Weekly Anime Reviews

[karaakii]

Blog Post: Your Name/Hetalia: Axis Powers/Sensōron

Watching Your Name, Hetalia: Axis Powers, and reading Sensōron together left me reflecting on how media both reflects and shapes collective memory, national identity, and our relationship to the past. These works, though vastly different in tone and style, engage with how Japan sees itself, as well as how it is seen by others, in the context of both trauma and globalization.

Your Name resonated with me most on an emotional level. The quiet devastation of Itomori and the comet disaster evoked Japan’s history of both natural and man-made catastrophes, similar to the 2011 Tōhoku earthquake and nuclear meltdown. But more than anything, the film's portrayal of memory loss, time gaps, and attempts at reconnection felt like a metaphor for post-disaster identity, like how a younger generation inherits trauma it doesn’t fully understand. It reminded me of my own experience hearing family stories that felt more made-up than memory because I couldn't imagine it, yet shaped how I see the world.

Hetalia, on the other hand, shocked me with how playfully it depicts World War history. It reminded me a lot of stories I've read before such as Maus. By personifying countries as anime stereotypes, it trivializes serious issues like colonialism and war crimes. That said, Hetalia's absurdity also made me reflect on how easily history is distorted in pop culture. There’s something troubling to me morally about turning national traumas into comedy skits, especially when compared with the more serious, nationalistic revisionism I encountered in Sensōron.

Kobayashi’s Sensōron is perhaps the most disturbing, not simply because it glorifies violence directly, but because it undermines collective memory by challenging historical documentation. This is especially prevalent regarding the Nanjing Massacre and comfort women. His argument that much of Japan's guilt is the result of American “brainwashing” post-WWII positions the nation as a victim of misinformation rather than a perpetrator of violence. It is a complex topic, as the American occupation was horrifically shaping to many, but it is not fair to frame any nation as a victim that was also a very violent one. Compared this to the emotional depth and historical resonance in Your Name, the revisionist attitude in Sensōron felt not only cold, but dangerous in a potentially influential attitude way.

One clear connection across these works is the theme of pop nationalism. Hetalia and Sensōron both contribute to a version of nationalism that is either sanitized or defiant. Your Name, by contrast, feels more interested in memory, empathy, and interconnection. It is not in glorifying the past, but in healing from it, which is very interesting to me.

[reviewer28]

Hi! I love how well you tie together all of the anime and manga with the overall theme of pop nationalism. You make a really interesting point about not glorifying the past, but rather healing from it. By this same logic, I agree with your reflection on Sensoron and that this manga definitely glorifies the violence from the past. It is very problematic to depict Japan as the victim of misinformation when there is a great deal of evidence proving some of the atrocities committed. Even if the American occupation was also problematic, this does not mean Japan's history should be reframed to deny the violence that occurred. I also like your reflection on Hetalia, and I agree that although the anime may have comedic value, the stereotypical personifications trivialize national trauma. Using too much comedy to discuss serious subjects can minimize the suffering that occurred as a result of events such as World War II. Finally, I agree that Your Name has the most powerful personal connection, as many can relate to younger generation not understanding the value of certain traditions and ways of life.

[reviewer28]

Your Name, Hetalia, and Sensoron

Your Name is an extremely interesting anime that explores the beauty present in two different ways of life. In this anime, Mitusha, a girl living in a small rural town, longs to experience life in a big city, feeling bored of her seemingly mundane environment. Despite the rich traditions that have been passed down through her family, she grows frustrated with them and questions their value. She eventually ends up switching bodies with a boy named Taki, who lives in Tokyo, a big city. When they have the chance to experience each other’s environments, they both begin to have a greater appreciation for what they have. Mitsuha enjoys living in Tokyo, but begins to miss her small town lifestyle. Taki, on the other hand, begins to also see the positives of living in a small town. They also both develop more respect for passed down religious traditions. While trapped in each other’s bodies, they also communicate by leaving notes for each other, allowing for an unexpected connection to form. When a natural disaster threatens to destroy Mitsuha’s town, Taki is tasked with saving the village. This highlights many important messages while also relating to some popular films and personal experiences. Although this is not exactly what happens in this anime since both Taki and Mitsuha learn to appreciate small-town life, the biggest takeaway I get from this film is that the grass is not always greener on the other side. In my experiences, I have frequently had times where I wanted a reality that I did not have, while forgetting at times to appreciate what I did have. When I eventually got what I thought I wanted, I realized that I was content with what I had in the past, and began to miss what my life looked like before. This relates to the anime because Mitsuha desperately wants to get out of her small rural town and move to a big city, but when she does, she gains a greater appreciation for the life she had before. Your Name also reminds me of the popular movie, Freaky Friday. In Freaky Friday, a mother and daughter both switch bodies, which helps them better understand and relate to each other, allowing for a resolution of their conflicts. Another important related theme in Your Name is the magic of small-town life. There is a major trend towards urbanization, with most people dreaming of living in big cities in pursuit of better job opportunities and a more vibrant social scene. However, the anime shows that there is beauty in simplicity. Small towns can have a strong sense of community and care, as well as a rich history worth celebrating. Coincidentally, Virgin River, the show I’m watching right now, also shows the strong sense of community and culture present in small towns. The show is set in a fictional town called Virgin River, and the main character is a nurse practitioner who has moved from Los Angeles. Despite reluctance at first, she eventually is amazed how the town always comes together to support those in need. Finally, a key theme of the anime is the value of human connection, and how understanding the perspectives of others is important in order to build this sense of trust. When Taki and Mitsuha understand what life is like for each other, this helps them form a strong bond. In real life, it is also often the case that relating to others’ experiences is necessary to build a sense of empathy. 

In Hetalia: Axis Powers, Italy, Japan, and Germany, three major players in World War II, are depicted in a satirical way. Each country is represented by an anthropomorphic character, with the characters following national stereotypes. Historical and cultural events, as well as disagreements between the countries, are portrayed in a humorous way. One of the main issues this anime connects to is that of the cultural stereotypes, which are often considered to be controversial and problematic. Many argue that Hetalia presents a reductive representation of the countries, ignoring the diversity present in the nations and their cultures. Some of the ways the countries are depicted are also inaccurate, with, for example, Germany being depicted as a good guy despite being the perpetrator of the Holocaust under the Nazis. In the anime, wars are also presented as being similar to conflicts between friends. While some argue that this makes learning about the wars more accessible to all audiences, this has the potential to trivialize the suffering and brutality that occurred during these conflicts. With the millions of people that died during these wars, as well as the oppression and discrimination that occurred during events such as the Holocaust, turning the conflicts into a comedy can be insensitive. Finally, there is the issue of colonialist discourse being presented in the anime. For example, by showing Korea’s attachment to Japan, this can be seen as a reference to times when colonized countries were seeking Japan’s guidance. Today, there is also a substantial amount of controversial media, with books, movies, and music being constantly under scrutiny. One example of a piece of popular media that also depicts national stereotypes and has therefore been the subject of debate is the Eurovision song “Espresso Macchiato.” This song references things such as pasta and the mafia, as well as describes Italians in an exaggerated manner. Similar to the anime, this song also inspires debate amongst fans as it is very comedic and entertaining in nature, but it can also be considered offensive. 

