Value Me, Jack and any (or all) of his dads
Sequel to And Save Me From The Dark
DARKNESS WAS FAMILIAR to Sam Winchester, somewhere between an ancient enemy and an old friend. He had fought with and against it, accepted and banished it, and even surrendered to it in one form or another for his entire life. He had no fear of it, and felt no pressing urge to leave it now, wrapped within it as he was, warm and quiet and without pain.
"He's been like this for days, Cas. You sure you can't..."
"Even if I could use my Grace to wake him, I would not. You and Sam have a bad habit of not allowing yourselves time to heal and rest as you should, and there is no need to wake him immediately."
"Jack is as Sam hoped to make him. Safe and whole. Dumah has been dealt with and can no longer manipulate him into killing humans to create new angels the way she had been doing."
"No. To forcibly rouse Sam now would do him more harm than good. Or do you no longer prioritize your brother's safety and health and happiness above all else?"
"...Nothing more important than Sammy."
Sam let himself drift down and away again, floating in the darkness. Jack was safe. Jack was whole. Dean was impatient, but Castiel had him in hand for now. He could rest. They would wake him if he was needed, if the situation became dire, but for now he could take his time to rest, to rebuild himself after unravelling his soul so far that he felt more like a knotted string inside than a proper soul. It would take time to unravel himself again and rewind all the filaments back into cohesion, but he could finally do it. He had time.
"Sam, I... I'm so sorry..."
No, Jack, you don't need to be sorry, son....
"I know you think I don't need to be sorry, but I do. I am. I... I messed up so much, hurt so many people--"
You're still a kid, Jack, you made mistakes and when you found out the truth you wanted to fix it. Nobody with sense could blame you for being manipulated.
"Dean is back to wanting to kill me again, but he can't. There's nothing out there that can."
I said nobody with sense, Jack. Dean's not sensible, not when it comes to people with powers. Too much like Dad.
"He says he doesn't want to kill me, but he's lied to me before. So many people have lied to me, and part of me just wishes everyone would stop lying...but then I remember that I've lied, too, and I don't know what makes some lies hurtful and some lies okay."
I wish I could answer that for you, Jack. I grew up being fed lies until I learned to lie right back and sometimes I can't tell the difference either.
"Castiel says that it's hard to tell the difference and that the best way to determine what lies are okay is if the truth would hurt someone more than help, but that's hard to guess too. Like with my grandparents. It would hurt them to know that my mother is dead, but what if it hurts them more to find out that she's dead after being told by people that she's alive?"
Finding out that your child is dead will hurt no matter when it happens, Jack. In the case of your grandparents, though, they'd want to know what happened to Kelly's two year old son, probably want to take custody.
"Castiel said it's better they think she's alive so they don't start asking questions about me. I don't look like a two year old human, and I don't think I'd want to live with them anyway, not when I have my fathers."
"I mean... I mean Castiel, of course, but... I also mean you."
"Do you remember the day I was born? I called you Father, because you were the first person I saw and you felt like the Grace I'd felt before... like Castiel's Grace. You said you weren't my father, and I guess at the time that was true... but I think... I think you became my father not long after that. When you protected me, and cared for me... comforted me when I got upset or scared... And you said you care about me. That you love me."
"I love you, too, Sam... Dad. I hope... I don't know what I'm doing, and I don't know who I can trust besides you and Castiel, but... I hope one day I can make you proud."
"Jack..." Sam sighed, dragging his eyes open as he turned his head to look up at his son. "...you do make me proud... every day."
"Dad!" Tears spilled over Jack's cheeks and he slumped forwards over the bed and Sam's chest, shoulders shaking with sobs.
"It's okay, Jack," Sam murmured, dragging one weighted hand up to rest on his son's back. "It's okay, let it out... It's all going to be okay."