The destination area of our expedition, Cordillera Blanca (CB) and Cordillera Huayhuash (CH), are the most prominent mountains ranges in all of Peru. CB is a straight mountain chain, 180km long, with NNW to SSE direction, running parallel to the coast from 8°5’ S to 10° S latitude. It also forms the main watershed. From a geologic perspective, CB is made of plutonic rocks that have penetrated into the layers of the Earth’s crust. These rocks consist mainly of light color granodiorite (intrusive igneous rock containing more plagioclase than orthoclase type feldspar), which can be found in the glaciated areas, forming the base of the peaks. Stratified rocks such as black slate (foliated, homogenous, metamorphic rock) surround the granodiorite. These seem folded and strongly compressed towards the crests (Kinzl and Schneider, 1950).
Cordillera Blanca offers some of the best mountaineering in South America. Its advantageous position in relation to traffic routes and exceptional bold, high summits make CB an accessible high altitude climb. From a climate perspective, CB has a tropical climate with two main seasons (dry and wet) alternating according to the distribution of rainfall. The rainy season begins in November and ends in April reaching its greatest intensity in January to March. The dry season occupies the other months and it is the best season to visit the two cordilleras.
Cordillera Huayhuash is a compact sub region of Cordillera Occidental, 30km long with NNW to SSE direction, running fairly parallel to the coast from 10°8’ S to 10°24’ S latitude. It contains sharp summits, six of which exceed 6000m. The geology of Huayhuash comprises limestone, interbedded with sandstone and shale. Volcanic activity is also present under the forms of cinder cones, hydrothermal alteration (sulphate minerals and iron oxide) and vertical hexagonal columns comprising lithic tuff. In some limestone beds, marine fossils such as ammonites and bivalves can be found. CH is home to some of the most spectacular and difficult alpine climbing in all of the Andes as well as one of the best treks in the word, known as the Great Huayhaush Trek (Frimer, 2003).
The Deutscher und Osterreichischer Alpenverein (DuOAV) expeditions, created the world-renowned Alpenverein maps, using terrestrial photogrammetry from mid to high altitude photopoints. Moreover, thousands of glass negative plates and Leica photographs were also produced. These historic landscape photographs provide a unique opportunity to qualitatively document contemporary landscape changes (Byers, 2000) The maps below show details regarding the photo locations and transportation links for the main research area, Cordillera Blanca as well as the trekking route in Cordillera Huayhuash.
The Huascaran National Park
The Huascaran National Park is situated in the Ancash department in the north – central part of Peru and includes most of the Cordillera Blanca. The national park was established in 1975 and two years later was declared a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve. The park hosts 60 peaks with altitudes above 5700m, the highest being Huascaran 6768m. Forty-four glacial valleys transect the range from both west and east. The terrain below 4800m is characterized by high altitude grassland (puna) with remnant quenual (Polylepsis species) forests located within the upper inner valley slopes. The Polylepsis forest cover contains a high diversity of flora and fauna as well as providing habitat for many endemic species of Andean birds. Unfortunately, the Polylepsis forests have been drastically reduced during the past century, with as less as 3% of the original forest continues to remain today.
West of the park lies the agricultural and earthquake-affected valley of the Santa river, a densely populated region containing cities such as Huaraz (90 000 inhabitants), Caraz (15 000 inhabitants) as well as hundreds of rural villages. These cities are relatively prosperous however most of rural settlers still rely on subsidence as means of living. Incomes are mainly based on agriculture, livestock and growing tourism especially in the west parts of the park.
Important environmental issues exist in the area. These comprise of: overgrazing of alpine and subalpine pastures, concentrated tourism, uncertain land titles and park boundaries, government policies supportive of resource extraction within the national park and subsequent external pressures such as new roads, mining, dams and tourist infrastructure. However, during 1995 and 1996, the Mountain Institute along with governmental, non-governmental, private sector and local communities produced the Huascaran National Park Ecological Management Plan, the country’s first participatory plan for protected areas (Byers, 2000).