The manga, Sensoron, has a much darker theme that is arguably dangerous historical revisionism. Japan’s history has been somewhat tainted by atrocities committed during World War II, the Rape of Nanjing, and other acts of colonialism. This has significantly hurt Japanese national pride. However, Sensoron takes the approach of arguing that these events are not depicted accurately in history. The manga takes the approach of denying the massacres that occurred, or at least minimizing the extent of the damage they caused. For example, the manga denies the events of the Nanjing Massacre, as well as denies that prostitutes were forced into service as opposed to choosing that lifestyle. This is achieved partially by cherrypicking examples of images that were fake, despite them not being representative of all evidence in existence. This manga has also been seen as a work of nationalism, as unconditional national pride is prioritized over criticizing the numerous mistakes Japan has made in the past. This manga connects to the global dangerous theme of denying and repeating history. For example, Holocaust denialism has risen, with many arguing that it either did not happen or minimizing its impact, despite the significant amount of evidence proving its occurrence. Without acknowledging past injustices, it is impossible to create a better future. The manga also connects to the global issue of rising nationalism, which is something that is especially prevalent in the US. This can be seen in anti-immigration policies, as the desire to preserve a strong sense of national identity has been leading to stricter immigration control. The approach that this manga takes should be greatly scrutinized, as the way to restore national pride should never be to deny past atrocities, but rather to take accountability and ensure these events do not occur again.

[karaakii]

Blog Post: Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind/Xenoblade Chronicles 2

After watching Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind and the cutscenes of the video game Xendoblade Chronicles 2, I felt heavy-hearted thinking about the relationship between humans and nature. This is something that is deeply personal in my life and interests, so I found the material, particularly Nausicaä, very engaging and relatable. It was not just their ecological themes, but how both works grapple with the human desire to dominate, use, and "fix" the world, as well as the resistance against that instinct. Both stories present post-apocalyptic settings that are shaped by ecological collapse and human hubris, but both argue for the redemptive power of empathy and coexistence.

In Nausicaä, the Toxic Jungle is initially seen as a disturbance, but is ultimately revealed to be purifying the poisoned earth. This idea that nature is healing, not hostile, subverts the instrumentalist mindset very common in industrial modernity, that nature exists only to serve humans. Similarily, Xendoblade exposed the suffering caused by viewing others (especially Blades) as tools. Blades are born to serve humans, and are objectified by having their memory and any personal feeling erased, only seen for their purpose. Jin's transformation into a Flesh Eater is a tragic rebellion against that fate. These stories, despite their different tones and mediums, make the same argument that salvation is from listening, understanding, and resisting utter control, rather than power and domination.

Living in a world that emphasized productivity and utillity, especially at the cost of the environment, I was very impacted by these anime, because this is a topic I care a lot about. I see many around me treat other people, the environment, and even themselves as things to be optimized, rather than cared for. I also unfortunately have to watch as the climate collapses, with an uneasy feeling of inheriting a world doomed for the future. What Nausicaä and Xenoblade offer is something very hopeful and comforting, a possibility of healing through slowness, care, and humility.

Globally, both narratives resonate with Anthropocene anxieties. Begging the question of what happens when human activity reshapes the planet beyond repair, before realizing we're far beyond that point. More locally in Japan, there are echoes of the destruction of Hiroshima, Fukushima, and the trauma of rapid modernization that truly began under American influence post WWII. The fear of technology unmoored from ethics is very evident in both pieces. The Giant Warrior in Nausicaä and the Aegises in Xenoblade are "godlike" weapons born from human ambition, that turn against their makers, which I feel is even more relevant now. Both medias ask the viewers how they use the world, and more importantly, why they use the world the way they do.

[reviewer28]

Hi! Your post does a great job analyzing the anime! I like how you talk about nature being healing and about the logic of instrumentalism, or assuming that nature is valuable insofar as it benefits humans. I also think your point about the redemptive power of empathy is very effective. The only way that the environmental can be restored is by having empathy for nature, animals, and even other humans. Recognizing the suffering that they will face as a result of destructive human activities is a precondition to preventing further damage. I also think it is interesting to consider the Blades being used as tools. They are used to help restore the environment, but at the same time, the way they are created to only serve humans and are not given the ability to have any feelings is quite exploitative, raising an ethical dilemma. Your personal perspective on seeing the influence of productivity and optimization is also very important. The root cause of environmental destruction is the desire to continue producing more, which eventually comes at the expense of the environment. This greed is what is driving much of the destruction, especially that from extraction of energy. Finally, I like the way you compare the destruction in the anime to that from Hiroshima and modernization post-WWII. I did not originally consider those comparisons, but those are definitely accurate parallels.

[reviewer28]

Saving the World or Destroying It?

Both Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind and Xenoblade Chronicles 2 depict the complex interplay between humans and the environment. Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind is set in a world that was previously left in ruins due to what can be inferred to be nuclear weapons, which caused the formation of a Sea of Decay, toxic jungle, and poisonous insects/fungi. Nausicaa, rather than fearing the environment, seeks to learn more about it, discovering that the soil the plants grow in is toxic as a result of warfare from the past. While exploring nature, she tries to respect the Earth rather than destroy it. However, the Tolmekians exploit nature, harvesting it to extract resources and killing it as they please. They view nature as an enemy and therefore attempt to interfere with it for their own interests. This highlights the major global issue of climate change and environmental destruction. Currently, high levels of environmental exploitation exist. For example, extraction of fossil fuels for energy, deforestation, overfishing, and pollution are rapidly intensifying the climate crisis. As society is rapidly industrializing, the environment continues to be seen more as a means for serving humans rather than as something that should be protected in and of itself. The environment is seen not as having intrinsic value, but rather as having value only as it can benefit humans. This has numerous impacts, habitat loss, biodiversity loss, extreme warming of the planet, and food/water shortages. Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind is a warning of the importance of preserving the environment and the dangers of pursuing limitless consumption. The anime also relates to the issue of violence and warfare, as it shows the destruction to the environment that resulted from using weapons in the past. Society still has not moved past the use of military action to resolve conflicts, which continues to be extremely dangerous. 

