The thing is
Andy assuring people that every question was asked means nothing when you remember that he's bad at pushing back when someone tries to pussyfoot around the question that he's asking. He's also quick to be like, "Well, I want to move on".
Another thing is, 9 times out of 10, he doesn't even really ask the important questions.
As much as it pains me to say, because now she's a bird that's gone off the deep end, Nicki Minaj's segment hosting the RHOP reunion truly was lightning in a bottle because she was actually asking the questions that fans had her on mind. You could tell she was actually listening to what people were saying on social media that season. She was not just allowing them to skirt around answers.
And if Andy were smart, he would have learned from that and tailored how he conducted these reunions. But it's 2026, and he hasn't improved a damn thing.
I will say, though, when did he advise Jessie Solomon to make sure the timelines were aligned? He ate that. Because watching Schwartz stutter through answering on WWHL (about when he knew about Raquel & Tom) and then watching him stutter again at the reunion, where even Sandoval looked at him like wtaf are you even saying rn, was embarrassingly painful to watch.