The top four NADDPod Encounters, as determined by this tournament, are:
High King Durretar (c3e27)
Lord Ultrus (c3e44 and e45)
Heradecia and Cerenysus (c2e41)
Thiala (c1e100)
Thank you to everyone who participated!
occasionally subtle
RMH

No title available
d e v o n
Phantogram Three
Cookie Run:Kingdom Official!

Product Placement
The Bowery Presents
Fieri Frames
let's talk about Bridgerton tea, my ask is open
The Stonewall Inn
Interview Vampire Daily
taylor price
Claire Keane

PR's Tumblrdome

Discoholic 🪩
todays bird
cherry valley forever
🪼
No title available
seen from Denmark

seen from Dominican Republic
seen from TĂĽrkiye

seen from Indonesia

seen from United States

seen from TĂĽrkiye
seen from United States
seen from United Kingdom
seen from Maldives
seen from Australia

seen from TĂĽrkiye

seen from Switzerland
seen from United States
seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from Syria

seen from Indonesia

seen from TĂĽrkiye

seen from United Kingdom

seen from Singapore
@naddpod-encounter-tourney
The top four NADDPod Encounters, as determined by this tournament, are:
High King Durretar (c3e27)
Lord Ultrus (c3e44 and e45)
Heradecia and Cerenysus (c2e41)
Thiala (c1e100)
Thank you to everyone who participated!
A little over 16 hours left in the first place and third place polls!
Vote, tell your friends to vote, bribe your neighbors to vote!
Third Place - Encounter Tournament
Heradecia and Cerenysus
Thiala
Option 1:
Enemy: Heradecia and Cerenysus
Episode: C2 E41: Cerenysus
Time: 4:04-2:46:22
Finish: Fia (Cerenysus), Jabari (Heradecia)
Notes: 2 concurrent battles. 2 spellcasting enemies. 2 players juggling 2 PCs each. Surprise Lou and Hexbuds! Caldwell as Lake, Lou ass the spells. Emboldening bond and damage sponging. Living spells for Fia to fight. Jabari trapped in banishment with dry toads. Corbeau staying up and almost forgetting the death ward. Zirk's fucking crown removal and the deal he makes for his life. Hank breaking the curse. Tarragon's halfling abilities coming in clutch. Fia casts the first revivify in Eldermourne in centuries.
Propaganda: (anonymous) Fia won't fight Irina. The hexbloods are fighting their mom again. Lou Wilson voices the living spells. Caldwell gets to be the dog. Zirk fucking dies and then Fia tells hank to kill her girl(hood) friend it's all so crazy. It's 4 players and 6 PCs across 2 locations fighting 2 demigods and one demigod is kinda mind controlling the other. It's just a great final fight.
2 absolutely legendary encounters for the price of one. "Mr Henry, kill her" makes me weep every time. Also Lou Wilson as Bigby's Hand.
THE LOU REVEAL GETS ME EVERY SINGLE TIME. the back and forth. the emotional damage. everybody's playing multiple characters. Zirk is dying. "You took his death save?!" Caldwell 'playing' Lake the dog. Lou voicing the sentient spells and making wind noises. "What about the death ward?" truly the encounter of all time
Option 2:
Enemy: Thiala
Episodes: C1 E100: Heart of the World
Time: (ads) 58:56-2:41:30 (*used the ads version because it's two episodes on patreon so it wouldn't be a great timestamp)
Finish: Moonshine
Notes: Hardwon's insane first 2 rounds (almost 600 damage! and he does miss!! he does a total of 1,082 damage to Thiala in the entire fight and there are 2 rounds where he doesn't have a turn because he's unconscious!). Moonshine counterspells and then uses Chill Touch to make sure all of Hardwon's damage can stick. The flashback scenes that do psychic damage and enlighten the audience at the last minute on characters we hadn't seen a lot of. Bev goes Elder Champion and casts revivify as a bonus action. The terrain moves to in front of the Heart of the World where Melora and Telaine are holding the world together. Ulfgar and Alanis are used for their power by Thiala, and Galad is fucking back and Thiala's bestie. Erlin is freed by Handy Andy. "I'm gonna fucking eat her."