Xenoblade 2, similar to Nausicaa, tells the story of a destroyed planet covered by waste and a “cloud sea.” The main characters search for Elysium, believing that they will find a paradise where the environment is intact and nature has been preserved. However, upon arrival, they learn that they have reached an artificial space station, as well as a scientist named Klaus, who explains how he has destroyed all aspects of the world and of nature itself. This also connects to the issues of human destruction of the environment. Although Klaus was not necessarily attempting to destroy the world, but rather was trying to create a divine world, his attempt to interfere with nature ended with catastrophic effects. This shows how unchecked human activity has the potential to do great damage. In the real world, a lot of environmental destruction, such as the extraction of fossil fuels, is motivated by the desire to grow the economy, reach energy security, and produce new innovations. While the intentions behind this may have some justification, this abuse of nature ultimately is causing severe destruction rather than producing a better society. In Xenoblade 2, humanity is ultimately restored due to efforts from Klaus to use Titans and Blades to give rise to new life, as well as nanomachines that connect genetic data to recover the ecosystem. This presents a somewhat different ending than the one in Nausicaa, where restoration happens due to coexistence with the environment. Restoration in Xenoblade 2 requires significant human intervention, which begs the question of what the best method of reversing environmental destruction in the real world is. On one hand, it is intuitive that since humans are the main cause for environmental issues, humans should also be responsible for fixing it. This approach involves developing renewable energy, limiting emissions, restoring forests, conserving resources, and taking other approaches to protect nature. This appears to be the more realistic solution, as it is unlikely that nature will restore itself without some measures being taken. However, it can be argued that if humans try to fix the environment, they will end up causing more damage in the process, and that the best thing people can do is to leave the environment alone. Contrasting Nausicaa and Xenoblade 2 therefore introduces the important question of what the best course of action is to ensure the survival of the planet, especially in an era where climate change is accelerating at a fast pace. 

[karaakii]

Blog Post: Neon Genesis Evangelion/End of Evangelion

Watching Neon Genesis Evangelion and The End of Evangelion felt like entering a very dreamlike atmosphere, but with an outstandingly uncomfortable subtext of mental health, maculinity, and existentialism. More than any other anime I've seen, Neon Genesis Evangelion doesn't shy away from confronting the emotional nature of trauma, loneliness, and a need for validation. Shinji at times resonated with me not because he is a traditional hero, but because of how flawed he is. His struggle with self-worth, fear of abandonment, and dependence on others' praise was extremely relatable to me, but also stood as a great critique on social pressures, and felt very universal in its portrayal of alienation.

The anime made me think on my own ideas of masculinity. Shinji doesn't fit a stereotype of hegemonic masculinity, as he isn't stoic, confident, or aggresive. Instead, he is passive, emotionally volatile, and desperate, which puts him in a unique position of a marginalized form of masculinity. Kaworu's brief presence challenged this even further by offering Shinji unconditional acceptance, which is something extremely rare in his world. Their relationship edged onto tragic queer intimacy, and I found myself grieving with Shinji when he was forced to kill someone who may have been the only person who ever showed him kindness without expecting something in return.

I really enjoyed The End of Evangelion, because I felt it pushed all of these topics to their psychological extremes. The apocolypse was not only global, but extremely internal. The collapse of the world mirrored the collapse of individual psyches. I really liked how the film portrayed the desire to disappear into others by losing the burden of individuality through the Human Instrumentality Project. Yet, it ultimately affirmed the value of separate existence. The message that we are shaped by others but must learn to live with ourselves is something I'm still processing, I was hit by this so hard.

[reviewer28]

I totally agree that the anime does a great job in showing the struggles associated with loneliness and needing external validation. I love how you recognize Shinji's strength as coming from his flaws rather than him being a traditional hero. It is important to acknowledge that being a traditional hero does not define one's worth, and that imperfections are a part of making people who they are. I like that Shinji does not fit the traditional profile of masculinity, and I think society would be better if things such as stoicism and aggression weren't always expected of men. Men's mental health can often be disregarded because they are expected to deal with problems on their own and not open up to others, which can be very damaging. Finally, I think your point about how the collapse of the world mirrored the collapse of individual psyches is really important and deep analysis. I agree with your final message that even though our personalities are shaped by others, ultimately we must learn to process our own emotions and develop our own identity, even if it goes against what is expected by society.

[reviewer28]

"Man Up?"

Neon Genesis Evangelion tells the inspiring story of a boy who struggles with his mental health and finding his identity as he faces pressures from society to conform to traditional expectations of masculinity. In this anime, Shinji is forced by his father to control a robot meant to fight monsters known as Angels in the futuristic city of Tokyo-3. However, Shinji does not want to engage in violence, and he initially refuses despite facing great pressure from his father. He only finally agrees to pilot the robot when he realizes that the alternative is a wounded woman doing the job. Even when he does agree, Shinji is not very competent with operating the machine, and does not perform his duties well. During the show, Shinji struggles deeply with his mental health. Since he is not able to do what society considers “manly” such as exerting aggression, he feels unworthy and like a coward. Additionally, when he expresses his fear and frustrations, he is told to “be a man” and to deal with it. Shinji is shamed for his signs of weakness, taking a major psychological toll on him. This connects to numerous global issues. The first is that of mental health struggles, which are especially common amongst adolescents/teenagers. In the real world, coming-of-age is associated with numerous stressors and challenges in discovering oneself. For example, the desire to get into a top college and feeling inferior to others who see more accomplished is common. In addition, the feeling of not fitting and feeling unworthy compared to peers is common. Neon Genesis Evangelion is a perfect example of this, as the main character is a teenager who feels unworthy and struggles with depression and anxiety as a result of his rejection by society. The anime also connects to the idea of toxic masculinity. Men are not only expected to be strong and confident, but they are also often told to hide their emotions. When men express their emotions or ask for help, they are seen as weak. This can be clearly seen in the case of Shinji, as his concerns and his sadness are shut down since he is expected to act like a man. It is only when Shinji is able to free himself from society’s expectations of him as a man that he is able to accept his value. 

