Buttercup Farm Chapter 3 - Horsin’ Around’ ✮ ˚。⋆ ˙
2.1k!!! Cowboy Abby Anderson x farmhand femme reader. Mostly comfort but some slight angst (mentions of Owen eek 😟).
A/N: I made them both bi because I’m indecisive so I hope that’s okay with you cuties? We also have our first Abby diary entry in this chapter so I hope you enjoy 🫶
⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆
The beams of dawn break through the laced curtain of your room, gently kissing your face awake with their warmth and golden hues. You muffle an earth-quaking yawn and peel the curtains just enough to peek outside, amazed at the prismacolour sunrise ahead of you. You stretch your arms above your head, wishing that Abby was there to pull them down as she did yesterday, before you force yourself out of bed. Abby promised to take you horse riding today so you tried to dress accordingly - opting for brown boots with flower embroidery, a duck-egg blue blouse, and bootcut jeans with stars sown onto the back pockets. You tie your hair into a simple ponytail and open the door to go outside where collide with a tall, muscular figure with a distinct thump. “Oh sorry darlin’, didn’t see you there. Just wanted to check if you were awake” Abby says abashed, placing her hand behind her head and chuckling lightly. Her golden hair is illuminated by the early morning sun, with her baby hairs appearing as if they were a halo around her face. For a brief moment, her eyes caught the light and transformed from their usual cobalt to a dazzling sapphire. Only then did you realise that you had been staring for a little too long so you decidedly break the silence, “well I’m up but thanks for being my personal alarm clock anyways. You ready to go?”. She laughs again, titling her head up which allows the sound to graciously spill into the shared space between you too. God, you want to make her laugh forever, you wished silently, hoping that the dancing peonies in the grass beneath you would somehow hear and make your dreams a reality. “Hmm”, Abby ponders, “I am but your not honey, where’s your hat? Wouldn’t want you to burn. Not saying you couldn’t pull it off or anythin’ but it’d sure as hell hurt”. After you explain that you don’t have one she smiles in a sickenly soothing fashion and offers you one of hers, beckoning you to follow her to her cabin.
⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆
It’s not far from yours, similarly situated a far distance outside of the other ranch cabins. She puts a hand on your lower back to encourage you inside where you try to subtly investigate where she calls home. It is scarcely decorated and surprisingly clean for a cowboy. A few horseshoes lined the walls and a small collection of books, weathered due to what can only be years of enjoyment, sat on top of her bedside table. “You read?!” you exclaim, trying to hide the shock on your voice which was to little avail. Abby met your eyes and smirked, “What, cowboys can’t read now? You’re awfully small-minded pretty”. You stumble over your words, making weak attempts to defend yourself which Abby deems hilarious by the way that she is leaning on her door frame for support - almost doubled over in laughter. “Lord your easy to tease, I’m only kiddin’. Are ya into books?”. You nod in response and Abby smiles painfully gently once more, “well, you can borrow my books anytime you like. How ‘bout you start with this one? It’s a killer”. Abby resolutely places a novel in to your hands, it is clothed with a linen cover which had been stained by ink marks and faded gold font which you couldn’t quite decipher. “Let me know what ya think of it sometime, my thoughts are in the margin so you can pay mind to those too if you’d like”. You didn’t expect someone so seemingly rough to be so gentle, so kind. Your dwelling on that thought when her eyes widened and she spun around, remembering why you came her and lifting one of many cowboy hats off of a rusted hook by the door. “It’ll be too big for you but it’ll have to do” Abby sighs, strolling back towards you and tucking a stray strand from your ponytail behind your ear before placing the hat on top of your head. She adjusts it slightly and stands back to admire her work, appearing so effortlessly collected whereas you feel like a blushing wreck. The rose-tinted shading your cheeks only brightens when Abby comments “You can keep that hat, it looks way prettier on you than it does on me darlin’”. You mutter a quick thanks, trying to retain any dignity you have left, and Abby beckons you outside - directing you steadily to the stables.
⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆
Once you arrive, she diverts your attention to a beautiful cooper-coloured mare - with white spots that appear as if they were freckles lining her back. “I call her Sienna” Abby explains, fondly stroking the horse’s chestnut mane with such devoted care that it makes your heart melt upon the sight. “She ain’t the flashiest but I’ve had her since I was little, I couldn’t join the ranch without her”. You smile at the thought of a younger Abby, her skin untouched by hard labour and with her flowing blond hair tied messily into twin pigtails. “She’s easy too yeah? Won’t be bucking ya off anytime soon I hope” Abby remarks, throwing a sly wink your way. She then helps you onto the saddle first, lifting your hips with an effortless ease with innately reminds you of those stunning muscles she has built. She leaps up after you, placing a heavy head on your shoulder and curving strong arms around your waist. “So darlin’, you lead her like this…” Abby explains, gesturing to the leads around the horses’ neck. Her careful explanation is lost on you however, too distracted her faint smell of whisky and pine trees and increasingly heavy breathing which seemingly kisses your earlobes with every exhale. You nod in feigned acknowledgment as you continue to daydream about the cowgirl, craving desperately to know everything about her. Her story, her past, who she wants to be, who the cruel world has told her she shouldn’t be through undeserved scolds and turmoils. Little do you know, as she claps her scarred hands around your limber digits, she feels the exact same way. Abby chuckles when you gasp at her yanking on the reigns, causing the horse to quite literally leaps into action. Sienna canters away at an alarming speed, instinctively pushing Abby even closer to you as the hare bucks with every oncoming leap. Abby whistles behind you and quiets her excitement to whisper to you “ain’t never rode anything quite like this pretty, have ya?”. With no feasible air remaining in your lungs, you offer her a simple nod which she remarks with another honey-deep chuckle.
⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆
Sienna slows as you reach a clearing, now far away from the ranch behind you. The scene before you both is evidentially breathtaking. A cerulean lake reflects the rare cloud in the sky, only seldomly disturbed by a traitorous ripple, and trees enclose the water so closely that you feel it is mothers natures way of reclaiming a landscape which is even beyond her nurturing touch. Your eyes widen at the sight, pinching Abby’s arm in a wondrous disbelief. “It’s beautiful ain’t it? I wanted to show you that life here ain’t all baren”. “I didn’t think that for a second” you reply without thinking, still breathless from the intensity of the journey (albeit quick) and the picturesque scene which lights your soul as a cowboy would ignite a smoky cigar in dim, evening light. Abby lightly nudges Sienna into action once more, causing the horse to endeavour on a gentle gallop as you circumvent the serene body of water. The cowgirl clears her throat before asking “So…ya got a boyfriend to come home to? Give him a lay of the land and that?”. You sigh as the memories of your ex pollutes your bliss - you had a boyfriend but he treated you with such apathy and harshness that you had prayed never to suffer the misfortune of crossing paths with him again. “No”, you reply after a moments silent - needing to regain your composure. “I did have a boyfriend yes but he wasn’t the kindest to put it gently. Part of the reason I came here was to escape that, to escape him”. Abby responds by kneading the flesh of your thigh, humming melodically in doing so. “Yea I get that, I had the same with a fella’ named Owen. Nice enough but was far too concerned with his own wellbein’ to pay attention to me”. “I’m sorry” you utter truthfully, placing your hand onto hers as she continually works her fingers into your leg. “Don’t be, they’re in the past now huh?”. “I had a girlfriend too”, you admit - anxious to expose the fact that you liked women. You feel her nod gently, inhaling deeply into the crook of her neck - that mere act giving you the confidence to continue. “Her name was Alice, she was much sweeter than my ex-boyfriend but we just drifted you know?”. “Oh I know all right darlin, same thing happened to me a few months back. I met a pretty girl at a bar and thought we had something goin’ on but I guess I thought wrong”. You frown at the thought, how could someone possibly reject someone like Abby? Pushing the anger temporarily aside, it was becoming increasingly impossible to ignore the flutter in your chest - Abby likes women. Is it completely freakish to think that you could have a chance?
⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆
You and Abby rode back to the farm at a gentle pace, talking softly about anything and everything in a way that felt just so comfortable. You hadn’t realised how long you had been out for until your met with Meemaw’s feigned angry expression, sympathetically chastising you with a caring smile which made her ‘disappointment’ seem all that less convincing. You helped with dinner and quickly headed to bed, tired from a strenuous day of horse riding. Before you let sleep take its familiar path over your aching body, you pick up the novel which Abby had given to you. Opening the first page, you smile fondly at her annotations. The title is missing some girls punctuation and you see her circle the errors, illustrating obnoxious question marks by the blatant mistakes. ‘Good thing you’re a creative writer’ she reads, making you muffle a giggle at the thought of Abby writing as if she was being condescending to the author herself. You quickly fall asleep to the exhilarating thought of Abby’s breath on your neck, the words she whispered to you which you knew she had never said to anyone else. The book lays on your chest, too tired to place it on the wooden panels beside your bed - somewhat reminiscent of Abby’s looming hands on your figure from just a few hours earlier on this fateful day.
⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆
Abby’s Diary - POV: ˙⋆✮
Abby sat down at her antiquated teal-washed desk and collected her diary from her draw, pulling an ink pen from an old soup can to try and sort through the plethora of emotions which she felt today.
‘Good God, I’ve known this girl for two days and I’m already actin’ stupid? Asking her if she’s taken like I’m not interested - what am I doing. She was laughing at dinner like she hadn’t a care in the world and the way she tipped her head back as she smiled - lord I’m so fucked. Wearing my hat today too, she’s so gorgeous and I can tell that she doesn’t know it and what’s worse is that it only makes me want to show her how much I know it even more. She is into women though and that’s a relief, but I’m still scared that I’ll end up on another wild goose chase like I did with that stupid girl at the bar. The way we chatted today, I didn’t know that talkin’ could be so easy. I’m scared I’m bein’ too handsy with her but I can’t help but comfort her - I feel like I could kill that motherfuckin’ ex boyfriend who broke her heart. I mean, her heart of all people. I knew I was done for when I saw her passing out on that table, how can someone look so gorgeous when they are so spent? Abby Anderson, you need to pull yourself together. You don’t even know if she likes you! Be calm, be collected, and be cool. This ain’t like herding cattle or aiming the trigger at the shooting range, this shit is important. I’ll try again tomorrow.”.
Abby sighs as she lets the ink pool into her notebook, for someone so meticulous it’s unusual for her to be this careless. She tries to sleep, she really does, but she’s too distracted by the way you felt when she touched your thigh. She way she swore she could hear your breath catch when she whispered sweet nothings to you. Damn, it was going to be a long night.
⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆ ⋆✴︎˚。⋆














