Screw the guys who sending you links about Deltarune reviews, it's time to ask the real hard-hitting questions
Who's your best bet on who the Roaring Knight is?
Conversely, of the popular pics, who do you think is the least likely to be?
At this point there's very little doubt in my mind that it's Dess when everything in the story is pointing to her. She's the popular pick for a reason. She's the Laura Palmer-esque figure looming over the entire story. All of the facts line up, it's a rich thematic vein, and it would probably be the option that hits the hardest emotionally when the entire story is building up to a big reveal about what happened to her. The only other option really worth considering is Carol, but I think she's probably a red herring. There's a good chance she's involved, perhaps coordinating things with Kris in the Light World while Dess is stuck in the Dark World, but I don't think she's the Knight.
Anyone pitching a theory saying the Knight isn't one of the Holidays is just lost in the sauce and overthinking it. There is no fucking way it's Papyrus or whoever. Like at that point you'd have to believe that all of the evidence throughout the game so far, including the Knight literally having reindeer antlers, is pure misdirection so Toby can catch us off guard with a random reveal that came out of nowhere. And I just don't think he's that kind of writer.
At this point the real question isn't the Knight's identity, it's the specifics. Is it really Dess as everyone knew her, simply lost in the Dark World all this time, or is it some sort of grim echo of the person she once was created by the Dark World? Did Carol try to bring back her dead daughter, like how Gerson was revived in Chapter 4, and she somehow came back wrong? Is all the evidence just there to give us false hope that Dess might still be alive and well, when in reality the Knight is a shell of her former self that shouldn't exist, tying into the game's central themes of nostalgia and escapism?