The End of Evangelion explores similar themes, but it shows Shinji grappling with his struggles in deciding whether to resort to hegemonic masculinity in a different way. Shinji tries to engage in displays of traditional masculinity through objectifying women and eventually attempting to inflict violence upon Asuka after he feels betrayed by her. However, Shinji eventually is unable to keep up with the expectations placed on him, and he returns to abandoning traditional masculinity. When he expresses his emotions and gives up on violence, he is called disgusting, showing how embedded hegemonic masculinity is in society. The analysis for The End of Evangelion is similar to that of Neon Genesis Evangelion. However, in this ending, it is clear how emotionally taxing it was for Shinji to pretend to be something he wasn’t and to abandon his values. This shows how in the real world, despite societal pressure to “fit in,” trying to change oneself in order to conform can be damaging and betray one’s true identity. From both of the anime, it is important to also take away the fact that in order to be a man, there is no specific way that one must act. Proving oneself as being strong or repressing one’s emotions is only unnecessary and damaging. 

​​

[animatedworldblog]

Convention

I have personally never attended an anime convention before or during this course so I cannot relate. However, after watching the True Otaku clips from the documentary, I can understand how big of a fandom these conventions actually are. I always used to think that anime was just another show that people watch and talk about but you can understand that it has a deeper meaning after watching the documentary. People embed themselves into the anime world and feel like they are genuinely apart of the show. Anime holds a deeper meaning to these people and audiences compared to a popular tv show that people watch. The documentary is intriguing because it follows a group of people as they explore the different cultures throughout the animated world. People feel like they are a part of the show through playing different characters. Whether it is through costumes or participating in different actions, these people feel like they have a greater purpose because they represent someone or something that is in the anime. Cosplaying is a very popular thing when it comes to anime and people actually feel like they are solving their own personal problems through acting out different anime scenes. This could be important in the mental health field as some people feel like they are cured after participating in these actions. The fandom throughout anime is participating form because people are involved in what is actually going on. A popular theme that most people find themselves feeling is loneliness. These people feel like they have been isolated from society so people feel like they are brought back into a completely different world through anime. The anime promotes a sense of communion and togetherness because they are a part of something greater. Groups of people through all over the world come together with different ideas or opinions based on the anime that they watched and share them together. On top of that, they also dress the parts and participate in group activities relating to the anime that they all have watched together. While some people may not feel like they are accepted into society, they feel a connected and happy when they are able to relate back to their own animated world. While I've never attended an anime convention nor been a fan before taking this class, I can see that people feel like they are more connected to one another and brought together because they share a similarity in the animated world. People go through different things all the time so it is important to have something that will always make you feel comfortable and take you to a happy place. For me personally, I don't use anime as a form of comfort but I can see how it helps other people find their own mental happy space. True Otaku helps people understand that fandom is something greater than just liking something it holds a deeper purpose to people. People all over the world participate in this form of fandom but it will always hold a deeper and more meaningful interest to them as they attach themselves to the specific anime that they watch. Whether it is online through a digital chatroom or social media platform or in person, people all over the world connect with one another to share their different ideas and experiences and grow together as a fandom community. I personally find my fandom group when it comes to sports. I feel like I can have a conversation with anyone when it comes to sports and it definitely brings me a lot more happiness. I think it is important for everyone to have some sort of fandom because it can go a long way when it comes to your mental health as well as your personal growth as an individual.

[reviewer28]

Hi! Your post does an amazing job of explaining how the otaku fandom community helps address people's loneliness and bring people together. I like the point you make about how people feel as if they are solving their personal problems through acting different anime scenes. This definitely shows how anime has more relevance than a normal movie or TV show. Also, it shows an interesting perspective of what draws people to anime. Although anime is technically an imaginary role, it clearly provides people with an escape from reality that helps alleviate some of their everyday struggles. In addition, I like how you talk about the theme of people experiencing loneliness. The feeling of being isolated from society is very difficult, but finding a community where one can be accepted without judgement is extremely helpful and, as you mention, importing in addressing mental health. Finally, I like how you tie the post together by saying how the fandom means more to people than simply enjoying anime. Rather, the fandom allows people to find community, explore their identities, and escape from their daily problems.

[reviewer28]

Convention

The documentary “True Otaku” serves to humanize and challenge stereotypes surrounding the otaku community. Otaku culture is often stigmatized, and there is a lack of acceptance of the community due to characterizations of its members as being antisocial and lacking in meaningful hobbies at the expense of pursuing an interest that is seen by many as “childish.” The documentary shows the power of having a like-minded community where people can embrace their identities and bond with others without fear of judgement. In the documentary, narratives of individuals who enjoy otaku culture are given, allowing people a chance to have their perspectives understood. Some of these individuals include collectors of anime, manga, and comics, as well as gamers. Their stories challenge the idea that otaku enjoyers live an exclusively solitary life, showing how events such as conventions establish a sense of community and connection. The documentary helps viewers understand the diversity amongst the otaku community to dismantle negative societal perceptions, such as through showing members’ creativity, social interactions, and passions. Also, by showing the fanfare at the conventions, the documentary highlights how large the otaku community is, as well as the power of otaku to bring together a diverse group of people. 

Reflecting on the documentary, it is very powerful because it shows the power of shared passions in bringing people together who have nothing in common otherwise. Similar to how activities such as sporting events can bring people from different backgrounds and cultures together, otaku conventions help people from all around the world find common ground. Thousands of people line up to participate in the conventions, as well as purchase merchandise, comics, and other related items. Having a supportive community is extremely important, especially for those who may feel misunderstood by society and like outsiders. It can also help people find a community that they otherwise may not have had. Although I have little experience with the anime fandom and never explored anime much before taking this class, I have experienced enjoying niche extracurriculars that can be misunderstood. Throughout high school and college, I have found great comfort in finding groups with likeminded people who I felt I could be myself around. For example, my high school debate team and my college chemistry fraternity have greatly helped me come out of my shell and bond with others.  

Another impactful part of the documentary is seeing how fulfilling otaku is for fans, as well as how they have found their identities through the otaku community. Many who are interviewed are forming social networks amongst other fans. Some also produce creative work such as drawings related to the otaku, showing how their love for otaku pushes them to pursue other hobbies such as art. Seeing how otaku sparks people’s creativity is extremely insightful, and it also challenges the misconception that otaku fans lack other hobbies. The interviews also show the diverse looks and personalities of the fans. There is typically a stereotypical image associated with people in the community, but the documentary helps to dismantle the prejudices. The emphasis on interviews and individual perspectives makes the documentary significantly more impactful. 

