer, the glow of the monitors casting his face in cold light.
Behind him, Dick helped Alfred clean up, his voice low, steady, and worried. Cass stood silently by Stephâs bedside, her fingers lightly brushing Stephâs wrist to make sure she was still breathing.
But Bruce didnât see any of it.
He focused on the case file on the screen. Names. Routes. Data. A world he could control.
If he stayed here, in this clarity, the noise may fade. Maybe the doubts would go quiet.
He stared at the glowing screen, jaw set, and forced the words echoing in his head to disappear.
Solve the case. Fix the problem. Get control back.
That was what mattered.
Tim had not gone to bed.
He sat at his desk, the blue light from his monitors spilling across his face in sharp angles. His room was quiet except for the faint buzz of the computer fans and the hum of Gothamâs night pressing faintly against the windows. The chair creaked every so often when he shifted, though he barely moved.
His notes were still open on one of the screens. The footage from the café on another. He kept replaying it over and over, watching the moment Y/N turned to leave, the blur of the man waving after her. It was impossible to make out a face. Every filter he ran, every enhancement tool he coded, only made it worse. The image warped. The pixels bled. The shadows deepened until it looked as if something were eating away at the frame.
Tim dragged a hand over his face, feeling the ache behind his eyes. Bruceâs words still echoed in his head, low and sharp. Priorities. Real problems. Minor inconveniences.
He should not have cared this much. Not about one person. Not about her.
And yet, every time he thought of Y/N standing in that driveway with that letter clutched in her hand, her breath coming too fast, her eyes wide with something close to terror, he felt sick.
He remembered how Bruce brushed it off.
He remembered Alfredâs face when they read the new message.
He remembered doing nothing when Bruce dismissed them.
Tim leaned forward until his forehead pressed against the cool edge of the desk. He tried to breathe evenly, but his chest felt tight.
The glow from the monitors flickered once, then again, as if the power was about to dip. Tim frowned, looking up. Every screen had gone a little darker, though he hadnât changed anything. The cafĂ© recording opened again, looping silently.
Y/N walking away. The man is waving.
Then, for half a second, the blur around the manâs face seemed to turn.
It was not possible. The camera was stationary.
But for that half second, the dark static aligned in the vague shape of a grin.
Timâs pulse jumped. He pushed back from the desk, staring. The image stayed still now, nothing wrong, nothing moving, just shadows on a feed that should not mean anything.
He sat there for another long minute before reaching over and shutting down every monitor. The hum stopped, the room suddenly feeling too quiet, too empty.
Tim leaned back, staring at the ceiling.
He thought of Bruce and how he had called Y/N a distraction.
He thought of how Alfred had looked when she came home shaking.
He thought of his own reflection, how tired it had looked lately, how much it resembled the man downstairs in the cave.
Maybe Bruce was right. Maybe Tim had lost focus.
Still, when he finally pushed himself off the chair and crawled into bed, one thought circled back like a broken record:
If he didnât look after her, no one would.
And in the faint silence before sleep caught him, something in the corner of his room shifted, so slight he could have imagined it. The air grew colder.
He exhaled and stood, pulling on the sweatshirt heâd left draped over his chair. The manor was cold this early, the kind of cold that seeped into the walls and stayed there. He told himself he was only walking to clear his head, that he needed space from the noise in his thoughts, but his steps carried him down the long hallway before he even realized where he was heading.
Y/Nâs door was half open.
The faint light from the hallway stretched across the room, soft and golden against the edges of her blanket. She was still asleep, curled on her side, breathing steadily. The curtains stirred slightly with the draft.
Tim hesitated in the doorway. He told himself to turn back. This wasnât right; she deserved privacy, peace, rest. He had no reason to be here.
But he couldnât make himself leave.
There was something about seeing her like this, so still, so small against the vastness of the room, that made his chest tighten. The bruised shadows beneath her eyes had faded, though not wholly. The corners of her mouth twitched now and then, the way people do when theyâre trapped somewhere between a dream and a memory.
He stepped inside quietly, his hands in his pockets, his heartbeat too loud.
The morning light caught on the frame of the photo on her nightstand. A picture of her when she was younger and Alfred, her grin wide and awkward, his expression patient and proud. It made Timâs throat ache.
He remembered being that small once.
He remembered waiting by the window for parents who never came home.
He remembered telling himself they were just busy. That maybe if he stayed quiet, if he didnât cause trouble, theyâd notice him next time.
