Iām rereading One Piece and I made it to Fishman Island, I forgot how bad Sanjiās characterization is for the first stretch of post-timeskip. Iām on chapter 605 at the moment and the only cool moment for him so far is taking down a pacifista with Zoro. The nosebleeds are annoying and do a lot to flatten him out. But thatās not as bad as everything surrounding the Kamabakka kingdom. Iāve heard interpretations of the queens there as being a radical representation of gender, breaking free of societal conventions and living in their own way. That sounds nice, but I donāt buy it personally. Their depiction feels too mean spirited and draws on too many negative stereotypes for it to feel like anything other than a cruel joke. And thatās a shame because I absolutely adore Iva as a character, as well as other canonically queer characters like Kiku, Bon Clay, and Yamato. Overall, Sanjiās timeskip adventure feels like a giant missed opportunity to me. Now is the time that I start pushing my transfem Sanji agenda. Hereās what I am seeing that fuels my belief that Sanjiās character would have benefitted from returning to Sabaody a woman.
First off, he seems happier when presenting more femininely. The two main pieces of evidence for that is when he first arrived on Kamabakka and was put in a dress and makeup and the body switch in Punk Hazard. In both cases he was visibly exuberant at his body being more traditionally feminine. If thatās not gender euphoria then I donāt know what is. I mean when heās switched back to his own body he laments that the dream is over.
My second point ties into repression. Sanjiās character as a whole is kind of predicated on feeling like heās not enough as is seen in Whole Cake Island. He believes himself to be a burden to his crew so he leaves and doesnāt join until it feels like thereās no other choice. We see how his childhood as a Vinsmoke fueled that inferiority complex, always being the runt and eventually being erased. I see this as being a potential factor of why he canāt see himself as a woman. He puts women as a whole up on a pedestal, refusing to hurt them and being incredibly charitable to any and all who interact with him. It feels like he cannot see himself as being worthy of that kind of love, respect, and adoration, so itās not possible for him to be a woman.
Next, as much as I dislike the whole perv gag, I can see it as another hint. Speaking from personal experience, I felt guilty about taking pleasure in being a woman. I thought that maybe I was some irredeemable weirdo fetishizing womanhood, not a real woman just a sicko. I can see that mindset being plausible for Sanjiās character as well.
With the āreasons Sanji reads as an egg to meā out of the way, letās look at what what this hypothetical transfem Sanji would look like and what her story would be. (Im going to start using she/her pronouns to refer to Sanji for clarityās sake now).
I imagine that during the process of fighting the 99 new kama masters, she not only learns new fighting and cooking techniques, but also starts to understand the people of Kamabakka more and in the process discover her own identity. Like Iva said, only those with the heart of a maiden can learn their ways. After learning all she could, Sanji would ask Iva to use their powers on her. I imagine this alternate post time skip design to be similar to the canon one (women in suits šāāļø) just with longer hair and a more feminine figure. I could also see her in skirts and dresses in other arcs, but I adore Fishmen Island and Raid Sanjiās fits and can easily picture a more fem version of them.
Moving on to the actual story and Fishmen Island. To start, I think that instead of her losing blood from seeing the mermaids she should lose blood by protecting her crew from a group of roided up New Fishmen Pirates. Have her do a 1v4 in the ocean that she barely wins, establishing the threat of the New Fishmen pirates especially in the water while also showing off how much she has learned during the timeskip. This allows for the search for blood and the knowledge that human and fishmen blood is not allowed to be mixed. She can still be saved by a couple of the queens, but she would probably be more nice to them. From there Fishmen Island is pretty similar, sheās still there to hear about Fisher Tiger and Jimbei, still tells Jimbei to kill himself, etc, etc.
Punk Hazard Iām less sure of what would happen with body swapping shenanigans. If she swapped into Namiās body all those gags wouldnāt really be necessary since she inhabits a womanās body already. And after the body switch happens, I can still see her leading the Navy men and saving Tashigi. I wish I had more ideas, but if you have any Iād love to hear them.
Dressrosa is much the same. I donāt see why she couldnāt have got Viola on the Strawhatās side, fight Doffy briefly, and then escape when the Big Mom Pirates show up. Again, if you have any story opportunities here Iād love hear them.
Now for the big one and the entire reason for this post, Whole Cake Island. Sanji being confronted with her past would be even more heartbreaking if she were trans. Not only is she leaving behind her crew, but she has to go to the source of her trauma and self doubt, feeling like even after going through as much as she did sheās ultimately still a pawn for her father. A fem Sanji adds extra drama to the Vinsmoke family, with her now looking almost exactly like her mother. She and Reiju grow closer, Reiju seeing just how far Sanji has come and hoping to see her free. Judge despises her more, being reminded of his dead wife and a perceived weakness that he despises. Maybe sheās able to bring just a little bit more humanity out of her brotherās by choosing to not only look like Sora, but by following in her steps and choosing kindness. Puddingās betrayal and redemption can be a mirror to Sanjiās journey, feeling ashamed about an unchangeable part of her core identity because of how she was raised only to realize that she was worthy of being loved the whole time. The things she thought she should be ashamed of is actually the thing that makes her beautiful. WCI is all about family, both biological and found. Having the queer undertones of a transfem Sanji amplifies the message of no matter who you are, you are deserving of a family that duly loves and cares for you, and it doesnāt matter whether they are actually related to you or not. The actual content of WCI doesnāt even need to change all that much, just having a trans character revisit her abusive family does enough to elevate the material as written.
When it comes to Wano, Egghead, and Elbaph I imagine the raid suit and mutation would be the center of Sanjiās development much like in the canon story. This time it takes on a deeper meaning with Judgeās influence not only turning her into a weapon of Germa, but also being a vision of what could have happened to Sanji had she not discovered herself during the timeskip. What if the suit and mutation changes her body back? The threat of becoming Stealth Black is made all the more apparent. There are small things that would be different too. Like instead of just happening to be at the bathhouse for creepy reasons, she could have just used her observation haki to save the women there, small tweaks like that. And of course she would be part of the Yamato and Kiku going to the correct bathhouses.
To close this out I want to talk about her relationships with the rest of the crew. I donāt really ship any of the crew together so donāt expect any of that stuff here, but more power to you if you do. For the majority of them things would stay the same. I cannot imagine Luffy, Ussop, Robin, or Franky caring at all, or treating her any different. And Jimbei only met Sanji in Fishmen Island, so their dynamic stays almost completely intact. Zoro would be confused until he sees the curly brow, then the rivalry would start again as normal. Nami would still be waited on dutifully by fem Sanji, but I see Nami helping Sanji out with shopping and doing girly things like clothes and makeup. Chopper would be confused, but after hearing about Ivaās powers would start working on new regiments to fit Sanjiās new body. And Brook would just ask to see her panties before being kicked.
Ultimately I still love Sanji, even with the rise in prevalence of the perv gag and not as many suave secret agent moments like Mr. Prince or the train scene. Most of this is just projecting my own shit onto the character, but I canāt help but see the missed opportunities. Transfem Sanji you are real to me.