[PLL THEORY] Spencer has a twin sister that is Uber A since Season 5 + Aria was A’s helper in seasons 1-2-5-6 (PART 2)
Hey guys ^^ This is part 2. I hope you liked part 1 of my theory, and if you didn’t read it, here is the link. Now, I’m going explain why I think Aria is A’s helper in Seasons 1-2-5-6. But first, please, read the disclaimer:
DISCLAIMER
1- English is not my first language I could make some mistakes while writing it. You can send a message if you find any grammar mistakes. But my English is not really bad so I’m sure you’ll be able to understand it.
2- I’m not sure if anyone thought of a similar theory before, but I had the idea for this one by myself. I’m not copying anyone’s theory! So please credit me if you wanna spread this theory.
3- None of the images in post are mine. Credit to the owners ^^
4- SPOILERS ALERT
Aria Montgomery was A’s helper in Seasons 1-2-5-6A
So now I’m going to tell you why I think Aria is A. Many people believe that Aria is A and they have a lot of evidence actually. I’m not going to say all this over again, so if you wanna know more Aria being A, here’s a helpfull link to a blog that I like a lot
Link (by the way, I didn’t write anything in the theory in the link. aria-is-a-pll IS NOT MY BLOG. I just like it and recommend it).
I believe Aria was A in Season 1 and 2 mainly because of the evidence present in the post linked above. There were a lot of scenes that she looked suspicious and there were scenes that A had a perfect timing sending a text.
Like, in 02x16, when Hanna drinks the lake water, Emily tells Hanna to not drink that, because she saw that the color of the water is weird.
But then Aria says: “That’s lake water.” How does she know that? It’s only a weird colored water and Aria didn’t even touch the bottle, so if she knows that it’s lake water, she already knew it before.
And right after Hanna drinks it, she gets an A text, talking about the lake water. Okay, I know Mona is always watching them, but would she really stay all night long watching them just to send a text to Hanna when she drinks? It’s a lot easier to think that Aria waited for her to drink it and then sent her the text.
The image above shows the exact moment when Hanna gets the text. Aria is right behind her, and she looks distracted with something. If you watch this scene, you can see that right after Hanna drank the water, Aria changed her position and attention to something else. Like if she was sending the text.
This clue and many others make me believe that Aria was helping Mona in Seasons 1 & 2. Why? Well, I believe that really suffers from split personality and Mona found out about it. A person with split personality could have REALLY different personalities. So, Aria could have the personality we know and could have the A personality, that seeks revange from something that the girls or Alison did to her in the past, or is just a mean personality that want to them suffer.
Okay, so I believe that Aria was helping Mona in Seasons 1 and 2. The image (THAT IS NOT MY IMAGE. CREDITS TO THE OWNER) shows an example of a strange thing related to Aria.
(AGAIN, THE IMAGE ABOVE IS NOT MINE. CREDITS TO THE OWNER).
Aria was reading a magazine in Emily’ house, and then the same magazine was in A’s lair.
After Mona went to Radley, (in 02x25) Aria decided to stop with the game. But then, Charlotte took over the game in Season 3, remember? So I think Aria didn’t have any connection with the new A. That’s because:
1- All the “A evidence” of Aria that I read about in Seasons 3-4 were not clear and obvious like the ones in Seasons 1-2-5-6. And could be easily ignored or mean something else.
2- In fact, A (Wilden and Melissa) try to kill Aria in 03x13. I believe Mona tried to make she play the game again, but she said no. So, Mona (or even Charlotte) thought it would be a good idea to kill Aria, so she wouldn’t be able to help the liars to find out who A is (afterall, she was A once, so she knows how to play the game better than Emily, Spencer and Hanna).
3- In Season 3 she has a panic attack, and she had it when she thought A was in the bathroom with her. It’s like she was actually scared of A this time, because now she doesn’t know who she’s dealing with.
4- In Season 4, she decides to learn how to defend herself. Because this time, she feels like she needs to know how to defend herself, since she’s actually in danger.
And there might be more clues too, that’ll try to find and post more here.
So she really wasn’t A in seasons 3-4, in my theory.
But, in Season 5 she’s suspicious again. In the part 1 of my theory, I said that Spencer’s twin was Uber A since Season 5, and Charlotte and Sara were helping her. But I think that Charlotte could have told Spencer’s twin about Aria’s split personality and the twin decided to use it against the liars.
I think that Spencer’s twin, at some point of Season 5, talked to Aria and blackmailed her: if she didn’t help her with the new A game, she would tell the liars about Aria being part of the A team in the past and that would ruin her friendship with the others. Aria had no choice but help A.
