Chris Tomlin, Passion and Hillsong have definitely radically affected the "worship and praise" culture for many churches (which I think is great) but at the same time for many seeing/being at huge conferences like Passion they quickly realize that many elements feel like...a concert. Dr. Tim Keller in his article "Leadership and Church Size Dynamics" writes:
"Every church has a culture that goes with its size and which must be accepted. Most people tend to prefer a certain size culture, and unfortunately, many give their favorite size culture a moral status and treat other size categories as spiritually and morally inferior. They may insist that the only biblical way to do church is to practice a certain size culture despite the fact that the congregation they attend is much too big or too small to fit that culture."
While there are many elements of a "concert"...does it mean it's good/bad? Integrating contemporary elements (such as videos) into "church" almost feels like a necessity for engagement when you gather a room with 20,000+ young adults. On the other hand, having been at many contemporary young adult churches, I also hear lots of "criticisms" on how other churches are just too "old and boring" (a thought that's crossed my mind many times) but yet...are they "supposed" to follow the culture of contemporary young adult churches when they're not that?
This quick reflection has just opened up more questions for me on what it means to make the Gospel "relevant" to our culture...an enterprise where even the audience size alone can be such a huge factor in how we communicate a message.