Now that i’m on the jury, where I should have been (thanks Willow, xo), I get to have a say in who wins the game. Obviously i’ve been out of the game for the longest out of any juror, therefore I missed out on witnessing the moves made during the critical jury portion of the game.
Before I ask question(s) about either of your games, I want to note two things. Firstly, congratulations on making it to the end! My vote will not be based on who I was necessarily closer with, or anything related. It will be purely based on who I think played the better game. Secondly, my vote as of now has not been determined and I am of absolute no clue on who I am going to vote for - so fight hard ;o
Luke. Our game history together has been pretty weird. We were with one another, then you voted me out (even in a tiebreaker), so I tried to vote you out, but you idolled and in the end we were on the same page (I think?) when I was voted out. I got to witness more of your game than I did Alex’s. You presented in your opening speech that you had social alignments, as you knew when to play the idol accurately, and the orchestration of flushing Willow’s idol out.
So I have a few questions for you, nothing big.
a) Were you wanting me out during my vote out?
b) Why, when you used your idol, did you vote out Nicholas over anyone else?
c) What would considerably be your biggest move (or in other words, your most pivotal move) in the game, and why?
d) If you could choose anyone to be sitting with you in the final two, who would it be and why?
and e) Taken from a fellow friend, rank the jurors (including me and Kendall I guess) game’s from 1 (being the best) to 10? (being the worse) and provide reason.
Now onto Alex. We didn’t really connect ever, which may be because of the continuous merge swaps and us never really being together. However, our lack of communication won’t really interfere with my jury vote. In your opening speech, you stated that people assumed you were playing the game after my blindside. This will be addressed below as I have some questions regarding that. In addition, you displayed an excellence of a strategic game otherwise, including dethroning Jay, who seemed to be in a powerful position in the jury phase.
So, here are my questions for you!
a) How did my vote instigate you as a player? What was your impact to my vote? What role did you play?
b) What was the most pivotal moment in the game for your particular game? It’d help if you explain why this was pivotal.
c) Who do you, in all honesty, think played the best game (provide details if necessary)
d) Why should your gameplay be rewarded over Luke with the case of you winning 7 (give or take) immunities? In other words, why should competition wins be valued over not winning any competitions and still making it to the end?
and e) Taken from a fellow friend, rank the jurors (including me and Kendall I guess) game’s from 1 (being the best) to 10? (being the worse) and provide reason.
And with that, my questions are concluded. Good luck to both finalists on not only answering these and other questions, but in general! Make the best player win, and once again, congratulations to you both on doing what basically everyone else couldn’t this game.
Thank you very much for the kind words Zach, I was totally blindsided by the last minute jury swap and wasn't sure what to expect, so I'm happy you're willing to ask questions and take my input. We did talk at the beginning on the original tribe, then we split and you working on the opposite side to John during the swap is pretty much the reason we ended up not communicating afterwards. I saw you and Ruthie as one unit and since I never met Ruthie before the merge, there wasn't a lot of room for me to work with you closely.
a) The main reason why your vote was my first big play is simple – that was the first (important) tribal council I attended in the game, if we're not counting Jack and Liana. After we merged, I felt like Ryan was going to be the natural vote since I knew he had little connections with most of the fans, and that was the vote I was going to make until I learned of the alliance which included you, Ruthie, Luke, Colin and Jay. You had 4 double votes between you and possibly an idol from Jay's reward secret search, so I realized that letting you all go forward even just one more vote would be destructive for my game.
My role was mostly approaching Ryan with the idea and getting him on board, and to some extent keep Kendall updated and in contact with the rest of us, and instruct her to use her double vote (in addition to mine) to ensure we had the numbers in case one of you used a double vote too.
That was not an easy move to make, I've been told right afterwards how much of a threat I am, and I knew this would come. Going out of your comfort zone and go against a very powerful alliance is something most players don't dare to do.
b) My most pivotal move in the game was during Willow's elimination. John found an idol that round (after I stayed hunting long on purpose, to make everyone think I'm doing a puzzle), and promised Willow that he would play it for her. I felt like that move was too risky, and definitely not going to help me after I was told Ryan isn't willing to consider working with me anymore. Even if we played the idol correctly, it would still leave the three of us in minority and me as the main target. John himself was very paranoid he could go home, and I had to go on call with him a few minutes before the deadline and convince him to not only not play the idol for Willow, but give it to me to hold in case he's blindsided. In that situation, no matter who was the target eventually, I would still have the idol in case I don't win the next immunity and could plan from there. Asking John to do that, break his word to Willow and put his life at risk was a very bold and difficult move, he passed me the idol literally on the last minute.
