can you write one were reader is matts sister and Noahs best friend and the band always tease the shit out of them when their glued together? thank you:)
Subtle’s Overrated
Noah Sebastian x bsf!dierkes!reader
Summary: Y/N and Noah’s friendship sparks teasing and undeniable chemistry on tour, but when feelings finally surface, nothing—especially their bandmates—can keep them apart.
Words: 4k
Warnings: Teasing, Friends to Lovers, Use of Alcohol, Mention of smoking weed, I din't proofread it so maybe there's gonna be mistakes. lmk if i forgot something.
Disclaimer: While the characters in this story are inspired by real people, the events and interactions are purely fictional and not reflective of reality.
The airport was buzzing with early morning activity, travelers pulling their luggage through the terminal, announcements echoing overhead. You were leaning against one of the sleek chrome pillars, your carry-on by your feet, scrolling through your phone to pass the time.
Noah was right beside you, as usual. He had his arms crossed, a hoodie tugged over his messy hair, and he was squinting at the boarding pass in his hand like it was written in hieroglyphics.
"I swear they make these things harder to read every year," he muttered, flipping it over like the back might offer some hidden insight.
"It’s not a riddle, Noah," you said with a laugh, reaching out to snatch it from him. "Gate 22. Terminal C. You’ve been doing this for years, and you still act like it’s your first time at an airport."
"Not all of us are travel pros like you, princess," he shot back, smirking as he leaned casually into your space.
Before you could reply, a loud wolf whistle interrupted the moment.
"Ah, look at ‘em! Joined at the hip, as always!" Nick Folio’s voice carried across the terminal as he walked over, balancing a precariously large coffee in one hand and a bag of snacks in the other. "Should we just start planning the wedding now?"
"Shut up, Folio," you groaned, rolling your eyes, though the warmth creeping up your neck betrayed your nonchalance.
"Yeah, shut up, Folio," Noah parroted, tossing a crumpled napkin at him. "Jealousy’s a bad look on you."
Nick feigned hurt, clutching his chest. "Jealous? Me? Never. I just think you two make a cute couple."
"Do you ever let up?" Jolly chimed in as he approached, his bag slung over one shoulder. "I mean, they’ve been attached at the hip since day one, and nothing’s happened yet. Maybe they’re just... eternal besties."
"Or they’re both in denial," Matt teased, appearing out of nowhere and clapping Noah on the back hard enough to make him stumble. "Classic slow burn."
"Right, because you’re such an expert on relationships," you shot back, raising an eyebrow at your older brother.
"Hey," Matt replied, grinning. "Just calling it like I see it. And as your big brother, it’s my job to keep the guy glued to your side in line."
"Yeah, yeah," you muttered, shaking your head as the rest of the group laughed.
"Big brother or not, you’re still a pain," Noah quipped, though there was no malice in his tone.
"As if you’re one to talk," Matt retorted, pointing at him. "If I had a dollar for every time you’ve mooched off her snacks, I’d be retired by now."
The group chuckled, and even you couldn’t help but crack a smile. This was the usual routine, and as much as you liked to complain about it, it was comforting in a way.
As the teasing died down, Nicholas Ruffilo joined the circle, pulling out his phone. "So," he began, "who’s gonna be the one to lose their luggage this time?"
"My money’s on Noah," Jolly said without hesitation.
"Why me?" Noah protested, looking genuinely offended.
"You lost your passport twice last year," Jolly replied flatly.
"That’s different!"
"How?"
"Uh, it just is," Noah said, his argument faltering as you snorted.
"I’ll help you keep track of your stuff this time," you offered, patting his shoulder mockingly.
"You’re a saint," he said, putting a hand over his heart. "An angel sent to save me from myself."
"Don’t encourage him," Matt groaned, shaking his head.
The overhead speakers crackled to life, announcing the boarding process for your flight. Matt immediately took charge, ushering everyone toward the gate.
"Alright, lovebirds, let’s move it," he said, his tone dripping with sarcasm.
"We’re not—"
"Save it," Nick interrupted, throwing an arm around your shoulders as the group started walking. "We all know it’s just a matter of time."
You exchanged a glance with Noah, who shrugged with a small, amused smile. It was the same old joke, but this time, there was a flicker of something in his eyes that you couldn’t quite place.
As you reached the gate, Noah fell into step beside you, close enough that your arms brushed. "You ever feel like they know something we don’t?" he asked quietly, just for you to hear.
"All the time," you admitted, your voice just as soft.