Repeat photography is an analytical tool capable of broadly and rapidly providing preliminary clarifications related to landscape/ land use changes within a given region. This was aided by interviews with local people and scientists, literature reviews. The specialist equipment that was used included: a Canon EOS Mk III DSLR camera with three different lens systems: EFS18-55mm f/2.8, Canon 24-105mm f/4 IS and Canon EF 70-300mm f/4-5.6 IS; a Canon EOS 550D DSLR camera with two lens systems: Canon EFS 18-55mm, f/3.5-5.6 IS, Tamron AF 28-300mm f/1:3.5-6.3 IF and a Panasonic DMC LX2 28mm digital compact camera. For the video documentation of our expedition we have used a HD Sony Handycam and a Go Pro Hero 2 video camera. Unfortunately due to the poor quality of the batteries, we used the GoPro little. Personal, photography and location release forms provided by the National Geographic Society were filled in by every person and landlord interviewed or photographed. For individuals lacking literacy skills a simple video acknowledgment was used.
It is important here to specify some of the problems that have arisen during our fieldwork. Ideally, the historic photographs should be replicated using the precise equipment used by the original photographer. Season, time/date and weather conditions should also be replicated as closely as possible. This was quite challenging due to practical and budgetary reasons and the remoteness and high altitude of the photo locations. The lack of time and the late departure date of our expedition, forced us to reduce the number of photo locations. We also tried to identify areas, which provided both scientific and mountaineering interest, in order to double our efficiency. Nevertheless, the overall objective of high quality reproduction of the historic photographs to address landscape changes in the two cordilleras has been reached. Moreover, insights regarding other problems that the local communities are facing have made us reconsider our objectives.
The Alpenverein maps used for our research included: DON, Deutschen Alpenverein und den Osterreichischen Alpenvereins, Munchen, 1932. “Cordillera Blanca y el Callejon de Huailas (Peru)”, scale 1: 100,000 and 100m contour intervals. This map is commonly referred to as the Parte Norte or north sheet of the Cordillera Blanca. The DON, Deutschen Alpenverein und den Osterreichischen Alpenvereins, Innsbruck, 1939. “Cordillera Blanca Parte Sur” or south part of Cordillera Blanca with scale 1: 100,000 and 100m contour interval was also used. Moreover, we also acquired the Cordillera Blanca und Mittleres Santa-Tal (Peru). Cordillera-Blanca-Expedition des Deutschen und Österreichischen Alpenvereins, 1932. Expeditionsleiter Dr. Ph. Borchers scale 1:100,000. Lastly, we also used a new map of Cordillera Huayhuash, entitled: DAV Alpenvereinskarte Cordillera Huayhuash (Peru), 2008. Scale 1: 50 000.
The Google map image below shows the main photo locations used in our research. These locations have been cross-referenced with the Alpenverein maps, journals and expedition report. Our contact in Peru, mountain guide Mr Christian Silva Lindo has proven to be very insightful in finding these locations in the field. His knowledge of the area was crucial to our fieldwork.
Figure 1: Map showing our photo locations after cross-referring with the locations from the Alpenverein maps
Our expedition managed to reproduce 21 pairs of photographs. 14 of which are shown here in greater detail.
Nevado Ranrapalca (6126m)
Date: 08.08.20102 Aspect: 272°
Time: 12:41 Map Station: S24
Altitude: 5028m Original: DuOAV
Figure 2: Nevado Ranrapalca (6162m). DuOAV, 1939
Figure 3: Nevado Ranrapalca (6126m). S. Jiduc, 2012
The thinning and retreat of several hundred meters of ice is clearly visible from the two photographs. The formation of a new glacial lake in the cirque depression at the bottom on the SE side of Ranrapalca, (right hand side of figure 3) is probably due to the meltwater coming from glacier and snow cover above. The erosive effect of glacier ice can also be observed.
