Gosh dude I love this, I'm having a blast w these reposts. Thanks for your thoughts! We all really should talk about race in kids media a whole lot more, it really has an impact on kids who watch it, and it says alot about the biases of showwriters in any company, disney or NerdCorp or anywhere else. Intersecting progressivism is a must for a better world to come about, and people should talk about this a whole lot more when analyzing media; people don't because it's pretty advantageous to look past the subject for these networks, and while I'm sympathetic to nerdcorps, I'm not at all to Disney, or any critic who brushes past how marginalized characters are portrayed. Slugterra's really good at some messaging, and relies on the audience's goodwill interpretations for some others. I don't think they're ever super bad , just sometimes, they're handled not fragile enough. And could be easily fixed with more character lore; which is why I have so much headcanons about Saturday and how human society found Slugterra and whatnot. Here's a few things I thought of reading ur lovely response:
absolutely w Jimmo, but how was Redhook a part of that slavery? Ive never thought about that before, I'm very interested in what you mean by that.Ā
Oh Slugterra hates going into detail. But I will say that this show is impossible to follow if the viewer doesn't assume dark details about the plot. It's off-screen, but also very integral to the story to read between those lines.
I think they did think about the woman in Slugterra, though. I think they were told by Disney to have a bunch of dudes, and they tried to insert woman where they could. It's like the woman were carefully placed to be cool characters, to be honest. Trixie, a journalist and Shane gang member. Dana, a smart funny thief who gets redeemed and turns kind (unlike her boy counterpart). Indra, a badass militia leader for like 5 minutes, notably basically the only adult slugslinger who helps them in actual battle. Drucilla, a girl who inherits a man's tech empire and is now known as the smartest technician in the whole eastern caverns. Shanai, the unbeatable master who is strict but kind and remorseful. Lian, a kind teacher figure who fucks shit up when needed and guides everyone with her wisdom and expertise. And literately no woman work for Dr Blakk...cause honestly yeah I can see his workplace being full of misogyny and no one working for him. That woman and girl in It Comes By Night; she's the one who took initiative to call the Shane's, not the men on her cavern council! There should have been more, and notably, most these characters besides Trixie have roles delegated to one or 2 episodes only. But they are there. As for the voicing, I didn't even realize that, that's a bit yikes. Their likely reasoning was that they worked with a small voice crew - every actor worked on at least like 3 characters, I think - but still, ick. Thanks for pointing that out.Ā Especially for Dana, cause I think Dana's voice actor was a guest voice.
Ah, okay, so being critical of colorism in Slugterra is valid. I've seen ppl be annoyed at the eastern caverns arc for this too. But honestly, the fandom helps a lot in this aspect. Idk how long you've hovered in online slugterra fandom activity, but I'll note this for anyone new looking at these posts; I think over half of everyone thinks Eli is Latino, or at least not white- due to his skin color looking dark in a bunch of scenes, the jokes about Eli in a sombrero and moustache, him and Will looking less white than Jim, etc...and there was a good few years where due to how Slugterra aired, the Spanish fandom was more active than the English one - that's why we tag Bajoterra pretty often. Plus, with all the implied messaging with Kord and Pronto's species and how they're treated...I watched the show not really thinking anyone but Trixie in the main cast was white. Oh, and I think I made a post a long time ago noting that it's kinda an epic move to have Blakk's skin grow lighter as he starts working with more evil people. Idk if it's colorism in the other direction or if it was or wast meant to be viewed like that, and I'm very very white and live in a hella white enviorment I don't speak with personal experience - but I liked that detail. The villains always looked more white than the main cast and I appreciated that as I watched it, especially since Blakk is also a portrayal of corporatism, which often fucks over black communities while the media and the world don't even blink at it. And I liked the whole thing of the Shane's being purely vigilantes, coming to caverns when needed only and working with the people there only till the bad guys gone. I liked the episodes when they went to new caverns and we got to see other enviorments/cultures a bit more. With tom Por, and the shadow clan being non-human, and Junjie's prominence, and Junjie's friends not being human either, and the non-human-ness of the cast, plus Eli not being white, the show felt inclusive in terms of the basic "don't treat people based on their looks" ideal. Colorism subconsciously effected the brains of the writers definitely - gosh, could we not really get more detailed backstories of them all? The vagueness makes the show prone to being analyzed in this way, especially in the Eastern Caverns, where ur not sure for a few minutes what the writers meant by some lines here and there - but so did the very clear messaging that anyone of any species can be anything they want (shown with Kord and pronto, both not following the lifestyle expected of them). I don't really know what my own point is here, just that I don't know if Slugterra did good or bad in writing their diversity, or if they wrote it in a third much more complicated way, not perfect and not bad. But I always left an episode thinking the Shane gang were the good folk and woke as fuck, and the bad guys hated animals and cavern independance and species unlike their own and woman and poor people, so I do end up liking the writers portrayal of fighting stuff like racism, even if the writing room themselves could've done a better job with expanding the characters lore. Like seriously, Dana would not be remembered like a thief if we just had an episode or 2 of her helping out the gang later on in the plot; she's far more a burned legacy of a very brave man who fought with will Shane than a criminal by the end of The Gentleman, and they could've made that point more if she came back and helped out in the finale or something. I think it's implied to be very complicated in the show, and that is something important to display in kids media - that people are complicated, cultures and races and species's and ideologies are complicated. Dana's labeling as a thief could be avoided entirely if we had any more information about her life. Charactures run on limited information, after all! If we knew Dana's true life story there wouldn't be much issue.
