choosetofight replied to your post “choosetofight replied to your post “// protip: throws hands w/...”
Yeah, I know what you mean. I get that people have a right to their opinions of course, I'm not gonna get at people for that at all; but I do see people put these huge expectations on erwin especially and claim that he'd know "exactly what to do" & it does often ironically seems to ignore the fact that he was only human... maybe he would've done, but there's no way we could know either way - this is something completely different to anything that the SC has ever faced.
I personally think levi's choice was meant to be ambigious regarding whether it was "right", anyway - there's no way anyone can know for sure. Maybe that's just me, haha. more importantly, levi made his choice because he wanted to free erwin from all this to begin with... I mean I'm sure he doesn't want Hange to go through what she's dealing with right now either, but he'd lived with that burden of having to be this perfect Commander/a "neccessary devil" for so long and even after finding his dream, it wasn't gonna get any better. Unfortunately, the world of SNK wasn't gonna let him retire and get therapy, as much as I'd like that for him otl... ;~; again, people have every right to disagree with me, and I get why they might, but - I think levi's choice was one of the kindest he could give in the world that they live in personally.
Anyway, I got off topic lol. But the expectations people put on Hange sometimes are insane, especially now that they're dealing with an entire world of people who want to kill them. It's so depressing reading Hange seeing herself as a failure of a Commander and trying so desperately to get Eren to just communicate her when she's in such a shitty situation... it's like man. I just wanna give her a hug ;~~~; okay, holy shit that was a long reply. sorry about all that!! ^^''
@choosetofight // I love you and your giant wall of text and I keep forgetting to break my inactiveness (busy with work) to tell you I like everything you said
People don’t appreciate the story enough for what it is. I see so much entry-level understanding about characters and relationships in this fandom. ‘Hange said she’s a bad commander so she is and that’s that.’ ‘Everyone liked Erwin so he’s the best commander that’s that.’ And often viewing Levi as kind of an accessory to other characters. I know both Eruris and Levihans are really bad at that- They just like Erwin or Hange and Levi is their funny little grumpy man rather than his own character in his own right.
Erwin’s character arc was as an obsessed, wounded man that hated himself for being so obsessed with a goal of proving his father right to make up for causing his death, that he hated himself because he was willing to waste countless lives to follow that dream all while accidentally making people believe he was a righteous person, until it came to a head and he was able to sacrifice himself like he’d sacrificed everyone else, and became the kind of person he ‘tricked’ people into thinking he was.
Being sacrificed was extremely important to this character arc but they complain he should have lived just because they liked who his character originally was early on.
Like people blabbering about Hange being awful but not actually picking up on her character arc and how it’s developing, especially with Flegel and the journalists popping up again recently to show she’s disappointed them, obviously to foreshadow her going back to her pre-Commander roots some time in the future. Or people just going ‘LEVI IS 2 POWERFUL!!’ not paying attention to the fact his character arc goes beyond that and he fact that he loses most of the fights he’s in because he has to run away to protect others...
I know it’s kinda dumb but it’s obnoxious to me because AoT isn’t a super derivative, turn-your-brain-off kind of manga. It’s got some actually legitimate writing, even if the anime is trash and even if it’s gone through some really bad writing points. If you can say anything for Isayama, he’s good at writing characters and having very interesting, philosophical points (that apparently people can’t pick up on). His only problem is that he’s a pansy who rolls over to others’ opinions too much.
I mean, it’s like people have gone all this way without comprehending that the running theme of the damn series is moral grayness, and how Erwin was the first big example of it. AAAAALL the way back in the FTT arc., when Armin had his whole spiel..
All I want is for people to read the fucking seriessss