The moment hung in the air for a beat too long before Matt’s voice broke it. "Hurry up, or we’re leaving you behind!"
With a shared smirk, you and Noah picked up the pace, falling into step with the rest of the band.
The plane was relatively quiet as everyone settled into their usual spots. You slid into the window seat with a satisfied sigh, propping your backpack under the seat in front of you. Noah dropped into the middle seat beside you, and Folio followed, plopping down with a dramatic groan.
“Man, who made planes so cramped?” Folio grumbled, stretching his legs as far as they could go without hitting the seat in front of him.
“Quit complaining, Folio,” Matt called from his aisle seat, shooting him a look over Ruffilo’s head. “You know it’s worse on the tour bus.”
“True, but at least I don’t get stuck in the middle of these two on the bus.” Folio gestured to you and Noah. “You’re like magnets, always leaning into each other.”
“Jealous you’re not in the middle?” Noah quipped, earning a snort from Jolly.
“Nah, man. I just don’t want to be collateral damage when this whole slow-burn romance finally combusts,” Folio said, winking at you.
You groaned and shoved his arm lightly. “You guys really need new material.”
“Maybe we’ll stop when you two finally admit it,” Jolly chimed in, earning a chorus of agreement from the others.
Noah just smirked, leaning back in his seat. “Keep dreaming, guys.”
As the plane took off and the initial excitement of the flight settled down, everyone fell into their own routines. Matt pulled out his laptop, muttering something about emails, while Ruffilo popped in his earbuds and started sketching on his tablet. Folio tapped away on his phone, and Jolly was already half-asleep, head tilted against the window.
You glanced at Noah, who was scrolling aimlessly through his phone. “What are you looking at?” you asked softly.
“Nothing interesting,” he said, tilting the screen toward you briefly before locking it. “You thinking of sleeping?”
“Maybe,” you replied with a yawn, leaning your head back. “Flights always make me sleepy.”
“You always knock out within the first hour,” he teased, grinning.
“Can’t help it,” you murmured, already feeling the pull of sleep. Without thinking, you shifted slightly, leaning your headagainst Noah’s shoulder. It wasn’t the first time, and judging by the way he didn’t even flinch, it wasn’t a big deal to him, either.
Time passed, and you drifted off, your breathing evening out as the noise of the plane faded into the background.
It wasn’t long before the teasing began.
“Look at him,” Jolly whispered from across the aisle, his voice low but just loud enough for Noah to hear. “He looks like he’s holding his breath.”
“I think he’s afraid to move,” Ruffilo added, smirking. “Wouldn’t want to wake her, huh?”
“I’m not afraid to move,” Noah said defensively, though he kept his voice quiet so as not to wake you. “I just don’t want her to wake up cranky.”
“Oh, sure,” Matt interjected, leaning forward to get a better look. “That’s a real heroic excuse. But let’s be honest, you’re enjoying this, aren’t you?”
Noah shot him a look. “You’re her brother. Shouldn’t you be discouraging this kind of teasing?”
“Should I?” Matt said, feigning deep thought. “Nah, this is too much fun.”
“Careful, Noah,” Folio added, nudging him. “You keep letting her nap on you, and the next thing you know, you’ll be the designated human pillow.”
“Already am,” Noah muttered, but there was no real annoyance in his tone.
The ribbing continued for a bit longer before everyone settled back into their respective distractions. Noah shifted slightly, trying to keep his arm from going numb under your weight. Despite the teasing, he couldn’t help but smile faintly at how peaceful you looked.
As the captain announced the descent, Noah gently nudged your shoulder. “Hey, we’re landing soon. Time to wake up.”
You stirred, blinking sleepily and taking a moment to realize where you were. “Oh, sorry,” you mumbled, sitting up and rubbing your eyes.
“Don’t apologize,” Noah said, his voice soft. “You looked like you needed it.”
From across the aisle, Jolly piped up, “Did you get any drool on him this time?”
“Jolly!” you exclaimed, your cheeks flushing as the rest of the band burst out laughing.
“I’m kidding, I’m kidding,” Jolly said, holding up his hands in mock surrender.
Noah just smirked, grabbing your carry-on from under the seat. “Ignore them. They’re just mad they don’t have someone to nap on.”
You rolled your eyes but smiled as everyone prepared to disembark.
The airport was bustling with activity as you and the band made your way outside, your bags in tow. In the bus parking lot, your familiar tour bus stood waiting. Its sleek exterior and logo had become a second home over the years.