Propaganda: (anonymous) hardwon surefoot deals 582 points of damage against thiala in two rounds. that’s all
Murph's flashbacks to Elias Sr., Ol' Cobb, and the Legendary Heroes? Chef's kiss. Also riding into battle on flying elephants.
What's the best NADDPod Encounter?
High King Durretar
Lord Ultrus
Option 1:
Enemy: High King Durretar, Ancient Blue Dragon of the Sapphire Scale
Episode: C3 E27: King of Dragons
Time: 48:48-2:11:35 (battle stops at 2:03:55 but initiative ends at the later time)
Finish: Princess Shiverblight
Notes: On 3, regicide! The level 8 party decides to fight an ancient dragon on their own when only one of them manages to long rest beforehand. The mechanics of this encounter include dragon riding and are so goddam cool. It's also incredibly visual and one of Murph's best uses of lair actions to date.
Propaganda: (anonymous) CMON ITS KING OF DRAGONS. SO SICK. genuinely from the bottom of my heart the most exciting, interesting, and cool encounter I've ever seen. Rad as hell both mechanically and plot wise. SHIVERBLIGHT SWEEP!!
MY SUPERBOWL OF DND FIGHTS!!!!! TRULY SO ICONIC AND FUN!!!! COMBAT OF ALL TIME
I mean, come on! It was a giant fucking sky battle on the backs of dragons, unbelievably cinematic, lots of close calls, princess shiver blight, nothing comes fucking close!
Princess Shiverblight MVP
you know.
it's just so sick and scary
Option 2:
Enemy: Lord Ultrus and the Order of the Runny Eye
Episode: C3 E44: Trial by Steel and C3 E45: Lord Ultrus
Time: 1:04:08 (44) - 1:42:08 (45)
Finish: Hardwon (traps Ultrus in the Kingshammer)
Notes: Hardwon starts the battle with a Battlemaster ability. Jaina and Calder finally get involved in a fight (from inside the helm!!). Callie joins them inside the helm, and Ultrus and the cultists keep swapping who is inside the helm and who is outside the helm. Hardwon has a real Hardwon moment of standing alone, facing down a god (or a giant who made a deal with a god and has the powers of a god, who was responsible for the death of his best friend). Sol does some shenanigans and kind of keeps missing but is also impossible to hit. Kenna keeps saving lives. I cannot actually describe in words the moment where Hardwon regains the Kingshammer, casts Spirit Guardians, and an army joins them, as we get to finally see Cobb's final moments and the memory that was stored in the hammer. Jake is playing 2 PCs wonderfully. Also: "Hardwon! Catch!"
Propaganda: (anonymous) Not only is the battlefield dynamic and engaging (having Ultrus and his cronies switching between battlefields, making it effectively two battles at once) it also has narrative emotional stakes and big character moments (Old Cobb’s last words to Hardwon).
(also this post)
The concurrent battles in the material plane and in the demiplane, Ultrus's ability to switch between the two so everyone got to fight both him and the warlock goons, the extra abilities stolen from the trapped prisoners, the mechanics for breaking out of the helm, HARDWON AND JAINA AND THE DWARF DADDIES
god i know so many people will add this one but i love it so much. the way they jump back and forth between the Trial by Steel and the fight inside the helm is SO GOOD. i still have goosebumps from Jaina throwing the queenshammer through the barrier and Hardwon catching it. also the stakes were SO HIGH it was FANTASTIC. 10/10 combat
HUGE!!!! ITS HUGE!!!!! omg where to even start with this. the rolls alone feels INSANE AGSHAJDJSKD. JAINA AND CALDER. THE MOMENT WITH THE KINGSHAMMER. CALDER SUCCESSFULLY TACKLING ULTRUS. HARDWON GETTING A 30 TO PUT HIM IN THE HAMMER. THE SPIRIT GUARDIANS???????? I CRIED
truly the epitome of murph encounters! two different battles waging at the same time, with different combat styles (one big enemy vs lots of weaker baddies) in different planes, that then switch so everyone gets to fight in every situation. great group of PCs and NPCs that make excellent choices (shoutout to jake for playing two characters at once!), tons of emotional beats, and a very satisfying narrative closure to the arc. gotta love it
Final two polls will go up around 10am eastern today!