Eventually, after disarming Jay and her alliance of their double votes and idol at final 9, and of Jay's tribal skip advantage at final 7, that same idol was used to take Jay out when there was no doubt about John being the vote, and Jay had no way of protecting herself anymore. If the idol was played at final 8 and went back into circulation, someone else could've found it and mess up with my plans.
c) John has played the best game in my opinion. I know, I am a bit biased because John and I have been very close and I know his game first hand, better than anyone else I believe, so I'm basing it on my personal experience.
John has been in the know about every single thing that happened in this game, or he simply predicted it correctly. He wasn't left out of any pre-merge vote, He predicted Kendall was the vote at final 9, he predicted Willow was the vote at final 8, he knew not to play his idol at 7 and then play it at 6. Once Jay left, John went from the obvious next boot to single handedly dictating the vote to take Colin out. I believe he had the highest chance of winning the game out of the final 4, due to both gameplay and likeability.
d) This question is almost philosophical, but I'll try to give you the best possible answer without going too deep into it. It all depends on how you see the concept of being immune in Survivor – is being immune an achievement, or is it just a free pass to the next round? It depends who you ask, different people have different takes on this.
I can tell you that personally, I believe winning an immunity challenge is something that deserves credit. It requires time, effort, skill, and dedication – not any less than talking to people and strategizing to keep yourself safe, maybe even more. Seeing the same person winning immunity over and over might seem like it's the "easy way out", but it's not easy. Knowing you need to win, having all this pressure on you and still winning 7 times in a row is not to be taken for granted, I challenge all of you to attempt this in your next game.
Playing an idol for example, is a flashy move that also makes you immune. Is any skill required to find an idol? No, just luck, but an idol play still seem to be perceived as a move more than an immunity win. Playing the idol correctly is tricky, but an idol play is still practically an immunity, same thing for any advantages that make you immune.
While being immune is a privilege of sort, you still need to prove strategical and social abilities in order to be on the right side of the vote and succeed in making your moves.
My connections with Willow and John were pivotal in taking you out, and eventually taking Jay out – a process which took 4 rounds in total. There was a lot of work to be done other than winning these immunities, and at the end of the day I had by far more influence on this game than Luke had.
Luke was next to inactive while he was still playing in Switzerland, he also needed immunity (in the form of an idol) in order to survive, then he needed the 2nd swap to survive following that. Once we merged, Luke was not seen as a threat in any aspect of this game – after Ryan, he was the popular person to take to the final 2 as a goat. This is the reason why he's sitting here over anyone else, and I'm saying that as someone who had numerous opportunities to take Luke out. Why didn't I do it? Because he never posed a threat to me, he was providing information to John – which John relayed to me, and indirectly helped me execute my plans.
1. John – most of the reasons were already given in question c), but I will add my personal favorite about John – the fact that I was not willing to write his name down, willing to take him to the final 2, even if it means losing to him. We were so close it honestly didn't matter to me if he beats me, I'd be just as happy.
2. Jay – Jay had the second strongest social game after John. She made sure to establish a working relationship with everyone, in and out of her alliance. She was the only person other than me to win challenges this season! One of them being literally a mini-Survivor game. She was always in a position of power, even when she lost the vote, she knew how to get up and fight back. No one would've beaten Jay in this game with any combination of jury, period.
3. Ruthie – Ruthie was the silent killer of the season. She went to every single tribal in this game! (Except for one) and got no votes against her up until the final 5. This is pretty amazing and an evidence to nearly perfect social game. The only thing that kept Ruthie from winning this game was the fact she was open and genuine about the relationships she had, which ultimately made her too big of a threat to consider going against.
4. Willow – Willow made the biggest sacrifice in this game, in order to help the people she considered her closest allies. She gave up on a comfortable spot in the majority to play a much riskier game and if it wasn't for my immunity run, she could've made her way back into a power position later. She had the social skills to make herself a popular ally while not being seen as a threat.
5. Zach – I will admit that I don't know much about your game first hand, mostly from what John, Jay and Ruthie have told me since we weren't together for a long time. You had a tough time being on a losing tribe and you went through a few crazy votes. Like Colin, you've been paired up with Ruthie and Nicholas for the most part. However, you were the one person I felt the most threatened by when you left (after Jay). Jay claimed it was your idea to bring together the alliance, and the fact you were able to get back with Luke after trying to vote each other out is an evidence to a good social game.
6. Colin – The only major flaw in Colin's game was the fact he's been constantly paired up with other people (Jay, Luke, Zach) and never actually seen as an individual player on his own right. This fact prevented him from creating new alliances because the perception was there's always someone he wouldn't go against. He was eventually blindsided by John, mostly for not having much of a relationship with him like Luke and Ruthie had.