And suddenly, looking at her, that old feeling crawled back into him, the one that had never really gone away.
The loneliness.
The waiting.
The ache of wanting someone to see you and realizing they probably never would.
Tim swallowed hard and lowered himself into the chair by her desk. He stayed there for a while, elbows on his knees, staring at the pattern of light moving slowly across the floor.
He didnât know what he was supposed to do. He couldnât fix this; not for her, not for himself, not for anyone. Bruce was too far gone into his mission, the family was stretched thin, and Alfred could only hold so much together before it broke.
But sitting here, listening to her breathe, Tim felt something steady for the first time in a long time.
He wasnât the lonely boy in the empty house anymore. He wasnât forgotten.
And neither was she.
He stood just as the first full wash of sunrise touched the windows, soft gold spilling over the walls. He lingered for a moment longer, his hand brushing the doorframe before he turned and left as quietly as he came.
Behind him, Y/N stirred faintly in her sleep, brow creasing like sheâd felt the air shift.
The early morning light filtered in through the tall windows, soft and gray, glinting off the marble floor. Her footsteps sounded too loud in the hallway. For a moment, she thought about turning back, crawling into bed, and pretending none of this existed. But the smell of coffee and something sweet drew her forward.
The kitchen was full when she stepped inside.
Dick sat at the counter, one hand curled around a mug, looking like he hadnât slept. Jason leaned against the wall, a permanent frown carved into his face, arms crossed as if daring the room to challenge him. Alfred stood by the stove, quiet but sharp-eyed, stirring something that steamed faintly.
And at the far end of the table sat her.
Cassandra Cain.
Y/N froze, her breath catching before she could stop herself. She knew that face. She knew that posture, the stillness that wasnât still at all, the way her eyes tracked everything, the way her presence filled the room without a word.
In the comics, Cass had been silent, deadly, and compassionate all at once. Here, she was real. Solid. The quiet between her and the others wasnât awkward; it was instinctive. Like the silence was a language only she spoke.
Y/N shifted her weight and muttered a soft, uncertain âmorning,â to no one in particular.
Dick glanced up, managing a tired smile. âHey. Youâre up.â
Jason grunted something that mightâve been a greeting. Cass didnât move. She just looked at Y/N for a beat, eyes unreadable, before dipping her head in a slow, almost polite nod.
Y/N nodded back before slipping into the nearest chair. The silence stretched, filled only by the faint hiss of the coffee machine and the clink of Alfredâs spoon against a mug.
âCoffee?â Dick asked, voice low.
âSure,â Y/N said, though she didnât feel like drinking anything. She wrapped her hands around the warm cup when Alfred set it in front of her. The warmth helped steady the tremor in her fingers.
Something was wrong. She could feel it. The tension in the air wasnât just tiredness; it was worry. Fear, maybe. No one was saying anything, but the silence wasnât comfortable. It was hiding something.
After a moment, she glanced at the empty chair across from Cass. âIs Steph coming down too?â she asked, careful and casual, like she wasnât trying to read the room.
The words landed like a stone in water.
Alfred froze. Dickâs head dropped slightly. Cass looked down. Jason sighed.
âSheâs not coming,â Jason said, his voice edged and tired.
Y/N frowned, glancing between them. âWhat do you mean?â
Jason pushed off the wall, dragging a hand through his hair. âShe got shot last night.â
The words hit her like ice water. âWhat?â
Dick shot Jason a sharp look, reprimanding, before turning to Y/N. âSheâs okay,â he said quickly. âSheâs stable. It was a bad night, but Alfred handled it. Sheâs resting.â
Y/Nâs throat tightened. âThat doesnât sound fine,â she murmured.
âWe didnât want you to worry,â Dick said softly.
Jason scoffed. âYeah, because that always works out.â
âJason,â Alfred warned, still not turning from the stove.
Jason didnât respond, just folded his arms again, jaw clenched.
Y/N stared into her coffee. The steam blurred her reflection. Her mind spun with fragments, Steph laughing, bright and reckless; her being shot, lying somewhere bleeding. She didnât know her well, but the thought still made her chest ache.
No one spoke for a long time. Even the air felt heavy.
Finally, Jason muttered, voice rough, âSheâll be fine. Sheâs tougher than the rest of us combined.â
Dick nodded, rubbing a hand over his face. âSheâll bounce back. She always does.â
Y/N managed a quiet, âYeah,â but it sounded small.