If you have any additional propaganda, send it now! you can also reblog the poll posts with it and I will but those on here as well.
The Semifinals round has ended! The results were incredibly close, but we have our winners as we head to the final, week long polls.
First Place:
1. High King Durretar vs 2. Lord Ultrus
Third Place:
4. Heradecia and Cerenysus vs 11. Thiala
If you would like to send in propaganda for any of the remaining contenders, please do! I have loved reading all the pitches for why certain encounters are the best!!
Only a couple hours left in the second to last round!
Vote, tell your friends to vote, bribe your neighbors to vote!
Encounter Tournament - Semifinals 2
Lord Ultrus
Thiala
Option 1:
Enemy: Lord Ultrus and the Order of the Runny Eye
Episode: C3 E44: Trial by Steel and C3 E45: Lord Ultrus
Time: 1:04:08 (44) - 1:42:08 (45)
Finish: Hardwon (traps Ultrus in the Kingshammer)
Notes: Hardwon starts the battle with a Battlemaster ability. Jaina and Calder finally get involved in a fight (from inside the helm!!). Callie joins them inside the helm, and Ultrus and the cultists keep swapping who is inside the helm and who is outside the helm. Hardwon has a real Hardwon moment of standing alone, facing down a god (or a giant who made a deal with a god and has the powers of a god, who was responsible for the death of his best friend). Sol does some shenanigans and kind of keeps missing but is also impossible to hit. Kenna keeps saving lives. I cannot actually describe in words the moment where Hardwon regains the Kingshammer, casts Spirit Guardians, and an army joins them, as we get to finally see Cobb's final moments and the memory that was stored in the hammer. Jake is playing 2 PCs wonderfully. Also: "Hardwon! Catch!"
Propaganda: (anonymous) Not only is the battlefield dynamic and engaging (having Ultrus and his cronies switching between battlefields, making it effectively two battles at once) it also has narrative emotional stakes and big character moments (Old Cobb’s last words to Hardwon). (also this post)
Option 2:
Enemy: Thiala
Episodes: C1 E100: Heart of the World
Time: (ads) 58:56-2:41:30 (*used the ads version because it's two episodes on patreon so it wouldn't be a great timestamp)
Finish: Moonshine
Notes: Hardwon's insane first 2 rounds (almost 600 damage! and he does miss!!). Moonshine counterspells and then uses Chill Touch to make sure all of Hardwon's damage can stick. The flashback scenes that do psychic damage and enlighten the audience at the last minute on characters we hadn't seen a lot of. Bev goes Elder Champion and casts revivify as a bonus action. The terrain moves to in front of the Heart of the World where Melora and Telaine are holding the world together. Ulfgar and Alanis are used for their power by Thiala, and Galad is fucking back and Thiala's bestie. Erlin is freed by Handy Andy. "I'm gonna fucking eat her."
Propaganda: (anonymous) hardwon surefoot deals 582 points of damage against thiala in two rounds. that’s all
Encounter Tournament - Semifinals 1
High King Durretar
Heradecia and Cerenysus
Option 1:
Enemy: High King Durretar, Ancient Blue Dragon of the Sapphire Scale
Episode: C3 E27: King of Dragons
Time: 48:48-2:11:35 (battle stops at 2:03:55 but initiative ends at the later time)
Finish: Princess Shiverblight
Notes: On 3, regicide! The level 8 party decides to fight an ancient dragon on their own when only one of them manages to long rest beforehand. The mechanics of this encounter include dragon riding and are so goddam cool. It's also incredibly visual and one of Murph's best uses of lair actions to date.
Propaganda: (anonymous) CMON ITS KING OF DRAGONS. SO SICK. genuinely from the bottom of my heart the most exciting, interesting, and cool encounter I've ever seen. Rad as hell both mechanically and plot wise. SHIVERBLIGHT SWEEP!!