So, she was part of A team again. And she became suspicious again. Like in that clue that fans found in her e-mail a message about a fence install and later the Dollhouse had fence around it. And many other clues that you can find in the blog I linked in this post.
Aria being part of the A team, but only being part of it because she was being blackmailed would explain why it seems like she wasn’t tortured as much as the others in the Dollhouse. Or maybe, she actually was a bit tortured, because she is a member of A team, but she’s only part of it because of the blackmail. So, Spencer’s twin wanted to torture her too, since she doesn’t like Spencer and any of her friends, in my theory.
After the Dollhouse, Spencer founds out about the ships. The liars were shipped when they were in the Dollhouse, so A would know where they are all the time. But, the “detector” (I don’t know what was that, but it detected that they had ships in their heads) that she used to find out about only detected Hanna’s ship and her own ship. Spencer never put the detector next to Aria’s head, so how are we suppose to know that Aria is actually shipped? If she was in A team again, they wouldn’t have to ship her.
In 06x10, when Charlotte is reveled to be A, Aria is surprised but her reaction is weird. When A turns around, instead of being totally shocked, she says “CeCe?!”. Like, she was expecting A to be Spencer’s twin, but it was CeCe. In my theory, she never knew CeCe was part of the A Team.
(Check the video below, it happens around 0:25. You can’t see Aria saying it but it sounds like her voice to me and she’s the only that is not with a wide open mouth)
So, she probably thinks Spencer’s twin was only helping CeCe or that the twin gave up being A, since CeCe never said anything about Spencer’s twin being part of the A Team. So Aria decides to forget about all this and leaves Rosewood.
Now, in a Season 6B promo, something weird happens:
In the first part of my theory, I said that I believe Spencer’s twin is the A threading the liars in Season 6B, so far. And if this is true, this text that Aria gets in the promo would make sense. Spencer’s twin knows about her story in the A Team, and she’s going to make Aria tell it.
To finish my theory, I just wanted to say that I don’t think Aria is a monster. I just think that she has the split personality problem and the A Team used it against her and the liars many times. Mona, knowing about Aria’s split personality, used it to make Aria help her in 1st season. People with split personality have really different personalties and they don’t control any of them really well. Aria could have a really mean personality and Mona used it to get help with her plan.
But it was a huge mistake being part of A Team, because Spencer’s twin could use it against Aria later and make she a part of A Team again.
In 06x02, Aria even tells Spencer “Sorry.” out of nowhere. When Spencer asks about what she is sorry, Aria doesn’t tell her. I believe Aria is really sorry for all she did, but it might be too late for being sorry.
Also, Aria could have a reason at first to help Mona. We never know. But, following my theory, I don’t think she would help Uber A with the Dollhouse stuff. I don’t think that even her mean personality could be that mean.
Anyway guys, I know my theory is HUGE so if you read until here, really, really thank you. I hope you liked it ^^
All the ideas present here are mine, so please credit me if you want to spread my theory.
Thank you for reading again and bye~
BONUS: (THE IMAGE BELOW IS NOT MINE. CREDIT TO THE OWNER)
Aria wore this dress in 02x25. Someone on Twitter said it looked horrible and Marlene answered that it has a meaning. The dress is similar to the poster of the movie “Black Swan” that it’s about a dancer that has mental problems. I believe that Aria could have a similar mental problem. Like if there was a Black Swan Aria and a White Swan Aria.
Anyways, you guys should watch the movie. It’s pretty good and would help to understand what Aria might have been through.
[PLL THEORY] Spencer has a twin sister that is Uber A since Season 5 + Aria was A’s helper in seasons 1-2-5-6 (PART 1)
Hey guys ^^ This is my first PLL Theory, so don’t expect a lot. I recently restarted watching the show and I have an theory for who is this new Uber A that is following the girls this season. So, please read it until the end. And also read the disclaimer below:
DISCLAIMER
1- English is not my first language I could make some mistakes while writing it. You can send a message if you find any grammar mistakes. But my English is not really bad so I’m sure you’ll be able to understand it.
2- I’m not sure if anyone thought of a similar theory before, but I had the idea for this one by myself. I’m not copying anyone’s theory! So please credit me if you wanna spread this theory.
3- This theory may help people who hated 06x10 to see with other eyes and like it/hate it less.
4- None of the images in post are mine. Credit to the owners ^^
5- SPOILERS ALERT
So, let’s start.
