Pit Bulls Length of Stay Affected by Labeling~
Going to an animal shelter can be quite the adventure, especially when looking for a potential partner in crime, but, have you ever looked at the different breeds and thought “Just how long have you been waiting for a home?” Three researchers from Arizona State University did. They conducted a structured three part investigation into different breeds, and their ‘lookalikes’ that were left within the shelter based upon phenotypes, the use of labeling, or perceived behavior.
Lisa Gunter, Rebecca Barber, and Clive D.L. Wynee, are the three researchers from Mary Fulton Teachers College and Department of Psychology, who decided to conduct extensive research to find out why certain breeds of dogs stayed longer in shelters than others.
The first section of their research revolved around the perceived ‘attractiveness’ of three dog breeds (Labrador Retriever, Pit Bull Terrier, and Border Collie), as well as the effects of a handler’s appearance on their perspective of pit bulls. They theorized that the pit bull breed would have a much lower desirability and adoptability rate compared to the other two dog breeds.. They also theorized that the appearance of a male child or an elderly woman alongside the pit bull would improve the public’s perception of the breed. However, a tough looking older male would cause a negative impact for the breed. By the end of the testing, and original final results were analyzed, they found that the pit bull was seen as a less approachable, less intelligent breed, and had a very slim chance of being adopted. Comparatively, the other two, despite being rated higher for aggression and difficulty to train, were also found to have had a positive impact with an elderly woman or child next to them, and a small negative effect with a tough looking older adult male.
The next study was based around the labeling of the different breeds and how potential adopters viewed them attractive or not, and to see if this affected the length of stay for the different breeds. The theory was that the pit bull dogs would have a longer length if they were labeled as a pit bull, while those who looked phenotypically similar (lookalikes) but were labeled a different breed, would have a shorter stay. The end results were quite shocking. They found that the pit bulls labeled as pit bulls stayed three times longer, than their ‘lookalikes’. They concluded that the shelters labeling of the breeds, influenced the result of how long the dog remained without a home.
The final part of their research seemed to be the most interesting out of the entirety of all their research put together. They decided that the second study needed to be pushed more. So the last part of their study was designed to further test the impact on labeling between pit bulls and their ‘lookalikes’. This time however, they would be using short videos of the dogs being presented along with a manipulated breed label in order to further expand upon the true impact on potential adopters views. They predicted that the pit bulls and ‘lookalikes’ viewed without a label would be rated as equal, and those with the pit bull label would decrease ratings while the ‘lookalikes’ rating would be significantly higher. The conclusive results exhibited exactly that.
Gunter, Barber, and D.L. Wynee created a factual experiment showing just how vital labeling and perception has to do with how the life of a dog, especially with breeds having a bad reputation, can be manipulated. Their main goal was to find a reason as to why certain breeds end up living all their lives in shelters, compared to the others. The results were quite eye opening, to say the least. The fact that a simple label can dictate the decision of whether or not a dog got a home or was euthanized, is to say the least, unbelievable and staggering.
Research like this goes on to show that people still haven’t changed their minds on how they perceive the pit bulls. They may claim to want to end the fighting and the stereotypes, but if they were put to a test, like the people who were picked out for this experiment, would they really want to adopt a pit bull based upon the label, or would they go to there ‘lookalikes’ and pick them instead? An article with this amount of evidence is quite valuable, and gives us an insight on just how much influence these shelters have in what happens to these that live inside.
Gunter LM, Barber RT, Wynne CDL (2016) What’s in a Name? Effect of Breed Perceptions & Labeling on Attractiveness, Adoptions & Length of Stay for Pit-Bull-Type Dogs. Retrieved from http://web.b.ebscohost.com.ezproxy1.lib.asu.edu/ehost/pdfviewer/pdfviewer?vid=8&sid=d73c5db8-7274-430e-a694-476097b6ee2c%40sessionmgr120