The house smelled like roasted vegetables and too much tension.
Dinner at the Reaper household had never been “normal,” but tonight was something else entirely. The long dining table was full—Karmine sat between the triplets, Luci, Kira, and Fae, cutting up their food, while Giovanni poked at something purple and steaming with mild suspicion. Across from him, Mimosa—Science Baby’s daughter and his cousin—was happily chatting about her new drawing while scooping mashed potatoes into her mouth.
Grim sat at the head of the table, silent, watching. Aadhya was at the far end, her usual place—arms crossed, wine glass untouched, her expression like carved obsidian. She and Grim never got along. Not since day one. Too similar in their own twisted ways: Aadhya, cold and cutting; Grim, ancient and absolute.
The tension was already thick when Aadhya spoke.
“It must be convenient,” she said suddenly, voice smooth and venomous, “to spend eternity acting like a father while skipping the hard parts.”
Forks paused mid-air. Karmine froze.
Grim’s head tilted, slow and deliberate. “And yet I don’t recall you ever having a child without ruining the relationship entirely.”
Aadhya smiled—sharp and humorless. “Careful. That sounded almost like an insult. You want to go there in front of your children and mine?”
Karmine stood up, voice tight. “Let’s not—”
Grim rose, shadows unfurling like a second skin. “You manipulate your son with guilt and silence. Don’t talk to me about parenting.”
“You haunt your children like a specter waiting to see if they’ll fail you,” Aadhya snapped. “You’re not a father, you’re a curse.”
A chair scraped. A glass cracked in Grim’s hand.
And then they moved—Aadhya lunging, Grim matching her blow for blow. Dark energy and raw force collided in a flash. Dishes shattered. A candlestick flew. Giovanni leapt from his seat, shielding Mimosa, who yelped in surprise, wide-eyed and trembling.
Karmine threw herself between them, magic glowing at her palms, voice hoarse: “Stop it! Now!”
The triplets were crying. Fae had her hands over her ears, Luci was whispering “Is Daddy okay?” and Kira was frozen in place, eyes locked on the chaos.
Grim backed off first, his chest heaving but face cold as stone. Aadhya turned away, hair wild, lip bleeding slightly, rage simmering beneath her skin. No apology. No explanation.
Karmine’s voice was tight as steel. “Go. Upstairs. All of you.”
The kids scattered—Fae and Kira clutching each other, Luci trailing behind them. Giovanni helped Mimosa up, both of them shaken.
Only silence remained in the dining room.
No one said it, but everyone felt it: a line had been crossed. One they couldn’t uncross.
The house was finally quiet.
The triplets were asleep, curled into one another like puzzle pieces. Giovanni and Mimosa had stayed up whispering in the guest room, but eventually even their soft voices had faded. Broken dishes were cleaned. Scorch marks scrubbed off the dining room wall. The chaos was over—for now.
Karmine sat at the edge of the bed, her hair unbrushed, a mug of cold tea in her hands. She stared into it like it held the answers she hadn’t been able to say out loud. Grim sat in the armchair across the room, cloaked in shadows that flickered with whatever storm still boiled in his chest.
“I’m so tired,” Karmine said finally, her voice barely above a whisper. “I’m tired of pretending like this is okay.”
“I get that Aadhya doesn’t like you,” she continued. “But tonight—tonight she humiliated you. In front of our daughters. Our family. Me.”
He looked up slowly. His face was expressionless, but his hands were clenched on the armrests. “She’s a weapon Willow refuses to wield.”
Karmine nodded, a tired, bitter laugh slipping from her lips. “Willow doesn’t care. She’s too busy being… Willow. Avoiding everything. Making jokes. Leaving me to deal with Aadhya’s fire while she dances in the smoke.”
Grim stood and crossed the room slowly, crouching in front of her. He didn’t reach for her—he just looked.
“I won’t ask for permission to defend myself,” he said. “But I know what I did scared them. I saw Luci’s face.”
Karmine’s eyes filled with tears. “I don’t want them to grow up thinking this is normal. That dinner ends in violence. That someone always has to win.”
They sat in silence for a long time.
