libbybreyer.
The morning after Libby and Finley had spent that romantic night alone in her empty house had been a big shock to Libby - but she was angry with herself for letting it be a surprise to her in the first place. She should have known, she shouldnât have been so dumb and so naive to assume that suddenly out of no where, after months, after a year of cruelty and dominance Finley would return to the loving way heâd been previous years - her Finley. He had made Libby feel dumb and small for assuming him to do the simplest of tasks for her - being kind, staying around the morning after, doing really anything that would be considered normal in any other relationship. But Libby should have known better. It had been however many months since sheâd seen any resemblance of that type of old Finley behavior, how could she truly think anything had just changed over night? But in the blondeâs defense, he had acted differently the night before. It had been weeks - no - months since heâd even given her a choice to pick really, well, anything. What they did that night, what food they ordered, what movie to watch. They were four simple decisions but they were four decisions that she had not been given the privilege to pick in a long, long time. And at the end of the night the most important thing to Libby was that was happy. She felt like he was finally coming to terms with how things were, that his parents were gone, that he was almost, in the most possible way, free. Free from the abuse of his parents, free from their constant putting him down. He could be himself again, not the person theyâve molded him to be. She should have known it was all too good to be true.
The rest of the day Libby felt useless. She felt played and stupid for falling for it, but did she even second guess that feeling stupid and played by her own boyfriend might not be okay? No, she did not. For Libby being made out to feel that way was normal. It happened on a near daily basis. If she accidentally said something wrong - said something in even the slightest manner that might warrant a âdumb blondeâ remark, Finley had every one laughing at her. Not with her, but at her. Libby knew it wasnât right but yet she never did anything to stop it. So that day, after she let Finley âput her in her placeâ, make her feel stupid for assuming that her boyfriend of nearly four years might stay the night without having to sneak out the next morning, without having to berate her for simply wanting him to be sweet with her for the first time in too long, Libby spent the rest of the day laying in bed, re-writing her college essay over and over. She needed something to distract her although even that couldnât truly take her mind off of the boy she loved dearly, and the amount of worry she had for him at all times - but especially then. She had tried to text him multiple times a few hours later, apologizing, telling him that she loved him. That she was sorry. As much as Libby knew deep down that she had nothing at all to apologize for, on the surface and in her conscience she felt otherwise. For whatever reason Libby felt like she had been the one in the wrong. She had pushed him away this morning, sheâd been too clingy, too needy the night before. She didnât blame him for wanting to leave.
But he didnât reply, not to one single text. Sheâd pissed him off far too much. So the next day when she went into school she thought sheâd surprise him, write a rough draft for the assignment they had due in history that she knew he hadnât written, and wear the shirt he always loved on her so much. But he wasnât there, yet again. Her boyfriend had begun skipping school more often now than ever before. His weekends were becoming longer than the school week itself - to nobodyâs surprise. Sheâd texted him multiple times throughout the day, gave him a few calls, left a few voicemail but still nothing in return. She was almost worried even though deep down she knew that he was just ignoring her. After the final school bell rang Libby found herself sitting at the wheel of her car, dialing his phone one last time to see if she could finally get him. She wanted to see him and make up, see him and apologize for being so clingy and overbearing and offer to make it up to him somehow. But still, after two more calls, no answer. Sighing heavily, Libby turned the keys in her ignition and drove straight past her house towards Finleyâs. Upon pulling into the driveway the girl swallowed nervously before letting out a heavy exhale and grabbing her keys, walking up to the door. The young blonde knocked on the door a few soft times before wrapping her arms over her body, pulling her cardigan sweater tight over her as the chilly wind blew around her. After a few moments of nothing Libby lifted her hand to knock a second time but her mouth parted, cheeks instantly brightening a shade of pink when the door opened to reveal Finleyâs older brotherâs girlfriend. Melanie, was it? Nervously, Libby lifted her already lifted hand and brought it to her blonde mess, brushing a wind-blown strand of hair behind her ear. âOh,â she greeted, surprised to see her. Without her needing to even say anything Melanie answered the question that Libby really didnât want to ask. She felt awkward, not knowing her at all, not really having ever said more than a few words to her at the memorial service.
