YOU ARE THE REASON

Kaledo Art
Acquired Stardust
occasionally subtle

JVL
wallacepolsom
Three Goblin Art

★
h
KIROKAZE

❣ Chile in a Photography ❣

ellievsbear

if i look back, i am lost

pixel skylines
Show & Tell

roma★
Peter Solarz
trying on a metaphor
Cosmic Funnies
Keni

seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from United States

seen from Australia
seen from United States

seen from Malaysia

seen from Australia
seen from Australia

seen from United States

seen from Indonesia
seen from Germany

seen from United States
seen from United States
seen from Australia
seen from South Korea
@mouse-fischer
Because of the length and extensivity of the Talmudic scripture, how do modern Jews - Reform, Conservative, Orthodox; all except for Karaite, since they don't believe in additional scripture - interpret the beliefs, stories, laws, and traditions espoused and argued over by the various Jewish scholars within the text?
It would appear, on its own, that due to the size of the Talmud, as well as the sheer quantity of scholars within, that there would be multiple branches producing different variants of Judaism. Is that what the aforementioned branchers already are, or, is it the case that there's a pretty universal contemporary agreement on which rabbis to agree with and which to ignore, or the individual points and arguments created by the rabbis, those which modern Jews do and don't agree with?
To put it simply, there are two metrics of understanding in Judaism. The originality of the Old Testament, then the scholars of the Talmud, and then the modern Jewish experts and modern Jews in general who agree with this or that as part of the Talmud, and reject this and that. So, are Jewish people supposed to believe in only what certain rabbis said, while excluding other rabbis entirely, or certain individuals things within the total text?
It would appear that reading the Talmud would be more easily done by reading a commentary on it, which presents the mainstream, academically-accepted Jewish view at the forefront of the text.
.
@bluequest09, there are a number of distinct assumptions underlying your question, including a Christian-centric perspective of "sola fide"--"faith alone"--that does not map onto Jewish practice, but also a degree of historical contextual ignorance.
Historically, for the entirety of Rabbinical Judaism's existence, barring the last seventy years in our homeland, Judaism has been a minority treated absolutely horribly by the surrounding Christians and Muslims. Under those circumstances, fracturing into tinier and tinier mutually exclusive factions would have been ethnic suicide. Furthermore, as part of that, there was never a 30 Years War or 4th Crusade equivalent in Judaism that was the sort of event that entrenched the political and social splits between the different factions in Christianity.
Secondly, Jewish religious practice does not rely on belief as much as it does forms of practice and action; yes, there is a broad spectrum of argument over what constitutes acceptable practice, with multiple subgroups upon subgroups following different "minhagim", which is the sort of fragmentation that you're visualizing... but at the same time, the distinctions are much more fluid. One person transfers from one community to another, joins in with their minhag, and there's not exactly much in the way of issues, religiously speaking. Most of the major splits in Judaism--such as the Reform and Orthodox--come from deep-seated arguments over practice than over doctrine. The "Trefa Banquet" is perhaps the most egregious example from when the split was really getting formalized. But the whole "This rabbi interprets things differently than this one? Okay, let them argue over it" is more the mindset.
Third, you're forgetting that Judaism is as much an ethnicity as it is a religion, if not moreso. In the end, other Jews are family and community, which gives a glue of common connection that helps keep things together, and that has been a constant theme through Jewish history. To give an example there that probably ties exactly into the sort of question you're considering, there was an issue of Jewish heresy in the Yemenese Jewish community around 1170 CE, due to a messianic claimant there and religious persecution by the Muslim authorities, which created a syncretic, heretical Jewish-Islamic faith. Maimonides (who we call the Rambam) sent a letter now called the Epistle to Yemen, encouraging them, as fellow members of Am Yisrael, to not lose their Jewish practice and follow this heretical path, while he also went to Saladin in Egypt to politically intervene.
So, just to emphasize that point, a 12th century Rabbi from what is now Spain heard about a problem with an extremely small Jewish community on the other side of the known world, and sent them an encouraging letter to help stick together with the rest of the Jewish people... and it worked.
I hope that helps with some understanding?
Downstream
Victoria Ball
"Spring garden"
“Cleaning the House” painting by Sally Welchman.
I know I sound like your mom but you kids need to stop fucking vaping
1) Vaping is confirmed to cause cancer. Vaping coats the lungs with toxic substances, such as heavy metals and benzene, which are known to cause cancer
2) Many vapes contain diacetyl, which, when inhaled causes popcorn lung, or scarring of the lung
3) Ultrafine particles, when being inhaled, can be lodged in the trachea (not good!)
4) Ultrafine particles can also constrict the arteries in the lungs potentially causing A HEART ATTACK
5) Vaping is relatively new. Not much studies have been done in comparison to tobacco. Plus, the vaping companies are powerful people. There is a large chance that they are purposely downplaying and even burying any evidence that vaping is harmful - just like the tobacco companies before them. They do not care about you, or your health, or the truth. They only care for money
Also STOP VAPING INDOORS AROUND OTHER PEOPLE. Holy shit, if you're gonna wreck your lungs at least give me the option not to wreck mine.
It’s such an issue that the MTA had to run a campaign about it
yeah okay ill reblog that
Please I’m begging yall as an asthmatic, your fruit-flavored vapor will still give people around you who are smoke-sensitive attacks. So will weed. Don’t do it inside; if you’re at a bus stop or something try to not stand right next to people or move downwind of them if you can.
sent this message to my coworker today and he sent me this screenshot with microsoft teams's suggested replies... incredible 10/10 no notes.
I just had an argument with someone who was like “why would we settle for food stamps when we could have universal basic income?”
And it’s just like. People need food right now you know.
I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again. Hippie church moms donating quinoa chips to my local food bank have done more for me materially than any internet idealist ever has.
People get pissed at me for being a pragmatist in my political ideals but I’ve been in the position where I was out of food right now.
And who helped me with that? Not people calling for some nebulous revolution. Not people telling me that the system was useless. Not people preaching at me to grow my own food. It was a church food bank partially funded by the state of Texas that some southern hippies donated a bunch of Whole Foods nonsense to.
And you know what? I’m sick and tired of defeatism. What can we get done right now, huh? Are you gonna accept something a bit better to help people right now or are you waiting for your perfect utopia to come to you?
Yeah, UBI is better than the quinoa chips. Sure. But right now the quinoa chips are stopping people from going hungry and if all we can do is get the food bank quinoa chips to more people, then I say so be it. That’s something. I’ll almost always take baby steps over nothing.
Food bank today so we can get UBI tomorrow. Rome wasn't built in a day.
Transphobia is so antithetical to genuine feminism it blows my mind there's such a wide overlap like you either believe in autonomy and self determination or you don't
Orion over the Central Bohemian Highlands
Credits: Vojtěch Bauer
shrews on my mind
free museum trips are wasted on unappreciative middle schoolers. let me go
Springtime in Uzhhorod, Ukraine. X
Lonely trail
Sometimes I am flabbergasted that it seems like goyim think Jews just picked eretz Yisrael out of a hat to form a state.
As if our entire culture, religion, and existence isn’t tied to exactly one place.
I always think about this when it stops raining after pesach.
When it starts raining after sukkot.
When the almond trees flower for tu bshvat.
When pomegranates are massive and abundant for Rosh Hashanah.
When the wheat is golden in the fields in time for Shavuot
Morning in Karachay-Cherkessia, Russia by Yulia Maltseva