masterlist
ollie reeder
1 • ollie fucks bunny reader at the office halloween party
2 • boss ollie x shy reader
3 • reader falls asleep in ollie’s office
4 • ollie fucks reader’s anxiety away
gerard way
1 • gee comforts shy reader in interview & f!ngers her in the car afterwards!!
2 • gerard babys you and your anxious state after you watch him beat someone to a pulp
3 • gerard pulls overstimulated reader into spare room, fucking her to make it all better
4 • “daddy’s good girl”
5 • tired, sweetheart?
6 • good puppy
7 • gee comforts reader because she got overwhelmed after he spanked her.
8 • gerard discovers his sleepy puppy melts completely when he scratches behind her ear while smoking with ray.
9 • gee lets puppy reader drink for the first time, he deals with her hazy, anxious state.
10 • puppy waits by the door for gee to come home, clinging to his comfort when he comes back!!
11 • gerard fucks reader rough against the wall
12 • gee massages readers head to relax her for her speech tomorrow
13 • gerard makes puppy ride him to calm her anxiety, comforts her in the bath after!!
14 • puppy surprises gee with a new cute little outfit she bought and he can't keep his hands off of her!
15 • reader makes a shy attempt at being bratty after an argument, gerard soon resolves it for her.
16 • gerard comforts puppy after she has a bad dream about losing him :(
17 • puppy doesnt know how to tell gee she wants sex, he makes her say it.
18 • gee finds out about readers self-harm
19 • frank babysits puppy while gerard is away, (gerard comes back later and comforts her)
20 • how gerard + reader first met ♡
21 • threesome with dom gerard, dom andy biersack and puppy reader!!
22 • timid puppy reader meets gerards friends!
23 • gee surprises reader with ears and tail just for fun, he makes them try them on and he gets wayyy to excited about it...
24 • reader is fingerfucked by andy while he and gerard hold her open and tickle her!
25 • gerard reminds puppy reader who she belongs to after some random tries to flirt with her
26 • fem gerard fucks her poor puppy
27 • gerard lets his sleepy girl suckle on his cock to fall asleep.
28 • gerard and frank roughly overstimulate their shy puppy girl, then give her gentle aftercare
29 • sweet little camp counsellor reader gets fucked by killer gerard
30 • gee comforts depressed puppy!reader
31 • gerard breeds puppy
32 • how gerard would react to puppy!reader being pregnant
33 • gerard teases shy!reader with a feather from her angel costume
34 • monster sub gee is soo needy he pounces on reader and fucks her with his tentacles
35 • dom!gerard edges puppy!reader with sex toys
36 • crybaby!reader has a teeny breakdown after being woken up in the backseat of ray’s car with gerard and frank, they all comfort their sweet girl.
37 • olderbf!gerard spoils puppy!reader, but also punishes her.
38 • older!bf gerard punishes shy!reader affer catching her watching porn, teasing her for her masochism.
39 • older dom fem!gerard pounds shy, sweet reader
frank iero
1 • reader has an oral fixation and your boyfriend frank soothes it with a pacifier he bought you ♡
2 • frank babysits puppy while gerard is away, (gerard comes back later and comforts her)
3 • owner!frank gets too rough with puppy
4 • frank and gerard roughly overstimulate their shy puppy girl, then give her gentle aftercare
5 • crybaby!reader has a teeny breakdown after being woken up in the backseat of ray’s car with gerard and frank, they all comfort their sweet girl.
6 • shy!reader asks dom!frank to slap her in public to calm her tiredness/anxiety.
7 • older!frank comes across shy!reader in the midst of an apocalypse
andy biersack
1 • timid reader cant handle her first drink, panicking that shes lost andy, he comes over and comforts her cute drunken state.
2 • reader gets clingy when andy smokes, he comforts her after finding out why!
3 • threesome with dom andy , dom gerard way and puppy reader!!
4 • reader is fingerfucked by andy while he and gerard hold her open and tickle her!
5 • andy makes shy!reader cockwarm him for an hour, making her cry wantonly, before punish fucking her!
6 • andy makes bunny hold her pee
7 • sugardaddy!andy fucks his little bunny ♡
8 • andy brat tames & fucks bunny!reader
9 • bunny gives andy a bj to cheer him up
ray toro
1 • ray gently reins in his shy girl’s playful misbehaviour.
2 • bsf!ray comforts shy reader after her bf broke up with her!!
3 • crybaby!reader has a teeny breakdown after being woken up in the backseat of ray’s car with gerard and frank, they all comfort their sweet girl.
4 • dom!ray comforting reader on her period