Glacier Lake Palcacocha, Quebrada Cojup
Date: 08.08.2012 Aspect: 01°
Time: 13:04 Map Station: S24
Altitude: 4991m Original: DuOAV
Figure 4: Glacier Lake Palcacocha, Q. Cojup. DuOAV, 1939
Figure 5: Glacier Lake Palcacocha, Q.Cojup. S. Jiduc 2012
Palcacocha is a tropical glacier lake subjected to Glacier Lake Outburst Flood (GLOF). On December 13, 1941, an ice avalanche coming from a hanging glacier on Pucaranra – Palcacocha, fell into the impounded Palcacocha Lake showed in figure 4. This event caused the breaching of the terminal moraine that contained the lake. A massive wave swept down the entire Cohup valley, also entraining the water of another lake (Laguna Jiracocha) situated 2-3 miles down the valley. The combined water of the two lakes descended on Huaraz, delivering rock boulders, ice and liquid mud. More than 6000 people died and large parts of the city were destroyed (Ayers, 1954). The approximate arrival time of the flood was around 22 minutes with the peak in downstream discharge produced 33 minutes after the breach (conceptual models, Rivas, 2012). The flood has drained a large volume of water as shown by figure 5. Comparisons show widespread glacier recession, especially in the center and left hand side of the figure. The thinning of ice is also present on Palcaraju 6274m. New geomorphic features such as gullies, sumps, torrents have formed. Climate change is accelerating the retreat of tropical glaciers in Peru with hydrological consequences such as the increase in glacier lakes volume. Even though the 1941 GLOF has drained a substantial amount of water, the volume of Palcacocha Lake, has increased from 1941 to 2010 with over 7 million m3 mainly due to climate change induced glacier melting (Rivas, 2012). Knowledge about the behavior of an expected GLOF event in Palcacocha is required in order to identify emergency strategies to prevent human life losses as well major infrastructure damage in the downstream areas.
Date: 08.08.2012 Aspect: 038°
Time: 09:18 Map Station: S39
Altitude: 4525m Original: DuOAV, 1939
Figure 6: Glaciar Lake Palcacocha, Q. Cojup, DuOAV, 1939
Figure 7: Glacier Lake Palcacocha, Q.Cojup. S. Jiduc, 2012
Figure 8: Glacier Lake Palcacocha, Q. Cojup. S.Jiduc, 2012
This set of photographs shows the evolution of Palcacocha lake and the glaciers that surround the lake. Comparisons show extensive and widespread glacier retreat and thinning, especially in the center of figure 7 and the accumulation of moraine debris (probably due to erosion and rock avalanches) on the right hand side of figure 9. The size of the lake has increased substantially since 1941 due to increase in meltwater input. The Peruvian Government, Mountain Institute and Glaciological Institute have taken measures to prevent future GLOF. Figure 8 shows the construction of a dam as well as drainage pipes in order to control the water volume of the lake and prevent future GLOF. The water is drained through pipes, which are floating on the lake. Workers drag them using boats, ropes and human muscle power. This is one of the most important water supplies of Huaraz. A clear example of anthropic intervention in glaciated environments.
Breakthrough Morainal Dam, Quebrada Cojup
Date: 07.08.2012 Aspect: 020°
Time: 17:25 Map Station: S1
Altitude: 4368m Original: F.D. Ayres, 1954
Figure 9: Breakthrough Morainal Dam, Q. Cojup. F.D. Ayres, 1954
Figure 10: Breakthrough Morainal Dam, Q. Cojup. S.Rechitan 2012
Figures 9 and 10 show the breach caused by the ice avalanche. This is estimated to be around 45m high. Comparisons show an increase of the width of the breach due to erosion and the usage of boulder material for the construction of the dam and drainage system. The boulder flow that accompanied the flood can be clearly depicted in figure 11. Puna grassland (alpine vegetation) has covered some parts of this terrain. The degree of shrinkage and thinning of the glaciers on Pucaranra and Palcaraju is alarming. Since 1954, hundreds of meters of ice have disappeared. As a consequence, the Palcacocha lake behind the moraine has increased dramatically since the flood occurred.
View through the south cut of the moraine wall, Quebrada Cojup.
Date: 08.08.2012 Aspect: 188°
Time: 08: 49 Map Station: S2
Altitude: 4513 Original: F.D. Ayres, 1954
Figure 11: View down the south cut of the moraine wall. F.D. Ayers, 1954
Figure 12: View down the south cut of the moraine wall. S. Jiduc, 2012
This pair of photographs shows the view down between the walls of the south cut (breach) through the moraine when the 1941 flood occurred. In 1954, F.D. Ayers estimated that the height of the walls was around 150 feet. Today, the height of the wall is a few feet less. This change is mostly due to erosion processes as well as human intervention as moraine material was used to construct the Palcacocha dam, shown in figure 8. The width of the cut has also increased by a few feet. The moraine material is composed of debris, rock and ice deposits. The drainage pipes are visible in the bottom part of figure 12.