Spencer’s twin sister is the one torturing the liars during seasons 5-6
Let’s start by this part of the theory. In the books, Alison had a crazy twin called Courtney that wanted to kill her (I guess, I didn’t read most of the books, correct me if I’m wrong) and Marlene King confirmed that there’ll be a twin storyline in the series too, but it won’t be Alison’s twin.
So, I think Spencer is the one with a twin. And I’m going to show you why.
In 05x25, when the liars are trapped in the dollhouse, a man (that we all thought it was Charles or even Charlotte dressed as a man) appears behind Spencer. She asks “Is that you, Charles?” and the person never answered her. Then, Mona shows up and the person leaves.
But in 06x01 (I guess, it could be somewhere in 06x02 or 06x03 too, sorry), when Spencer tell the others about she meeting Charles, she says that she felt like it was someone that she met in her childhood.
So, my theory is that Spencer had a twin when she was born. I don’t know if it’s a female twin that look exactly like her or if it’s a male twin. Both are possible but I believe in the female twin more. For some reason that we don’t know about (maybe this twin was mentally ill and tried to harm Spencer or Melissa) the Hastings sent their daugther/son away to a asylum. Since the Hastings are super worried about their family’s image, I don’t think they would put their child in Radley because everyone in Rosewood would know. So, I think they tried to send Spencer’s twin to a asylum where he/she would get the best mental treatment possible. Maybe, even in Europe. Why not?
So, after that, the Hastings lived as a 4 member family. If Melissa remembers Spencer’s twin, her parents probably conviced her not to tell anyone about it.
After that, everything from 01x01 to 04x24 happened and Spencer’s twin was not involved with A at all.
But, when Aria kills Shana in New York (I think it was on 04x24 or 05x01, maybe 05x02) CeCe/Charlotte said in 06x10 that it was the perfect chance for her to stop with the game, because they would think that they killed A and everything was over. CeCe/Charlotte left USA and went to Paris, France. But remember that I said that the Hasting sent Spencer’s twin away for mental treatment? I think they sent her to Paris, and when CeCe/Charlotte was there, she met someone that looked exactly like Spencer and that called her attention. She tried to talk to this person and found out it was Spencer’s twin. Since her twin was sent away from home, I believe she hates Spencer and probably told CeCe/Charlotte about her hate. So, Charlotte told everything that she done to the liars (which I believe was everything that A done in seasons 3 and 4) and Spencer’s twin liked it and conviced Charlotte to come back to the game. Like Charlotte said in 06x10, she was addicted to it and if someone wanted to help her, why not? So now Charlotte and Spencer’s twin came back to Rosewood, and Spencer’s twin took over the control of the game. She was Uber A since Season 5 and Charlotte and Sara Harvey (and Aria, in my POV, but I’ll talk about it in part 2) were only helping them.
In 06x10, Charlotte decides to tell Alison the “truth”, probably because she didn’t want to play the game anymore. So she told Ali her story (which I believe is completely true, except by she starting the game again, alone, after she came back from Paris). She lied because she was afraid of telling about Spencer’s twin. I believe she was afraid of her because we all saw that A gets really, really crazy and creepy after season 5. That’s why I believe Charlotte wasn’t the one controling the game. Because the game got scarier.
So Charlotte lied and gave up the game. Afterwards, she went to therapy and died now in 06x11. After 06x10, I believe Spencer’s twin and Sara Harvey were still planning something againts the liars, and when they came to Rosewood in 06x11, 5 years later, Spencer’s twin tried to call Charlotte to help her and Sara again with the A game. Charlotte didn’t want to help her, so Spencer’s twin killed her and is now the one threading the liars again with Sara Harvey’s help and maybe Aria’s help (but I’m not sure about Aria since the 6B has only two episodes aired so far).
I believe Spencer’s twin was the one that made the Dollhouse (with Aria and Charlotte’s help). Because I don’t think Charlotte would go that far torturing the liars, and Spencer’s twin would have a reason to go so far: she’s psycothic and wants to torture Spencer and her friends. If you actually pay attention, Spencer seems to be the one the suffered the most in the Dollhouse and I believe she had a really hard time in Seasons 5/6A too. That would also explain why the person dressed as a man in the Dollhouse behind Spencer (05x25) didn’t kill or hurt her. It was Spencer’s twin dressed as man and she didn’t want to kill Spencer; she wanted to make she sufer. That would also explain why Spencer felt like she met that person when she was little. Because she did.