Cass looked up then. Their eyes met, just for a second, and Y/N thought she saw something there. Not pity, not sympathy. Something quieter. Understanding.
Then Cass looked away, her face unreadable again, and the silence fell over them once more.
Y/N took another sip of coffee she couldnât taste, pretending she didnât notice the weight pressing down on everyone, pretending that everything would go back to normal.
It wouldnât. She could feel it.
Before she could dwell on it, Tim entered the kitchen with the hollow look of someone who hadnât slept in days. His hoodie was creased, his hair pushed back like heâd dragged his fingers through it one too many times. He stopped in the doorway, taking in the room; the silence, the coffee cups, the lingering smell of burnt toast.
For a moment, no one said anything.
Then Dick started, his voice careful, too light for how brittle the air felt. âHey, Tim. You should eat something. Alfredââ
âIâm fine,â Tim said flatly, cutting him off without looking his way.
The sharpness in his tone froze the air again. Jasonâs jaw flexed, but he didnât comment. Alfred sighed softly behind the counter. Cass turned her gaze toward the window.
Tim walked straight past all of them until he stood beside Y/N. He didnât say anything right away, just leaned slightly against the counter next to her, close enough that she could feel the warmth of his shoulder brushing hers. His posture was tight, his eyes scanning the mug in her hands like he was counting her breaths.
Y/N blinked, startled. The last time sheâd spoken to Tim was weeks ago, his sarcasm still sharp, his patience already worn thin. He hadnât so much as looked at her since. Now he was standing beside her like he was guarding her.
She shifted in her chair, uncertain. âUh⊠morning.â
Tim finally turned to her. His voice was quieter than she expected. âMorning.â
Dick cleared his throat, trying again. âTimâŠâ
Tim ignored him completely. His focus stayed locked on Y/N, his eyes flicking briefly toward her bag near the chair, then back to her. There was tension in the way he stood; shoulders hunched, but every muscle alert, as if he were waiting for something to happen.
âDo you want to get out of here for a bit?â he asked suddenly.
Y/N hesitated. âWhat?â
âOut,â he repeated. âYou can bring your laptop, study somewhere else. I have to go over some Wayne Enterprises stuff, butâŠâ He trailed off, shrugging like it didnât matter. âItâs better than sitting around here.â
Dick frowned. âTim, I donât thinkâŠâ
But Y/N was already nodding. The air in the kitchen felt suffocating; the quiet grief, the tension still hanging heavy from the night before. And Tim looked⊠different. Not angry. Just exhausted, but determined in a way she didnât understand.
âOkay,â she said softly.
Tim blinked, as if he hadnât expected her to agree so easily. Then he nodded once. âGood. Ten minutes.â
He turned and left as abruptly as he came, footsteps fading down the hall toward the garage.
Y/N stared after him, then looked down at her untouched coffee. âHe seemsâŠâ
âLike he hasnât gotten over it,â Jason muttered.
Y/Nâs head cocks in confusion, and tries to ask about what, but Dick already starts to speak, sighing, he rubs his temples. âHeâs been under a lot of pressure.â
Alfred set down his spoon and gave Y/N a look that was half warning, half worry. âPlease do be careful.â
âI will,â Y/N promised, though her chest felt tight. She didnât really know why she said yes, maybe because Tim looked like he needed company more than she needed peace, maybe because she couldnât take the silence of this house anymore.
Maybe because if she sat still too long, sheâd start thinking about the letter again.
Either way, she grabbed her bag and went to get ready, ignoring the faint tremor in her hands.
Outside, she could already hear the low rumble of the car engine waiting in the driveway.
Next Chapter
A/N: Maybe a little Dami action next chapter
Taglist: @shycreatorreview @lilyalone @cupid73 @thatbitchanna27 @jovialthings @shirayukiuzukaze @bk-4-trash-fire @coldcomputerpanda @faelvz @lunadi1una @cssammyyarts @yuurisfavblog @mymmyrym @wosoarchives @chaosandcandies @natllo @vikkus-main @unclearblur @calico-cheriies @maaaahhhiii @odetteandink @yuurisfavblog @degenerates-posts @
Please let me know if I missed you or if you'd like to be added.
I've been binged reading this series and damn it is peakđ„đ„đ„
