As you approached, Folio let out a dramatic sigh. “Ah, the tour bus. Where dreams of legroom come to die.”
You climbed aboard with Noah right behind you. As expected, you both took the booths across from each other—the same ones you’d claimed on every tour since your first. He threw his backpack onto the seat before flopping down, stretching his long legs.
“Surprise, surprise,” Matt said as he followed behind. “You two gravitate toward each other like it’s magnetic.”
“Yeah, we get it, Matt,” you replied, rolling your eyes but smiling. “Maybe we just like consistency.”
“Consistency, huh?” Jolly drawled, sliding into a booth further back. “Sure it’s not because you two can’t go five minutes without making googly eyes at each other?”
Noah shot him a look. “You’re projecting, man.”
“Yeah, totally projecting,” you chimed in, grinning.
“Call it what you want,” Matt teased as he threw his bag into the seat beside him, “but it’s only a matter of time before we’re writing ‘Mr. and Mrs.’ on the bus windows.”
Ruffilo smirked. “Or printing it on the next batch of merch.”
“You guys are insufferable,” you muttered, trying to suppress your laughter.
The drive to the venue was filled with similar banter, the kind that made the long hours on the road bearable. When the bus finally pulled into the lot behind the venue, everyone piled out, stretching and groaning after the ride.
Inside, the band got straight to work setting up for soundcheck. You wandered into the sound booth where Matt was stationed, helping coordinate with the crew.
“You’re still gonna be my unpaid assistant this tour, right?” he asked, grinning as you leaned against the console.
“Of course,” you said with mock enthusiasm. “Living the dream.”
As the band began their soundcheck, you couldn’t help but watch Noah. He was in his element, mic in hand, his voice effortlessly commanding the space. The way he moved, the focus in his expression—it was mesmerizing.
“Subtle,” Matt said dryly, breaking your trance.
“Huh?” You turned to him, feeling the heat rise in your cheeks.
“Your staring,” he teased. “You’re not exactly sneaky about it.”
“I’m just watching the sound levels,” you lied, feigning nonchalance.
Matt chuckled. “Sure, let’s go with that.”
The band wrapped up soundcheck, and everyone took a break before the show. Back in the green room, the teasing resumed as everyone grabbed snacks and drinks.
“Are we gonna have to peel you two apart again tonight?” Jolly asked, smirking as he sipped his water.
“Not unless you want to lose a limb,” Noah shot back, earning a laugh from Folio.
“Relax, man,” Folio said. “We’re just pointing out the obvious. You two are like those couples in rom-coms—everyone knows what’s coming except you.”
“We’re not a couple,” you said, exasperated. “Can we change the subject?”
“No,” Ruffilo replied immediately, earning a high-five from Jolly.
As showtime approached, you found yourself backstage, the energy in the venue electrifying. The band took the stage, and you couldn’t help but sing along and dance to every song, caught up in the moment.
From where you stood, you could see Noah glancing your way more than once, a small smile tugging at his lips when he caught your eye.
When the show ended, the crowd’s cheers still echoing in your ears, you were more than hyped. The moment Noah stepped offstage, sweaty and flushed from the performance, you ran to him, wrapping your arms around him in a tight hug.
“Y/N,” he laughed, his voice still rough from singing. “I’m literally soaked in sweat.”
“I don’t care,” you said, grinning as you held on tighter.
“Aww,” Jolly cooed from behind you. “A post-show love fest.”
“Jealous?” Noah shot back, his arms briefly tightening around you before he pulled away, though his smile lingered.
Before you could respond, Matt approached, crossing his arms as he looked at the two of you. “Still hugging, huh?”
“Don’t start,” you warned, though your tone lacked any real bite.
“I’ll start if I want to,” Matt said, smirking. “But I’ve got a better idea. Drinks to celebrate the first show?”
Noah glanced at you, his brow quirking. “What do you think?”
“Sounds perfect,” you replied, still buzzing with excitement.
“Great,” Matt said, clapping his hands. “Let’s pack up and get out of here.”
The bar was dimly lit, buzzing with music and chatter as you and the band made your way to the VIP section. The staff had cordoned off a cozy corner for you, complete with plush leather couches and a low table littered with menus and coasters.
Matt was quick to take charge, ordering the first round of drinks. He came back carrying a tray with an assortment of glasses, grinning like he’d just won a prize.
“To the first show of the tour!” he declared, raising his glass.
“To surviving another tour without killing each other,” Jolly added dryly, earning a laugh from the group as everyone clinked glasses.
