Okay. I'm gonna put my opinion out there about the morals of HDG as if I am anything more than a nobody but here goes.
A lot of people go "Yeah I love all these ideas in a fantasy kink setting but never in real life!!! Taking away agency is bad!!! It's actually slavery!!!" and stuff like this where the person judges the setting and the actions of the Compact based on human morals. I have MAJOR issues with this. It is the absolute HEIGHT of hubris to think that human morals THAT WE CAN'T EVEN AGREE ON are some fucking universal constant that are infallible and should apply to every other species out there. The amount of ego it takes to think that is insane. In the setting it is agreed upon by the majority of authors, JUST LIKE HUMAN MORALS IRL, that the Compact only takes away agency in the event the sophont is a danger to themself or others. Now at first glance this seems kinda bad yeah? The Affini taking away agency is bad because some dumb idea that free will is the best idea. We literally have laws to stop people from hurting others, and we peer pressure each other into taking care of themselves. Both of these things are outside influences to stop a person from hurting themselves or others. We literally do what the Affini do, just without the forever part of it, in most cases (hello life sentence?). And yet we can all agree that the way we do this is imperfect and sometimes downright harmful itself (see US prisons for just one example). So why not just let a theoretically perfect being do this to us perfectly? What is so wrong about letting the better version of this happen? Do you really think that untold billions of deaths of humans at the hands of free will humans is better than taking away the free will of some humans?? The counterargument to this is that in reality the Affini couldn't be perfect IRL because humans arent. Which again, is really dumb. Sure it's theoretically possible they aren't perfect, but why can't they be perfect either? Why assign a HUMAN norm, HUMAN understanding of HUMAN psychology to a COMPLETELY ALIEN SPECIES?? Again, this is a ridiculous amount of hubris to think that what applies to humans MUST apply to everything else alive. Now, I'll readily admit that it's EXTREMELY unlikely for the Affini to exist exactly as we describe them, or some equivalent species. BUT it is theoretically possible in my opinion. And if by some miracle that they do exist as we imagine them, I honestly think they are in the right here and should keep doing what they're doing. Ill happily take possibly losing my free will in exchange for us all to finally be safe and happy forever.