Option 2:
Enemy: Heradecia and Cerenysus
Episode: C2 E41: Cerenysus
Time: 4:04-2:46:22
Finish: Fia (Cerenysus), Jabari (Heradecia)
Notes: 2 concurrent battles. 2 spellcasting enemies. 2 players juggling 2 PCs each. Surprise Lou and Hexbuds! Caldwell as Lake, Lou ass the spells. Emboldening bond and damage sponging. Living spells for Fia to fight. Jabari trapped in banishment with dry toads. Corbeau staying up and almost forgetting the death ward. Zirk's fucking crown removal and the deal he makes for his life. Hank breaking the curse. Tarragon's halfling abilities coming in clutch. Fia casts the first revivify in Eldermourne in centuries.
Propaganda: (anonymous) Fia won't fight Irina. The hexbloods are fighting their mom again. Lou Wilson voices the living spells. Caldwell gets to be the dog. Zirk fucking dies and then Fia tells hank to kill her girl(hood) friend it's all so crazy. It's 4 players and 6 PCs across 2 locations fighting 2 demigods and one demigod is kinda mind controlling the other. It's just a great final fight.
Schedule update!
Semifinals polls will go up in about 20 minutes!
Final polls (first and third place) will be published on Thursday and will last a week, unlike the other polls in this tournament.
If you have propaganda to add, reblog the poll and put it in the comments (or send an ask) and I’ll put it on this blog!
Semifinals Bracket!!
Polls will go up tomorrow morning! Send propaganda if you want!!
Encounter Tournament - 4.3
Lord Ultrus
Dragon Wilhelm Bronzebeard, Marabelle's Pretender, Beverly Toegold IV
Option 1:
Enemy: Lord Ultrus and the Order of the Runny Eye
Episode: C3 E44: Trial by Steel and C3 E45: Lord Ultrus
Time: 1:04:08 (44) - 1:42:08 (45)
Finish: Hardwon (traps Ultrus in the Kingshammer)
Notes: Hardwon starts the battle with a Battlemaster ability. Jaina and Calder finally get involved in a fight (from inside the helm!!). Callie joins them inside the helm, and Ultrus and the cultists keep swapping who is inside the helm and who is outside the helm. Hardwon has a real Hardwon moment of standing alone, facing down a god (or a giant who made a deal with a god and has the powers of a god, who was responsible for the death of his best friend). Sol does some shenanigans and kind of keeps missing but is also impossible to hit. Kenna keeps saving lives. I cannot actually describe in words the moment where Hardwon regains the Kingshammer, casts Spirit Guardians, and an army joins them, as we get to finally see Cobb's final moments and the memory that was stored in the hammer. Jake is playing 2 PCs wonderfully. Also: "Hardwon! Catch!"
Propaganda: (anonymous) The concurrent battles in the material plane and in the demiplane, Ultrus's ability to switch between the two so everyone got to fight both him and the warlock goons, the extra abilities stolen from the trapped prisoners, the mechanics for breaking out of the helm, HARDWON AND JAINA AND THE DWARF DADDIES
Option 2:
Enemy: Dragon Wilhelm Bronzebeard, Marabelle's Pretender, Beverly Toegold IV
Episodes: C1 E81: Greed, Anger, Heresy
Time: 7:31-56:33
Finish: everybody gets their guy (Moonshine first, then Hardwon, then Bev)
Notes: 3 separate one on one battles. Moonshine has to save Paw Paw, defend her role as fungal queen, and her spores damage changes (permanently option to change as well) to adapt to the circumstance. She also finishes with the dope max damage mechanic from Blight. Hardwon has to fight a dragon with just his dads, the dragon steals his hammer so he finds the Bronzebeard one. Bronzebeard is rejected by the hammer, even when he has it, and Hardwon gets to prove that he's the better man, once and for all. Bev is fighting his dad. It's not great. He smites his dad, hastes himself, and crits because of his casino drink. He then goes unconscious and is brought back up due to his dad storing Lay on Hands in the Devil Book long ago. He then sends his dad to Shadowfell and the Dusk Mother.
Propaganda: (anonymous) i literally dont even feel the need to say anything about it because the encounter speaks for itself. it's absolutely incredible
Propaganda for Greed, Anger, Heresy:
Moonshine: My name is Moonshine Cybin and I'm here to protect the Crick. On every possible plane.