The night unfolded in a haze of laughter, stories, and an ever-growing pile of empty glasses. It wasn’t long before Folio and Matt were deep into their cups, leaning heavily into their drunken states.
Folio slumped back into the couch, a lazy grin on his face. “Damn, I’m so drunk,” he mumbled to himself, chuckling. “Shouldn’t have smoked that joint during the show.”
You and Noah, seated next to each other on the crowded couch, exchanged amused glances and laughed quietly at Folio’s confession.
“What’s so funny?” Folio slurred, his glassy eyes focusing on the two of you. Then he paused, squinting as if his vision had just betrayed him. “Wait a minute… are you… sitting on his lap?”
Your cheeks immediately flushed as you realized he was right. The couches were too crowded, and at some point, you’d perched yourself on Noah’s lap to make room. It had felt casual—comfortable even—but now, under Folio’s scrutiny, it was anything but.
“Uh, yeah,” you said, trying to play it cool. “There’s no room.”
“No room,” Folio repeated, his grin widening. “Sure, let’s call it that.”
“Here we go,” Noah muttered under his breath, his arm resting lightly around your waist to keep you steady.
Folio leaned forward, as much as his inebriated state allowed, a mischievous glint in his eye. “You’re awfully cozy for two people who are ‘just friends.’”
“It’s practical,” you countered, though your voice lacked conviction.
“Practical,” Matt chimed in, sliding onto the couch beside Jolly with his drink in hand. His face was flushed, his grin even wider than usual. “That’s what we’re calling it now?”
“Oh, come on,” you groaned, burying your face in your hands.
“No, no, let’s explore this,” Matt said, clearly delighted. “You’re telling me, out of all the space in this VIP section, the only place you could sit is on Noah’s lap?”
“Exactly,” Noah said with a straight face, though the corners of his mouth twitched. “It’s basic physics.”
“Physics,” Matt repeated, laughing. “That’s the best you’ve got?”
“Better than whatever logic you’re using to justify that shirt,” Noah shot back, gesturing at Matt’s garishly patterned button-up.
“Deflection,” Folio sang, pointing at Noah like he’d cracked some great mystery. “Classic deflection.”
“You two are unbelievable,” you said, shaking your head, though you couldn’t help but laugh.
“Unbelievable? No, no, no,” Matt said, his voice full of mock indignation. “What’s unbelievable is that you’ve been in each other’s pockets for years, and you’re still pretending nothing’s going on.”
Folio nodded vigorously, almost spilling his drink. “They’re like… like one of those slow-cooking stews. Taking forever, but you know it’s gonna be good when it’s done.”
Noah groaned, pinching the bridge of his nose. “Alright, I think it’s time to get these two to bed.”
You nodded, standing up and grabbing Folio’s arm. “Come on, big guy. Let’s go.”
“I’m fine!” Folio protested, though he made no effort to resist as you and Noah guided him out of the booth.
“You’re fine, huh?” Noah said, steadying him when he stumbled. “Tell that to your liver.”
Behind you, Jolly and Ruffilo waved lazily from the booth. “We’ll hang out a bit longer,” Ruffilo called. “Good luck with those two.”
The walk back to the bus was anything but quiet.
“You two looked real comfortable back there,” Matt teased, slurring slightly but still sharp enough to make you groan.
“It’s not like that,” you said for what felt like the hundredth time, focusing on getting him up the bus steps.
“Sure, sure,” Folio chimed in, leaning heavily on Noah. “Bet you’re just gonna sit on his lap the whole tour, huh?”
“Folio, shut up,” Noah said, though his tone was more amused than annoyed.
Once you got them into their bunks—after much coaxing and a few more poorly aimed jokes—you and Noah retreated to the living room section at the back of the bus. It was quiet now, the gentle hum of the bus’s engine filling the space.
You sank onto the couch, exhaling a long breath. “Well, that was… something.”
“Every tour starts like this,” Noah said, sitting across from you. He leaned back, stretching his arms along the top of the couch. “It’s like a rite of passage.”
You laughed softly, running a hand through your hair. “I’m surprised they didn’t start singing wedding bells on the way back.”
“Oh, give them time,” he replied with a smirk.
You rolled your eyes but couldn’t help smiling. A comfortable silence settled between you, and when you glanced up, you caught Noah watching you, his head tilted slightly, a faint smirk on his lips.
“What?” you asked, your brow furrowing.
“Nothing,” he said, though the look in his eyes suggested otherwise.
