@artykyn replied to your post:
Wow I just watched Fantastic Beasts and wow that...
What didn’t you like? :(
Spoilers for Fantastic Beasts if anyone cares
Technical Issues:
Multiple instances of poor or no lighting on characters’s faces during dialog scenes.
Sloppy cinematography that is completely disinterested with the story
Expecting us to be wowed by 100% CGI scenes and creatures we have no emotional attachment to
The visual design of the Obscurus is incredibly lazy and derivative
Character Issues:
They’re really boring?
Like really, they hardly show any emotion besides at peak stress levels and have such thin characterization to go off of.
Jacob’s character feels so pointless, he mostly just wonders around in awe and enjoys the ride and makes no lasting impact on the story
The romance between Jacob and Queenie feels completely forced and unnecessary.
We really need to be told more about Grindelwald and what his deal is
Newt is a hard-to-understand, bumbling exposition machine and he’s not interesting to watch
Thematic and Other Issues:
The movie shows the psychological damage of a child living in an abusive household, but has zero compassion for him even as it is the precipitating event that leads to the climax of the film.
MACUSA is a horrifyingly cruel and indefensible organization (complete judicial failure, clinic executions, child murder under the guise of “following the rules”), but helping maintain the status quo and forgetting about the child they just executed is played as a happy ending because all the animals got back in the suitcase and i guess this is just the way the world works. Tina is happy to go back and work for them.
Unnecessarily dark. The creepy witchhunt cult, the child abuse, the execution chamber, the child murder, the complete lack of humor.
Grindelwald’s appearance playing into the queer-coding villain trope, which goes along with the whole franchise’s terrible track-record with queer representation.
The Deus Ex Machina of AoE obliviate + repair everything to instantly erase all consequences of any actions feels so narratively cheap, no matter how much visual spectacle and emotional musical swell they put behind it.
Poor narrative focus: too many plotlines that don’t convincingly tie into each other.
Overall there’s a lot of injustice shown in the film : child abuse, failed judicial system, magical segregation. But there is no one fighting against that injustice in any meaningful way, which would’ve made a much stronger core narrative.
I’m sure this isn’t everything, but it’s late and I want to get my thoughts down while they’re fresh. To me, that movie was cringe-worthy, morally bankrupt garbage.
@therisingtithes












