#arridaeus

[myidic]

Alexander having a close, protective relationship with Arridaeus is Occam’s Razor. It’s the most psychologically coherent read I can come up with, and it makes later actions explain themselves. Desperately want opinions on this.

[myidic]

This has been living in my head the last few hours, I had to get it out, so here. You can have my riff. This is basically fanfiction, so enjoy.

**

Alexander’s chamber had settled into evening. The brazier took the chill out of the air, and the lamplight glowed on the painted walls. After the meal, the four of them had pulled nearly every pillow in the room into a loose heap across the floor.

Leonnatus had claimed the highest part of it and lounged there like a victorious general, tossing a carved knucklebone into the air and catching it again while he talked. Hephaestion sat nearby with a scroll open across his lap, though he had not shifted it in some time.

Alexander lay on his side with his chin propped on his hand, listening with half his attention as Leonnatus described a groom who had nearly been kicked across the yard that afternoon.

Leonnatus spread his arms wide, reenacting the moment with enormous dignity. “And then the fool looks straight up at the sky and says, ‘Clearly the gods oppose me today.’”

Alexander snorted aloud at that. Hephaestion’s mouth twitched though he kept his eyes on the scroll.

Leonnatus tossed the knucklebone once more, caught it neatly, and shook his head. “Not that the horse kicked him because he grabbed its ear like a drunk barber. No. Divine intervention.”

The knock at the door cut across the room and drew all three of their heads up at once.

Alexander called for whoever it was to come in, expecting a servant or a message. Instead Arridaeus stepped through the doorway. The sight of him made Alexander push himself upright immediately.

“Arri? Is everything alright?”

Arridaeus closed the door behind him and walked a few steps into the room before dropping onto the edge of the pillows.

“Father spoke to me.”

Alexander’s chest tightened slightly, bracing himself for the news, but he said nothing.

“He says I’m to be married.”

Alexander went still. Marriage. Alliance. Heirs. A chill ran through him before he forced his shoulders to loosen.

Arridaeus scrubbed both hands down his face in frustration.

“Alex,” he said, voice thick with exasperation, “what in the world am I supposed to do with a wife?”

Leonnatus inhaled sharply. “Arri,” he began, delighted, “I can explain exactly what you do with a wi—”

A pillow struck him square in the face.

“Shut up,” Alexander hissed.

Leonnatus shoved it away, laughing.

Alexander rubbed the back of his neck and glanced briefly at Hephaestion and shrugged before answering.

“Arri… wives are for… treaties. Alliances…children.”

“Children?”

“Heirs.”

Arridaeus frowned. “Children… how—”

He stopped, and his eyes widened. Color flooded his face. “Oh.”

Leonnatus made a strangled sound.

Alexander pointed a pillow at him. “Leon.”

“I am silent,” Leonnatus said immediately.

Arridaeus looked back at Alexander with mounting frustration.

“Alex. Have you ever?”

Leonnatus burst into laughter. “Arri,” he wheezed, “Alexander is the wrong person to ask.”

Alexander grabbed another pillow. “Leon, I swear—”

Leonnatus waved a lazy hand. “Come on. Everyone knows you prefer Hephaestion’s…”

He paused, abandoning the word he had started with.

“…company…”

Another pause.

“…to that of women.”

The pillow hit him again.

“Finish that thought and I will throw you out the window,” Alexander said.

Leonnatus spat feathers and grinned.

Alexander folded his arms. “I know how it’s done.”

“Oh?” Leonnatus said brightly. “Did Hephaestion explain it while you were kneeling… for instruction?”

Alexander punched him hard in the arm.

“Gods, Alex!”

“We’ve all heard the soldiers talk,” Alexander said sharply. “Besides, Hephaestion has no more experience with women than I do.”

Hephaestion rolled the scroll closed with a quiet sigh. “That is enough.”

He looked at Arridaeus.

“No, Arri. Neither Alexander nor I have been with women.”

Arridaeus nodded slowly.

“But I have been with someone,” Hephaestion added.

