“More than anything? More than slam poetry or people who think their cats love them?” She takes a sip of her Manhattan and grimaces. Her ginger tabby leaps lithely from the bookshelf to the back of the couch. “More than anything, I hate the Platonic equation of beauty and virtue.” You try to roll your eyes, but you’ve never gotten the hang of taking her less than seriously. “No really. As a foundational ideology, it’s criminal. Eugenics, misogyny, the media’s total erasure of difference…It all goes back to Plato and his dumbfuck idea that the beautiful is the good and the good is the beautiful.”
“Why? Because beauty is subjective?”
“Well yeah, but even with that aside, even if beauty were this quantifiable thing, the idea that because it’s pleasing to the eye it must be good! What a terrible, dehumanizing concept. It disqualifies most of us, not to mention our art, from engaging in the pursuit of virtue. It’s an abject failure of the imagination.” She squints into the distance as if there’s someone else, some skeptic in the room; as if she’s turning the best angle of her face toward a camera. “I mean, I’d go so far as to argue the opposite, to argue that the good becomes good through labor, through being practically eviscerated by struggle and made ugly by the world. The hideous is the good and the good is the hideous.”
“And you want to be good.”
I’d rather be virtuous than beautiful.”
“And your art? You’d rather your art be virtuous than beautiful?”
“My art? I don’t know. I’d rather my self be virtuous than beautiful.”
“It takes a beauty to say that.”
She winks at you, sleazy and sultry, not entirely for your benefit though you’re the only one here.
“An intentional obfuscation of my point.”