Moonshine: (As Beverly turns away from facing his father) I will love you no matter what you choose. But a child has a duty to his father, a hero has a duty to the world. It’s time for you to decide what you are.
Beverly (to his father): All I’ve been doing this entire journey is collecting people who were as cool as you.
Hardwon puts his hair up in a topknot and Wilhelm snarls "That's a dwarven topknot, take it down." Hardwon answers "I'm more of a dwarf than you, you fucking dragon."
Beverly: This is where the sweet saltwater of Pelor baptized me, Dad. Come on. DM: You see a look of concern on his face, and then he looks up at you and says “I don’t remember that at all”.
Also, going to elaborate on the moment Beverly goes unconcious and gets healed from the book his father gave him:
Murph: Your father swings into you with this staggering smite, critical hit, right in the chest, right in the heart. An explosion of necrotic energy, you feel yourself fading… and then your book begins to glow. You know what it feels like when Moonshine heals you, when you take a healing potion… this is your father’s magic. This is what healed you when you fell off a horse, this is what heals you when you got a scratch on your nose.
Also, this is technically the aftermath of the fight but I'm including it:
Moonshine: In the coming days, you are going to second guess whether you did the right thing every single day, and I want to be the first voice to tell you that you did the right thing. Beverly: You are who I thought of in those moments, because I thought even if I had to send my dad away, nothing is going to keep me from coming home with y’all.
Encounter Tournament - 4.1
High King Durretar
Undead Dragon, Wilhelm and Rust Bronzebeard, Pale Prince, Akarot
Option 1:
Enemy: High King Durretar, Ancient Blue Dragon of the Sapphire Scale
Episode: C3 E27: King of Dragons
Time: 48:48-2:11:35 (battle stops at 2:03:55 but initiative ends at the later time)
Finish: Princess Shiverblight
Notes: On 3, regicide! The level 8 party decides to fight an ancient dragon on their own when only one of them manages to long rest beforehand. The mechanics of this encounter include dragon riding and are so goddam cool. It's also incredibly visual and one of Murph's best uses of lair actions to date.
Propaganda: (anonymous) CMON ITS KING OF DRAGONS. SO SICK. genuinely from the bottom of my heart the most exciting, interesting, and cool encounter I've ever seen. Rad as hell both mechanically and plot wise. SHIVERBLIGHT SWEEP!!
Option 2:
Enemy: Undead Dragon, Wilhelm Bronzebeard, Pale Prince, Akarot, Rust Bronzebeard
Episodes: C1 E45: Kingshammer
Time: (ads) 38:36 - 1:45:58 (but don't stop there. fr)
Finish: Bev (Wilhelm* (*Technically killed by gravity but Bev did trip with him on his back), Dragon), Hardwon (Rust* (*given the option of catching him, refused), Pale Prince)
Notes: Hardwon faces his childhood bullies in the snow. Wilhelm casts Earthquake and turns things into a fall/chase encounter as everyone races for the Kingshammer. Moonshine jumps down immediately to play defense. Bev tries to kill Akarot, who just leaves, and then has to keep saving everyone. He ends up being the only one with decent HP at the end, and this fight is so close to a TPK. Hardwon gets the Kingshammer. Paw Paw has to do CPR on Balnor.
Propaganda: (anonymous) The fact that Murph was able to design this sheer number of factors and have it be balanced perfectly as a dire, near-deadly, but winnable fight, is so impressive. And those factors were so creative. There was the kingshammer falling 2d100 every round, and players able to run or fall to get to it, a complicated goal that invited gambling, sacrifice, and creative use of spells. There was major bad guy Akarot in his prime body, the pale prince, and a fucking white dragon. There was Wilhelm Bronzebeard and his shit nephew-son who wouldn’t pick a side. There was Toma and her wolf slowly steadily running down the mountain in the background lol. There was escalation that made the battle start before Wilhelm’s avalanche, navigated flexibly by Murph. He was not fucking around, throwing Bev’s amulet into the snow, and keeping track of so many enemies and their conflicting motivations as well as their mechanics. The imagery in my mind of the chaotic tumbling snow is so real, and the scene of the last conscious pc exchanging blows with a dragon was so fucking epic. And the terror at the end of genuinely not knowing whether they were going to have won the battle only to freeze to death. Such a thick sode, a chunky battle, an incredible narrative, such a cool encounter for an arc finale.