Despite the influence of the documentary, there is still some lack of acceptance from otaku culture in certain spheres. Societal prejudices still exist, and despite becoming more common, the otaku community is still not entirely mainstream. However, by humanizing and reducing the stigma around the community, the documentary will likely help inspire others to not hide their interests, however niche they may be. This may also help people feel less isolated knowing others share their passions. This does not only apply to otaku. Many are ashamed of the activities they enjoy because they are considered to be “nerdy” or “uncool.” However, there is never a need to hide one's true personality, and it is always possible for one to find a community where they belong. 

[karaakii]

Blog Post: Sailor Moon/Aggretsuko/Wandering Son

As a woman, Sailor Moon, Aggretsuko, and Wandering Son all felt like looking upon different phases of what it means to grow up and find power, especially as a girl in a society with rigid expectations around gender, success, and appearance. Even though these anime differ in tone and style, they each dive into the struggles of identity and agency, not only in Japan, but globally.

Sailor Moon as the most nostalgic of the three, but underneath the glittery aesthetics and moon tiaras was a very honest reflection on girlhood. Girlhood is something extremely important to me, and I loved the way these episodes of Sailor Moon portrayed it. Usagi's self-doubt, her fixation on appearance, grades, and crushes, all hit home for me as well as anyone who has ever felt like they were failing the expectations placed on most girls. It was so powerful to me how Usagi was often scolded for being late, eating too much, and not studying, however when she is Sailor Moon, her emotions are essentially her superpower. Her tears flip the idea that femininity is weak and embrace emotion. The reversal was extremely empowering, especially for someone who often felt they had to hide emotions to be taken seriously, even if the anime still works within some traditional gender roles.

In constrast, Aggretsuko confront adulthood. Retsuko's rage resonated with me, especially the scenes where she holds in her frustration all day at work, only to unleash it in an expressive way after (for her, death metal karaoke). Aggretsuko takes on workplace sexism, corporate culture, marriage pressure, and performative feminity with a darkly comic tone, but beneath it is a real exhaustion felt by so many women. Watching her try to balance pleasing others with staying true to herself reminded me of myself growing up, and furthermore that gender performance doesn't stop in childhood, just changes form.

By time I reached Wandering Son, I was very emotional. Shuichi and Yoshino's quiet, tender journeys toward understanding their gender identities felt so beautifully vulnerable. The episode where Shuichi walks to school in a sailor uniform, expressing both hope and terror, made me cry. Their "test of courage" is not just about clothing, but being seen for who you are in a world that refuses to understand.

Together, all three anime served to remind me that gender is not fixed, but rather navigated, resisted, and redefined. Whether it is through magical superhero girls, rage-filled office workers, or transgender teens, each story challenged me to rethink how identity is shaped, and how reclaiming it can be such a powerful act of resistance.

[reviewer28]

Hi! I love your analysis and the way in which you contrast all the animes but yet connect them together extremely well. Your point about Usagi's emotions becoming her superpower is extremely powerful. I love the idea that expressing one's emotions should not be seen as a sign of weakness, but rather a sign of strength. No matter how brave and heroic someone may be, they are still human, and therefore understanding and dealing with their emotions is necessary for growth. Although "Sailor Moon" does reinforce some gender roles, I agree with your analysis that by viewing Usagi's emotions as part of her power, the anime does contribute to women empowerment. I also love your analysis of Retsuko. I agree that many women often feel the need to please others by hiding their frustration, which can be incredibly emotionally exhausting. I also agree that Retsuko releasing her rage after work is extremely powerful, and shows the toll emotional suppression can take on people. Overall, your analysis is extremely sophisticated, and I enjoyed reading it!

[reviewer28]

The Many Angles of Girl Power

“Sailor Moon” explores themes of feminism and gender roles in Japanese society. Through certain events in the anime, certain gender stereotypes are defied, while others are unfortunately reinforced. In this anime, the story of Usaki, a middle school girl who discovers she is the reincarnation and guardian known as Sailor Moon, begins her journey to save the world from evil alongside her talking cat. She recruits a group of friends to help her find the location of the Legendary Silver Crystal, and eventually after numerous battles, she emerges victorious. Along her journey, she falls in love and eventually marries Mamoru, a man she is accompanied by. Usagi’s heroic quest connects to global issues because it reflects women’s independence and empowerment. The anime challenges ideas of women being relegated to the household and reliant on men. At the same time, the characters still enjoy activities/items considered to be “girly,” showing how girls can enjoy things traditionally associated with femininity but still be strong and powerful. This challenges the idea that strong women must behave a certain type of way, and allows the characters to continue to do what makes them happy while also growing into their new identities. However, while gender roles are challenged in the anime, certain problematic ideas are also reinforced. For example, Usagi still feels pressured to conform to rigid beauty standards, forcing herself to attempt to lose weight. Being extremely thin is often expected of women, with many taking extreme measures to lose weight such as participating in excessive exercise or restrictive diets. Some even develop eating disorders due to societal pressures to maintain an “ideal” body. This can be seen with Usagi, as she becomes insecure due to negative comments on her weight gain, engaging in diets and exercises advertised as being good for weight loss. She even decides to continue her fight due to the belief that it will make her lose weight. This also shows how society takes advantage of vulnerable women by advertising quick fixes for weight loss that are not actually effective in order to profit off of insecurities. Finally, the sexualization of Usagi’s school uniform also raises many questions about the purpose of the characters revealing more revealing uniforms as minors. Some argue that this is inappropriate, white others view this as experimentation with transitioning between the characters dressing/acting in a more mature fashion and then returning to their childhood. 

In “Aggretsuko,” the protagonist, Retsuko, struggles with being in a hostile work environment and requiring an outlet to express her frustrations. She works with a misogynistic boss who treats her as inferior to her male colleagues, forcing her to do tasks that are considered to be “women’s jobs” rather than treating her as an equal. After work, Retsuke expresses her rage by screaming at a karaoke bar, which is something that is traditionally considered to not be “ladylike.” This allows her to have an escape from her everyday life and to take a break from hiding her emotions. She is expected to be obedient in her workplace rather than speaking up against the mistreatment she experiences. This is similar to how in real life, women are often expected to smile and take orders from others, regardless of whether they are fair or not. Women are not expected to speak up or express their anger, but rather, they are constantly forced to maintain a friendly and polite demeanor. This can lead to strong built up emotions, as seen with Retsuko. The karaoke bar is the only place she feels she can truly let out her emotions in a world where she is constantly forced to suppress them. The anime shows how emotionally taxing being devalued in a sexist workplace can be, as well as the unreasonable expectations placed on women for how they are supposed to manage their emotions. 

