I mentioned this in the comments of Chapter 5.2 but I wanted to also share my thoughts here.
As a Garou fan, I love me some Garou slander.
They are a very much creatures of Rage, and because of their very nature they see everything as a nail and themselves as being born with hammers for hands. They are fighting a noble war but they are not fighting it with the nobility it requires. It’s dirty, it’s bloody, and their enemy uses every underhanded trick it can find to win, and it most always does. For every Garou that dies, four more vampires are embraced and three more fomori are born. Their ancestors failed during The War Of Rage, failed during The Impergium, failed during their coming to the American continent during the colonial era, and failed to realize that either all stand together against the Wyrm (non-kinfolk humans included) or they will all fall alone. And whats worse... The Garou Nation is failing, and your PC can either follow the party line and be rewarded, or walk the more difficult path to create true change. You face enemies more ruthless than even you, and you must be wary at times, for fanaticism turns even good intentions into twisted and impotent idiocy. You can be heroes, but The Garou as a whole are not, they are just what's left, the last line of defense. There are no pure good guys in WOD, even WtA, the only reason your player character/your pack/The Garou aren’t the “bad guys” is because you are fighting something way worse. And thats why I love it. Though we shouldn't generalize them too much, all splats/factions are complex in their own ways, no doubt.
Also, as a final thought, I would like to personally celebrate Alfabusa and his team's wider approach to WOD. They seem to be using lore from all editions, from 20th, to 5th, to even Revised in some cases. And the way they use it, in my opinion, contributes to a rich tapestry for their personal vision of the World Of Darkness.
In the end, I always remember what my ST once told me; "It's your world of darkness - use the parts you like, ignore the parts you don't."