Propaganda for Mt. Forge:
Every single character, including the ones the party was actively fighting, ending up on the back of the plummeting dragon.
Hardwon hearing Gemma whisper "My tall dwarf" as he grabs the hammer.
The first appearance of the Kingshammer spirit guardians, also known as Hardwon's dwarf daddies.
Hardwon: I hold onto the hammer and say "Gemma, wherever you are, watch this". And I roll a Nat. 1.
Moonshine (As both Balnor and Hardwon are unconscious): I'm going to come out of my rage, bonus action Healing Word Balnor, and jump onto Hardwon and stab him with the pep stick.
Encounter Tournament - 4.4
Queen Ezra
Thiala
Option 1:
Enemy: Queen Ezra the Unkind
Episodes: C1 E57: Frozen Hearts
Time: 1:07:50-1:59:00
Finish: Hardwon
Notes: Ezra does mental probes and reveals things about party members while dealing psychic damage (Moonshine's dad is a high elf, Galad has Lydia in Shadowfell, Bev IV made a deal with Akarot). Moonshine's heals keep getting countered. Hardwon kisses Moonshine to help her. Hardwon also calls Bev his little brother when Bev goes down. Paw Paw gets really sad when Moonshine's heart is frozen.
Propaganda: (anonymous) I love fights that make the characters confront what they assumed and who they are and come out stronger from in. I also love fights that leave the characters completely exhausted physically and emotionally.
Option 2:
Enemy: Thiala
Episodes: C1 E100: Heart of the World
Time: (ads) 58:56-2:41:30 (*used the ads version because it's two episodes on patreon so it wouldn't be a great timestamp)
Finish: Moonshine
Notes: Hardwon's insane first 2 rounds (almost 600 damage! and he does miss!!). Moonshine counterspells and then uses Chill Touch to make sure all of Hardwon's damage can stick. The flashback scenes that do psychic damage and enlighten the audience at the last minute on characters we hadn't seen a lot of. Bev goes Elder Champion and casts revivify as a bonus action. The terrain moves to in front of the Heart of the World where Melora and Telaine are holding the world together. Ulfgar and Alanis are used for their power by Thiala, and Galad is fucking back and Thiala's bestie. Erlin is freed by Handy Andy. "I'm gonna fucking eat her."
Propaganda: (anonymous) hardwon surefoot deals 582 points of damage against thiala in two rounds. that’s all
Propaganda for Queen Ezra, because it's my favorite fight in all of naddpod:
At the beginning of the fight, Queen Ezra says, "There have been many Seelie queens over the years, but only one Unseelie. And in the end, I will rule both courts." Bev looks at Queen Ezra, who has been described as having a thorny crown growing into her eyes, and cheerfully says, "you can try."
Both Queen Ezra and Murph as a DM don't pull any punches for the rest of this fight. The revelation about Moonshine's father being a high elf could've been so easily played for comedy, but Murph and Emily really lean on how devastating this would be to Moonshine. Ezra describes Marabelle's lie to Moonshine that Jolene wasn't her mother, and then continues, saying to Moonshine, "she told you that she was your mother, that you were a monster. That was a lie. The truth is more painful, I'm afraid." Moonshine, after her heart has been frozen, says quietly to her party "Why would you touch me, I might rub off on you," and responds to Beverly holding her with "That's nice, but when you're dead inside, you won't feel nothing." When Pawpaw starts to get ice in his fur, Moonshine says "It's my fault. I did this for you."
After Hardwon kisses Moonshine to try to snap her out of the feeling, Murph narrates it as "You feel worthless, you feel like no one will ever love you, you feel like the thing that’s most important to you, your identity as a Crick elf, is in question, you’re half high-elf… and then Hardwon runs over and plants a big one on you." Later, Ezra looks at Hardwon and says "Oh, you think you can save her?" and Hardwon, who started the campaign desperate to play the hero and earn other people's respect, responds "I think she can save herself."
