@odearjohn @beatlesfan2000posts @stewy @bitchybillionaire ahhhh I’m sorry, there really isn’t that much tea I can spill without veering out of my lane. He didn’t do anything insane or #problematique or anything like that, I just know there’s a small section of Beatles fans (Paul-favoring fans specifically) who think that he is particularly, heavily biased against Paul. There are various arguments I’ve seen for it that range from reasonable to, IMO, almost microscopic levels of nitpicking. They have their right to their opinions, but, as happens in fandom with everything, I feel like they can sometimes overtorque and he becomes Just Like Every Other Biographer, which I don’t think is right. I have my issues with YNGMYM, but for the people I’ve seen who dislike his work, it feels like every single thing he says is somehow anti-Paul. (An exaggeration but you get me.) IDK, I personally came away from YNGMYM thinking he hated all of them, lmao.