Arridaeus frowned. He looked at Hephaestion, then slowly turned his head toward Alexander. Understanding dawned.

“Oh. With Alex?”

Alexander went bright red.

“How does that work?”

Leonnatus collapsed backward into the pillows, laughing so hard he nearly choked. “Yeah, Alex,” he wheezed. “How does it work?

Alexander threw another pillow at him.

Arridaeus watched them both for a moment before turning back to Leonnatus with renewed interest.

“Leon,” he said, “have you been with a woman?”

Alexander and Hephaestion both looked at him immediately.

Leonnatus froze.

Alexander leaned forward slightly. “Well?” he prompted.

Hephaestion watched with quiet interest.

Leonnatus shifted under their attention and groaned. “I regret beginning this conversation.”

[myidic]

Okay, instead of editing, I’m thinking through the sequence of events leading up from the Pixodarus affair to Philip’s assassination, and how tightly connected the events are. Now, the sequence as the sources lay it out only really makes sense to me if you begin from one assumption: Arrhidaeus exists under Alexander’s protection. Given that, this is the way I interpret the story.

We begin here: Arrhidaeus cannot easily advocate for himself in the environment he lives in. The Macedonian court is not a forgiving place. It runs on alliances, rivalries, manipulation, and constant political maneuvering, and Arrhidaeus is not someone who moves comfortably inside that system. If a situation becomes complicated or dangerous, someone else has to step in and speak where he cannot. In the dynamic I keep coming back to, that role falls to Alexander. Once that relationship is in place, the Pixodarus proposal looks very different.

So, Pixodarus offers his daughter in marriage to Arrhidaeus. From Philip’s perspective the idea is entirely practical. Even though Alexander prove him wrong later, Philip feels that Arrhidaeus cannot accompany the army into Asia, and a royal son who remains indefinitely at the center of the court becomes a complication that eventually has to be managed. Marriage alliances are one of the standard ways kings solve that kind of problem. A satrap’s daughter creates a diplomatic bond and at the same time places Arrhidaeus somewhere politically stable. From Philip’s point of view it is a neat solution.

From Alexander’s point of view, however, it looks like something else entirely. If Arrhidaeus is someone he feels responsible for protecting, then the proposal reads less like strategy and more like taking away a vulnerable person from somewhere he’s protected and dropping him into a court where he will be expected to navigate pressures he cannot safely handle. At that point the conflict becomes inevitable.

Philip believes he is making a sensible dynastic decision. Alexander believes he is preventing someone who cannot defend himself from being used as a political instrument. The two men are no longer arguing about the same thing, which is why the disagreement escalates so quickly. Philip is defending royal authority and diplomatic logic, while Alexander is defending a person he believes is his responsibility.

Eventually the conflict reaches the point where it stops being about Arrhidaeus at all. What Philip cannot tolerate is the precedent of an heir interfering with the king’s decisions. When that line is crossed the argument shifts into the territory every monarchy understands too well, where the question becomes obedience rather than policy.

Philip makes it clear where the line is. He is the king. He decides what happens to his sons, to his alliances, and to the future of the throne. If Alexander wants the crown that Philip has built, then he will stop interfering and allow the marriage to proceed.

Alexander does not step back. Instead he blows the entire arrangement apart. He sends word to Pixodarus offering himself as the groom, turning the negotiation upside down and publicly undercutting the plan Philip has just put in motion. What had been a political calculation suddenly becomes a direct challenge to the king’s authority.

Philip’s reaction is immediate and furious. The companions who helped Alexander interfere are exile as punishment, because tearing them away punishes Alexander and dismantles the small circle that had helped him shield Arrhidaeus from being used this way. Arrhidaeus himself is left standing in the middle of the wreckage of the argument between father and brother.

And Philip is not finished. He immediately goes out and marries Eurydice, a young Macedonian bride, niece of Attalus, celebrated loudly before the entire court. It is a spectacle, a declaration, a reminder to everyone watching that Philip is still king and perfectly capable of producing another heir if he chooses. The message is unmistakable.

