I don't normally engage with celebrity gossip but there's a documentary on one Hollywood family that I'm absolutely fiending to get my little pickled fingers on. It's a documentary on the Smith family, Will, Jada and their son are very curious personalities, and their time in the eye of the media makes them extremely interesting to me.
Will, for starters, is an industry icon. He's been in plenty of great films, and definitely has had a fair share of stinkers, but he's generally regarded as a talented, flexible actor. It's just very strange to then see him turn around and try to convince everyone that his family is an amazing, cohesive unit who spend a lot of time together. While that's fine if you just want to politely but distantly introduce your wife and kids to an executive at your company, it's going to play out a lot different to a camera with millions of people on the other end of the screen, and on some level, Will must know this. It's like he's trying to convince himself that his family is wonderful rather than share anecdotes about their time together, and that makes me feel like he's a deeply insecure person.
This theory of mine, that he's really insecure, definitely has some merit, I think.
Obviously, I have to bring up the Chris Rock-Will Smith Oscars slap. Appearantly, when Chris was doing his material, Will was laughing along to the jokes at his wife's expense. I say appearantly because this claim is just speculation from some photos. Though it does fit very neatly with the idea that he's insecure, and his wife is a narcissist, which isn't even debatable. She's cheated on him, and confessed to him because she thinks it would protect their family and support his happiness. There's also an infamous media appearance where Will talks about how set up a lavish 40th birthday party it was going to be a deep proclamation of love and she called it "the most ridiculous display of (Will's) ego".
To get back to the slapping, it fits into the idea that while he may have organically enjoyed the joke, she took so much offense she made him do something objectively humiliating to correct the situation. Will, despite his seeming lack of knowledge of how he might come across when he shares these really depressing glimpses into his family life, knows optics. If an A-list celebrity slaps a famous comedian on the stage of a yearly contest of Hollywoods most impressive tax write-offs, it's going to be all over the news, and it's not going to look like you made a rational decision.
It's going to make it look like your narcissistic wife didn't like that her bald-headed ass was catching some strays and, knowing that you're insecure, convinced you to stop laughing and make a fool of yourself in front of all your peers in the name of protecting her reputation. Because one thing narcissists hate is being criticized, even mild jokes. They have very thin skin. Disclaimer: I'm not saying she has Narcissistic Personality Disorder or something. Narcissism is still a trait independent of a psychological disorder.
Another example that supports my thesis that he's insecure is his terrible rapping he did a year or two ago. While I recommend listening to it because it feels like something a sheltered 11 year old would make with a baby's first DJ kit, the song is basically him repeating "I like pretty girls". Hardly Sappho's poetry. It's definitely got the highly sanitized feel of early Will Smith, but instead of feeling like the intent is to be family friendly, it feels more like he's very uncomfortable with his current identity and is trying to shift/return his public image to something explicitly positive.
It leads to some very cringey moments where he freestyles like a kid on rhymes.com on podcasts trying to promote his music, as well as ai generate crowds of fans cheering and dancing to his music, while when he did a live street show, it was underwhelming. Pretty much the only people moving were Will and the people he paid.
Everyone else just pointed their phones at him in probably one of the most horrifying situations I can imagine. Will must know that his music is being received poorly. If not by metrics, at the very least by the fact that crowd immediately around him is completely static, and are only there to watch him perform a droning, juvenile song he is presumably hoping returns him to a wholesome figure. Hundreds of phones, hundreds of eyes watching him with nothing but the nadir of enthusiasm, a motionless, judging sea of cameras as he performs his best, knowing the script he wrote has set him up for failure. Maybe, Will Smith is just an actor.