a-damn-good-batch answered: donnie darko
princessmoanna answered: inception or the prestige
fioisbatman answered: American Psycho :D
isittuesdayyet answered: ‘Shutter Island’ perhaps?
dr-hotson answered: Let me know when you find one. I haven’t watched a good movie in a while.
suivrelesoleil answered: 50/50?
Donnie Darko is indeed mind-blowing, but I've already seen it. Same goes to Inception and The Prestige. I tried watching American Psycho once, but it was with friends and I didn't get much out of it. I know how it ends, though, so I think I'm going to read the book first before I watch it properly. I've seen Shutter Island, too. Didn't blow my mind that much, tbh, but I loved the opened ending (I think Leo was right, in the end).
Dr-hotson (A+ url) if you appreciate cinematography much, like if you're really into it, I think you might love Conspiracy from 2001 and Sleuth from 2007. Both of them are mostly actors movies, but they're absolutely marvelous. The acting, writing and pictures are at the highest possible level. Conspiracy is about secret meeting in Wannsee, 1942, during which the Holocaust planes was set (it's not 100% historically accurate, though, but it's still worth seeing). Sleuth is based on a play by Anthony Shaffer. It's a remake, so some say the original from 1972 is better, but I like 2007 one best. You also might want to see We Need to Talk about Kevin, but I've heard many negative opinions about it and I'm starting to think I'm one of not so many that actually really, really liked the movie. It's made to look ~artistic, though, so it might be hard to understand sometimes. But I must say, I loved it. A Beautiful Mind or Arizona Dream are great movies, too. Arizona Dream is more weird and specific, though.
I like 50/50 idea, I wanted to see it for a while actually, but I always forget about it.
Thank you for answering, lovelies!