Could Ali be A?
2x25:
Mona “I know they’re watching me. I don’t look bad, concidering. I like this lip stick. What’s it called? Toffee Tango. They think it’s over (changing voice to Shana’s(?)) loser Mona is going to the nut house, and those precious liars are going home to sleep with their windows open and their doors unlocked. Don’t they know that’s what we want?”
Why Alison might be A
This was before she was talking to Cece about the A game. Mona was obviously playing with someone else. Someone who was ready to lead the game, because it was obvious that Mona planned to be caught. She had already organized for someone to clean out her lair at the Lost Woods Resort, bacause she had all her things in the RV when she snuck out of Radley. However, I don’t think Mona knew who she was working with, since she said in 3x24 that she was never going to know who she was.
6x10:
Cece is telling Alison about how she got to know Mona. She used to sneak into her room for story-time (Mona telling her all about the game). So that means that Cece did not need a visitors pass, like the one found in the Children’s Ward. Cece said that “She was so out of it, she thought I was you” and then right away we see the flashback of Mona getting visited by Red Coat, only now it changed to Cece wearing a red robe. Mona said to her “I did everything you asked me to”. So, apparently, Mona thought this was Alison. That means that Alison was giving orders to Mona. Was it orders on how to play the A game? Maybe. In that case, Ali is Uber A.
In addition: Cece said Mona gave her a way in and out of Radley - Mona said Cece gave her a way in and out of Radley. I think they are both wrong. Uber A gave them that. Alison did.
Also; it seems like Alison planned to fake her death, before Cece hit her over the head. She had money hidden all over. Bethany was wearing the Alison bracelet when she was found dead, Alison took off hers at the Lost Woods the next day, and left it with Mona. Alison’s dental records were switched out. Who would have a motive for this? Mona thought she had killed Alison, Cece and Jessica thought Alison was dead. So who knew Alison was alive and wanted to keep that a secret? Mona, Shana, Cece and Alison. Shana and Cece was pretending to be on Alison’s side, maybe Mona was too. So it all leads back to this being Alison’s wish.
Also, how was Alison able to watch the girls, and know what they went through? Shana didn’t know Alison was alive until Mona went to Radley. Cece didn’t figure out that Ali was alive until 3x24. The only persons who knew she was alive was Mona, Cyrus, Grunwald and probably a lot of people who didn’t know who she was. Cyrus didn’t enter Rosewood, as far as we know, until season 5. Grunwald was in Ravenswood. Mona probably told Alison about some of it, but Mona didn’t want Alison in Rosewood, so I bet she left out many things that happened. I think Ali had her own lair, watching the girls.
We all know how good Alison is at getting money, blackmailing people. This could be how she could afford cameras and other things to watch her friends.
And don’t forget about the time that Alison hired Noel to pretend to be A, reaking into the Marin home. She made him wear the iconic black hoodie.
Season 6B starts with Alison telling her friends to come back to Rosewood, and she convinces them to lie to a judge to get Cece out. Cece is killed the same night as she gets out. Holding a flower from Alison’s house. Could be a hint hiding in plain sight. Immediately the police are on to the liars. Aria is looking very suspicious because she left the hotel in the middle of the night, at the time Cece died.
I don’t buy that Alison has changed so much, and cares so much about her sister, who tortured her friends for years. I think she’s mad at her friends for some reason, and has been for years and years. Being A is the ultimate way to get revenge over them.
Doing a rewatch, so I will update if I find more clues. Can’t remember everything know.
I keep changing my mind between wanting Alison, Ezra, Wren and Wilden to be Uber A. For Wilden to e A, he has to be the one with a twin, and the twin is dead. I highly daubt that, though. Also because in the last scene of 6x10, the girls are warning Alison that “he” is there, implying that Uber A is a man. Maybe it is.
EDIT:
1x12
Hanna remembers a party they all went to with Alison. Ali broke up Noel and his girlfriend, saying she did it for Aria. Then Ali says “I only kill when I need food. Or when I’m bored”. Well, has she killed for real? May be a forshaddowing her killing her mother?
Emily is trapped inside a barn or something with a car running. She passes out, and wakes up in Alison’s lap. I don’t know if Ali really was there or not, but if she was, the conversation she and Ali had was interesting.
Em: Do you know who A is?
Ali: Of course I do.
Em: You have to tell me.
Ali:I don’t think that’s a good idea.
Em: Why?
Ali: Because to can only keep a secret if one of them is dead.
Ali said she knew who A was. At this time, Mona was A, as far as we know. But if Ali knew that, she would have stopped Mona. Maybe Ali knew because she herself is A.
If Ali’s not A, I think she gave Mona orders to figure out if one of the liars were A, and that’s how Mona started her game again, after Ali was out of Rosewood.
Photo disclaimer, got them from google.