In “Wandering Son,” two children struggle to discover their identities, as they both feel that they do not conform with the gender they were assigned at birth. They both wish to be opposite genders, and as they grow and enter puberty, they experiment with different ways to express themselves. However, they struggle with judgement and lack of acceptance from society, as many do not understand or support their lifestyle. This anime connects to the issues of conformity and societal prejudices. People are frequently judged and looked down on if they do not fit in with what is considered to be normal. Many are bullied and excluded for trying to express their identity if it goes against what is expected. This also connects to the issue of transgender and LGBTQ rights, as many in both the past and present have been discriminated against for being a part of this community. This has been in the form of both discrimination by society and legal restrictions on things such as gender-affirming care and gay marriage. Finally, this also connects to the issue of mental health, especially for members of the LGBTQ community. Many struggle with their mental health as they question their identity, especially if they are not supported by their close friends and family. 

[karaakii]

Blog Post: Genshiken

Genshiken was both deeply entertaining and surprisingly relatable, espectailly in how it captures the nuances of fandom and fan productivity. The anime dives into the subculture of otaku in Japan, offering a lens not just into niche interests like dōjinshi, cosplay, and visual novels, but also into the social dynamics that form around them. In episodes like the first and second, the contrast between Kasukabe's fashionable, normal interests and the otaku world of Kohsaka and the others mirrors a broader tension in Japanese society between mainstream conformity and niche subcultures. This tension exists globally as well, whether the interest is in anime, gaming, or fanfiction, there is often a need to justify or hide one's interests depending on social context.

One thing that stood out to me was how Genshiken portrays fan productivity not as a passive experience, but rather an active form of self-expression. Ogiue, for example, creates dōjinshi based on imagines slash pairings of her friends, which blends her fantasies with real people. This is quite an intimate form of fan productivity, by transforming private fandom into public creativity. It reminded me of consuming Harry Potter fanfics, seeing diverse narratives that the source material ignored. Like Ogiue, many fan creators build on existing works not just out of admiration but to reframe or reimagine stories in ways that make space for their own desires.

Madarame's episode stuck with me for how it used humor and awkwardness to show how isolating otaku culture can be, even among fans. His inner monologue mimicking a visual novel format while stuck with Kasukabe captured the loneliness and hesitation that come with being seen as "too much" or "too nerdy" which is something I've often felt. Yet, Genshiken never mocks its characters, but instead allows them the space to grow and connect. The inclusion of seemingly foreign characters like Angela and Sue also speak to how anime and fandom are global phenomena. Sue's quirky, exaggerated behavior may seem excessive, but it reflects how international fans engage with Japanese media in a different way, and furthermore how fandom can bridge language and culture.

Ultimately, Genshiken humanizes otaku culture. It shows how fandom becomes a site of identity, creativity, and community-building, even when those things can be messy and uncomfortable. Watching it made me reflect on how transformative and validatng fan spaces can be, especially for people who don't always fit a mainstream mold.

[reviewer28]

I love your analysis about how the anime humanizes otaku culture. One point you make that stood out to me is how people feel the need to hide their passions in certain social situations in order to be accepted. This definitely is a common occurrence, especially amongst teenagers and college students. Many feel as if they cannot express themselves without being bullied or rejected by their peers. People also desire to fit into certain social circles, and worry that if they don't match that group's interests, they will not be accepted. I also like how you make personal connections to your experiences of being seen as "too much" or "too nerdy." It can be easy to feel this way, especially in a society where people are expected to conform to strict social norms. Having niche interests and being considered a "nerd" is seen as a negative, when in reality, these qualities should be viewed positively. Finally, your point about international fans engaging with Japanese media and fandom bridging language/cultural gaps is very interesting and important.

[reviewer28]

Fan Culture: The Good and the Ugly

“Genshiken” creatively explores fan culture by telling the story of a group of people with unique interests in anime, manga, video games, and other hobbies related to visual media. The anime follows the character’s journeys of discovering their identities and going through personal growth. It also shows the friendships formed from over the characters’ niche shared interests. 

This anime has a more lighthearted message than many of the others explored in class that dealt with themes such as discrimination, exploitation by capitalism/neoliberalism, and hyperreality. Still, “Genshiken” has many important personal connections. Although I have never been a fan of certain types of media or artists to the same extent as the characters, I have had fulfilling experiences of finding like-minded communities who I have bonded with over specific hobbies throughout my life. For example, throughout high school, I was part of organizations such as the debate and math teams. Although this is quite different from the club portrayed in the anime, finding groups of people who shared my interests helped me to discover my passions and to grow as a person. 

This also connects to numerous global and social issues. In a world where many struggle to find “belonging” and to “fit in,” finding spaces where one can be themself without fear of judgement is especially important. This is especially the case for people whose interests may be less mainstream. Also, “Genshiken” helps to challenge stereotypes about otaku culture, as many fans are viewed as outcasts. 

The discussion of fan culture, its productivity, and the competition within it is especially interesting in the age of social media. On platforms such as Instagram, it has become increasingly common to see accounts dedicated to fanpages for certain authors, actors, movie characters, influencers, etc. There definitely has also become a hierarchy amongst fans and competition over who is the most invested. While being passionate about certain people or forms of media can help bring people together and help one discover their identity, there can be a point where this can become obsessive and unhealthy. If people begin to prioritize their fan behavior over real-life relationships or other hobbies/academics, this can majorly set people back. Becoming too connected to someone can lead to disappointment when the person does not conform to expectations. Finally, while being a fan can make up a part of someone’s personality, too much focus on the lives of others can take away from the formation of one’s own identity. 

[animatedworldblog]

Naruto/Wolf Children/A Silent Voice

Watching all of these different pieces of anime really made me think a lot as there was a lot to take in. To start, Naruto was unique because he wanted people to notice him and had felt like he was being left out throughout his life. This is relatable for a lot of people who grow up without that love and support and wish they had people there to notice them. As the youngest in my family, there were definitely some moments where you feel like this but overall it changes and you don't hold that same feeling anymore as you continue to grow. His story is very inspiring as well because I enjoyed seeing him suffer at the beginning but have the courage to never give up and keep pushing forward until he reaches his goal. Wolf Children brings in the parenting perspective as Hana is trying to integrate her children who don't exactly fit into society. It is another relatable story for parents trying to integrate their kids into society while they feel like they deserve the best care. A Silent Voice was one of the most emotional anime we have seen so far. The story was built to be very powerful and they didn't cover anything up. Bullying is a strong subject to talk about because it happens all over the world. The person getting bullied feels hurt and then later on the person doing the bullying feels guilt. This cycle never ends and always repeats as it is simply impossible to stop. Shoya represented how meaningful it is to hold yourself accountable. While he was showing empathy towards others, it is important to self reflect and hold yourself accountable for your actions and figure out ways to become a better person. This anime is a prime example of how someone who was the bully now comprehends what they did was wrong and they should make amends for it. Overall, these three pieces of anime all had their own unique perspectives and reflected relatable things for the different roles of people in society.

