genuine question here. you say that jewish people don't have to support the political choices of the israeli state, and that jewish people don't owe any sort of stance on the israeli state because the actions of it ≠ the actions of all jewish people. right? but then, you reblog posts with any genuine criticism of israel from a political standpoint as antisemitic, even ones made by jewish people. so im confused. is just criticising israel inherently antisemitic? because that's what Ive gathered from your posts. and why is it inherently antisemitic to criticize israel but its not inherently racist to criticize palestine? would those not be equivalent?
Apologies for the delay. I don't check this inbox often for reasons that are probably obvious.
First, let's get this out of the way: I don't and never plan to post about Israel on this blog when it's not related to antisemitism. This blog is called "examples of antisemitism," not "examples of reasoned critiques of Israel." If you want to learn about and discuss Israel, the Israeli government, or Israel's interactions with other countries and peoples, there are other places to do that.
I also don't think I've directly stated any opinion along the line of "jewish people don't have to support the political choices of the israeli state, and that jewish people don't owe any sort of stance on the israeli state because the actions of it ≠ the actions of all jewish people" on this blog, other than to say it's antisemitic to demand that random Jews express any opinion on Israel. That's because, again, this blog is not about Israel. It's also not about Judaism, Jewish beliefs, or what it means to be a Jew.
It's about documenting examples of antisemitism.
There are good reasons to criticize Israel
But it's antisemitic when it invokes antisemitic tropes
Using antisemitic tropes or antisemitic arguments does not become non-antisemitic when one uses them "for a good reason"
Sometimes people mix reasoned argument with antisemitism. If they say 99 words that aren't antisemitic and one word that is, the post is still antisemitic.
Sometimes people aren't trying to be antisemitic, but they live in a culture where antisemitism is rampant and have unconsciously picked up antisemitic language and views. That language and those views are antisemitic, even if the person is unaware of it.
Jews and people with Jewish ancestry can engage in antisemitism (often for the above reason, sometimes for other reasons: https://youtu.be/0TUHvVvIrck?si=-EpNPVYgOtcjll9u)
Palestinians can also engage in antisemitism. If they do, they might end up on this blog, which, again, is called "examples of antisemitism."
If you can't identify the antisemitic tropes in criticisms of Israel that I reblog, even after reading my explanations, tags, pinned posts, or explanations in the reblog chain, that's likely a you problem, not a me problem. You either aren't reading the post and criticism carefully, or you are choosing to classify the things identified as antisemitism as "not really antisemitic because [whatever reason comforts you]." While I can make mistakes like anyone, I'm not going out of my way to find antisemitism in things, and if I'm not sure something qualifies as clearly antisemitic or containing antisemitism, I don't reblog it here.
If you honestly don't see what's antisemitic about a post I reblog here even after reading the tags etc and thinking about them, you can always send me an ask about that specific post. I probably won't answer quickly, but I will eventually (barring unforeseen death).