7. Ryan – Ryan has openly admitted he's struggling with the social game. I don't know a lot about his pre-merge, but it seems like he was an easy target from the beginning and didn't manage to improve his position throughout the game. At final 8, Ryan refused to go to rocks and ended up going home next after Willow, which I believe was the move that cost him the game.
8. Kendall – Kendall's game was not necessarily the worst, but she has definitely been the least active after the merge. Her fight with Jay felt unnecessary to me, and that might've been the reason she was voted out. She wasn't around to change her vote that tribal, and she's not around here to take part in the jury, so I think based on activity it's fitting to put her last.
Oh wow! Okay, you're asking us to do so much ahhh. I'll go ahead and answer each of them, thank you for giving me a chance to be able to explain some things!
a) I absolutely did NOT want you to leave on your vote. I was 100% with you at that point, I know things had been a little rocky between us at that point but I was willing and ready to work with you but unfortunately Willow had other ideas and betrayed the alliance. I seriously wanted you to stay, though.
b) When I was using my idol, I did think very hard about who to idol out because I had five options, Same, John, you, Nicholas or Ruthie. John and Sam were my allies feeding me informtation, Ruthie and I were fairly close and had talked a little, you and I had been together since the beginning of the game and had been fairly honest with each other up until that point and I wanted to salvage some sort of relationship with you at that point. Then there was Nicholas. Nicholas had played in Hokkaido with both Ruthie and myself and Ruthie had been willing to go to rocks for him in that game to try and save him. I tried to think about a time where I'd seen you and Ruthie be that good of allies to one another and I couldn't. To me, it seemed like Nicholas was the glue that was going to keep you and Ruthie together so I decided to take a direct swipe at the head of the snake and eliminate that so there was some chance I could use the both of you in the future without the danger of Nicholas being there.
c) My biggest move in this game absolutely game at the final 4. Alex told me he'd take John over me to the final 2 but would take me to the final 2 over Ruthie. John was my closest ally but to ensure my space here at the final 2 I had to vote my ally John and take the risk and hope that Ruthie pulled out a win over John in the tiebreaker challenge which she thankfully did! Making that move, using Alex's words against him to better my position in this game was absolutely my biggest move and allowed me to sit here at the final 2.
d) If I could have anybody to be sitting here in the final 2 with me it would be John. We made a pact day one to make it all the way until the end and we almost had it. Had Alex not spilled the truth about taking John to the finals over me, I would have voted Ruthie out and stupidly gotten 3rd place. I had to adapt who I wanted to sit here with me to the person I least wanted to sit with but here I am and I'm going to try my best.
e) Ordering people's games from the worst to the best is always hard for me but I'll give it a go: (please don't let these affect your decision, I'm trying to be honest!!)
1. Jay - Absolutely flawless. She got herself into a good position in the merge with a large alliance and although that didn't work out, we still managed to flush an idol together and make it through several votes. It took an idol to take her out which just goes to show how good of a player she is. (Ranking out of 10: 10)
2. Ruthie - Ruthie always has a great social game. She was close with you, me, Colin and Jay whilst also sneakily being in contact with John and Alex and being in a good position come (Ranking out of 10: 10)
3. John - John, like Jay and Ruthie was in a good position. He was being protected by myself on one side and Alex on the other side which allowed him to slide by virtually unnoticed for a little while. Add in the idol play that took out Jay and here he is, top 3 of my rankings (Ranking out of 10: 8)
4. Colin - Colin was in the alliance that majority for approximately one round but he was involved in the exposing Willow's idol and wasn't really too much of a threat for anybody. The only reason he was taken out was because I was too busy trying to save John to realise that Ruthie was being a lil' sneaky queen! (Ranking out of 10: 7)
5. Zach - Your game was good, you were obviously taken out at the first merge vote by no fault of your own. Willow betrayed the alliance and you were voted out and I think you were targeted because people saw your potential of being a reall good strategic player. Your pre-merge game was amazing and you got insanely lucky with Nicholas joining our tribe. (Ranking out of 10: 6)
6. Willow - Willow really had the potential to be a good player, and she was, but she stumbled when she told Jay about the idol and then proceeded to turn her back on the alliance. This was a mistake that she couldn't recover from because after being exposed as idol holder and betrayer, there really wasn't much else she could do. (Ranking out of 10: 5)
7. Ryan - Ryan also had the potential to be a phenomenal player but I just don't think he was around all that often. He was come to the tribe chat to add his daily cheese emoji but I just didn't see him make those connections to stay. (Ranking out of 10: 5)
8. Kendall - We never talked, she wasn't very active in the tribe chat and was never really seemed to control anything. (Ranking out of 10: 1)