hi! since you seem to know more about the japanese side of the touhou fandom, i wanted to ask about something... there seems to be a big difference in how the japanese fandom portrays marisa and how the western fandom portrays her? i was wondering if this is an actual thing or if i've just seen too much of certain artists on either side of the fandom.
Hmm… I think there is a difference, based on what I’ve seen. (Huge generalisations time!) Basically, western fandom Marisa is the Marisa we see in IN’s magic team route: silly, somewhat irresponsible, doesn’t take things seriously, about to blow herself up in a wild experiment and Alice is the only one who can talk her out of it etc. It makes sense, considering MariAli is the big popular ship in the west, and the western fandom generally prefers the cute and silly side of Touhou, but I’ve seen her characterised like that in serious stories too. This Marisa is pretty fun to write, so I can see the appeal.
The Japanese fandom has a huge range of fanworks spanning well over a decade so I’m going to stick to what I’ve seen recently. The Marisa I usually see in doujinshi is a more serious version of the Marisa we see in the print works: she’s had a troubled childhood, struggles to keep up with Reimu and does everything she can to get stronger, sometimes dropping dead in the process. In recent stuff, she tries to become a youkai magician and has the inevitable tragic showdown with Reimu.
…But I suspect this reflects my taste in touhou doujinshi more than anything! I like my fanworks full of pain and suffering so that’s what I mostly read. It’s not all doom and gloom, I swear! But I think the Japanese love to think about her ‘omote’ (front) and ‘ura’ (back) sides a lot more than the Western side. ‘Omote’ is the side you show to people in public, and ‘ura’ is how you actually are; in private or with close family and friends. Marisa’s ‘omote’ is her carefree, jokey side, and her ‘ura’ is her studious, serious side who left her family to live in a forest full of dangerous youkai and experiments with hallucinogenic mushrooms.
I’ve seen a few Japanese creators depict Marisa as someone with a limited range of emotions, or empathy issues. Bizarrely enough, Akyuu seems to be one of those people: her real person fanfic about Marisa in AFiEU (everyone please read it!) depicts her as very… relaxed about all her friends getting murdered, and that ending…! Yes. Good.
God I wrote an essay… anyway the short version is, you can find lots of different Marisas in the Japanese fandom, and a lot of them are similar to how she is in recent canon. But I think you can only find one or two Marisas in the west, and she’s usually similar to early canon. In my experience.