In Plain Sight: XI and XII Final
Mulder and Scully are investigating the disappearances of three young women from a drop in centre. Set during the cancer arc.
(Written for a prompt from @crossedbeams - Mulder and Scully are in a room with a crowd of people, every time X happens, someone vanishes...)
Read the previous parts here: [I] [II] [III and IV] [V and VI] [VII and VIII] [IX and X]
Selina Sandoval backed into the room until she was butting up against the small desk. Mulder crossed his arms. Scully pinched the bridge of her nose. The already stifling air in the small room smelled like stale garlic and cheap tobacco. Outside, thunder rumbled in the distance. Scully could feel the pressure pushing against her temples.
“Where have you been, Ms Sandoval?” Mulder’s voice was soft against the grating wheeze of the fan on the floor in the corner.
The young woman said nothing, but tucked her hair behind her ears. It was shorter than the poster they’d seen days earlier.
“You were reported missing,” Scully said.
“I work here every day. I clean. I wash. I buy food,” Selina said. She looked at the manager. He coughed hard and dug a dirty hanky out of his shirt pocket.
“People were worried about you,” Scully said.
“I don’t understand why people think I was missing. Who reported me?”
Mulder looked at Scully. Scully couldn’t recall the detail of the report. “Marshall Comans. Do you remember him?”
Selina flushed. “Of course. He was my friend.”
“But you didn’t tell him you were leaving.”
She clasped the crucifix around her neck and Scully reflexively did the same. “I didn’t think he would care that much. And I didn’t go anywhere. I just didn’t go back to the centre.”
“And why was that?” Mulder said, staring at the manager who was chewing at the skin on the side of his thumb.
Scully squeezed her eyes shut as a crack of thunder hit overhead. When she opened her eyes again, Selina was crying quietly. Mulder turned on his empathetic expression and stepped towards her.
“What was it, Selina? Why didn’t you go back there? What happened?”
“Did he cheat on you, Selina?”
Selina rushed past. Scully followed her into the hallway. Lightning lit up the dankness. “Selina! It’s okay. You can tell me what happened. You’re not in any trouble.”
The young woman bawled for a few minutes and Scully stood, unsure whether to comfort her or to wait like the professional she should. Mulder would not have hesitated to step closer and embrace this woman. But he was talking on the phone in sharp tones. Thunder rolled around then burst in static spurts.
“Marshall told me he wanted to marry me. He said he would wait until I was 18 and then we would move away and have kids and a house. We used to go to the magic shows at the centre. They always made me feel that anything was possible, you know?”
Hopes, dreams, illusions. Where do you draw the line? Scully handed Selina another tissue. Mulder slipped his phone back in to his pocket and joined them.
“What happened?” Scully asked.
“That last show, there was a new trick. The lights went out, like so black it was as though the magician had sucked all the light out. I couldn’t see anything. I blinked and held my breath and when I opened my eyes Marshall was gone. I looked around. People were laughing and chatting like nothing unusual had happened. I went out of the room and saw him going out of the building. I followed. I saw him with another girl.”
Selina sniffed and shuddered out a breath. Her eyes were puffy and shiny, even in the miserable light of the hallway. A pair of young punk girls, arm in arm, walked past, knocking into Scully. Mulder grimaced and tapped his nose. She felt the ooze and bunched a tissue under her nose.
“He didn’t even tried to hide. It was like he was seeing this other girl all the time, right under my nose. In plain sight. I felt stupid. I believed him. But he was a liar and I wanted to run away. But that didn’t go so well the last time. So I stayed. Right here.”
“In plain sight,” Mulder said to her, but keeping his eyes on Scully. He lifted his chin up slightly, silently asking her if she was okay.
“The police investigated, Selina, when you were reported missing. We’ve seen the reports.”
“The police don’t care. They would have asked like three people in the centre if they’d seen me and then they would have stopped looking. People like me, we can just disappear. Nobody cares. We are invisible.”
Back at the motel, heavy rain pelted the windows with a monotony that Scully found comforting. She fanned her face with the out of date attractions magazine and twisted her feet around to release the pressure in her calves. Mulder had told her the bones under the hall were animal, likely a dog, buried years before construction. Selina Sandoval was never missing. Maybe the other girls were here too, or maybe they just didn’t want to be found or saved or even to go on. The police could do more than they could. Should do more.
The door opened and Mulder walked in with a take out bag containing chicken burritos and two bottles of Coke. She lay on the bed, her body working overtime to cool her. He put the food on the small table and sat down on the end of her bed unknotting his tie and dropping it over the bobbly bedspread.
“What do you think Scully?”
“About what?” She sat up to sip the soda and felt it track down her gullet. Out of sight but most definitely doing its job, fizzing and cooling, supplying her body with a quick hit of sugar.
He handed her a burrito. “Ami and Riley. Carol Arwen. Grunge girl?”
“I think we see what we want to see, we hear what we want to hear. We observe and we ignore, we weigh and measure and we interpret and we add meaning where there is none. Not always consciously but because humans love to tell stories to explain things, to understand, to cope.”
The spicy chicken was tender and she realised how hungry she was, how much her body needed the fuel. It was working overtime not just to cool her, but to kill her. The cancer cells constantly dividing. The normal cells trying to save her.
“You might not always be able to see things happening, but it doesn’t mean it’s not taking place.”
Mulder put his burrito down and turned to her. His eyes were heavy with sadness. He always understood. That was the problem.
She scooted forward and took his hand in hers. His was warm, heavy. “You have to face it. I have to face it. I want you to promise me that you won’t self-destruct. That you won’t lose yourself again. I need you to promise me.”
“I can’t. You know I can’t. But this isn’t going to defeat us…you. I’m still looking. I have to keep looking.”
She pulled his head to her chest and let him breathe onto her skin. His hot breath, the softness of his lips against her made her feel a rush of emotion, of hope even. “I know. I wouldn’t expect you to do anything but.”
“When you were taken, I was wild with anger. It was so meaningless, everything. But you came back then. Nobody saw you. You just appeared.”
“Like magic,” she said, chuffing out a small laugh into his hair.
“It was the best trick, Scully.” He looked up at her and kissed her. She stiffened at first, but her body relaxed and she kissed him back until she couldn’t breathe.
When they pulled apart, his eyes glistened with tears.