Review: The Sister Surprise by Abigail Mann
Last year, I read and adored Abigail Mann’s debut rom-com The Lonely Fajita, so I was delighted when the wonderful people at One More Chapter invited me to read her follow-up. I was involved in the cover reveal for this book months ago and I’m happy to say that the story inside is just as cute as its appearance.
When Ava finds out the results of an ancestry test live on social media and promptly vomits all over the studio, she takes it as a sign that she should probably get away from her life as a journalist in London for a while. Tasked with an assignment while there, she makes her way to the Scottish village of Kilroch to find Moira, the half sister that she has only just discovered exists. Staying on a farm that is in danger of financial ruin, Ava learns both the basics of rural living as well as some long buried secrets about the father she never knew.
Although at first glance, the communities of Dulwich in South London and Kilroch may seem worlds apart, there are some very strong similarities -primarily in the way that news and gossip travels fast. The people of Kilroch are very interested in Ava as soon as she arrives and this is very typical of small town life. In fact, I think the author depicted the atmosphere of a tiny, self-serving community perfectly. Once I was in Kilroch, it really did feel like I was a whole world away from anywhere else.
As a farm volunteer who knows absolutely nothing about the reality of farms, Ava has a few hilarious ordeals while running her first errands. The rather harried, patient Kian, who has inherited the farm from his ailing grandfather, talks about the animals as if they’re his children and this leads to some rather funny lines from him that Ava misunderstands at first. Their friendship is really wonderful to watch!
Ava is a very socially awkward, anxious protagonist and I’m pretty sure that means she’ll resonate with a lot of readers. Kilroch is blessed to be temporarily hosting an extremely handsome young minister named Ross, who takes a shine to Ava, much to the dismay of the other women in the village. I knew that as soon as Ava set her sights on the most sought-after man in the village for her love interest that I’d be in for some cringeworthy flirting and hilarious mishaps. When the chapter of their first date rolled around, my suspicions were confirmed!
Moira turns out to be an old family friend of Kian’s family and it transpires that she has been in love with Kian forever. She and Ava become fast friends a long time before Moira discovers the truth. I understood Ava’s reasons for holding it back for so long but I can’t pretend that I didn’t get hugely frustrated with her for not just coming out and saying it. Instead, Moira found out in the worst way possible.
Moira is a fantastic character who has big dreams but is afraid of leaving her mum and life in Kilroch. She is smart, sassy and apparently incredibly understanding because it doesn’t take her too long to forgive Ava for not telling her the truth sooner. I think this was the only part of the book where I wasn’t quite sure if this matched up with the probable reality. I would have liked to see Moira resist a little more to Ava’s attempts to apologise, therefore creating a bit of tension between them. But I am also happy enough to take this as a thoroughly light-hearted, joyous read!
Passages like this make me want to pack up my things and never go anywhere near a city again. The slow pace and tranquil atmosphere surrounding Kilroch makes it seem like some kind of pocket of serenity that is the perfect place to disappear. Knowing that there are places like this in the world causes the ending of the book to make so much sense to me.
The Sister Surprise is a funny, cute story about discovering the roots and finding where you truly belong. There is also a romance element, so I guess it could be considered to be a rom-com. However, the focus is on Ava and Moira coming to terms with a truth they should have known long ago and realising that they don’t need to let the past hold them back. It’s a wonderful, smile-inducing novel that you can escape safely into.