Since I have nothing better to do....
I might as well tell you what favorite portrayal of the characters from Ouran High School Host Club.
First off, I will start with Tamaki.
He is the character that I feel is done so well in the live action. However, I feel that some aspects of his character just come out better in the live action than the anime.
However, if I was to limit myself to the anime only to choose from, I don't know who I would chose because both Vic Mignonogo (if I spelled that right I will be surprised) and Mamouru Miyano do add something to Tamaki. However, I would have to say my opinion about which one is better is something that I haven't really thought about.
For one, I feel Mamouru makes Tamaki sound a little older than he is (that might be because I have watched the dub more). The other is that I watched too many videos of Vic at conventions that I sorta here himself when he plays Tamaki which interfers with my judgement about whether or not he is good enough for Tamaki. However, I do remember that I liked Vic's protrayal until I started watching some of the sub and convention videos.
Well, the next one will probably be about Haruhi since she is my favorite character.