“Come on,” you pressed, leaning forward slightly. “What’s that look for?”
He shrugged, his smirk deepening. “Just thinking.”
“About?”
“You,” he said simply, his voice low but teasing.
Noah’s smirk didn’t waver, his gaze steady and warm as he leaned slightly closer. The faint hum of the bus seemed louder in the quiet.
“What about me?” you asked softly, your voice barely above a whisper, curiosity and nervousness mingling in your tone.
He hesitated for a moment, as if weighing his words carefully, and then his lips curved into a gentle smile. “You’re really beautiful, you know that?”
Your breath caught for a second, and you blinked at him, taken off guard. “What?”
He chuckled, the sound low and almost shy, a stark contrast to his usual confidence. “I’m serious. You are.”
A flush crept up your neck as you tried to find your voice. “Noah…”
“What?” he teased, leaning his elbows on his knees, his body angled toward you. “Can’t I say something nice without you getting all flustered?”
“I’m not flustered,” you shot back, though the heat in your cheeks betrayed you.
“Right,” he said with a knowing smile, his eyes sparkling.
You folded your arms, narrowing your eyes playfully. “Why now? What’s with the sudden compliments?”
He shrugged, his expression softening. “Maybe it’s not sudden. Maybe I’ve always thought it, but I’m just bad at saying it out loud.”
Your heart thudded in your chest at his words. “You think… you think they were right all this time? About us?”
“No,” he said firmly, his voice steady and leaving no room for doubt.
Your stomach dropped a little. “Oh.”
He tilted his head, studying your reaction, and then his lips quirked into a small smile. “I don’t think they were right. I know they were.”
Before you could respond, he leaned in closer, his hand lightly brushing against your knee. The air between you felt charged, the space too small yet not enough.
And then he kissed you.
It started slow, tentative, as if testing the waters. His lips were soft, warm, and they lingered against yours just long enough for your breath to hitch. When you didn’t pull away—when you leaned into him, your hands instinctively finding his shoulders—it deepened.
Noah’s hand slid to your waist, guiding you closer as the kiss grew more passionate. The world outside the bus seemed to disappear, leaving only the quiet hum of the engine and the racing of your heartbeat.
Your fingers tangled in his hair, and he pulled you onto his lap without hesitation. The moment felt electric, the years of teasing, tension, and unspoken words finally snapping into place.
His lips moved against yours with a fervor that sent your mind spinning. You shifted slightly, your knees pressing into the cushions on either side of his hips. His hands rested firmly on your waist, pulling you impossibly closer.
It was as if nothing else mattered, just the two of you finally crossing an invisible line that had been drawn so long ago.
And then—
“Damn, I’m wayyy too dizzy to sleep in that tiny bunk—” Folio’s voice cut through the haze, slurred but loud enough to make you both freeze.
Your head whipped around, your eyes wide, as Folio stumbled into the living room. He stopped mid-step, his eyes blinking rapidly as they focused on the scene in front of him.
“Oh,” he said, his tone laced with a mix of shock and amusement. “Ohhhhhh.”
You scrambled off Noah’s lap, your cheeks burning hotter than the sun as you tried to compose yourself. Noah, on the other hand, stayed seated, though he ran a hand through his disheveled hair, his expression caught somewhere between frustration and bemusement.
“Folio,” you started, your voice a pitch higher than normal. “What are you doing up?”
He pointed vaguely in the direction of the bunks. “Too dizzy. Needed air. Did not expect to walk into… whatever this is.”
“This isn’t… it’s not—” you stammered, flailing for words.
Folio smirked, leaning against the doorframe. “Nah, don’t stop on my account. Just… maybe put a sock on the door next time or something?”
“Go to bed, Folio,” Noah said, his tone exasperated but still holding a hint of a smile.
Folio gave a mock salute before stumbling back toward the bunks, muttering something about how the tour was going tobe very interesting.
As soon as he was out of earshot, you buried your face in your hands. “Oh my God.”
Noah chuckled, his hand reaching out to tug gently at your wrist, pulling your hands away. “Well, that wasn’t exactly how I imagined this going.”
You couldn’t help but laugh, though your face was still flaming. “So much for subtle.”
“Subtle’s overrated anyway,” he said, his smirk returning as he pulled you back down beside him.
Taglist: @courta13
A/N: Likes, comments, and reblogs are greatly appreciated! Let me know if you'd like me to continue this as a mini-series. Also, my asks are always open—feel free to request anything!