1/5 Re: the John Green Situation; as someone who has followed the vlogbrothers for quite a few years now, here's what I think. Both brothers have screwed up in the past, but only Hank takes responsibility for his actions. John usually dodges, excuses or (as in the case of tweeting to known sexual abuser Ed Blann) gives an insincere apology. I remember thinking, when allegations against other pillars of the youtube community started showing up, "How would I react if someone accused one of the
2/5 vlogbrothers of something like this?“ And I remember answering, “It’s fine, because Nerdfighteria is about so much more than them.” At the moment I tend to view John as more of a dork who has unexpectedly risen to power, and as such, has no idea how to handle it. His fame is way more than he’s ever expected, and it just keeps increasing, so he isn’t getting accustomed to it in a healthy way. Unlike his brother, who’s still very prominent in the community work (DFTBA Records, P4A, etc.),
3/5 John has been busy with his family and movie adaptations and tours. These things aren’t bad, but he spends less and less time actively interacting with his audience as people, and more and more time interacting with them as crowds. Meanwhile, the fanbase hasn’t adjusted to this shift in the dynamics, and still seeks personal interaction with him. I believe it is this imbalance that creates a feeling of unease in so many. So, what’s the solution? I’ve never even been in the same State as John
4/5 but here’s what I think: John needs to talk about these changes in the creator-fan dynamics. He’s done it a bit, but mostly when talking about why /he/ isn’t sharing much of his personal life (see: his wise decision to not include his daughter Alice in videos), and not enough about how fans should be careful of him. Hank has acknowledged his power. John, whose power is (potentially) significantly more dangerous, hasn’t done enough in this respect.
5/5 And just a note to end with: John’s books are (very) far from feminist, but describing them as MPDG-positive simply shows that people don’t understand that genre.