Specifically with Saturday - I actually liked that part of the show. I like that, when humans came down to Slugterra, their cultures mashed together. I would ABSOLUTELY agree if this story was on the surface - the accent and the outfit and characterization doesn't make sense together, he'd need a rather interesting and complicated backstory to make that character at all okay - but down there, I can see human refugees becoming Slugterran culturally, and merging the little bits of surface culture they have left. Mario owning a pizza shop but sharing shooting-sport cultural references to Annie Oakley and her Irish husband - trixie liking corn fritters - Kord thinking slingings very cool, even if cave trolls don't normally take up the sport - pronto being more interested in the wider cultures, and the old reputation of travelers and singers and map makers his people used to have, and so on. Junjie speaking mandarin, specifically for meditation/slunging, because he probably mainly speaks a Slugterran language, and knows mandarin phrases purely in relation to slinging; kinda like how everyone knows what "es tut Brutus" despite knowing no other Latin words. Like of course, after a few centuries the cultures would evolve and merge. Maybe a lot of people in Saturdays home cavern looks and talks like that. It's like how everyone thinks Eli's bilingual! Of course he has to be, with the surface and Slugterra speaking different languages, and the Shane code being a thing. If Saturday was expanded upon, it would be a lot less jarring, and I would appreciate if this cultural merging was more explicit in the show, cause without thinking about the human lore in the show, it does come off racist af. But it's complicated š and we create fanon to fix what the show left behind. Why couldn't we get like 10 seconds of the show making human cultural merging explicit ššš very sad of them, I would be a lot more fine with their minimal screen time if we just had backstory that could develop these idea in the text itself, so when Junjie descendant of Yang unironically names a slug "Yin" in ROTE I'm not actively cringing. Just give context, writers! We can forgive you more if you kncorporate the future's a tinyyyy but more!!!
Shanai is human, to our knowledge. Just one that is lowkey immortal. And this not explained at ALL! So, we shall broth groan together over that lost lore. She could be an elf but I really don't know. And I recommend the eastern caverns movies/season - I really like them but there are things that could have landed better, mostly in the same vein as Saturday - they kept the lore vague, and it would have come off a lot better if we got to explore the cultures of the East more in-depth. But I am NO expert in multi-culturalism; in fact in in a uniquely terrible position for it, I'm white and my home county I've lived in all my life is known as the most historically racially segregated suburban area in the entirety of the United States. My education was conservative as fuck till college. So while I'm yapping a lot here, I really do like your takes, it's drawing my attention to things I haven't thought of in a lot of detail before.
Oh gosh, I also don't know enough about antisemitism in media to comment about Blakk. When I watched Back to Blakk I kinda thought he was biracial, and it stuck with me. But mostly, it was his family's cycle of abuse and the idea that pain rules the world - surviving pain is the only way to gain power and whatnot - that revolves around Blakk's character, that and the corporate power-hunger. Blakk's race's never was an important aspect of that to me personally, cause I've seen myself and my friends go through a trauma cycle like that. Any hurt human can hurt other humans, before or after a dark water trip that makes u literately whiter.
Nothing against u either! Genuinely, u seem really really cool. U know a whole lot more about a bunch of this stuff than me. This show is written by white ppl, and there are ways to still write as vague and mysterious with the world building as they wanted without sidelining the racism, speciesism, and misogyny of Slugterra as heavily as they did; and without keeping reoccurring characters who are darker and more feminine out of the overarching story. Sorry if I sounded like I was excusing it all; for one, I feel like a very inadequate judge for how colorism manifests in media, especially in situations where it seems like the writers aren't doing it on purpose (if it's obvious they are I get really mad, cause wtf are we doing at that point - If someone tells me to learn the really really popular flute arrangement of the Carman theme in my professional life one more time I will lose my shit). But yeah, I can point to the obvious shit of course but it's something I gotta work on more. I know it academically and whatever but I'm never gonna have to the personal experience to compare to the racially marginalized characters. Maybe I'll get that one day if I visit Eastern Europe and some bastard hates anyone who looks very Estonian/baltic, but I'm in America, so its not likely.
This whole thread makes me very glad for the fandom, actually. There's so many ocs that are black and Latino and Asian and woman and queer; this fandom doesn't feel cishetwhite at all and it's wonderful. I'd like to think we'll keep making content and we'll cover up the bad/inadequate stuff in canon.Ā Y'all know I've spent years now saying I'm giving them all stories that actually focus on their backstories and complicated characterizations and opinions and the discrimination that undoubtedly exists in Slugterra. Ur really dope @faceless-muses :)