Can I request a yandere naehara with shuichi as the yandere. Whether it's in your makoto in v3 au or in the au where v3 class is class 79. I think it would be fun to play around with those two in a yandere setting
(Putting this at Hope's Peak instead of Makoto in V3 AU, since putting yanderes in a killing game limits what kinds of things can happen. Here's a post just kind of establishing what the Naehara status quo is, for this premise.)
With most of the THH yanderes, the endgame is to be in a relationship with Makoto, and with all of the THH yanderes, there's a feeling of accessibility. Being Makoto's classmate is so different from being his kouhai.
Shuichi is a yandere in the "crush on an upperclassman" sense, first and foremost. It's fun and feels good and the most concrete end goal is to just imagine something coming of it.
"Alright, you have to tell me who it is!" Kaede exclaims, one day.
"Who what is?" Shuichi asks, angling his head slightly to hide behind the bill of his cap.
"Every time the 78th class comes out for their free period, you look up to watch them."
"Not every time," he says evasively.
"I'm just going to keep bugging you until you tell me, so tell me!"
"Okay, okay. But you can't tell anyone else. Promise me."
"I promise," she says sincerely.
And he tells her. Kaede and Kokichi are the only ones in the class who know he has a crush on Naegi-senpai. (He didn't tell Kokichi. He just knows.)
Kaede sometimes teases him about it, and he allows that as a regular friend thing, as long as she never does it where anyone else can hear.
Shuichi keeps a meticulous log of Makoto's comings and goings, with dates, times, just fully staking out.
He's the Ultimate Detective's Assistant, and usually he's pretty embarrassed or uncomfortable about his talent, but keeping tabs on Makoto makes him feel like a real detective, in a way that kind of gives him a sense of pride and satisfaction. He likes his shelf of notebooks that one would have to read pretty closely for a while to even know they were about Makoto.
The notes are like, "September 3rd, left dorm at 7:30, uniform missing third button, left shoe untied. Dining hall 7:35-8, school store 8-8:05, class 8:07-11:45 (math test, score: 82. left shoe tied by the time he left the classroom), lunch 11:50-12 (bento with [insert foods here]), didn't stay long because Yamada needed help with [insert thing here], didn't eat his vegetables." etc. Very factual, and not weird in and of themselves. He keeps them secret, but if anyone were to read them by accident, they wouldn't clock them as stalker stuff right away; they'd just think the detective is detective-ing.
Also, as the Ultimate Detective's Assistant, he works with Kyoko pretty frequently. Perhaps daily.
She's very professional and polite with him, and he's very professional and polite back, but he has beef with her. He feels she takes Makoto for granted and sometimes puts him in danger.
So, basic status quo is, Shuichi has a crush on Makoto, is stalking him, and lowkey resents Kyoko. She's not the only one– he resents a lot of people in Makoto's class –but she's the one he interacts with most, so his feelings get to really fester and develop.
"Excuse me, Kirigiri," Shuichi says one day, during their collaboration time.
Or, during their nominal collaboration time. Kyoko often works alone anyway, leaving him with her briefing notes on whatever she investigated on her own time. But she at least knows she has to let him work with her when he goes out of his way to do so.
"What's wrong?" she asks.
"I just noticed that your Tuesday notes mentioned that the suspect acted shifty when sharing a space with a bystander, but you didn't list the bystander's details. It seemed unlike you, so I thought I'd ask."
Kyoko is silent for a second, which is all the confirmation Shuichi needs: She used Makoto again.
Kyoko doesn't know that Shuichi is yandere for Makoto, but she knows that Shuichi tends to have reservations about the things she's willing to do to solve a case, and she knows that Shuichi has intense guilt around being a detective in general, so she sort of takes his negative feelings about her use of Makoto to solve cases as part of that. After he got upset the first couple of times she brought Makoto into the mix, she started deliberately keeping it a secret every time she does so. But this time, she got caught.
"Did you ask Naegi to sit next to a serial killer on the train?" Shuichi asks, doing his best to emanate professional disapproval instead of seething rage.
"No. I asked him to sit next to a suspect. Now, did you look through the thumb drive I left you?" She never feels the need to explain herself to him.
The fact that he can't even report her to the headmaster (or at least feels he can't, because the headmaster is her dad) makes him even angrier.
He frequently fantasizes about poisoning her, past the point where it stops being fantasy and instead becomes planning. He knows she's too smart for the first few murder methods that come to mind. She thinks quickly; a lot of murder victims panic and waste time trying things that won't work, to save themselves. With all the death she's seen, he has to assume she's thought through what she'd do in the event of most murder attempts.
Fortunately, he's been trusted with her notes and files. He can get ideas from where other murderers failed.
Wait, is he actually planning a murder now?
No, no. He's just...thinking about it.
He'll tell himself he's "just thinking about it" through every step of the planning process until it happens.
And then he becomes the Ultimate Detective. He wasn't even thinking about that part! Being handed her title and told to investigate her murder.
He supposes he'll...have to interview her friends, won't he? It'll be nice to finally have an excuse to really spend time with Makoto.
When he starts asking him a lot of questions, eventually Makoto panics. "Wait, am I a suspect?!"
And Shuichi would have immediately assured him that he wasn't (He would never let Makoto go down for any crime, even if he were guilty.), but he...froze for a second. And Makoto gets more anxious, so Shuichi slowly says, "Hey, it's okay. I trust you. I believe that you're telling me the truth. You are, right?"
And of course, Makoto is quick to agree.
Oops, now it's almost like Makoto has to spend time with him whenever he wants. Shuichi didn't intend for that part to happen...But it is nice to spend time with him.
And Makoto is so sad about Kirigiri's death. It makes Shuichi kind of jittery. As if being a detective didn't make him guilty enough, now he has to be a detective and a murderer. Not just convicting the wrongdoers; being the wrongdoer and convicting the innocent!
It's okay. He'll just frame their most recent suspect; the guy was guilty anyway. And all of this was for Makoto's sake, so it's okay!
And Makoto is worried about him, too. He doesn't address it right away, but it comes out later:
"Hey," the upperclassman says kindly. "Have you been okay? I know you worked with Kyoko every day, so solving her...her murder is...I can't even imagine. I'm here for you, if you ever need me."
Shuichi lets some tears fall– not just to be manipulative! He isn't grieving Kirigiri, of course, but he does feel really intense affection for Makoto in this moment. "It's been really hard," he chokes out, and Makoto touches him on the shoulder!
"I know," he says heavily. "She was really amazing. I'm glad I got to be her friend."
...Okay. If Shuichi just has to ignore all that stuff, then that's an easy tradeoff!
And he doesn't expect he'll have to kill anyone else in Makoto's class. Like Owada, or Togami...No, he's sure he won't need to do that. But if he did, Owada's death would be easy to stage, and Togami-
(Also, obligatory reference to that one post where yanderes are an accepted entity in Hope's Peak. I like to imagine Shuichi deciding whether or not to submit paperwork to be counted as an official yandere. Thinking through the pros and cons, probably landing at "no".)