Do You Like Scary Movies? Fic Masterlist
Find me on ao3
This collection of fics has Scully and Mulder entering the universes of iconic horror movies.
*MSR is always the main focus. *No knowledge of the movies is required before reading. *These are NOT scary, but any warnings will be provided when necessary.
**********
Bigger Boat
Scully and Mulder investigate a mysterious pair of shark attacks off the coast of Martha’s Vineyard, but things aren’t exactly as they appear.
Scary Movie: Jaws / Words: 9,658 / Rating: E
If You Were That Stoned, What?
Scully and Mulder head to Camp Crystal Lake to investigate the grounds, but things are derailed by partying camp counselors. Instead of breaking up the party, though, they become a part of it.
Scary Movie: Friday the 13th / Words: 4,284 / Rating: M
Vacancy
On the way to a case, Scully and Mulder lose their battle against the rain and have to spend the night at the Bates Motel. Smuttiness ensues.
Scary Movie: Psycho / Words: 2,859 / Rating: E
I Don't Want to Talk
Scully’s grief over losing Emily returns on a new case, and she turns to Mulder for unexpected comfort.
Scary Movie: Rosemary's Baby / Words: 1,159 / Rating: M
What Lurks in the Forest
Hikers are missing. Stories of an ancient being are whispered by the locals. Mulder drags Scully to the forest to investigate. Something strange is keeping them from the truth, but it only pushes them closer together.
Scary Movie: The Ritual / Words: 8,285 / Rating: E
Darkened Skies
Scully and Mulder help out Skinner when bird attacks derail his vacation to a seaside cottage. Everything changes after they are forced to take cover in a phone booth.
Scary Movies: The Birds / Words: 1,719 / Rating: E
Viewing Experience
Mulder and Scully have a scary movie night that inspires them to reveal their feelings. Basically, the ’90s version of “Netflix and Chill.”
Scary Movie: The Exorcist / Words: 1,951 / Rating: T
These Dreams
While unwinding at a bar, things get a little bit awkward, a little bit silly, and A LOT flirty when Mulder asks Scully about her dreams.
Scary Movie: A Nightmare on Elm Street / Words: 1,919 / Rating: M
These Dreams (Part 2)
This is a follow-up to These Dreams. Now that Mulder and Scully have confessed their dirty, secret, and unprofessional dreams to each other, they set about making them come true.
Scary Movie: A Nightmare on Elm Street / Words: 1,655 / Rating: E
Talk to Me
Scully and Mulder are broken up, but when feelings about William resurface, Mulder tries to comfort her in his own way. Takes place somewhere early in the revival, meaning there is angst.
Scary Movie: Frankenstein / Words: 1,142 / Rating: E
Boyfriend
Scully and Mulder might have recently crossed into a romantic relationship, but that doesn’t mean she wants to call him her boyfriend. However, when Mulder surprises her while babysitting her godson, it has Scully questioning her stance on labels.
Scary Movie: Halloween / Words: 3,056 / Rating: M
The Finer Things
Scully and Mulder are sent undercover onboard a luxury train to investigate the presence of a suspicious and undocumented train car. Playing a wealthy married couple is tricky, but they run into even bigger issues when an unwelcomed agent gets sent in for backup.
Scary Movie: Horror Express / Words: 15,681 / Rating: E
Unprofessional
Scully isn't happy when a case sends them to a New Orleans swamp. She's even less thrilled when a local tour guide gets the hots for Mulder and invites him to dinner.
Scary Movie: Hatchet / Words: 1,876 / Rating: E
Something
Mulder is ready for something more with Scully, but his hopes for romance shatter when he realizes Scully has reconnected with her ex-boyfriend.
Scary Movie: Trick 'r Treat / Words: 1,787 / Rating: T
Discussing the Case
While investigating the Babysitter Killer, the local PD files a misconduct complaint against Scully and Mulder. They swear it’s a misunderstanding, but if they want to keep their jobs, Skinner has to shadow them, ensuring the allegations of “unnecessary touching” and “standing too close together” aren’t true.
Scary Movie: Halloween H20 / Words: 8,397 / Rating: E
Fascinating
An awkward hiking scenario results in Mulder and Scully sharing a tent. The problem... Skinner is also there.
Scary Movie: The Blair Witch Project / Words: 1,405 / Rating: M
Fascinating (Part 2)
Scully and Mulder continue their hike in the woods after the new development in their relationship. If only Skinner wasn't around to witness it.
Scary Movie: The Blair Witch Project / Words: 1,651 / Rating: T
Desires Under Darkness
Scully isn’t happy when Mulder cancels their flight on Valentine’s Day to work a case. She’s lonely, she’s horny, and her new partner is the cause of both frustrations.
Scary Movie: My Bloody Valentine / Words: 2,288 / Rating: E
Stay
After an encounter with a terrifying ghost, Scully seeks comfort in Mulder’s bed. The issue: They both don’t want to stop, so they start sleeping together… literally. But what starts as just cuddling gets complicated as their feelings become harder to hide.
Scary Movie: Lights Out / Words: 3,651 / Rating: E
Sedimentary Rocks and Moonlight
When Byers’ new girlfriend invites Scully, Mulder, and the Gunmen to her lakeside house, Frohike encourages Mulder to tell his partner how he feels after six years of pining. But what was supposed to be a work-free trip gets upended when the group makes a gruesome discovery by the beach. And suddenly, Mulder’s fantasies of romance are met with new challenges.
Scary Movie: The Burning / Words: 9,709 / Rating: E
For the Sake of Honesty
Mulder and Scully get trapped in a house formerly occupied by three witches, and the only way out is to reveal the last time they had sex. The issue: They're in a secret relationship, Skinner is there, and so is Agent Kinsley (you know, that dork from "Detour").
Scary Movie: Hocus Pocus / Words: 5,464 / Rating: M
Dial Someone Else
Scully is content to spend a quiet night at home… until her phone rings. What starts as a seemingly harmless misdial transpires into something more ominous. (And yes, Mulder shows up, too.)
Scary Movie: Scream / Words: 3,134 / Rating: T
It Follows, But So Do You
In this alternate take on "Never Again," Scully's encounter with Ed Jerse ends with her being stalked by a supernatural entity hellbent on killing her. When Mulder arrives, jealous and confused, they must navigate their tension while trying to solve Scully's terrible predicament. Apparently, the only way to stop the curse is to pass it to someone else by sleeping with them, and much to Mulder's chagrin, that isn't something Scully wants to do.
Scary Movie: It Follows / Words: 19,667 / Rating: E
Hypothetically
A case surrounding a missing research team sends Scully and Mulder to remote Alaska, where a sudden snowstorm leaves them stranded and cold. Forced to take shelter with a local family, a bizarre mystery and huddling for warmth push the boundaries of their new partnership.
Scary Movie: Rare Exports / Words: 14,600 / Rating: E

















