Review: Sugar — Bernice L. McFadden
Okay, first of all, hell of a opener. Considering this last book I read yada main character called Jude, the first line being “Jude was dead” was a kick in the head let me tell you.
The first 12 pages of this book are difficult read, and to be honest I very nearly put the book down. It goes into gruesome detail of the death and mutilation of a child. None of these details are essential to the rest of the book, so if you are (understandably) put off by this, I would recommend skipping to page 13. There is still some detail into a character’s sexual abuse throughout the book, but don’t expect nearly as much gory detail as there is in the first chapter. Oddly, the prose also seems to change after the first chapter, as well. In the beginning it’s very detailed, very flowery as a writer might say, but after around page 13 the book changes to a simpler, more breezy kind of prose.
It was so refreshing to finally read a book starring black characters that didn’t revolve around white people in any way. Obviously stories about slavery and racism are important, but it’s good to know we have stories out there where the characters can just be black, and have the same cares, fears, loves, and losses as anyone else, without oppression or whiteness being essential to their stories.
The book features two very different protagonists, both flawed but likeable and easy to cheer for, both a good mix of strength and vulnerability. Throughout most of the booked, I was hooked by the blossoming friendship between these two women, and although it was a more character-driven than plot-driven book, the plot itself kept me on the edge, both excited and fearful about what would happen next.
However, even though it seemed like it was heading to a satisfying place, I was disappointed by the ending. Spoilers for the end of the book: I understand this is a book dealing with many heavy topics. The death of a child, sex work in the 60’s, lost family. But I thought the ending was unnecessarily brutal. I’m not against a sad ending, but the last time you the two protagonists one is packing up to go after being essentially run out of town and the other is a sweet old lady screaming in grief over the loss of her child. It left me with a bad taste in my mouth, and honestly, even this ending would have worked if McFadden had ended Pearl’s story on anything other than the most brutal moment of her life. Although I suppose it’s fitting that this book ended the way it began - making the reader extremely uncomfortable. Maybe that was the whole point.
Sugar is set in the 60’s, and does use a moderate amount of 60’s prose, so I would be careful when reading the dialogue, something I always recommend when talking about a book where the characters speak in a dialect. I would rate this book to be Intermediate Level English, and the prose itself doesn’t use any archaic words or expression.
I gave this warning in my review of The Vanishing Half, but I’ll repeat it here now: if you are not black, do not repeat the slurs used in this book. [Give picture examples.] Racial slurs are extremely offensive (I’m sure this is true of any language) and are not in any way socially acceptable. Not only are they hurtful and rude but they are a massive cultural taboo, and you can get in a lot of trouble by repeating them. Please be careful not to repeat any of the offensive words used in this book.