Simple Sweetness
Pairing: Jarren Duran x reader!
a/n: I’ve been insatiably parasocial over Mr Duran lately and the fics on here are scarce, so I wanted to maybe write some while I’m in a place to do so? I haven’t written anything in so long so I’m truly sorry if this is awful!! requests are encouraged and welcomed because I feel like I don’t even know where to start<3 go sox with that dub against the Yankees tonight, I was losing my shit on my couch!!
You watch the tv screen as Chap ends the game with a win for the Sox, striking out the third Yankees player. Everyone on the field looks so happy, grinning ear to ear all running toward the dugout, Tolle and Early being goofballs amongst celebration, and a rare smile from Chad Tracy even sneaks its way in there. Sadly, they skipped your favorite celebratory dance you love to see from Cedanne, Abreu, and Jarren. Everyone looks happy, and you should be too.
But something’s been eating at you all day, and the lingering feelings are making this big moment feel smaller than it should. Jarren will be home soon, you opted out of going to the stadium today, which is very unlike you. He was sweet and didn’t push you to go with him, but you could tell he was concerned. You need to get it together before he comes back.
Maybe it’s hormones, maybe it’s insecurities that have been built over a long time, hell maybe it’s even just one of those days where you feel blue, but you’ve been a mess since you woke up this morning.
You and Jarren have been together for quite some time now, coming close to a year at this point. Your relationship is the healthiest you’ve ever been in, everyone in your life comments on how you’re glowing and showing a newer version of yourself, and you love Jarren so much it concerns you sometimes (but he doesn’t know this, yet). Everything about your relationship is damn near perfect.
But you can’t help the thoughts. You know how fans feel about you. You were a fan who was brought into this world of MLB- this is every girls dream; dating their favorite player. People make sure to express how they feel about it, and they aren’t kind most of the time. Jarren convinced you that maybe it was best for both of you to delete social media for awhile and just focus on each other. You agreed, and it’s been a breath of fresh air for the most part. But today, it’s weighing on you for some reason.
The comments from fans on social media posts and reporters circle in your brain over and over. They think you’re not pretty enough for him, or that you’re going to fuck up his plays (you haven’t- if anything they’ve gotten better), people comment on your appearance all of the time and drag it because that’s all they know about you. You don’t show your personality through social media much anymore since being brought into his life, you aren’t famous on your own for people to know you from any kind of projects or work. You are simply a girl who loved the Red Sox since you were young and just happened to be living the dream of being romantically involved with your favorite player. And you’re not ugly, not even a little bit- but people are jealous and mean, that’s all it comes down to.
And despite knowing this, it still simmers sometimes. You’ve had to work very hard to think even remotely highly of yourself. Most comments don’t get to you anymore, but you’re human and sometimes the negative thoughts just take over.
You don’t even realize you’re crying and that the games been long over until you hear Jarren open the door to the room.
“Sweetheart?” he calls out, setting his things by the door. Shit. You need to pull yourself together. You run to the bathroom and turn the sink on, pressing cold water onto your face. It’s no use. You’ve been crying on and off all day, not even cold water can help the pink around your eyes and the swelling in your face.
“Babe?” He calls out again, closer this time, looking for you.
You creep out of the bathroom half faking a big smile for him. Performing was something you’ve perfected over the years- but even you know Jarren can tell when the slightest thing is off with you. Sometimes he knows it before you can even feel it.
“Hey babe, congratulations! That was a great win for you guys,” you greet him, pulling him into a big hug. Hopefully this can hide your face for just a little bit longer. God he smells so good, too. You love just holding him, taking in his scent and the feel of your lover close to you. “I’m so proud of you.”
He kisses the top of your head, letting his face rest there for a moment before replying. “Thank you sweetheart, we all wished you were there. Tolle was wondering where you were,” he informs you. It’s very unusual that you miss a game- Jarren loves having you there supporting him, and you’re eternally grateful to be in a place where you can pack up your life and travel alongside him to support him and the team.
You chuckle in response. “Yeah, he was probably sad I didn’t come in clutch with snacks for everybody.” You pull away from his embrace slightly, too fidgety to stay put but trying to hide your face as much as possible.
He laughs back. “Did you eat yet?”
“No, I haven’t. Are you hungry?” You ask, making your way towards the kitchen. You couldn’t bring yourself to eat all day, and you had no desire to now.
“Nah, we had something quick right after the game. I’m gonna shower quick.” He pauses and catches you playing with your fingers, hiding your face from him while leaning against the doorframe. “Sweetheart, are you alright?”
You nod quickly. “Yeah, I think I’m just exhausted from traveling. Needed to take a day to catch up.”