Glacier Lake Artesonraju, Quebrada Paron
Date: 15.08.2012 Aspect: 350°
Time: 14:30 Map Station: S37
Altitude: 4297m Original: DuOAV, 1939
Figure 13: Glacier Lake Artesonraju Q. Paron. DuOAV, 1939
Figure 14: Glacier Lake Artesonraju, Q.Paron, S.Jiduc, 2012
This pair of photographs is a clear example of the alarming amount of ice cover that has disappeared in last 80 years. The rock face in the center of the figure is around 400m high. It is easily observed that the entire hanging glacier has disappeared. The lake has increased substantially in size and volume. The large seracs present in figure 14 on the SW face of Artesonraju have disappeared also. Runoff has increased since 1939. A small dam has been built at the western shore of the lake where natural streams drain the lake. As in the case of lake Palcacocha, in Quebrada Cojup, this dam controls the water discharge further down the valley and prevents dangerous increases in water volume. Considering the importance of the hydrological properties of Paron Valley (i.e. Paron dam and tunnel, Canon de Plata hydroelectric plan) this area is one of the most accurately investigated areas of Cordillera Blanca.
New Glacier Lake in the Paron Valley
Date: 12.08.2012 Aspect: 22°
Time: 16:45 Original: Sorin Rechitan, 2012
Figure 15: New Glacier Lake at the foot of Artesonraju. S. Rechitan, 2012.
This photograph shows the Paron Glacier between Artesonraju and Piramide (the same glacier as in figures 14 and 15). The glacier lake has formed between 1932 and 1940 at the Paron Glacier terminus, (described also by H. Kinzl, 1950). The lake has increased in size and volume ever since. In order to avoid a possible outburst of the lake through the terminal moraine, a drainage system, similar to that in Cojup Valley, has been built further downstream to control the water outflow. A monitoring station, which measures the glacier melt rate, snowfall, solar radiation intensity, wind speed, humidity and precipitation has been installed on the glacier. These measurements are important to assess the volume of water in the two lakes and thus prevent a sudden outburst. Such an event would be disastrous for the communities downstream and cities such as Caraz.
Date: 11.08.2012 Aspect: 057°
Time: 15:03 Map Station: S38
Altitude: 4346m Original: DuOAV, 1939
Figure 16: Laguna Paron, seen from Huandoy Moraine. DuOAV, 1939
Figure 17: Laguna Paron seen from Huandoy Moraine. S.Rechitan, 2012
Laguna Paron is the largest lake in Cordillera Blanca and was formally used for the Canon de Plata hydroelectric plan. An interview with a local worker has raised concerns about the current usage of the lake. Even though, the lake has substantial hydroelectric potential, the lake water is only used for irrigation. This is due to the privatization scandal, which started in 1994, and the negative effects on the local communities of the excessive discharge rate of 8m3/s. Even though the comparison of the photographs shows a decrease in the lake size, the lake has actually increased in volume due to the excess meltwater coming from the surrounding glaciers. The tunnel that was built for the hydroelectric station is used to drain the lake and thus the reason for the low level of the lake.
Yerupaja 6617m seen from L. Carhuacocha
Date: 21.08.2012 Aspect: 230°
Time: 08:20 Map Station: S43
Altitude: 4138m Original: DuOAV, 1936
Figure 18: Yerupaja from Laguna Carhuacocha. DuOAV, 1936
Figure 19: Yerupaja from Laguna Carhuacocha. S. Jiduc, 2012
Glacier recession is present on a massive scale in CH as well. Figure 19 shows the Yerupaja East Glacier, which has lost around 200m of ice since 1939. Most of the hanging ice is lost through serac falls and avalanches. Recession is also present on the left hand side of the photograph, on the col between Yerupaja and Siula Grande. We have seen an increase in the number, size and frequency of crevasses on all glaciers visited. Many climbing routes are now impracticable due to massive bergschurunds that cross the entire mountain faces, some 40 meters wide. We had many difficulties crossing these bergschrunds while climbing Yerupaja West Face. If route descriptions from the 1970’ acknowledged the existence of bergschrunds, today these crevasses are often too wide to cross. Low latitude glaciers are sensitive indicators in the climate system. The atmosphere in the low latitudes is thermally homogenous in space and time and thus seasonality is caused by the annual cycle of atmospheric.