After hearing his mother's voice when he died temporarily, Ezra shows Hardwon how his mother is being tortured in Shadowfell, that killing Galad Rosell was for nothing, and tells him "The person who brought you into this world, and you sentenced her to an eternity of suffering… you are a bastard, indeed.”
When Moonshine takes her turn, she looks at Hardwon and says "I don't deserve you", and casts Bear's Endurance on the party. Ezra counters, saying "You really don't deserve it." Trying to save against the curse, Moonshine says "I look to my friends to see if they agree what she said." Beverly says "You can't see me because I'm currently hugging your leg."
Beverly has seen Moonshine fall to the curse and Hardwon emotionally ravaged in order to fight it off, two of the people he looks up to the most. Ezra shows him the truth that Erlin is fighting because he wants to make Beverly proud of him, that his father made a deal with a literal devil in order to save Beverly. He has been trying to help Moonshine this entire time to no avail. He is not yet sixteen years old. As his heart is breaking, he tells Queen Ezra, "You may have told me the truth, but it’s lead to your own death. I'll take that, and I will walk with it, and I'll have it, and I’ll wear that guilt. I’ll wear it like a crown, and it will make me strong, and we’ll get through this together." Queen Ezra responds "If you don't freeze first." Bev fails the saving throw, but he tried so very hard when everything was falling apart around him, and I think that's worth recognizing.
Balnor, the person who none of the characters thought was capable of doing anything at his introduction, including Balnor himself, is the character who tries to snap Beverly out of it by telling him how strong their party really is.
And after all this, Hardwon finishes the fight by giving the finishing move to Moonshine, who slices her with the broken glass of the nannerfly jar she threw at her earlier in the fight out of desperation.
Encounter Tournament - 4.4
Queen Ezra
Thiala
Option 1:
Enemy: Queen Ezra the Unkind
Episodes: C1 E57: Frozen Hearts
Time: 1:07:50-1:59:00
Finish: Hardwon
Notes: Ezra does mental probes and reveals things about party members while dealing psychic damage (Moonshine's dad is a high elf, Galad has Lydia in Shadowfell, Bev IV made a deal with Akarot). Moonshine's heals keep getting countered. Hardwon kisses Moonshine to help her. Hardwon also calls Bev his little brother when Bev goes down. Paw Paw gets really sad when Moonshine's heart is frozen.
Propaganda: (anonymous) I love fights that make the characters confront what they assumed and who they are and come out stronger from in. I also love fights that leave the characters completely exhausted physically and emotionally.
Option 2:
Enemy: Thiala
Episodes: C1 E100: Heart of the World
Time: (ads) 58:56-2:41:30 (*used the ads version because it's two episodes on patreon so it wouldn't be a great timestamp)
Finish: Moonshine
Notes: Hardwon's insane first 2 rounds (almost 600 damage! and he does miss!!). Moonshine counterspells and then uses Chill Touch to make sure all of Hardwon's damage can stick. The flashback scenes that do psychic damage and enlighten the audience at the last minute on characters we hadn't seen a lot of. Bev goes Elder Champion and casts revivify as a bonus action. The terrain moves to in front of the Heart of the World where Melora and Telaine are holding the world together. Ulfgar and Alanis are used for their power by Thiala, and Galad is fucking back and Thiala's bestie. Erlin is freed by Handy Andy. "I'm gonna fucking eat her."
Propaganda: (anonymous) hardwon surefoot deals 582 points of damage against thiala in two rounds. that’s all
Encounter Tournament - 4.3
Lord Ultrus
Dragon Wilhelm Bronzebeard, Marabelle's Pretender, Beverly Toegold IV
Option 1:
Enemy: Lord Ultrus and the Order of the Runny Eye
Episode: C3 E44: Trial by Steel and C3 E45: Lord Ultrus
Time: 1:04:08 (44) - 1:42:08 (45)
Finish: Hardwon (traps Ultrus in the Kingshammer)
Notes: Hardwon starts the battle with a Battlemaster ability. Jaina and Calder finally get involved in a fight (from inside the helm!!). Callie joins them inside the helm, and Ultrus and the cultists keep swapping who is inside the helm and who is outside the helm. Hardwon has a real Hardwon moment of standing alone, facing down a god (or a giant who made a deal with a god and has the powers of a god, who was responsible for the death of his best friend). Sol does some shenanigans and kind of keeps missing but is also impossible to hit. Kenna keeps saving lives. I cannot actually describe in words the moment where Hardwon regains the Kingshammer, casts Spirit Guardians, and an army joins them, as we get to finally see Cobb's final moments and the memory that was stored in the hammer. Jake is playing 2 PCs wonderfully. Also: "Hardwon! Catch!"