Libby nodded her head as if to agree, or say thank you for answering the question she didnât even need to ask. She mused a light nod, acknowledging what the older female was saying while kind of adverting her eyes, too timid to keep looking her straight in the eyes. What Libby knew of Melanie was minimal as Finn himself seemed not to know very much. She knew that Melanie was a lawyer and that apparently things with her and Patrick were pretty serious, but that was about it. She also knew that Melanie didnât care for Finley, that much was obvious. âUmm,â she hummed nervously as she glanced around, as if Finn might be somewhere watching, testing to see if sheâd align with the other side. Did she want to go in and wait? Wouldnât Finley just be pissed to see her there, saying something about how âshe was hanging out with them nowâ or something of the sort. But he was ignoring her and she was worried. âYeah, okay,â she nodded softly with a hushed down, her voice always being more on the quiet side. Keeping her arms crossed, Libby slowly stepped past Melanie and into the house. She lingered awkwardly in the foyer. Should she just go up and wait in his room or should she stay down her with Melanie. She was almost too embarrassed to do the latter. She figured someone like Melanie - a lawyer, or one in the making - would probably judge her for being with someone like Finn. Most people did. But most people were wrong and most people just didnât get it. Swallowing as she cleared her throat lightly Libby turned a bit on her heels to look at Melanie. âThanks,â she offered meekly in regards to letting her come in and wait. âI can just go up to his room if youâd like. I donât want to be in your way,â she offered, motioning towards towards the stairs with her finger. She glanced around anxiously trying to come up with things to say, her anxiety causing her to feel the need to talk to fill up time and space in the room around them. âI um - Iâm sorry that you have to deal with this. Finley taking Patrickâs time away from you. Heâs just going through a rough time..â
Melanie wasnât sure what she was expecting Libby to be, besides a doting and silent girlfriend whom she had only ever seen glued to Finleyâs side. She wondered if Libby ever detached from him, if she went off to do her own thing and hang out with her own friends, or if she was the kind of girlfriend who was so fixated on her boyfriend that she would only be around him and his friends, even if they werenât nice people. Melanie, of course, had met Finley, albeit briefly and not in the best circumstances, and she had been told first hand what he was like from Patrick and she knew that if Libby was the latter - which definitely seemed to be the case - then there would be more to it than Libby being attached to him. From the very few instances Melanie had met and seen Libby, she had showcased a personality that was very gentle, she was a soft spoken girl, and she was exactly the kind of person people like Finley ruined. Melanie wasnât being biased or going off her already formed opinion - which, yeah, she totally was but you couldnât blame her for that - but she had seen this kind of thing before, mock cases and even some real cases she had managed to shoe horn her way into, that these kinds of things usually never ended with a happy ending. If Patrickâs parents were anything to go by, it was something that always had a negative impact. Of course, this wasnât something Melanie had brought up to Patrick. She had seen the way heâd gotten hopeful that he could have rebuilt a relationship with his brother, sheâd seen the way that that had been ruined because of Finley. She was sure that if she voiced her opinion on him, if she told Patrick that she didnât like him - hated him, almost - that that would cause problems between them. It was something she hoped Patrick would be able to figure out and see for himself, she didnât want to jeopardised their relationship because of Finley.
But just because Melanie wasnât going to talk to Patrick about it, didnât mean she couldnât speak to other people about it. She was thanking whatever higher power there was for the perfect opportunity that had presented itself to her. It was almost a miracle that Libby had shown up and that she wasnât with Finley or coming to see him. It was good thing that Finley wasnât here for once - it was always a good thing for Melanie but once again, that was something she didnât say. She was interested in Libby, interested in the way she allowed herself to be pushed around, although that was something Melanie didnât blame her for. The Griffin men had a weird way of being able to pull people in, Melanie could attest to that. She would never have expected herself to be where she was now when she had first met Patrick but heâd drawn her in and after their first real moment of intimacy, she had realised too late that heâd gotten her hook, line, and sinker and there was no way she would have been able to walk away from him. But Melanie wasnât naive and if Finley had the same pull that his brother did, then she knew heâd done the same to Libby. The only real difference was how they had both changed, how they treated the ones they loved and Melanie was forever grateful that she had found the brother who hadnât been turned into someone he wasnât. She was so incredibly in love with Patrick and she was beyond happy that she had managed to make him hers.