Huascaran 6768m seen from Yungay Cemetery
Date: 06.08.2012 Aspect: 058°
Time: 15:04 Map Station: S21
Altitude: 2657m Original: DuOAV, 1939
Figure 20: Huascaran from Yungay Cemetery. DuOAV, 1939
Figure 21: Huascaran from Yungay Cemetery. S. Rechitan, 2012.
In 1970, Yungay city was completely destroyed and buried under a thick layer of liquefied mud, ice and boulders due to a 7.7M earthquake and its subsequent avalanche. The new city has been moved further north, however as visible in figure 23, people still live and work in the aluvion’s path. Eucalyptus species now populate the area more extensively than before the catastrophic event. The thinning and retreat of glaciers on Huascaran is spectacular. These people are totally reliant on the freshwater provided by the glaciers above.The limit marked by the difference in rock color (the lighter brown being the consequence of glacier erosion such as abrasion & plucking) represents the past snow line. Now, this line has progressed a few hundred meters up the mountain.
North View of Nevado Huascaran
Date: 09.08.2012 Aspect: 198
Time: 16:20 Map Station: S19
Altitude: 4500m Original: DuOav, 1939
Figure 22: North side of Huascaran seen from Llanganuco Valley. DuOAV, 1939.
Figure 23: North side of Huascaran seen from Llanganuco Valley. S.Rechitan, 2012.
This is another clear example of the massive scale glacier recession present in Cordillera Blanca. The highest peak in Peru has lost a few hundreds meters of snow and ice cover in the past 80 years. The North Summit is the most affected. Ice thinning is very obvious from this photographic comparison. Moreover, the moraine catchment has suffered severe changes such as moraine wall collapse, increase in surface area, rock and debris avalanches, ice retreat, and infills of melt water.
Date: 09.08.2012 Aspect: 165°
Time: 16:56 Map Station: S20
Altitude: 4726m Original DuOAV, 1939
Figure 24: North view of Nevado Chopicalqui. DuOAV, 1939.
Figure 25: North view of Nevado Chopicalqui. S. Rechitan, 2012.
This north view of Nevado Chopicalqui taken from the highest pass in Quebrada Llanganuco is another example of climate change induced glacier recession. The ice thinning is quite spectacular in some areas such as in the case of ice flutings. The glacier on the bottom left hand side of figure 24 has shrunk by a few hundred meters in the past 80 years. The hanging seracs present in the 1939 photograph (figure 24) have partially if not but all disappeared. The “Swiss roll” ice features present on the North ridge in the center of figure 25 have also shrunk considerably in size
Carhuas from Cordillera Negra
Date: 06.08.2012 Aspect: 072°
Time: 12:02 Map Station: S41
Altitude: 2829m Original: DuOAV, 1939
Figure 26: Carhuas. DuOAV, 1939
Figure 27: Carhuas. S.Jiduc, 2012
Carhuas has been entirely destroyed by the 1970 earthquake. A new city has been built on top of the old one, which has been populated with people from all around the country. According to interviews with local people, the population of the city has increased compared to the old one. The configuration of the city is similar; however the density of buildings is much greater. An increase in non-native eucalyptus species is observable. Regarding the cultivated areas and enclosed fields, there seems to be a decrease. Receding glaciers are visible in the background on Nevado Hualcan and Nevado Copa.
Date: 09.08.2012 Aspect: 234°
Time: 15:31 Map Station: S41
Altitude: 4493m Original: DuOAV, 1939
Figure 28: Quebrada Llanganuco DuOAV, 1939.
Figure 29: Quebrada LLanganuco S. Jiduc, 2012
Quebrada Llanganuco offers great views of Huascaran, Huandoy, Yanapaccha and Pisco (one of the most popular and easy climbs in CB) as well as the beautiful lakes Chinancocha and Orconcocha. Llanganuco experiences some intensive tourism, as a consequence of being included in the great Santa Cruz Trek, and providing the main access route to Pisco, Chopicalqui and Yanapaccha. Comparison of photographs show: a relative stability in the native ‘quenual’ (polylepsis) species, but an increase in anthropic impact. The building of the road that connects Callejón de Huaylas to Yanama, and other cities situated east of CB (Callejon de Conchucos), is one of the changes.
