Just a heads up, I wasn’t able to watch the Seoul Searching movie so I had to read a synopsis so because of that, I decided to go a bit further with my analysis of this documentary for myself. That’s why it’s very long but I’ve sectioned off a chunk of it that isn’t necessarily relevant to the aim of this project so I’d suggest skipping it.
Minding the Gap, directed by Bing Liu is a documentary that details the lives of three skateboarding friends that must face hardships and responsibilities that create hurdles in their decade-long friendship. The three friends, Bing, Keire, and Zack all formed their friendships through skateboarding, which was a way for them to escape their difficult lives and to actually have fun. As the years passed and their friendship grew older, their friendship also became more distant as they began to age and learn about the responsibilities of the real world and how harsh life is for those who are impoverished in the Rust Belt. Each of these friends faced their own difficult situations in their childhood that would ultimately impact their coming into adulthood. Because of the childhoods the three had, they might have made bad choices, but those bad choices are not solely because of their own decision to act in a certain way. This entire documentary was about confusion and self-discovery for the three friends. It was about understanding their situations, why they were in their situations, and what they could do to improve themselves.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bing, Keire, and Zack are all from working class families and asides from Zack, are minorities. For historical context, the Rust Belt is a region of the United States which consists of the Midwest and the Great Lakes that faced harsh industrial decline in the 1980s. The Rust Belt was known as the industrial heartland of America and held a large amount of manufacturing jobs. However, as automation made its way into the Rust Belt and manufacturing began to move overseas, many people lost their jobs and fell into their own depression which is still apparent today. Crime increased, the outcome of education worsened, job opportunities lessened, and the population of many cities decreased heavily. The situation in the Rust Belt is still terrible and is not seeing enough improvement as promised by the Trump administration. This brief summary of the Belt explains why our three friends have their low quality of life as displayed in the documentary.
The working class needs to work 24/7 in order to pay bills, put food on the table, and to take care of the family. The working class and minorities are simply pawns to be used for those who employ them, industries and corporations have no care for how the working class and minorities live. There is no care for the quality of life of workers and minorities considering the wealthy hoard their wealth while workers have to live off of unlivable wages. Since the 1970s, productivity has increased by roughly 150% while compensation has remained stagnant. So, we see the families of Bing, Keire, and Zack struggle to maintain a stable household which has clearly played a role in how the three enter adulthood. It is not the fault of Bing, Keire, Zack that they made choices that wouldn’t benefit them for the future, it is the system that we live in that has set them in a position where there is a small chance of making it out and possibly entering the middle class. It is not necessarily the fault of their parents for not being able to raise them properly or to care of them properly, it is the system in which they live in that is made to ensure that they, along with their family, do not succeed. An American can work as hard as they physically can, but they will only receive crumbs for their hard work.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
As for the connection into Asian American identity, according to Bing, his mother immigrated to the US because it was her American dream to have a traditional family, but that citizenship also played a role. She would marry a white man who would become Bing’s stepfather. Both Bing and his mother faced abuse from him, physically and emotionally. His stepfather had internalized racism and tried to use it to alter their identities. Race plays a huge part in a person’s identity, and his stepfather tried to erase that part. Bing himself even tried to erase part of his identity just to assimilate into American culture because in the land of the free, if you’re not white and you have a cultural background that’s different to an American, you’re not American. Skateboarding was a way for him to connect to others in the area because those skaters didn’t judge on how he looked, they welcomed him because he was a skater and they all had the common purpose of just wanting to skate. Asian Americans unfortunately have to face the same sort of intolerance that other minorities have to face as well as our current administration continues to divide the country and its people by so called “patriots” and the rest who are “against the country they live in”. Discrimination, xenophobia, racism is extremely apparent in the way that the Trump administration is handling minorities in the country and how it is handling immigration.
I can’t relate to the three friends because I have grown up in a middle-class family. My family situation is complicated considering how my mother was already in the US before she had married my dad, but both immigrated from India. My dad was lucky enough to get a government job working as a postman, and he still works, and that has been a large part in our financial stability. They continue to work but they have no time to enjoy the fruits of their labor. However, I can relate to some their feelings of mental instability. I also found myself in rough situations, nothing like theirs’ but I can relate to the anguish and pain that many of us felt when we were growing up, trying to understand the world they were in and the lives of those around us. But their experiences are not mine, I don’t want to dive deep into how we lived similarly because we didn’t. I come from a middle-class family and am privileged, so its not right for me to equate our situations except for maybe mentally.