OK so as we know their are multiple realms, Wish-realm, and all the others.
Just take a minute to image that for some reason a version of Baefire who took the dark one dagger instead of his father shows up in Storybooke. The emotional damage. On everyone's side.
This post will be long... you have been warned. Proceed with your own caution.
Maybe Bae lost his dad when rumple tried to take Bae to a land without magic, maybe Dark one Bae killed his father and now that their is a Dark One version of his dad he tries to kill that one too. Or he is super-hyped about doing evil together with his dark one father.
I do imagine that Bae also knows Belle because in his universe he also... traded? bought? her. And she became a mother figure to her and now he is in this strange town, with his dead Dark one father and his mother figure being together. Oh and his duplicate had a son, with the Savior, oh and said son is adopted by the evil queen who he hates.
Imagine telling Emma that a different version of the father of her child, now has shown up and he is the Dark One, oh and also looks like 14 but is like 300.
Would he care for Henry? Would he try to parent Henry? Would they be like brothers? I Imagine Bae taking one look at Henry and being like... You are so weak. I will teach you magic, this isn't love I just dont want you to be a burden, not that some idiot thinks he can just kidnap you to get to me. I see Bae caring for this strange kid.
let me just write down my thoughts on every season.
1S Idk really, I think everything is a good option for him, just because he will hate whatever situation he ends up being in. If thats being the kid of anyone, may it be David, Mary Margret, Regina, actually, I see him either being Archie's kid, or him being Rubies younger brother.
Whatever you do. Never forget, that Gold will suffer the ultimate emotional damage. Because he sees his Bae, always out of reach. Gold definitely would be trying to reach out to Bae and and it would be weird every time.
And than, at the end of S1 Gold would kiddnap Bae to be with him and Belle when the curse breaks only for the curse to break and Bae immideatly being like, WTF, you are dead. And gold just being confused. I see Gold being heartbroken after he realizes that the kid he thought for months which was his, is, but is a different version form another realm. And hates him with passion. Oh and also is the Dark One of his realm. upps.
S2 kill Regina (because of the you kidnapped my pseudo mother, and my version of you probably did the same in my realm but i cant get her rn so I will just slaughter you.) kill Cora not because of a romantic past (eternal 14 year old), but definitely something, being mad at gold, having an arc with Henry, passive aggressively hating the Charmings who are trying to parent him. (HE IS 300 he is very mature...) I see him going with to New York to meet his other version and than being like. OH NO THE FAMILY TREE! And immiditly establishing that he is older than Neal. I cant get over how much i Love the hypothetical relationship between the 2 Baefires. I just see dark Bae judging Neal for being magic-less and weak while Neal pities Dark Bae for being the Dark one.
S3 I am conflicted on making this version of Bae friends with his version of peter pan because just doenst know and Bae is an immortal kid. But regardless Pan kidnapped his... halfson? So off to kill the immortal trickster devil he goes.
S3b... so I see Regina kinda try to parent him in S3 and onward. Look he is an eternal 14 year old hanging out with her son, I just see Regina's motherly instincts kicking in without her really meaning too. I see Bae just not realizing that that is what she is doing. I also see him Trying to kill zelena after the... Neal business and zelena commanding rumple to kill Dark Bae.
S4a I see him not caring for the frozen arc. Just really not being interested. He and Henry have their own solo arc in this one, where Bae and Henry search for the author and Bae teaches Henry some more magic. Just bonding about their weird bond.
S4b I see him joining the Villain side. Only for Gold to have Isac make Bae either Neal. Just same person for gold. Or have Dark Bae be Neals twin. in both cases he would hate it once he wakes up because of course Henry would go to him. Dark Bae probably would try to kill gold again for this.
S5a. Also what does this mean for the entire Excalibur business?! Are baes dagger and the sword just not compatible because different versions or can you just forge idk mega Excalibur now.
Is he fighting Dark one Emma during the Dark swan arc because she wants to destroy all Darkness which is his power. At the Mention of S5 does he also loose his power? Or do we see him still having his powers and toying with his powerless father. Or is he actually supporting him?
Imagine Merlin finding out.
I do also see Dark Bae trying to form a rift between Gold and Belle, because thats his mum. And he doesn't want Gold to have nice things.
S5B, just the normal Season but with him in it. I dont really have anything else here. Other than him being on Belles side and trying to kill Gold again to protect Belle.
S6 is and its just about Dark Bae trying to protect Belle and baby Gideon form his dad. Who he hates. And when Gideon gets taken by the Dark Fairy Bae is like, "Bitch, its on time for war" and Fiona just being extetic about having another perfect DARK Grandchild.
S7 I do see him ending up with Rumple and Belle traveling together, and than living together. I do see him being their when Belle dies, just really really sad and angry. And probably also fully reverting back into evil scaly lizard. Just being his dark one self. I do see him kidnap children to not be alone anymore only for Henry to find him like that in the enchanted forest. I do see Bae and Henry making a Deal saying that if Bae lets all the boys go Henry promises that Bae can always be with him by his side. And weird relationship goes on. Where Henry now parents his half-father who is a little insane.
And honestly, I just see him being in a foster situation with Henry. Just Henry taking care of the alternative version of his dad. Who is 14 and has been for 300 years.
Also Dark Bae and Alice? Just the best neurodivergent friends ever. Not in a romantic way. This version of Bae is 100% acearo.
I dont see him dying. I do see him either living alone at Golds old house and working in the pawnshop or him moving in with Regina.
All over I must say this is a very fun idea. And I would totally read a 100k fic off this. If you want to know more about this idea or anything inperticlar. My ask box is always open.













