Are the Kids All Right?
Lisa Cholodenko’s The Kids Are All Right (2010)
The kids may be fine, but their lesbian parents are definitely not. Much to my surprise, I recently discovered that the director and co-writer of the famed lesbian comedy-drama, The Kids Are All Right, is herself a lesbian. Having discovered this I find myself with an even bigger headache. “Why such a headache?” you may ask....”finally some lesbian representation in mainstream cinema!” you may exclaim. Wrong. Unfortunately and contrary to what the movie may have promoted, this film is not about lesbian marriage, parenthood, and life. It is really about the couple’s sperm donor, Mark Ruffalo, and their kids’s quest to find him (don’t you know kids need a father figure!) and the subsequent shit storm that commences once he enters the family’s life.
All too often, “deviant” sexualities, such as lesbianism, become universalized and normalized with the inclusion of representation in mainstream media. The Kids Are All Right is a prime example. The inclusion of depicting a lesbian couple as the film’s protagonists comes at the price of the erasure of the true difference and fluidity of identity- not only within the queer community, but within the lesbian community. Lesbian couple, Jules and Nic, are the quintessential and stereotypical traditional butch-femme lesbian coupling. Jules fills the role of the feminine stay at home wife and mom, while Nic is the masculinized workaholic and alcoholic. Aside from this depiction of heteronormative lesbian identity and gender roles is a complete void of sexual attraction and intimacy between the couple. In fact, the only explicit depiction of sex in the film is between Jules and the sperm donor. This is overwhelmingly problematic. The contrasting images of a frigid non-sexual relationship between Jules and Nic and then the hot and heavy insatiable sex between Jules and the sperm donor supports the idea that lesbians can’t sexually sustain themselves within their own relationships and subsequently confers the power and dominance of the penis and hetero sexual coupling.