[reviewer28]

Great post! I love how you relate Naruto to growing up feeling unnoticed and being without love. I also appreciate the connection you make to your personal life and experiences growing up as the youngest. I think with Wolf Children, it is definitely an interesting perspective, as it is Hana, the mom, who wants her children to integrate into society. This can be seen as a negative and as her suppressing her children's individuality, but at the same time, it is clear her intentions were good and that she wanted the best possible life for them. Finally, I agree with your analysis about how A Silent Voice is powerful because it shows how the cycle of bullying is perpetuated, but also how important it is to hold oneself accountable for their actions and comprehend their wrongdoings. Overall, your analysis is amazing and the extent of the character development is definitely clear throughout each anime.

[reviewer28]

How Far Will People Go to be Accepted?

All three of the anime explore the stories of people who are unable to conform to traditional societal expectations, and are therefore ostracized and forced to endure numerous struggles to achieve their goals. In Naruto, the protagonist is an orphaned boy training to become a ninja, but he is burdened by having a Nine-Tailed Fox demon locked inside of him. Due to the demon living inside of him, Naruto is feared by most of the villagers. However, he is determined to earn their respect through becoming the Hokage. Eventually, despite all the challenges he faces due to discrimination, he saves the village and becomes recognized as the hero.  

In “Wolf Children,” Hana, a college student, falls in love with someone who is secretly a werewolf. Both of their children inherit the ability to transform into werewolves. When her husband dies, Hana is forced to adapt to raising her children alone, and is left struggling to decide how to deal with their unusual abilities. The children, Yuki and Ame, are also forced to decide how to express their wolf and human sides, grappling with choosing between embracing their identity and trying to fit in with society. 

In “A Silent Voice,” Shoya Ishida relentlessly bullies a deaf student, Shoko Nishimiya. However, once his bullying is exposed, he becomes the subject of bullying by his peers. This continues for years to the point where Shoya is still excluded and belittled by his classmates in high school. Therefore, he decides to make amends by learning sign language to communicate with and apologize to Shoko. Upon befriending Shoko, Shoya also begins to reconnect with some of his old peers, finally starting to be accepted by his classmates again. Through seeking forgiveness and accepting responsibility for his actions, Shoko is finally able to integrate with his peers once again. 

These anime all connect to global issues related to bullying, discrimination, mental health, and self-acceptance. All three anime deal with a protagonist who is completely excluded from society and must constantly struggle to conform. “A Silent Voice” is slightly different from the other two anime since rather than being discriminated against due to something he was born with, Shoya was targeted due to his own bullying of another student. This connects to global issues of discrimination, as both throughout history and in the present, people have been persecuted due to qualities they cannot control such as race, gender, and religion. This can be seen by looking at the Civil Rights Movement, as African Americans were previously enslaved, segregated, and mistreated due simply to the color of their skin. This can similarly be seen in the fight for women’s rights, as women were not given the same access to education, voting, and employment since they were seen as inferior to men. Religious discrimination in the Holocaust is another example, as millions of Jewish people were placed in concentration camps and/or murdered simply because Jews were not recognized as human. These anime also connect to the problem of bullying and its effects on mental health. Bullying can start from young ages, and it can significantly affect people’s self-confidence and potentially even lead some to take their own lives. The anime all show how bullying and ostracization significantly impacted quality of life for the protagonists. Finally, the struggle of accepting oneself when faced with pressure to conform to societal norms is explored. Often, especially during adolescence and with the rise of social media, many lose their originality by trying to fit into trends or integrate into certain friend groups to be considered “popular.” Many feel as if they have to abandon their true identity and adopt a fake personality in order to fit in, leading many to struggle to change themselves. 

[karaakii]

Blog Post: Shin Sekai Yori

Watching Shin Sekai Yori was deeply unsettling, but in a way that stuck with me and encouraged me to think about how we define what it means to be "human," particularly through the lens of childhood and social control. The episodes we watched show a world where children are raised under constant surveillance and psychological conditioning to prevent them from becoming "Fiends/Ogres," who are the monsters born from the failure of society to manage fear, power, and emotion.

What really struck me was how the show utilized the figure of the child to reflect deep cultural anxiety, something echoed in Arai's reading about Japan's 1990s obsession with "wild children." The children in Shin Sekai Yori are both feared and fetishized as the carriers of potential destruction. They are tightly controlled, but seen as essentially time bombs. It made me think about how in real life, people often view children not as innocent, but as mirrors for societal failure, where in education, parenting, or morality.

The society in Shin Sekai Yori is obsessed with harmony and stability, but achieves it through brutal and unnatural means: erasure of memory, state-sanctioned disappearance, and genetic manipulation. I found this frightening as it felt like a commentary not only on Japan, but on global systems that value order over empathy. The Monster Rats, who we learn are just genetically engineered humans, represent the ultimate "other," and their rebellion forces both the main characters and the viewers to question the moral foundations of civilization.

The most powerful moment for me was in episode 25, when Saki grants Squealer a merciful death. It was a moment of human emotional recognition, not just of his suffering, but the fact he was never truly a monster. It reminded me of how AI and risk assessment technologies today can reduce complex individuals into dangerous simplifications.

Similar to the Sibyl System in Psycho-Pass, the society in Shin Sekai Yori attempts to eliminate unpredictability through dehumanization. In the current world climate, the tension between individuality and social control represented in the anime felt quite personal. Shin Sekai Yori isn't complete science-fiction, but a warning about what we lose at the cost of engineering perfection, especially in children. In trying to eliminate danger, we risk eliminating the qualities that make us human.