“I don’t want to kick them out,” she said softly. “The kids love each other, it’s easier raising four with four… and I love Willow. I’ve loved her like a sister since the day Science and Xochitl got together. It would destroy her.”
“But you’re not wrong to want peace,” Grim said. “And boundaries.”
Karmine wiped her eyes. “Then we set them.”
He nodded once, final. “No one lays a hand on anyone again. Not in this house.”
Grim’s voice was cold, absolute. “Then they leave.”
Karmine exhaled like she’d been holding that breath for weeks. “I don’t want it to come to that.”
They sat together, not speaking for a while, until Karmine leaned her head against his shoulder. For all his darkness, he was steady. Loyal. Hers.
“We’ll talk to them tomorrow,” she said. “Together.”
“And if they don’t take it seriously?”
Karmine gave a sad smile. “Then we’ll do what we have to. For the kids. For us.”
And in the quiet of that fragile night, with the weight of love and loyalty pressing against the walls, they agreed: no more chaos. No more excuses.
This was their home. And it had to be safe again.
The next morning, the sun was bright and mocking, pouring into the kitchen like nothing had happened the night before.
But something had. And it wasn’t going to be brushed under a rug or swallowed in silence.
Karmine stood at the head of the table. Grim stood beside her—not looming, not intimidating, just present. Controlled. Composed. The way only he could be when he’d made up his mind.
Across from them, Willow and Aadhya slouched in their seats like two teenagers dragged into the principal’s office. Willow looked half-hungover, twisting her coffee mug by the handle. Aadhya had on sunglasses indoors, arms crossed tight.
No one spoke for a long moment.
Then Karmine cleared her throat, voice flat but firm. “We’re not doing what happened last night ever again. I want to be very clear—ever again.”
Willow opened her mouth, but Grim held up a hand. “Let her finish.”
Karmine’s jaw tightened. “You want to live here? Raise your son here? Then this house is a safe place. For everyone. No more screaming. No more fighting. And absolutely no more violence.”
Grim stepped forward, nodding once. “I owe you both an apology for losing control. It shouldn’t have happened. It won’t happen again.”
He glanced at Aadhya, who looked away.
“But,” Karmine continued, “you two need to face your own damage. Because it’s constant. The drinking. The fighting. The late nights. The bar tabs. The times you’ve come home high and stumbling. And you think we don’t notice, but Giovanni does. The kids do.”
Willow blinked fast, guilt flickering across her features.
“I love you,” Karmine said, her voice shaking now. “Both of you. You’re my family. But you have to grow up. You have to get help. You have to want better.”
Aadhya scoffed lightly under her breath.
“No,” Karmine snapped, eyes blazing. “Don’t you dare roll your eyes. Because this isn’t about you anymore. This is about Giovanni. Think about him. Think about what kind of man you want him to be in ten years.”
“You think he’s not watching? Every time you scream at each other, every time you disappear, every time you stumble into the kitchen reeking of alcohol and rage, he’s watching. They’re all watching.”
Willow looked down at her hands.
Aadhya didn’t speak, but the smug mask had cracked.
“We’re raising four kids in this house,” Karmine continued. “We have to set an example. That’s our job now. Not being right. Not being angry. Not drowning in whatever pain you won’t face.”
She paused, taking a breath. “We’re not kicking you out. Not yet. But this is the last time anything like that happens here. If either of you raise a hand again, you’re gone.”
Willow finally spoke, voice small. “…What kind of help are you talking about?”
“Therapy,” Grim said. “A real one. Not the bartender who pretends to care. Not whatever stranger you confide in at 3 a.m. A real one. And stop drinking when you’re angry. Stop using.”
Aadhya’s face tightened, but something in her shoulders shifted. The fight was leaving her, just a little.
Willow nodded, eyes rimmed red. “Okay. Okay… we’ll try.”
“Don’t try,” Karmine said. “Do.”
The silence that followed wasn’t cold—it was heavy. The weight of truth, finally spoken. The weight of what comes after.
They weren’t fixed. Not even close.
But maybe—for Giovanni, for the girls, for each other—this was where it started.