chipmunkwarcry replied to your post “I have a problem with my current Disney essays project and it’s that,...”
I don’t know what your criteria is for the ya books, but you could go with some older fairy tale retellings. There is Gail Carson Levine or Shannon Hale as well as a line of books by various ya authors that was released in the 80s/90s.
These ones. https://www.goodreads.com/series/49798
Oh never mind. I just realized you meant books like the twisted tales series Disney has been commissioning
Well, fml, I didn’t know about those twisted tales, I had no idea they existed. Damn you, Disney, making me read Descendants wasn’t enough, now there’s this. At least there isn’t a Snow White one yet but apparently there’s a Beauty & the Beast one so that’s gonna have to go on the list. Thanks for letting me know!
As for my criteria, at this point the non-Disney re-tellings I’m picking are based on either offering something entirely different that serves my line of analysis (in the case of The Beast, for example, I want to include Barbara Walker’s Ugly and the Beast and possibly Angela Carter’s Bloody Chamber, because Blue Beard is included in my analysis for reasons complicated to explain right now but trust me, it makes sense in context) and ones that are incredibly popular to the point of becoming new beacons of re-tellings, whether I like that or not (in the case of the Evil Queen from Snow White, I’m going with The Lunar Chronicles and I think that if I had to pick just one from the ya re-tellings of B&B that are a thing atm it’d have to be the one by Sarah J Maas, because it’s the most popular one by far right now, and it isn’t Beastly, so there’s that, I’m not sure about the rest of the options because I’m intrigued about the one with a trans Belle, but the lead character Beast apparently is absolutely terrible and undeserving of redemption as far as 95% of the GR comments are concerned, so...).
I read Ella Enchanted and The Two Princesses of Bamarre by Gail Carson Levine, I really liked them (especially Bamarre, amazing book), but so far I haven’t come across one of hers that fit the characters I’m working with right now. I did however come across a B&B re-telling by Juliet Marillier, and I’ve read a really good re-telling of The Six Swans by her (I read the 2 first books of Sevenwaters, I should finish that series) but I don’t know how relevant it may be to pick her books from the bunch of options when they aren’t either overwhelmingly different or very popular. It’s tough.
I’m keeping the non-Disney re-tellings to a minimum for this, though, because my work is mainly Disney-based, but in order to include comparisons, offering a few non-Disney things (not just books, films and shows as well, you bet I’m not going to do a Beast analysis and leave out Ron Perlman’s Vincent in the 1987 tv series, that’d be criminal) can help see the evolution more. But, to narrow them down, I think I’m gonna go with a couple re-tellings and pick from both plot and popularity among readers, at this point. I think that’s the best I could do.