Panorama of Huandoy, Huascaran and Copa
Date: 06.08.2012 Aspect: 080°
Time: 17:00-18:00 Map Station: S9 and S10
Altitude: 3810 and 3850m, respectively. Original: DuOAV, 1939
Figure 30: Composite Panorama of N. Huandoy, N. Huascaran and N. Copa, seen from C. Negra. DuOAV, 1939
Figure 31: Composite Panorama of N. Huandoy, N. Huascaran and N. Nevado Copa, S. Rechitan and S. Jiduc, 2012
The panorama provides an overview of the amount of glacier recession that has occurred on the West Side of Cordillera Blanca. The new location of Yungay city is visible on the left side of figure 31. There is an obvious increase in cultivated lands and contained fields, as well as in the density and size of settlements. New roads have been built including one traversing the cordillera through Quebrada Llanganuco up to a pass at 4760m, showed in figure 29.
In the context of an increasing population, the melting of glaciers in CB and CH is affecting the vulnerability of Andean communities and their access to freshwater. As glaciers melt, there is a transitory increase in runoff, due to mass reduction. Nevertheless, water stored, as ice in glaciers is limited and the apparent increase in runoff is only temporary. In a few decades, after glaciers have lost substantial mass, a decrease in runoff will follow. This trend will be even more pronounced during the low flow season when the relative contribution of melt water is at its maximum (Barer, et al. 2012). In the next decades, many mountain communities could be at risk because of water shortages.
The 2007 IPCC report, pointed out that the Andes of Peru is one of the most biologically diverse areas of our planet. A research carried by Florida Institute of Technology, suggested that the new century may bring hundreds or even thousands of plant and animal extinctions to this richly endowed area as a consequence of climate change and growing anthropic impact on the natural ecosystems. Cordillera Blanca lost over 25% of its glacial ice in the last 30 years. With over 70% of the population living in the coastal desert and dependent entirely on mountain water, the Peruvian population is extremely sensitive to hydrological changes caused by climate induced glacier melting. Moreover, Peru is the third most vulnerable country in the world to extreme weather, following Honduras and Bangladesh. With climate models predicting that the intensity and frequency of extreme events such as storms, droughts and El Niño southern oscillations to increase in the near future, Peru seems to be one of the most affected countries in the world by human induced climate change.
Besides the alarming shrinkage of glaciers, and the impact on the hydrology of the Rio Santa watershed, interviews with the local people raised concerns regarding the legal and illegal mining, in both cordilleras. It seems there is a lack of information regarding the exact number of mines, and their effects on the local soil, and water resources. Some locals believe there are contaminating effects with no quantitative or qualitative account of them. This subject is taboo, and opinions are divided. As a developing country, Peru has the right to extract many of its valuable resources, but what is the impact on the environment? The lack of sewage and the heavy exploitation of the Rio Santa bed for construction purposes, as well as redirections of the water from the river, are also problems identified by us during our visit in the Rio Santa Valley. The pollution of C. Huayhuash due to the increase in tourism and subsequently an increase in the disposal of waste consists a main concern of environmental degradation. Garbage can be found on many trekking trails and this phenomenon is more widespread than ever before. The degradation of grasslands, alpine areas and aquatic systems due to camping and waste disposal is quite common in C. Huayhuash.
Another important problem is poverty. More than two out of three Andean people live in extreme poverty, with 6 million alone in Central Andes. Poverty in the Andean area is the result of a few factors such as: the poor productivity of land, fragility of mountain environments, weak infrastructure, lack of educational opportunities and social marginalization. The latter two have been pointed out after our collaboration with Changes for New Hope a NGO preoccupied with improving the lives of the poor and underprivileged children and their families in the Peruvian Andes. Through the dedication of Mr Jim Killon, the founder and president of the organization, along with volunteers and supporters worldwide, Changes for New Hope aims to help families living in poverty to become self-sufficient, to develop opportunities for children to reach their fullest potential and to enhance the level of respect, self-esteem and community awareness.