[reviewer28]

Your analysis is amazing! I find the point you make about children not being viewed as innocent but rather as reflections of educational or parental failures. I have never had that thought before, but reading your post, I do agree that often, when a child is acting out in the real world, their families and schools are blamed. I also like the point you make about how the shift to obsession with harmony/stability and prioritization of order over empathy can be dangerous, as seen in the anime. I agree that AI can often reduce complex beings into dangerous simplifications, as AI cannot fully understand the depth of human thoughts/emotions. Finally, your conclusion about how attempting to engineer people to perfection risks eliminating qualities that make us human is extremely important. Imperfections are a crucial part of human nature and contribute to forming people's identities. A society where everyone meets a specific standard of perfection would likely be a very homogenous one. This consideration is especially relevant as more gene editing technologies are being developed, and concerns are being raised about the creation of "designer babies." Although these technologies are very relevant in the treatment of diseases, a line must be drawn to ensure that these tools are not being used to try to create humans with "perfect" qualities.

[reviewer28]

Shin Sekai Yori: When Psychic Powers Aren't as Amazing as they Seem

“Shin Sekai Yori” tells the story of a dystopian world where people have telekinetic powers, creating a seemingly perfect world. Rather than using the telekinetic powers for violence or murder, the people are made to resolve conflicts through love. To ensure this, they are even genetically modified so that they will automatically die if they kill another human. Because only those with telekinetic powers are made to die if they kill another person, those without these abilities are killed immediately to preemptively prevent crime. Children are also tested to see if they develop antisocial behaviors or violent tendencies and then eliminated if they do so. After a child named K loses his temper and kills his teacher and classmates, he is killed, and the rules of society are changed so that up until the age of seventeen, anybody who shows an indication of turning violent can be aborted. 

This anime is unique in that children are specifically targeted and surveilled. The idea of children being killed due to displaying slight signs of potential violent tendencies is incredibly flawed. Although it is technically possible that children can become violent, children’s brains are not fully developed, meaning they have the potential to greatly change over their lives. Since children are immature and do not fully understand right from wrong, it is very normal that they may have slight behavioral issues, and the idea of murdering a child due to them not conforming perfectly to societal expectations is extremely unjust. Also, many times, if a child displays concerning behaviors, this could be due to a traumatic upbringing or lack of familial influence, and instead of being punished for this, they should be given help so that they can overcome these issues. 

This anime connects to various global issues such as the dangers of technological development, genetic modification, and surveillance. Genetic modification is a major theme of the anime, as the people with psychic powers are genetically modified to die upon killing another person. Genetic modification is not only a dystopian concept, as it is becoming more of a reality today, although on a lesser scale. Techniques such as CRISPR, which allows for editing of DNA, are becoming more common and advanced. CRISPR has the potential to revolutionize the field of medicine and potentially cure certain genetic conditions, cancers, and other incurable diseases. However, there are concerns over this tool being misused to create designer babies that are engineered to have certain characteristics that are considered desirable. This could lead to eugenics and lack of diversity throughout society, and this raises many ethical concerns. The possibility of the misuse of genetic engineering in society calls for discussions on the proper regulations to prevent abuse of the technology. The anime also connects to the growing issue of surveillance, especially as the internet, social media, facial recognition technology, and AI engines are becoming more prevalent in society. As technology is becoming increasingly embedded into daily life, care must be taken to ensure that people’s privacy is protected and that technology does not become too powerful. Using the same logic, the anime also warns of the dangers of authoritarian societies that attempt to impose total control over citizens and eliminate those who deviate from expectations. For example, those without telekinetic powers are considered less-than-human and eliminated, relating to how genocides and ethnic cleansing can take place in these authoritarian societies.

[karaakii]

Blog Post: Psycho-Pass

Watching Psycho-Pass felt like peering into a future that isn't as far away as I'd like to believe, or unfortunately a society that is happening now that I try to pretend isn't. The episodes we watched unfold a world that at first seems absurdly dystopian, as a person's potential for crime can be measured, and your life can end early because a number says you're dangerous. I then realized, how similar this system is to many places globally.

The Sibyl System's method of constant surveillance and algorithmic judgment reminded me of predictive policing and risk assessment software already used in the U.S. among other countries, which the Machine Bias reading discussed. These tools often reinforce racial and social biases rather than eliminate them. In Psycho-Pass, the illusion of objectivity provided by Sibyl is similarly dangerous, especially when people stop questioning it. The system is very flawed, but also the characters (and real people) live in a world where challenging it can be unthinkable.

Episode 5 stuck with me, when the woman crying out for help is gunned down because her Crime Coefficient spiked from being traumatized. It is incredibly dehumanizing to reduce people to a number. Additionally, it pointed out how factors such as trauma, stress, and poverty can increase someone's risk factors in real life, and likewise how systems fail to see the context behind a person's behavior, and also don't offer equal opportunities to help those people.

I've realized in the last few years how systems judge people differently depending on who they are. Watching Akane question Sibyl's authority provoked reflection on the value of human judgment, as it is something that cannot be replaced by data or even AI. I admire her resolve in episode 17 when she choosed to not pull the trigger even when Sibyl says it's justified. It showed that justice isn't just about punishment, but included empathy, context, and responsibility.

In some ways, I think Psycho-Pass may exaggerate aspects of Japanese society, like conformity, pressure, and order, but does reveal universal truths. It asks an uncomfortable question to the viewers: Who gets to decide what kind of future someone deserves?

Psycho-Pass truly isn't as dystopian as I initially thought, it is agonizing to watch because of how much it reflects our current world. What is even more disturbing, though, is how ordinary Sibyl's rule becomes to those who live under it, which reminds me of many countries. The true danger is not just authoritarianism, but a quiet normalization of it. People adapt, look the other way, and eventually become complicit in it.

[reviewer28]

I love the analysis in your blog post. The point you make about how dangerous the system can become when people stop questioning it is especially interesting. This is relevant in many areas of life, as often, people are either too afraid to speak out against injustice or become so accustomed to a flawed system that they cannot envision any other reality. I also agree that a woman being gunned down because she suffered a traumatic event is incredibly unfair and dehumanizing. The whole Sybil System is based on the idea that mental stability determines likelihood to commit crime, but assuming that anybody who is struggling with mental health or dealing with trauma is dangerous is incredibly flawed. Finally, the point you make about human judgement being unable to be replaced by AI is a very important one. AI is replacing many jobs and taking on many roles, but it is true that technology can never have the same human connection with someone and does not have the same level of empathy. To answer your question about who gets to decide what kind of feature someone deserves, I believe that the government should not be able to choose who gets to live and die. People should be in control of their own futures, and nobody should be deemed unworthy of existing based on arbitrary and inaccurate metrics.