When Attalus later stands at the wedding feast and prays for a “legitimate heir,” the words land like a thrown spear. Everyone in the room understands what has just been said and why. The private war between father and son finally erupts in public. Cups fly. Philip lunges. The court fractures.

Alexander leaves Macedon soon afterward, and for a time the rift between father and son appears complete. But, the political realities surrounding them never disappear. The Persian campaign is approaching, and Macedon still requires a recognized successor. Eventually those pressures force a reconciliation, whether either man truly wants it or not. Alexander returns, the royal household attempts to restore stability, and the kingdom prepares to present a united front.

The sequence ends at Aegae with a royal wedding meant to project strength and continuity to the outside world, and within days, that wedding turns into a funeral.

[myidic]

Arridaeus, Alexander’s brother, is such an interesting character.

The popular story from the ancient sources is that Olympias poisoned him as a child and caused the mental impairment he later lived with. That explanation shows up a lot in the literature, but accusations like that were also one of the most common ways ancient historians attacked powerful women. Queens were easy targets for slander, especially when succession politics were involved.

A much more plausible explanation is something far less dramatic. Childhood illnesses in the ancient world could easily cause permanent neurological damage, especially if high fevers were involved. Something like meningitis, measles, or another infection could permanently change a child’s development. Arridaeus’s mother, Philinna of Larissa, also died fairly early, and it is entirely possible the same illness took her.

If that is the case, then the palace suddenly has a boy who is slower than the others, a child who had likely once been bright, the same age as Alexander and very possibly a playmate before the illness changed things, now without the one person who would have naturally protected him.

Philip is usually on campaign. Olympias has absolutely no reason to emotionally invest in another woman’s son, especially a damaged one who complicates dynastic politics.

Which means Arridaeus is growing up alone and abandoned in a court environment that values strength, brilliance, and political usefulness above almost everything else.

Except that there’s another boy the same age growing up beside him: Alexander. Alexander, who sources repeatedly show was fond of Arridaeus.

If Alexander decides Arridaeus belongs with him, that changes everything. A prince deciding someone is under his protection carries enormous social weight in a royal court. The other boys around Alexander, the ones who would later become the Companions, learn very early that if Alexander defends someone, they defend him too.

So Arridaeus does not simply become “Philip’s impaired son.” He becomes the brother inside Alexander’s circle. Safe within the orbit of the same boys who grow up beside them: the friends who learn to close ranks when someone from the outside pushes too hard.

Once you start looking at their relationship that way, some later historical events suddenly look very different.

Take the Pixodarus affair.

The traditional interpretation is that Alexander panicked because Philip planned to marry Arridaeus into the Carian royal house, which might signal a succession problem. But Arridaeus’s impairment was already well known. It is difficult to imagine Philip seriously positioning him over Alexander as heir.

What that marriage would have done, however, is remove Arridaeus from Macedon and drop him into a foreign court full of political sharks.

A vulnerable prince suddenly becomes an extremely useful pawn.

If Arridaeus had grown up inside Alexander’s protected circle, that situation would not just look like a diplomatic marriage alliance. It would look like someone ripping Arridaeus out of the only environment where he was safe. Away frm Alexander.

Alexander secretly offering himself as the groom instead suddenly reads less like ambition and more like intervention.

Philip’s reaction is explosive. Several of Alexander’s closest companions are exiled from court, Harpalus famously among them. The very young men who had likely spent their childhood acting as part of Arridaeus’s protective shield suddenly find themselves driven away.

Which makes the entire episode feel less like a succession panic and more like the moment those shields are stripped away. A group of fiercely loyal young men try, and fail, to stop someone from taking one of their own.

And a two years later when he becomes king, he does not eliminate Arridaeus, even though removing rival claimants was extremely common practice. He does not quietly sideline him or send him somewhere distant. Instead he keeps him nearby and even brings him along on campaign.

Seen through this lens, that pattern makes perfect sense.

Arridaeus stays where Alexander can keep him inside the circle that has always protected him.