He lets that sit for a moment before replying. “Come back here, let me see you.” He sits on the corner of the bed and motions for you to come be with him.
You hesitate, but quickly look at him and give him a small smile before walking to him and sitting on his lap.
“Look at me.” He repeats. You look up into his eyes. They’re so warm and pretty it’s not fair, but they show a mixture of softness and concern. He pushes your hair out of your face and holds your head in his hands. “What’s the matter? You’ve been different since this morning.”
You look away, not really knowing how to respond. You’ve been in your head all day. Had anything happened to get you like this? Not necessarily, but your long-term insecurities decided to hang out with you today and cause your thoughts to spin mindlessly out of control.
“I’m alright,” you lie while breaking eye contact. As good as you’ve learned to be at putting on a performance with your emotions, you can’t do it in the slightest with him. Your vulnerability with him is something completely foreign to you, but you also know it’s simply because he makes you feel safe. As great as that is, it’s times like these where you wish he couldn’t see right through you.
“You don’t look alright, talk to me,” he says softly while rubbing your back.
“I’m not good enough for you,” you barely whisper, tears threatening to fall again.
“What? Babe what are you talking about?” he asks in disbelief.
You shrug your shoulders and bite your lip, hoping it’ll be any help to postpone your cry.
“Sweetheart, why do you think that? That is absolutely not true.” he reassures you.
“You could do way better than me. There’s no doubt in my mind that someone better looking out there is perfect for you,” you reply. It’s too late to stop the tears- but you control them enough to only let a few fall.
He pauses but doesn’t take his eyes off of you. The hesitation scares you a little bit, causing your chest to tighten. Maybe he had been thinking the same thing for a while and had just been waiting for you to say it first.
“Do you remember the day we met?” he asks after what feels like ten minutes. You nod your head, how could you forget? You always managed to sit in the same section- maybe fate, you’re not sure- and after he had smiled at you a few times at a few games, that day he finally came over to you after a game and started to talk to you was the start of it all for you two.
“I had seen you many times, and every time we played at home, I started to realize just how much I was hoping to see you there again. I couldn’t get you out of my mind, and I knew I wanted to get to know you. And when I finally mustered up the courage to talk to you- you didn’t want an autograph or shove a camera in my face. You said…,” he says.
“I said, ‘I’m just happy to talk to you for a few minutes,’” you finish for him.
“And in that moment- I knew I needed to get to know who you are. And I haven’t regretted it since. I had always remembered your face because of how beautiful I think you are. I remember thinking it the first time I saw you, and I remember the little jump I got in my chest when I saw you again shortly after the first time. And then again, and then again. And after that, I found myself praying to God you would be at the next game. And when you were, I knew that was my chance, because what if I never saw you again?” he tells you.
You smile and wipe your tears. “Yeah, that was a great day.”
He pulls your head up to look at him and holds your head in his hands. “I am so grateful I met you. You are the most beautiful woman in the world, I love your personality. You’re absolutely hilarious, the guys love you and even tell me all the time they think you’re funnier than I am. You’re my biggest supporter and are willing to come into my interests and explore new things with me. We make a great team, babe. You are one hundred percent perfect for me. You are the only one I want. I don’t want to know this life without you in it, sweetheart,” he confesses.
You’re crying again, but not out of sadness. Not only do his words mean everything in this moment, but your body can feel the love he has for you. You’re overwhelmed with love and exhausted from a long day of emotional battles.
“I don’t know what to say,” you finally decide to say.
“I love you.” He replies. “I love you so fucking much I don’t even know where to put it or what to do sometimes. You drive me absolutely wild and I love having you in my life.”
You freeze. You haven’t said you love each other yet, trying to take things at an easy pace and see where things go. But you knew you truly loved him a few months in, and you wanted to hold that close until the right time.
“I love you so much, Jarren. I’m sorry you had to come home to this. Sometimes I just get in my head, you didn’t do anything wrong,” you reply. “God, I love you so much it hurts.”
He pulls you in for a sweet, long kiss. The warmth of your body close to his makes you feel safe and sleepy. But you’re feeling so much better. He really is your safe space.
“Don’t apologize for how you feel, baby. I just want you to know I’ll spend the rest of my life showing you how much I love you if you let me,” he says after breaking the kiss. You chuckle and nod, pulling him in close again.
“I would love that more than anything,” you reply.
“Come shower with me, pretty girl. Then we can get some sleep, because someone better be coming to the game tomorrow,” he teases.
“Oh, I’ll be there,” you say, pulling you both up and heading to a nice, hot shower.