Also, there were dices in the Dollhouse the formed the name “Charles”. If Charlotte was Big A by then, why would she give such a hint to the liars? Knowing that Spencer is so smart, that would be a mistake. But if Spencer’s twin was the one in charge, she would put the name Charles there to confuse the liars. After all, the wouldn’t find out CeCe being Charles in the past if she didn’t tell it herself, and they would think A is a man and would never found out about any A Team member, that were all females at that time, in my theory.
Bascially, I this is the A Team Timeline:
Seasons ½: Mona (Original A) - Aria (Helper) - Lucas (Blackmailed)
Season 3: CeCe/Charlotte (Big A) - Mona (Helper) - Sara Harvey (Helper) - Toby (Double Agent) - Spencer (Double Agent) - Melissa (Blackmailed) - Wilden (Blackmailed)
Season 4: CeCe/Charlotte (Big A) - Sara Harvey (Helper)
Seasons 5/6A: Spencer’s Twin (Uber A) - CeCe/Charlotte (Helper) - Sara Harvey (Helper) - Aria (Helper)
Season 6B, so far: Spencer’s Twin (Uber A) - Sara Harvey (Helper)
So, that’s it from my theory FOR NOW. In part 2 I’m going to explain why I believe Aria helped A in Season 1-2-5-6. I hope you like my theory so far and if you read until here, you are a beautiful person.
Does anybody know the name of the song of the krystal’s teaser for 4 walls ?? it’s like obsessing me, please help meeeee if you don’t know what song i’m talking about (-> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uS4uooaj0e8 )
It’s a remix version of ‘4 Walls’. There were severel remix versions of ‘4 Walls’ that were used for their exhibition. I know that two of those remixes are going to be released on 2015.11.06 (source: https://instagram.com/p/9bFK9rsHpC/?taken-by=fx_4walls) but I don’t know if the one that you’re talking is going to be released... sorry.
YOU GUYS. F(X) ANNOUNCED THAT THEIR FANNAME WILL BE RELEASED AFTER THE FANMEET GOING ON NOW ON THEIR HOME PAGE AND THEIR EXTRA PAGE SAYS COMING SOON. I CAN’T FUNCTION.
but... the extra page coming soon thing is the same with every artist. Check GG and Red Velvet’s websites. It’s the same. But they’re getting a fandom name after year ~my feels~
I was curious if someone directly insulted Amber for being tomboy, or if it’s just haters on her Instagram/Twitter accounts. Can someone tell me, please?
Why are people being so stupid about f(x) debuting in Japan?
I’m so happy that SM is finally debuting f(x) in Japan, but I’ve seen a lot of people complaining about it. Like what? Why?
I know SM is just being lazy and remaking songs that we already listened to, but who cares? f(x) is finally going to Japan and you guys react complaining? They’re still coming back on South Korea, you know? It’s not the end of the world having a bad Japanese debut. SNSD debuted with a lame remake of ‘Genie’. T-ARA debuted with a lame remake of ‘Bo Peep Bo Peep’. It’s a debut on somewhere that they’re not sure if it’s going to work, so they won’t put a lot of money on it.
Also, people are saying that they should debut in China. I don’t think so. China’s music market is not big compared to Japan’s. SM is getting a lot of money in Japan, so of course they’ll put their groups in Japan.
I just can’t get why people are no happy about it.
Maybe people on this fandom should complain less. If Amber is not wearing girly clothes, there are a lot of people complaining. If Krystal gets a lot of attention, there are people complaining. If Luna starts getting attention, people also complain! Is there anything that’ll be alright?
As a queer fan I really want to give my two cents on this whole Hoya issue. Now, while I completely understand why a lot of you are angry – I think it’s important to consider that Hoya might not even be straight. The reason I say this is important to consider is because I think a lot of fans –...
It’s not like you’re going to read this but I just want to say that I’m so proud of you. Of who you are and of who you aspire to be. Of what you’ve done and keep doing. I’ve realised so many things just by loving you, I’ve realised things that I probably would’ve never been able to realise if you weren’t where you are. I admire you for all that you are and for all that you do, and if I had to resume this in two words they would be: thank you. Because you’ve done more for me than I can put into words, and you didn’t have to do anything besides being yourself and doing what you love. And that is definitely something that pushed me even more in the right direction. Thank you for fighting so fiercily for what you want, thank you for being so humble, thank you for being so confident, thank you for loving and caring for others as well as you do, thank you for being you.
gummygunk
blakekathryn
dailybridgerton
izzy806
yousharknotpass
stormborns
kaledo-art