Propaganda: (anonymous) The concurrent battles in the material plane and in the demiplane, Ultrus's ability to switch between the two so everyone got to fight both him and the warlock goons, the extra abilities stolen from the trapped prisoners, the mechanics for breaking out of the helm, HARDWON AND JAINA AND THE DWARF DADDIES
Option 2:
Enemy: Dragon Wilhelm Bronzebeard, Marabelle's Pretender, Beverly Toegold IV
Episodes: C1 E81: Greed, Anger, Heresy
Time: 7:31-56:33
Finish: everybody gets their guy (Moonshine first, then Hardwon, then Bev)
Notes: 3 separate one on one battles. Moonshine has to save Paw Paw, defend her role as fungal queen, and her spores damage changes (permanently option to change as well) to adapt to the circumstance. She also finishes with the dope max damage mechanic from Blight. Hardwon has to fight a dragon with just his dads, the dragon steals his hammer so he finds the Bronzebeard one. Bronzebeard is rejected by the hammer, even when he has it, and Hardwon gets to prove that he's the better man, once and for all. Bev is fighting his dad. It's not great. He smites his dad, hastes himself, and crits because of his casino drink. He then goes unconscious and is brought back up due to his dad storing Lay on Hands in the Devil Book long ago. He then sends his dad to Shadowfell and the Dusk Mother.
Propaganda: (anonymous) i literally dont even feel the need to say anything about it because the encounter speaks for itself. it's absolutely incredible
Encounter Tournament - 4.2
Heradecia and Cerenysus
Glen and the Old Folks' Circle
Option 1:
Enemy: Heradecia and Cerenysus
Episode: C2 E41: Cerenysus
Time: 4:04-2:46:22
Finish: Fia (Cerenysus), Jabari (Heradecia)
Notes: 2 concurrent battles. 2 spellcasting enemies. 2 players juggling 2 PCs each. Surprise Lou and Hexbuds! Caldwell as Lake, Lou ass the spells. Emboldening bond and damage sponging. Living spells for Fia to fight. Jabari trapped in banishment with dry toads. Corbeau staying up and almost forgetting the death ward. Zirk's fucking crown removal and the deal he makes for his life. Hank breaking the curse. Tarragon's halfling abilities coming in clutch. Fia casts the first revivify in Eldermourne in centuries.
Propaganda: (anonymous) Fia won't fight Irina. The hexbloods are fighting their mom again. Lou Wilson voices the living spells. Caldwell gets to be the dog. Zirk fucking dies and then Fia tells hank to kill her girl(hood) friend it's all so crazy. It's 4 players and 6 PCs across 2 locations fighting 2 demigods and one demigod is kinda mind controlling the other. It's just a great final fight.
Option 2:
Enemy: Glen and the corrupted Old Folks' Circle
Episode: C3 E29: Crown of Dreams
Time: 43:30-1:27:38
Finish: none! The Old Folks escape and Glen just hangs out. Ultrus gets Calder.
Notes: poisoned. surprised. confused. stabbed. bitten. This was supposed to be a fast encounter where the Helm of Ultrus got stolen and that was it. And then Jake said "no." Glen is frazzled and losing it. Eloise's heel turn is completed. There's a hilarious bit about Callie and confusion while everyone is trying to subdue the Duck Team so they can get the helm. Calder decides to make the harder saving throw (and fight Ultrus inside the helm!) to keep Ultrus from Glen. Sol goes down, hard, and the Old Folks are supposed to not hit to kill. They haven't long rested since well before the King of Dragons fight at this point!! And, of course, "Ultrus. Make a deal with me."
Propaganda: (anonymous) moments of ever. the building tension. the accumulating failure. THE CLIMAX. it's everything