Libbyâs first response to her invitation to come in and wait instantly struck a chord with Melanie. It seemed as if she were hesitant because of somebody who wasnât even here. Melanie doubted that Patrick would be able to find Finley and that he wouldnât come home; he never did anymore. She offered Libby a small smile as the younger girl came into the house and she gently shut the door behind her. She wondered how many times Libby had actually been in the house, itâd been the place where Patrickâs parents had spent their days getting wasted and neglecting their children and it definitely wasnât a place you would bring your significant other, Melanie was sure about that. âIâm sorry about the mess,â she said off handedly. âTrying to keep on top of the house and everything is a little difficult at times.â There was no real reason for Melanie to divulge that information to Libby except for the fact that she was trying to make small talk. She couldnât exactly dive into any real conversation when they had barely talked and she was getting rather strong timid vibes from Libby. Theyâd have to build a rapport if Melanie wanted to get anywhere. Her eyebrow raised when Libby suggested that she go elsewhere, almost as if she didnât want to be around her. But Melanie understood that, she knew it must have been difficult for Libby to be around someone she didnât know, someone her boyfriend had probably spat out endless hateful words about. Melanie didnât care about that stuff but she didnât care about the way it hurt Patrick. âNo, donât be silly, you wouldnât be in my way.â Melanie said, half shrugging. âI wasnât doing anything too important anyway. I was just trying to pass the time, really.âÂ
The apology was surprising to Melanie, it wasnât something she had expected to hear and it only made her wonder how many times Libby apologised on Finleyâs behalf, how many times heâd gotten into trouble and Libby had been the one who had to pick up the pieces. It was a natural thing to pick up the pieces of the person you loved, it was a natural instinct to want to take care of them, and it was fine to do it, so long as it was done in return. Relationships were mutual and Melanie had the sinking suspicion that Libby didnât get to experience that mutuality. âDonât apologise.â she said. âI might be a little upset that I no longer get Patrick all to myself now but Patrick wanted to come here and deal with this, I was more than happy to come and help him. God knows he needs the help.â It was another spiteful dig at Libbyâs boyfriend and Melanie should probably have watched her words but Libby wasnât giving off the impression that she was the kind of person who liked confrontation, not that Melanie wanted to argue with her. âWhy donât we go into the living room? Itâll be much better than standing around in the foyer and we can wait for our men together.â Even though she posed the question, Melanie didnât leave much room for argument as she turned around and made her way into the living room. She only glanced back once to make sure that Libby was following her. The living room always carried an aura of disuse about it, it was a room that had been used for something other than friendly gatherings and a place that only positive things happened in. The house itself often felt like a bad place to be, the wall carrying untold things within them, things that the people who had once lived here did and what others had to suffer. Whenever Melanie thought about that, she always reminded herself that she was here for Patrick and she wasnât going to leave him. She sat down on one of the crappy sofas, a leg tucked underneath her and she watched, almost expectantly for Libby to do the same. She knew she was asking too much from her already, they were still strangers after all. âWhen Patrick first told me about his parents, I never expected they would live in such a nice house.â For perhaps the first time, Melanie had found herself in the presence of something who had also vicariously experienced what the Griffin parents had been like. It felt like a safe starting point. âI shouldnât have been too surprised, however, itâs always the assholes who get the best places. Iâm going to change that.â The last part of her words was her own aspirations slipping into the conversation. It was things she had told Patrick many times before, it was things she had added onto her list of things to achieve when he told her everything. âDid Finley ever bring you around here when they were alive?â













